Cousins on The Road Not Taken

PROLOGUE

French Canada, 1995

Cousins Jo and Emilie had both grown in Jehovah's Witnesses families, a religion famous for not teaching sex education and not letting their kids attend these classes in school. At least back then. The most exposure they had had to sex, even at their current age, had been late-night erotic movies on TV and the very few erotic magazines there would have been at the small convenience store in the town they lived in.

Their mothers were sisters, and both their parents were oblivious to what had been going on and would be going on. Jo was the oldest and was almost 19 when their story began, a tall and thin young man with short spiked hair and glasses; he was a nerd, and so was she. Emilie had turned 18 the very same weekend and it was a complete coincidence, as their religion did not celebrate birthdays. A very small girl at barely an inch under 5 foot tall, she was thin as well with short boyish hair and bright green eyes. Her hips were narrow, but her butt was nicely curved for its size. Sadly, her breasts were not even half a handful and it made her look a lot younger than she was.

The two cousins had become very close during their teenage years as they were both unpopular in school and their mother spent a lot of time together. They had always been curious about each other but nothing had ever happened.

Very innocent exploration had happened the first night they had met again after her 18th birthday and they had been drinking secretly, nothing super unusual between cousins the same age. Light touching and such, and she had seen him naked from the waist down by accident, but not the other way around, after changing at the pool. From then on, she had always been curious. But they would not see each other again for a couple weeks.

Emilie dressed very conservatively and cheaply, like white thighs and knee-high skirts, or loose jeans and hoodies. Due to the small size of her breasts, she never wore a bra. Jo was a typical teen wearing jeans, no muscles, very thin and wearing band t-shirts.

Jo's family used to have a big house but had to downsize due to his father losing his business and they now lived in a two-bedroom apartment that included a basement unit for storage that could be accessed through a door at the back of the 4-unit building. The basement was filled with tires and tools, but also all the summer toys and sports gear, as well as a full couch. There was plenty of room to play, and that is where Jo would often play with his other male cousin.

THE FIRST TIME

So when Emilie arrived that afternoon with her mother, the two cousins reunited and hugged normally, then spent some time with their parents in the second floor apartment. After a while, Jo offered to show Emilie the basement and she gladly accepted, and the two teenagers headed downstairs. Emilie was wearing white tights and a hoodie that reached just below her ass.

The instant the door of the basement was closed behind them and the light was on (there were no windows), Emilie wrapped her arms around her taller cousin and hid her face against his chest. Jo hugged her tight, but then she almost climbed on him and wrapped her legs around his waist, hanging on to his neck and burying her face in it. "I missed you!"

Jo had literally zero real sexual experience aside from seeing a few magazines and a lot of naked girls on TV. They had no computer, both went to small schools, but they had both been super horny, and never had any chance to do anything about it. Jo had barely masturbated at all in his life, and she never had. Jo smiled and then he did what he had been dreaming of doing for so long, and as she wrapped her legs around him he reached under her and grasped her small ass with both hands, squeezing her cheeks tight as he pulled her against his groin.

"I missed you too. I missed you so much." They had been talking on the phone the day before on her birthday, about what had happened before and about their fantasies. She told him she had never stopped thinking about that time at the pool." He let her go gently and smiled down at her, pointing to the couch. "You want to come catch up and play?"

Emilie smiled and blushed, distinctly feeling herself getting warm between her thighs already. "I felt you through your pants, you know. You're hard already?" Her cousin laughed and he blushed a bit as well, nodding as her took her hand and brought her to the couch. Sitting against each other, she put her head on his shoulder. "I really missed you, cuz. It's too bad we only have one hour."

Then they made small talk for a little bit, catching up and telling each other what they had been up to. Then after a while, her hand brushed the front of his pants as she was trying to shift her body a bit off of her butt and more on her side to be closer to him and tighter against him. She looked up to him a bit shyly, but with curiosity in her eyes. "Can I, cuz?"

Jo's nicely long cock had gotten even harder now to the point of throbbing and he only nodded, putting one arm around her waist. "Can I touch you too, Em? I've been thinking about your ass for so long." She nodded and it didn't take but a second for Jo's hand to slide down to cup and then grasp her small ass through her tights, beginning to grope her softly. For her part, Emilie reached down and unbuttoned then unzipped her cousin's jeans, Jo lifting his hips up a bit so she could pull the jeans down to his knees. Timidly, she slipped her hand in the opening of his boxers and the first thing she touched was his balls, causing him to moan loudly at that first touch.

The sound surprised her but she wasn't sure what to do so she just stroked his balls gently and cupped them in her hand for a moment, before finally pulling his entire erect cock out of his boxers. Looking down at it with wide eyes, she looked up at him. "What should I do?" Right as she was wrapping her hand around his hard shaft.

"Just... just stroke it up and down, jerk me off like that. And it felt really good when you touched my balls." She nodded and did as told, beginning to truly masturbate her cousin for the first time. That is when she gasped, as Jo's fingers, had slipped between her cheeks and brushed heavily against her double-covered pussy. Jo looked at her face. "Did that feel good? Want me to do it more?" She looked at him and nodded.

Pressing two fingers right over his cousin's pussy, Jo started rubbing up and down in a fairly inexperienced way but it was still managing to beginning to get her aroused and moist. Looking at his cock as she stroked him, she smiled a bit and realized that she enjoyed hearing him feel good, and she enjoyed doing this.

But then they both heard someone open the upper basement door and they had to fix their clothes quickly and pretend to be playing, before their dads came to get the baseball gear. And that was the only moments they had this time. They hugged at the end and whispered to each other that they could not wait to do more.

BETWEEN THE FIRST TIME AND SECOND TIME

It was a while before they could have complete alone time again. But they spoke on the phone often, about their fantasies and how they imagined these things went, with their limited experience. When they would meet quickly at or after church, they would sneak touches as much as they could. Jo had even made a hole in the pocket of his dress pants and would not wear boxers, and they would meet at the back of the Kingdom Hall (the Jehovah's Witnesses' church) near the washrooms and Emily would slip her hand in her cousin's pocket and stroke his bare hard cock a little bit before they went back to their seat.

Another part of their weekly ritual at church was when it was over, Jo would ask his dad for the car keys and the two cousins would quickly go await in the car together. They would always hug in such an innocent way, her small face buried in his neck as they lost themselves in this short moment of closeness and intimacy. But it never took very long before Jo would feel her hand on the front of his pants, unzipping his pants and pulling his already hard cock out. Those soft, small fingers would wrap around the long length and begin stroking it up and down tenderly until one night a thin coat of precum covered her fingertips. It was the first time it got this far.

Looking down at her hand around his cock and feeling her fingers get wet, she then looked up to him and saw his eyes were closed, his arm around her shoulders still as he moaned softly. Her cousin looked as if he was really feeling good and so she continued jerking him off like this and closed her eyes, pressing her lips against his neck in what would be their very first kiss. It was too good to last, as people were starting to come out of the church and into the parking lot, and so they had to stop and pretend they were talking until Jo's dad arrived too and they drove Em to her home. Again they whispered goodbye and that they couldn't wait for the next time.

They spoke on the phone often still, talking about what they did and even talking about what sex would be like, and roleplaying about it.

THE SECOND TIME

One weekend, their mothers had to quickly go to the grocery store and offered them to come, or to stay home. So of course they chose to stay and the second their moms were gone, they locked themselves into Jo's room and hugged right away, sitting on the floor against his bed. Em was wearing her flannel tights as it was cold outside, with a short skirt on top and a hoodie with a small t-shirt underneath. After snuggling for a bit, Em smiled up at her cousin and reached up to kiss his cheek. "Do you want to play a bit?"

Jo nodded quickly and smiled down at her, feeling himself getting hard already. "But today I want to touch you more, okay?" Em nodded and smiled in a unusually shy way as she reached for his sweat pants and began pulling them down, seeing he wasn't wearing boxers and his cock was half hard already. She bit her lip a bit, still shy about the whole thing and herself having never been in any state of undress with her cousin yet despite how often she had seen his cock. Every time he had touched her, it was her ass. So she knew he liked that.

Slowly, the small teen got up on her knees and then bent over her cousin's bed, lifting her skirt to expose her bubbly ass covered by those flannel tights. She looked back at him and smiled as he moved behind her without needing to be told. Em had to bite her lip again when she felt both her cousin's hands dig into her butt and squeezing gently, his hands exploring her backside and groping her just as he had imagined he wanted to do for so long. After a few minutes of him grasping her ass non-stop, his fingers slipped between her thighs and rubbed against her pussy, and this time it felt very warm. Jo also felt that she was not wearing panties, so his fingertips could feel her pussy lips for the first time.

That got a small moan out of the virgin teen and she looked back at her cousin as she got down from the bed and onto all fours on the floor, her hand quickly going to Jo's cock as he knelt next to her and continued rubbing his fingers between her ass cheeks. "That feels so good, Jo. And you're getting wet again already." His cock had already started leaking precum as her small hand stroked it, his own hand returning to groping her ass before again slipping two fingers between her legs and rubbing against her small pussy, not knowing what he was doing at all and having no clue about fingering or anything.

Once more, their moms arrived and interrupted them, the cousins quickly fixing their clothes and hugging one last time, sneaking a few last gropes.

After that, the build up intensified as all they had for a long time was their short moments at church and even that came to an end, and then some very quick moments at family gatherings. The most was the same kind of quick jerking off session while he groped her ass, he was way too shy and innocent to do much more at this time, and she was by no means thinking about removing her clothes or anything of the kind yet. It would remain innocent like this for several months.

Em had asked her aunt to come sleep over so she could play videogames with Jo. Jo's mom took strong sleep medication and was always out cold, and the three of them were alone in the apartment. That would be their final chance to go further, but both simply did not have the dirty thoughts of today's teens and they truly were innocent, so they missed their chance and simply fooled around again one last time. It never went past Jo groping Emily's ass, and her stroking his bare cock.

This is where it should have stopped. But what if Jo had gotten some ideas from somewhere, and had something prepared for that night? What if he was finally ready to pressure her to do more? In this particular case, it was one of his friends who had told him about what he was doing with his girlfriend. So Jo made up a story in his mind to tell Em, to get her to do more and make her think and feel it was okay.

THE ROAD NOT TAKEN, PART 1

Everything happened normally when Em arrived at Jo's apartment that night with her aunt, the cousins having no time to be alone together all evening. But then came bedtime, and everyone said goodnight and Jo went to his room, Em going to sleep with her aunt. And so the two teens waited for Jo's mom to fall asleep.

After an hour, Jo heard his door open and looked over, seeing Emily slip in the dark room and close the door behind her. She was wearing a long night shirt that reached her knees, and it wasn't long before Jo was out of his bed and had his arms wrapped around his cousin, hugging her tight. He was not wearing a shirt, only boxers, and she could feel he was already hard.

They hugged for a long time, his hands over her back and her own roaming over his own bare back. Her heart was beating fast, she had no idea what to do or even any idea what was going to happen. So she did the only thing she knew how to do and slipped one of her hands down to grasp his cock through his boxers. She blinked in surprise when Jo reached down and pulled his boxers down, stepping out of them and standing in front of her fully naked for the first time. Em looked him over and blushed, her heartbeat quickening when she saw him moved to her. "I want to see you too, cuz."

Em was almost frozen as she watched her cousin reach down for the hem of her shirt and start pulling it up. Soft, pink thighs came into the view of the pale light in the room, then the small white panties she was wearing. Jo was mesmerized as her flat stomach came into view and finally her small breasts were freed as he pulled the shirt over her head. He barely had the time to look at her that she quickly hid in his arms, too shy to let him look longer.

That first full contact of their warm, soft and bare bodies was the most intense feelings the two teens had ever experienced. Those small breasts and now hard nipples rubbing against his stomach, his hard cock against her and now his hands sliding down her back until they grasped her ass tightly, lifting her against him. Em gasped softly and felt something electric between her legs when in this position and in this hug, her cousin's hard shaft was pressing against her thinly-covered lips, and she could feel she was wet now. All she could do was hug him tighter and bury her face in his neck as he whispered. "You feel so good, Em. You're so soft." They continued hugging and rubbing against each other like this until they finally let go, and Em quickly climbed in bed to hide under the blanket.

Smiling at her and standing there with his cock straight and hard, Jo slid into the bed with her and they hugged again, this time her hand going straight down to his shaft and beginning to stroke him quickly. It wasn't long before her hand was messy with precum. She looked at him. "Why does it do that?" Jo moaned softly and then looked back at her, his hand going to her ass and giving one of her round cheek a squeeze through her panties.

"If you continue doing that, or if we do more, it will feel really good for me. I will ejaculate, a lot of what's on your hand now." That's when his fingers had slid under the waistband of his cousin's panties, caressing over her naked ass cheeks from behind. Then he found her wet pussy lips, the contact making Em gasp and moan softly. She closed her eyes and squeezed her cousin's cock gently as she felt his fingers rub all over her tiny cunt until he naturally found that burning hot little hole. They had talk about the concept of sex before, and had roleplayed on the phone about putting his cock inside of her, but only had giggled about it and never truly considered it.

Jo remembered what his friend told him, and decided to begin manipulating his cousin right as he felt she was beginning to pull back, either nervous or too shy and he knew she was on the verge of stopping this. When his finger pressed for entry and slid into that wet and hot little pussy, Em moaned softly and looked at him when he started whispering. "Raymond told me that he does this with his sister almost every night. He told me what they do, and that it's normal. He said it feels really good." His finger pushed deeper into the velvet depths of his cousin's pussy, her own hand quickening on his cock almost out of instinct. "And he told me what she does to him to make him feel good. Do you want to know?"

Listening to what he said and trying not to moan out loud as his finger entered her, Em closed her eyes and tried to relax, her hand not stopping on her cousin's shaft as it slid up and down, both her hand and his cock slick with precum now. Nodding a bit, she snuggled tighter against him to try to give him more access to her ass. "I want to know... and I want to do more. Tell me." As she said that, her cousin slowly rolled on his back and pulled her on top of him, causing her to squeak softly as she had to let go of his cock. Jo pulled his small cousin and made her straddle him until they both could feel the length of his cock sliding length-wise along her covered pussy lips, making them both gasp. The fabric was soaking wet now.

Em realized that Jo could see her breasts, but all her cousin could do was reach behind her to grasp her ass again and drag her along against his cock, so she leaned in to hug him and hide herself at the same time. Her cousin's hands gripped her narrow hips and he began grinding his hard cock up against her groin. With all these movements, Emilie's small panties were now wedged between her cheeks and when she began moving along and sliding herself back and forth against Jo's wet length, the tip of his cock poking between her legs, his hands reaching back and finding her ass bare and slightly wet. He began groping her wildly now as they moved with instinctual passion but also with clear inexperience.

After several minutes of this and feeling a tingling in his groin as he was close now, Jo opened his eyes and looked at Emilie as he made her sit up on him. She saw him looking at her breasts and she blushed, trying to lean down to hug him again but he kept her up. "I'm really close, Em." There was an urgency in his voice that she had not heard before and she looked into his eyes, a sudden intense need to make him feel good.

"What do you need me to do?" She whispered softly as he moved her from on top of him and shifted her on all four while kneeling in front of her. Em blushed as she looked at his wet cock up close like this and she reached up to wrap her small, sticky fingers around his length and resumed doing the one thing she truly understood how to do, stroking him quickly now as Jo moaned louder.

"When I tell you, close your eyes and open your mouth, okay cuz? Trust me." All the poor innocent girl could do was nod as she continued jerking her cousin off. Then it happened. "Now, close your eyes and open your mouth!" Em's heartbeat quickened as she squeezed her eyes shut and opened her mouth, Jo scooting forward and driving his cock between her lips and along her tongue. One of his hands went to the back of her head and her eyes snapped open as her cousin filled her mouth and by now he was so horny that he just started humping her face for a few seconds.

Em was way too lost in all of this to fully grasp what was happening as her cousin's length stretched her mouth open and filled it. The taste was sweet and pleasant, and the act of his cock being in her mouth was somehow such a turn-on that she felt juices squeeze out of her hole and soak her panties even further. Before she could react, Jo moaned loudly and held the head of his cock just past her lips as he began cumming, spraying cum down his cousin's throat and on her tongue. Without thinking, without having any idea what to do, Emilie just swallowed her older cousin's seed and shut her eyes as she did, his cock remaining in her wet mouth.

After he had fully come down from his orgasm, Jo tried to move but Emilie's mouth remained on his cock and he felt her suck softly at his shrinking shaft, licking at him as if cleaning him. She was doing it in a clumsy way, not knowing the spots that would feel the best. But it didn't matter. For some reason, this act of having her mouth on his cock was so intimate and so erotic that she was kind of losing her mind now and was getting hornier and hornier, wanting to feel good too but not knowing how. And so she continued licking at his shaft, sucking softly on his tip to taste him more.

She was about to take him fully into her mouth again when the sound of the toilet flushing alarmed them to the fact that Jo's mom was up, and Em froze like a deer before quickly getting up from the bed and grabbing her shirt. She looked shyly at her cousin when she turned back for a second to put her shirt on, the two smiling to each other before she bolted out of the room to get back to her aunt's bed.

THE ROAD NOT TAKEN, PART 2

The next day was church in the morning, and neither teen had slept until much later in the night. After everything that had happened, a question lingered in Emilie's mind: If his fingers felt so good inside of her, and his cock felt and tasted so good in her mouth, how would he feel inside of her?

Jo was still sleeping when his mom left to go get breakfast. But then he woke up to a wet and soft, then tight sensation on his cock and he opened his eyes, seeing the blanket covering his lower body moving up and down. Removing the blanket completely, he uncovered his cousin who had his cock deep down her throat now, her ass up in the air as she sucked him and he moaned, reaching down to stroke her hair.

Her lips were tight around his shaft, keeping suction and the more she did this, the wetter she was and she could feel it. So all she did was suck her cousin deeper and harder, finding this came naturally to her like stroking his cock had been. She continued devouring his cock sloppily for a while before looking up to him, sliding up his body so he could hug her while she was on top of him. It felt so good to have their bodies press against the other. "What else did Raymond say he does with his sister? I want to try. Tell me." She whispered to him as she kissed his neck softly, feeling his hands slide down her sides and to her ass, his fingers grasping her cheeks tight.

He looked up at her and smiled, turned on like crazy. "First, you need to take off your clothes." Emilie blushed but started pulling her shirt over her head, looking away for a moment as her small breasts were exposed in the morning sun. Then she got on all four facing away from him and hooked her fingers into her panties, sliding them down her hips. Jo's eyes were glued to her ass as it came into full view and then to her two pink holes, his cock getting even harder if it was possible. Her butt may have been small, but it was round and her holes truly were pink and perfect.

Emilie quickly turned around and climbed on top of him, hiding her face in his neck and settling on top of his body. Her cousin's hands took a hold of her hips and shifted her around until her drenched little pussy was pressed down against his cock, the shaft cradled between her tiny lips. Letting out a soft moan, she sat up and looked down at him shyly. Jo was smiling at her but he had an expression on his face that she had never seen before.

"Use your... pussy, to massage me. Move up and down, try to squeeze my... my shaft. And you can lean back and use your ass too, to squeeze my cock." And before she could react, he had moved his hands back up and reached for her chest, covering her small breasts and squeezing them softly. Biting her lip, Emilie looked down at the head of his cock poking between her pussy lips and she began slowly sliding herself back and forth against his length, moaning when Jo began to play with her nipples.

Jo looked down and watched the head and first inch of his cock between her legs, her soft, pink pussy lips slick with virgin juice cradling her cousin's cock in a warm embrace. Leaning back, she slid his cock between her ass cheeks and squeezed them, then slid back and forth once more like he had told her to do to stroke him. How all this came so naturally to her, she would never know. Doing this for a while, she then sat back down with her wet little cunt pressed hard against her cousin's cock.

But their movements had not stopped, and both his cock and her pussy were obscenely wet now as they continued humping each other. It's when his hands returned down to squeeze her ass and spread her cheeks that it happened. When she pushed her body down this time, the hard head of Jo's cock poked against her hole at just right angle required to partly penetrate her and she could feel the tip of her cousin's cock fully past her lips and inside of her. Emilie knew it was the last chance to stop, get dressed and go, remain pure and tell her mother about it all. She was almost fully sitting on him when it happened, so she looked down at him.

Emily could feel her cousin's eyes all over her body and that is when she fully realized how it affected him, how he was excited and getting harder because he was looking at her. This would plant the constant desire to show herself to him, to be naked in front of him or for him to touch her anywhere. She would never stop being horny from now on. And that is when she consciously decided to push herself down, leaning in to bury her face in his neck and hug him as she began taking Jo's cock deeper inside of her. Soft, wet walls spread open and squeezed tight as both cousins moaned softly as the hard length impaled her fully and she was sitting on top of him.

Her body clenching him tight, both teens were still moaning as the soft wet walls of Emilie's virgin pussy squeezed her cousin's sensitive length, she could feel him pulse inside of her and it felt amazing. They both held onto each other, breathing heavily. Emilie slowly sat up and looked down at him, then down at their crotches, feeling him so deep inside. "You... you're inside me Jo..." Is all she could say as she collapsed on top of him again and his arms wrapped around her tight, his hips instinctively pushing up to keep them tight against her so that his hard cock stayed all the way inside of his cousin's pussy.

They stayed like this for a moment as Emily adjusted to his size and to losing her virginity before she finally whispered something. "Cuz, what should I do? This feels really good. Really, really good." The end of that whisper was like a sigh, reflecting how good it felt to have him inside of her and also to have their naked bodies fully against each other. It was so intimate and so special to her, she felt she could do anything with her cousin. And she would constantly want it now.

"You can just... move up and down. But, Em... I already feel close to cumming again. It feels so good... inside you." Her cousin's voice was full of pleasure as he held her small hips, feeling her lips on his neck as her face was still buried in it. Then slowly, she began lifting herself up, feeling his hard length sliding against her soft and wet inner walls until only about two inches were left inside. Her eyes shutting tight as her lips continued kissing at her cousin's neck and as she took him all the way inside of her tight pussy again, she found herself moaning and licking at his neck now. Jo could feel her hard nipples against his chest as she only moved her hips up and then down, hands moving from her hips to her small ass.

It happened before they could do anything about it. As Emily's pussy lips spread tight around the base of her cousin's cock and he was fully penetrating her again, her walls squeezing him, Jo felt that familiar tingling sensation at his groin. Grasping her ass cheeks tight, he moaned as he started cumming -hard-, Emily feeling him release inside of her and realizing that her cousin had just filled her with his seed. But it is what drove her to an orgasm that she had not even seen coming, triggered by Jo ejaculating deep inside of her, and her walls squeezed him even tighter as she held onto him, her body quaking in her very first orgasm.

It took minutes for them to calm down and catch their breath, Emilie having rolled off of her cousin to hide under the blanket, his crotch a mess and thick cum dripping out of her pussy after her very first time. But they didn't get much time to unwind or even talk about it, as they heard the car outside and knew Jo's mom was back, so Em got up in a hurry and ran out of the room and to the shower.

Jo just stayed there for a while, heart beating fast again as his eyes closed and he started imagining all the possibilities that this opened for them.

TO BE CONTINUED SOON