Light From The Darkness Ch. 25

I awoke the next morning with a start, worried that everything I had built up with Taylor was going to be ruined as soon as she found out that Michelle gave me a blowjob the night before. I looked at Taylor as she slept peacefully next to me and broke out in a sweat as I worried about what to do, what Michelle had planned for today, and how I probably just ruined the entire cabin trip, if not my entire life. And what were Taylor's parents going to think when they find out we were getting a divorce before even knowing that we were married?

I grabbed my phone, seeing that it was barely five o'clock, and got up out of bed to go to the bathroom. When I returned, I accidentally bumped Taylor and she slowly opened her eyes. "Sorry," I told her as I crawled back under the covers.

"It's OK. What time is it?" She asked and I told her. Scooting closer to me, she said, "I missed you last night. Do you think everybody else is still asleep?"

"Probably. I didn't hear anything when I went to the bathroom," I said, putting my arm around her waist as we faced each other, laying on our sides.

"Good. Then we can do this," she said as she leaned forward and put her lips on mine. I returned her kiss at first, but felt an immense sense of guilt as I remembered what I did with Michelle and what I tried to do with her.

I pushed Taylor away a bit, as she looked at me confused and asked what was wrong. I took a deep breath, rolling over to lay on my back, and said, "Taylor, last night, I was out alone with Michelle in the hot tub and something happened that I shouldn't have let happen and I'm pretty sure I just ruined everything. It was so stupid."

Sitting up on her elbow, Taylor leaned over to look at me and asked, "Did she give you a blowjob?"

I opened my eyes wide in surprise and shook my head, clearing the cobwebs to make sure I heard her right. When I nodded my head to tell her that she did, Taylor laughed and said, '

"Oh, Christopher, you didn't believe her when she told you that I would be OK with it? Heck, it was partly my idea."

"Seriously?" was all that I could think to say.

"Of course. I saw how happy you were sleeping with Lauren. Especially after me and you started doing stuff. And, Michelle, if she didn't tell you, has always had a little side-piece besides her husband. So, I just put two and two together and made the suggestion."

"Wow," I said, still in shock.

"So, how did her blowjob compare to mine? Or to Lauren's?" Taylor asked me as she moved her arm under the blanket and down to my groin, where she began to rub my cock through my boxers while she started to kiss my neck as well.

"Umm. It was good," I told her, growing hard as she slipped her hand into the flap of my boxers and wrapped it around my shaft.

"Just good? It didn't make you want more from her?" Taylor teased as she slowly kissed my lips, pressing her body against mine, and jacked off my six-inch-long, thick cock.

"Oh, it definitely did," I told her, starting to kiss her back as I put my arm around her back and rubbed her back. Taylor was wearing one of my T-shirts that was quite big on her, so I easily slipped my hand up it to touch her bare back.

Ending the kiss, Taylor threw the blanket off me and made her way down to my groin. She stuck her tongue out and licked all over my shaft before wrapping her lips around it and started to bob her head up and down the first few inches of my cock. "Oh, man, Taylor," I softly moaned.

She continued to blow me for a few minutes before she took me out of her mouth, sat up on the bed, and climbed onto my lap. As she sat her groin down on mine, she started to rock back and forth, and I could feel the warmth from her vagina coming through her underwear. I pushed up the shirt enough to see her groin and to put my hands on her hips, helping her move back and forth.

With a smile on her face, Taylor pushed herself up enough to slide her underwear down and off her legs. She grabbed onto my cock to insert it into her wet pussy and let go of it as she slid down my shaft. I kept my hands on her hips as she rocked back and forth, sliding my cock in and out of her.

"Oh, baby," Taylor moaned. "I've missed this."

"It's only been a day or two," I said with a little laugh. "We've gone longer."

"I know. I think there's just something about being around people, especially those that don't know, that just has me so turned on," she said, moaning as she started to bounce a little on my cock.

I moved my hands up her shirt and around to her front, cupping her breasts, and squeezing them as she rode me. Taylor closed her eyes, using her hands on my chest to support herself, and softly moaning as she went up and down. I used my fingers to pinch and rub her nipples before I moved my hands off her breasts and back down to her hips. Taylor lowered her head down until our lips met and we passionately kissed.

Taylor kept moving her hips up and down, sliding her pussy on my cock, while our tongues swirled together. I moved my hands up and down her body, brushing across her nipples, her breasts, her stomach, and her hips. Ending the kiss, Taylor rested her forehead on mine, whispering, "Yes. Yes. I'm so close. Oh, my gosh, Christopher!"

Taylor's face scrunched up as she started to cum, her pussy clenching around my cock, and her riding slowed down as her body stopped moving as she orgasmed.

I pulled my arms out of her shirt and wrapped them around her body. My cock slipped out of her pussy as I flipped us around, getting Taylor onto her back and me on top. We easily got my cock back into her as I started to thrust in and out of her.

Taylor grabbed onto a pillow and used it to cover her face, stifling her moans, as she lifted her legs into the air, spreading them wide to give me plenty of access as I slammed into her. Over and over I went, using my arms on both sides of her body to support myself.

I smiled to myself as I felt the bed moving against the wall, listening to the sounds of our groins as they slapped against each other, and wondered if Michelle was awake in the room next to us, listening to us as I fucked her sister.

As the thoughts of Michelle, the night before, and the little glimpses of her body that I saw filled my mind, I started to orgasm, pushing deep into Taylor and letting out a loud moan that I tried to keep quiet as I came. Taylor pushed up with her hips as I shot my load inside her, her eyes rolling into the back of her head as she felt it inside her.

When I was done, I rolled off her, pulling my cock out of her pussy. We were both breathing deeply as we laid next to each other, eventually getting ourself cleaned up a little and falling back asleep for a couple more hours.

When we finally woke up, we each quickly took a shower, helped my kids get ready, then went downstairs and met up with the rest of the family as we all made and ate breakfast. After eating, Michelle went upstairs with her son to get themselves ready for the day.

When she came back downstairs, I was shocked to see her wearing a tiny top, with spaghetti-strings, and a cut right in the middle to show off her cleavage. Her belly button was just poking out under the bottom of the top. She was wearing short jean shorts, that barely went down her thigh. I saw both her parents raise her eyebrows at her, but didn't say anything. She did put on a little cover-up jacket, but kept most of it unzipped.

I was reading a book while sitting outside on the deck, watching my kids play with Taylor and her parents when Michelle brought her son outside. After setting him down and letting him walk over to his grandparents, she came and sat down next to me.

"Do you think anybody would notice if we snuck off inside? Adam and Kai are immersed in a video game, so I'm sure we could find something to do, quietly," she teased me.

"You're crazy," I told her with a smile.

Michelle giggled as she took off the jacket covering her, pulled a lounge chair out from the deck to be in the sun, and laid down on her stomach on it. After a few minutes, she looked up at me and asked, "Hey, Christopher, do you think you could rub some sunscreen on my back?"

I said sure as I put my book down, grabbed the bottle of sunscreen she had brought out, and walked over to her. I squirted some on my hands and started to rub it on her back. Michelle let out a little moan and said, "Hmm. Your hands feel good," as she reached behind herself and pulled her tanktop up, revealing more of her back for me to cover with the sunscreen.

"You should see what else I can do with them," I teased her, as I went under the straps on her shoulders, making sure to cover everywhere.

"That's the plan, one day," she teased back as I closed the bottle and went back to sit down.

I went down to play with my kids and Taylor as her parents went inside to make lunch for everybody. When they yelled out that it was ready, my kids ran right inside to start eating, while I grabbed onto Taylor's hand and slowly followed them. Noticing that Michelle hadn't moved yet, Taylor said, "I think she fell asleep. Do you wanna go wake her up?"

I said sure as Taylor went inside and I walked over to Michelle. I touched her shoulder and shook it while saying her name, causing her to wake up. "Sorry," she said as she woke up. "I didn't mean to fall asleep."

"Right. Lunch is ready; everybody else is inside eating already," I told her, giving her a hand up as she spun around and stood up.

"Really? We're alone out here?" She said as she stretched and looked around. Seeing that we were alone, Michelle took a step towards me and quickly got onto her tippy-toes to give me a kiss before turning and walking inside the house.

After lunch, the adults pulled out some board games while the kids relaxed and watched a movie. I was sitting next to Taylor and across from Michelle as we ran through games of Ticket to Ride, Betrayal at House on the Hill, Apples to Apples, Life, and Clue. Nearly the entire time, Michelle was running her toes up and down my leg or bending over the table, letting her tanktop fall open in front of me.

After all the games were played, most of the family went outside to hang out on the deck while the kids ran around, while I stayed inside to grab a drink and fix a snack for everybody to share. I picked up the tray I had put the snacks on and started to walk towards the back door as Michelle walked in and said hi to me.

"Hey," I said back as she stood in front of me. "What's up?"

"Nothing much, but I do have something I want to quickly show you," she said with a smirk on her face.

I asked what it was as Michelle shot a quick glance behind her to make sure nobody was watching before she reached down, grabbed the bottom of her tanktop, and pulled it up, flashing me her bra-covered breasts before lowering it back down, and walking behind me to the fridge.

I shook my head as I walked outside, setting the tray down on a table that everybody was sitting around, and sat down next to Taylor. When Michelle walked back outside a few minutes later, she winked at me as she sat down and joined the conversation.

Taylor and Michelle were making everybody dinner that night and got up from the table outside to go make it an hour later. I got up a few minutes later to see if they needed help and the two sisters gladly put me to work.

I sat down at the island in the kitchen to begin chopping up a large pile of vegetables they had given me as the two women stood on the other side, back to me, huddled over the stove. I couldn't help but compare the two, mainly their butts. Michelle's was definitely more shapely, probably due to her playing lacrosse in high school and college, or maybe thanks to her wider hips, a benefit of having given birth. But, then I thought of how Taylor's butt felt in my hands, either just grabbing it to squeeze or holding it as I fucked her, and I knew that I preferred it. Now, their lips wrapped around my cock might be a different story...

I snapped back to reality when Michelle called my name and asked if I could hand her something. As I did, our fingertips brushed against each other, and we made eye contact. With our eyes and fingers lingering, Michelle smiled and said, "Are you enjoying the view back here?"

I told her of course as she turned back to Taylor and they continued to cook. When I was done with the vegetables, I grabbed the plate I had cut them onto and walked it over for the girls to use. As I walked past Michelle, I had one of my hands down by my side, and I purposefully brushed it across her butt. Michelle stood up straight as I touched her and I saw her turn out of the corner of my eye to look at me as I put the plate down, put my hands on Taylor's hips, and leaned down to kiss her neck, looking over at Michelle and winking as I did so.

After Taylor put dinner in the oven to cook, she went outside to sit with the family while I stayed inside with Michelle to start cleaning up. "Did you enjoy that little touch you had earlier?" She asked me as she put the ingredients away and I wiped down the counter.

"Maybe. Pretty sure you enjoyed it too," I said.

"More was surprised but, also, maybe hoping for a little more," she said, walking past me and laughing as her hand "accidentally" bumped my butt.

"Don't tempt me," I said.

"Or what? Gonna do something? I guess it would be a shame if I had hesitated in this cupboard, wouldn't it?" She teased as she opened up a cupboard door to put something in it. I watched her for a second, slowly swaying her body from side-to-side before I straightened up and took a few steps towards her. But, before I reached Michelle, she turned around and said, "Oops, too late."

We both laughed as we went back to cleaning, finishing it up pretty quickly. Michelle had mentioned that she was thinking of getting back into the hot tub and suggested that we should go change before heading back outside. We were standing pretty close to each other as she suggested it, heavy with an implied sexual undertone, and I let her watch as I looked up and down her body.

"I don't know. People might get a little suspicious if we both walk out in our bathing suits. Maybe I'll go see if Taylor wants to join first," I said as I took a step away from her.

"Fine. Have it your way," Michelle said, also taking a step back.

We both walked away from each other, me going towards the door and Michelle towards the stairs leading up to the bedrooms. Just before I pushed the door open, Michelle called my name and I turned to watch as she slipped off her jacket, letting it fall to the floor behind her. She then reached for the bottom of her tanktop and pulled it and her bra up and over her head, exposing her breasts to me. She quickly cupped them with her hands, but not before I saw everything she had to offer. With a smile on her face, she turned and went up the stairs.

A short time later, everybody was relaxing in the hot tub, adults and kids alike. I mainly played with my kids or tried to get them to hold still, while they all reminisced about past family events or shared stories from when they were growing up. Every time Michelle would talk, my mind would drift to the night before and how her lips felt or to a few hours before when she flashed me.

I was greatly enjoying the attention and the teasing that Michelle was giving and doing to me, that was for sure. But, deep down, I still knew that it was a bad idea and not fair to Taylor, no matter what she said. The selfish part of me remembered how great it was to have both Stacy and Lauren to sleep with or get a blowjob from, and couldn't help but think that having both Michelle and Taylor would be just as good, if not better.

When the kids started to get tired, Adam took his son inside to get him ready for bed, while Taylor's parents volunteered to take my kids, leaving me, Taylor, Michelle, and their brother in the hot tub.

The three of time continued to talk about their childhood, while I sat back, closed my eyes, and enjoyed relaxing in the hot tub, with one of the jets hitting directly onto my lower back. A few minutes later, I felt a hand on my groin, softly and slowly rubbing up and down, and smiled as I thought of how risky Taylor was being. I could feel myself getting hard at her touch as her fingers attempted to curl around my shaft through my swim trunks.

When I heard Taylor begin talking a few moments later, my eyes shot open as she sounded farther away then I had thought. She was, in fact, sitting across from me in the hot tub. I glanced over to my side to see Michelle sitting next to me, turned slightly to the side, propping her head up with her hand, with her elbow resting on the edge. She paid no attention to me, keeping her eyes on her sister, but there was no doubt that it was her hand under the bubbles.

"You OK, Christopher? You look a little startled. Did you fall asleep?" Taylor asked me, interrupting her conversation with her brother.

"Um, yeah, I'm fine. I guess I didn't realize that you had moved somewhere else," I said, trying to not react as Michelle rubbed me.

"Right. Do you miss me not being right next to you? Michelle won't bite you... hard," Taylor teased before going back to talking to her brother.

Michelle, keeping her hand on my cock, leaned up and whispered in my ear, "I was wondering if you'd be able to tell them difference. And I do feel bad that I'm gonna have to leave you like this. But, I don't think you could hold it back if I started to make you cum." As she let go of my hard cock, Michelle quickly kissed my cheek before sitting back down.

Mark came back out, telling us that his wife was laying down with the kids and told him to come relax with us, sitting in between me and Michelle in the hot tub. I was glad for the separation, but had to try not to move too much as my boner died down. Eventually, it went down, Mark, Michelle, and their little brother all went insde, and Taylor and myself were left by ourselves.

"How bad was Michelle teasing you?" Taylor asked, coming to sit next to me.

"Oh, my God," I said. "You have no idea. All day long."

"Really?" Taylor asked, rubbing my arm with her hand. "What all did she do?"

As I described to Taylor what her sister had done, and even me touching her butt, she continued to rub my arm, making little comments about everything. When I was done, she asked, "So, how are you going to get her back?"

I laughed and said, "Honestly, I'm still struggling a little with the whole thing. Rather anybody knows it or not, but Michelle is my sister-in-law. And I love you and just want to be with you. It just doesn't feel right."

"But, you didn't have a problem sleeping with Lauren when me and you started to date," Taylor questioned me.

"That was a little bit different," I said. "And it still didn't make it right."

"No, but you did enjoy it. And you still enjoy all the naked pictures she sends you. And you really enjoy looking at those pictures when you're inside me," Taylor said. "And its such a turn on for me, knowing that my man is getting turned on by another woman. Even if it is my sister."

"Really? Why?" I asked her.

"I don't know. But, when I realized what Michelle was doing to you earlier, I got wet. And it wasn't from the hot tub," she said.

I sat in the hot tub for a few minutes, deep in thought. Taylor kept stroking my arm before asking, "What are you thinking about, baby?"

Taking a deep breath, I said, "I'm thinking that I either need to take you inside and make love to you or go see if Michelle is still awake and find somewhere private."

Taylor laughed and said, "I love how honest you are. I guess that I could go see if Michelle is still awake, if you want."

I thought about it for a moment, debating on her offer. Before I could answer, she said, "I'll always be there for you in the morning."

I slowly started to nod my head and watched as Taylor got up and out of the hot tub, quickly drying herself off, and walking into the house. I sat in the hot tub for a few more minutes, wondering if I should go inside with Taylor or not. I ultimately decided that since we weren't caught the night before, maybe staying outside would be best, if Michelle wasn't already asleep.

I did, however, get out of the hot tub, grab a towel, and started to dry off. I sat down in a lounge chair, relaxing in the cool night air and started to grow hard in my swim trunks when I started to think about what could potentially be happening in a few minutes.

I heard the door to the house open and shut and was determined not to look to see if it was Michelle or Taylor. I felt a hand touch my shoulder, and honestly, couldn't tell who it was. "So, everybody is still awake," Taylor said as she stood in front of me.

"Really?" I said, both sad and little disappointed.

"Yep. They got all the kids asleep in my parents room and they're all watching a movie in the living room," Taylor said, reaching out her hand to help me off the chair as I stood up.

"Well, damn. Guess we better go join them," I said, as we walked into the house.

After Taylor and I changed into our pajamas, we joined the rest of the family in the living room, where they were watching a random Marvel superhero movie. Mark and his wife were sitting in the two recliner chairs in the living room, while Michelle and Adam were cuddling on a couch under a blanket, with a bowl of popcorn on their lap, and Taylor and myself claimed the other couch, throwing a blanket over ourselves as well, and getting a comment from her mom to keep our hands above the blanket.

As I settled onto the couch with my arm wrapped around Taylor, I looked over at Michelle and made eye contact with her. She winked at me and stuck out her tongue, and I knew that I had to do something with her that night, no matter what it took.

Halfway through the movie, Taylor asked if I wanted popcorn and I volunteered to go make it, asking everybody else if they wanted anything while I was up. Much to my surprise, Michelle got up as well, telling me that she wanted more and could show me where it was.

I let Michelle walk in front of me, kinda wishing she still had on her shorts and tanktop or her swimsuit instead of the pajamas she had changed into. In my head, I started trying to calculate how long it would take to make the popcorn versus how long it would take me to get Michelle on her knees and my cock in her mouth.

Once in the kitchen, Michelle grabbed out a couple bags of popcorn and put one in the microwave. "Sorry if I teased you too much today," she said, standing next to me in front of the microwave.

"I enjoyed it," I said.

"I can tell. Must still be on your mind," Michelle said, glancing down at my groin and my very obvious hard-on.

We were silent for a moment, listening to the popcorn beginning to pop until I said, "So, maybe we should go check on the kids after the popcorn is ready."

Michelle giggled and reading my mind, said, "If you want a blowjob, you just need to say so. And better hope that you can cum while the popcorn is being made. Maybe we'll make a third and split it."

Michelle quickly grabbed out a third bag as I switched out the first bag that was done for the second bag. As I put it in the microwave after pulling off the plastic, Michelle squatted in front of me, and pulled my pajamas down just enough for my cock to pop out. She wrapped her hand around my shaft and started to rub it up and down, while sticking out her tongue and swirling it around my tip.

We luckily had the kitchen island to shield us if anybody came walking into the kitchen as Michelle started to bob her head up and down, but I still kept an eye towards the living room as I tried to remain quiet. My eyes briefly rolled back into my head as Michelle took my entire cock into her mouth, keeping her hand wrapped around the base, and moaned around it.

As I listened to the second bag popping in the microwave, I knew we didn't have a ton of time and I slowly started to move my hips back and forth, hoping Michelle was OK with a bit of face-fucking. The microwave dinged to indicate that it was done and I opened it to switch out the bags again as Michelle kept blowing me.

After I got the last bag going, I watched as Michelle used her hands, keeping her mouth going on my cock, to unbutton the top few snaps of her pajama top, exposing the top of her breasts to me. Hearing the first few kernels pop, I reached my hand down, sliding it into her top, and cupping her breast. I gave the handful of flesh she had a squeeze and felt her moaning around my cock as her nipple hardened at my touch.

I was forced to close my eyes as I felt my orgasm building up, saying a little prayer that nobody would walk in. The popcorn was going crazy and I knew it was almost done. I pulled my hand out of her top and put it on the back of her head, still moving my hips back and forth. Michelle continued to take me all the way into her mouth every time she bobbed her head, her hand following up and down on my shaft as we worked in tandem to get me to cum.

When I finally reached my climax a few seconds later, I had to reach out and grab onto the counter to keep myself from falling over. I held my mouth closed so that I wouldn't moan, but it caused me to nearly double over, holding Michelle where she was as my cock pumped its cum down her throat, which she eagerly swallowed.

When I was done, I stood back up straight and took a deep breath while Michelle quickly tucked my cock back into my pajamas and stood up. I opened up the microwave to take out the last bag of popcorn and began to open them up, dumping out all three bags evenly between two bowls while Michelle got a drink of water to wash out the smell and taste of my cum.

We walked back into the living room, Michelle going back to sit with Adam, while Taylor held the blanket open for me and I sat down next to her, handing the bowl of popcorn to her as she threw the blanket back over us. I grabbed a handful of popcorn and stuffed it in my mouth, making eye contact with Michelle again. She gave me a wink before eating some popcorn herself.