My Amish Boyfriend

I met Theo, short for Theodore of course, while driving down the road, his buggy had lost a wheel and he was alone trying to get it back on. I stopped and asked if I could help, he seemed reluctant at first then said yes, we got the wheel back on and he thanked me so many times. His hand on my shoulder, the feel of his calloused hand, the strength within it, the initial shock from it was making me hard for him.

He and I talked for a bit, I got him a bottle of water from the cooler in the car and we sat on the side of the road and talked, he was easy to talk too, I felt connected to him some how. I wanted to be able to get to know him better but with him being Amish this would never happen. Staring into this man's eyes I was pulled in, I felt some deep emotions for this man, it felt like love at first sight. The growth in his trousers hard to hide for him.

Before we left each other I asked if we could possibly talk again some time, but he told me this was not allowed, he was to keep to his kind and not to fraternize with the English. I was open and honest and told him I felt a connection with him, I was attracted to him, I wanted to kiss him, hold him, make mad passionate love to him. He quietly told me his family were waiting for him so he had to get be on his way. He got back on his buggy and rode off, I stayed at the roadside and watched him go.

I waited till he turned down the gravel road then got back in my car and left for home, I had lived in this community and never really had a real interactions with a man like him or any of the Amish people before to be honest. He was so strong and full of life, so handsome and his eyes drew you in, I wanted to kiss him, I wanted him to make love to me. In the back of his eyes he looked sad and lonely, like he needed to be held and loved he needed a friend.

To describe Theo he was tall six foot two tall, the Amish beard blonde of course, rugged facial features, a broad manly chest, strong legs and big feet.

It was two weeks before I ran into Theo again, he was in the general store buying supplies, I was behind him, he turned and said "Hello", again he thanked me for the help with the wheel on his buggy. We chatted a bit while we waited to be served, he got what he needed then seemed to wait for me just outside the door. We sat on the bench outside the store and talked, he still had that look about him sad and lonely.

Staring into his eyes I was lost, I wanted him so badly, he smiled at me and he knew what I wanted from him. He and I lost in conversation we had talked for almost an hour, his family would be worried and angry that it had taken him so long to do this simple chore of buying supplies. He pulled me in for a hug and held me to his muscular frame, my heart was beating a mile a minute. He got on his buggy and left me standing there at the side of the street.

The drive home I was lost in thought, Theo had my heart, I was in love with a man I could never have, when he hugged me I felt butterflies. I wondered what it would be like to kiss this man have his strong arms holding me as he pressed his lips to mine. I went home and jerked off three times, with just a hug he had me in his spell.

It was another week before I ran into Theo, he was parked on the side of the road and I quickly stopped almost being hit by a car behind me. I walked up to Theo and asked if anything was wrong, he told me there was something.

"Billy I can't stop thinking about you, when we hugged outside of the store I dreamed of you each and every night. You're in my thoughts every minute of every day."

"Theo it is the same for me, you're in my thoughts all day long and I have had so many wet dreams of you and I in my bed."

"Billy I cannot have these thoughts of you and I, it is against my religion, my way of life, a man should not lay with another man."

"But yet you are having these thoughts of you and I making love to each other."

"Yes Billy I am, but I cannot, it is wrong, it goes against everything I have been taught."

"Theo what would you do if I kissed you?"

"Billy No you cannot, it is not right."

"But yet you have the thought of us kissing, you holding me as our lips press in to each other and our bodies are meshed with each other."

I took a step closer to him, he was still maybe a foot away from me, he did not move back, he stood his ground, I leaned in closer, my hand on the side of his face, his beard prickly, his face worn and weathered. Still he did not pull back, I went in closer, we were hidden by the buggy and there was no traffic on this road.

My chest against his, my body in tight with his, he reached around my torso and pulled me in tight, he turned us so he was pushing me to his buggy, he leaned in and pressed his lips to mine. I gently sucked his lips to my own and I pressed my tongue into his mouth, I felt his cock push out in his trousers. His body had me pinned to the buggy, his hands roamed my back and ass, his lips stuck to my own.

He pulled back and stared into my eyes, he and I lost in the moment, we did not see or hear the buggy pull in behind us. Theo pulled back when his name was called out, his father and mother in the buggy behind him. They had seen way to much to brush it off, his father told me to get away from his Son and to leave him alone, to stop putting these evil thoughts in his Son's head.

"Papa it is not Billy who started this it was me, I want and need him Papa."

"You do not know what you want my Son, you English, get out of here and leave my Son alone."

I reluctantly walked away, crossing the road and getting in my car, I stared at Theo as I did this, at this point I knew I was in love with this man. I drove off and did not see Theo for three whole weeks and believe me I searched for him, I hung out at the Store and watched each and every horse and buggy that drove by. It was a Monday I had basically given up when I spotted him at the General Store, he was walking in, I jumped out of my car and followed him in.

I pretended I was looking for something specific, but my eyes were on him, the boots and the trousers, suspenders and the hat, this man was the picture of the most beautiful man on earth, okay in my eyes. When he saw me, he turned red and avoided me, he was in line in front of me once again, he gave a half turn and looked at me.

I smiled at him and said "Hello Theo" he did not turn but said "Hello" I was so red faced, I wanted to be under him right here in the middle of this store, on my knees worshipping his cock, kissing his lips. He paid and walked out he waited by his buggy when I walked out he turned and he had a tear in his eyes.

"I'm sorry Billy but I can't be near you, you tempt me to do things against everything I believe in, everything I was taught, I have very deep feelings for you but I cannot act on them. I have to stay away from you Billy."

"Theo please just let me talk to you for a few minutes, I will not try to do anything but talk to you, what we did on the side of the road at that moment I knew I was falling in love with you, with just a kiss. You have to know this has never happened before for me, I feel like you are a magnet and I am being drawn to you. Theo I love you."

He stood there his mouth open, his eyes tearing up, he went to get in his buggy then turned and looked at me. That is when I knew he felt it too, he stared at me, the tears streaming down his cheeks.

"Billy I will lose my entire family if I do this, so I can't, I'm sorry."

"I understand Theo, please only do what feels right to you, I do not want to push you into doing this if you are not comfortable with all of this."

He got on his buggy and rode off, I of course cried, how could I fall in love with him so quickly and so easily? It was two weeks before I saw him in town again, he was with his father so I avoided him, I knew he saw me and his father turned him away from me. I snuck a few looks at him and he for me but we didn't get to talk.

Another week later I saw him again in town, this time with his Mother, she went in the store and he waited outside. I walked up and he smiled at me.

"Hello Theo."

"Hello Billy."

"I've missed seeing you Theo, how are you?"

"Missed you too Billy, honestly Billy I'm very lonely not being able to see you."

"I love you Theo."

He did not respond, I walked in the store and his mother stared at me, she came up to me and we had a very brief private conversation. She told me it would be in her son's best interests if I left him alone and stopped confusing him, this is not something that can ever happen, her son was to marry a local girl an arranged marriage next week, they would have many children and live a happy life.

"Please leave my Son alone Billy, he is very confused by your actions."

"Your Son is in love with me and I am in love with him."

"Billy there is a difference between love and lust, you are in lust with my son because you cannot have him, we always want what we cannot have. He will lose his community and family if he goes to you and I know your type you will use him then discard him to the wolves. Please if you care for my Son whatsoever. Please I beg you to leave him alone."

Her words cut deep, what if he did come to me and it did not work out for him and I, he would be alone with no one to lean on, but still I knew this was more than a passing thing, I truly loved this man. His Mother talked to him on the way home, he told her how he felt about me, that he really was in love with me and not this girl he was to marry.