Our Neighbor Dave Pt. 02

This is a follow on from my previous story called "Our Neighbor Dave" about my sexual encounter with our neighbor Dave. This will make more sense if you read that story first. Im a new author and didn't know how to create a linked storyline im sorry so you will have to search for it or view my other works.

Im not a girl to mess around and am very happily married but the actions of my husband John has left me fantasizing about fucking our neighbor after we gave each other mutual orgasms after a game that my husband setup.

It was the morning after our bbq party and as my eyes opened ive never woken up so fast, my heart racing as I remembered what had happened with Dave. The nervous anxiety in my stomach meant I couldn't lay there and simply chill, I had to get up.

I headed downstairs and made John and I a cup of coffee. As I was waiting for the coffee machine to finish I looked over at the kitchen counter where Dave was stood when I sucked him off. The thought of his dick in my mouth started to turn me on again I could feel my pussy coming alive. I put my head in my hands and took a deep breath.

The night before I wanted nothing more than for this to happen again and to confess everything to my husband John and ask for another roll of the dice with Dave, but with a sober mind I thought these feelings may subside. I was wrong, I was getting wet, really wet and my pussy was on fire. My face flushed as I thought about what had happened.

The coffee machine played its tune to say it was finished and I poured us two cups from the jug and headed back up to bed. John was sat up scrolling on his phone,

"All ok babes, sleep well, what a great night." He said

"Yes thanks babes, ive made us a nice cup of coffee."

He thanked me and I got back into bed. I had to say something, there was no way I couldn't. John had led me into the situation so he couldn't be that mad. I mean I could say nothing, move on and no one would ever know. Dave wouldn't say anything I know that, but I felt I had to for two reasons. Firstly, I couldn't live with myself knowing what had happened and keeping it from John and secondly, maybe we could do it again. Like I said, John was my man, my love and well Dave, although I don't want a relationship with him, the whole thing was such a turn on. John and I have fantasized about having a threesome and we both get off on it when we role play about me fucking another guy, maybe this would let us play it out for real.

I sat there quiet, heart beating out of my chest and with a deep breath said "John ive got to tell you something, im so sorry I should of said last night when you asked me".

"Whats that Liz, your making me nervous" he said.

"Well you know that stupid dice game you pushed me and Dave into the room to play"

"Yes" he said.

"Well I was pissed off so I told Dave to actually touch me and he did, he fingered me babes"

"What the fuck Liz, why did you let him do that"

"Well you were pushing and shouting for him to do it and egging me on and trying to embarrass me and him, and with the booze inside me I thought fuck it, it would teach you a lesson, so I told him to do it"

We both sat there for a few minutes saying nothing. "Well say something" I said.

"Did you like it? Be honest" he said.

I decided to be honest and told him how I liked it more than I thought I would and that i almost cum cause he had already turned me on during the day. I bit the bullet and also told him that when he had gone to the shop I was chatting to Dave and I let him do it again and that he did actually make me cum the second time in the kitchen and then I felt compelled to repay the favor as I knew Dave hadn't had a women in a long while and I felt sorry for him so I sucked him off.

I felt a wave of relief, anxiety, shame, fear and arousal come over me.

"Im so sorry John" I said, "I was dunk and you had encouraged the whole thing and made out that it was all fine to do and it just happened, I promise didn't fuck him though, and I felt like it was ok with the other stuff as I sort of stuck to the rules you had laid out".

He looked at me and I noticed he had an erection. He reached over and put his hands between my legs. "Your dripping fucking wet" he said, "Your turned on now just thinking about it aren't you!".

I couldn't tell if he was angry or excited about the whole thing. The emotions got too much for me and I started crying, turned over onto my front and put my head in my pillow. "Im so sorry John, I cant bear the thought of hurting you".

John said nothing, threw his leg over my back, lifted up my hips, pulled my panties to one side and just started to fuck me. I was so wet he slid right in.

I was confused why he was doing this. It felt really nice but I wasn't sure if he was angry, sad, aroused or what. He really fucked me hard and It must of only taken him around 20 seconds and I felt him cum inside me.

He slumped on top of me and said "listen, I understand, I did push you into it but I need time to digest all this". It was like the whole thing turned him on so much he just simply took me like we were primal animals, I was his and who was I to argue.

All I wanted right now was some certainty that everything was ok between us. Id gone from fantasizing about Dave to fearing for my marriage and my sexual fantasies had now become the last thing on my mind.

"So is everything ok my love?" I said with tears in my eyes.

"It will be babes, to be honest, and I know we've played these fantasies out in the past but I never thought it would happen. I kinda feel turned on by it all but I just don't know how to deal with it, what do I say to Dave, I mean do you fancy him?"

"NO NO NO" I said "your the one I want, I have zero interest in pursuing anything with Dave, I have to be honest it turned me on loads and I came really fucking hard but it was just the orgasm that I wanted. The whole thing of it was really sexy but it was just pleasure seeking, there was no emotional connection at all"

"Ok", John said. Well lets just move on and see what happens, im going to have to go speak to Dave but as far as im concerned lets just all try and get back to normal"

"I'd really love that" I said.

We spoke for a little longer and I got up and took a shower. I felt like the weight of the world had been lifted off my shoulders and I could breath easy again. Hopefully all would be ok between John and Dave.

John went around to see Dave later that day. I don't know exactly what was said but John just said all was ok, they had had a chat and were both honest about everything. John told me that they had agreed they were just going to move forward like we all were before and forget it had ever happened. Like ive said Dave is one of those father figure kind of guys you can trust. John wouldnt feel threatened by him or worried about him pursuing anything with me behind his back.

A week had passed and we were back to the excitement of a fresh weekend ahead of us. We both finished work on the Friday and eagerly opened a bottle of our favourite wine. It wasnt long until we were a glass or two in and we could feel the stresses of the week slowly drift away into the distance. We put on a film on Netflix and cuddled up on the sofa.

During a pretty steamy sex scene, John just out of the blue, comes out with "you think that guy has a bigger dick than Dave lol?"

I had almost forgotten about the whole thing and this shocked me, my mouth went dry and I looked at John, I could see he was being playful and not being an arsehole.

I said "Nah, Daves fucking massive babes" and I laughed, matching his playfulness.

"Bigger than me?" he said.

"Not really" I said, a little bit thicker but hes got a foreskin which made it look longer to start with, but I don't think it is, just a little thicker".

This was the first time we have spoken about it like this and it was turning me on.

John looked at me and I at him, we embraced in a heated kiss, what the fuck was happening, this was clearly turning us both on, but why?

Suddenly it was like someone had a gun to our heads and said fuck now else ill shoot you both. We both fumbled with incredible speed and urgency to remove our bottoms and I straddled him on the sofa. I was excited and so turned on about the thought of us both talking about my encounter with Dave the previous weekend.

I held his dick in my hand and guided it into me. We hadn't had any release all week and as I pushed down onto to him he pushed back towards me and we fucked with insane passion and intensity like the world was going to end. We both put everything into it as hard and fast and passionately as we could.

John came pretty fast leaving me horny as fuck and wanting more but obviously this turned John on so much he simply couldn't control himself.

"Im sorry" he said, "I couldn't hold it, I cant remember being that turned on in a long time, i felt like i was going to cum the second it went in"

"Its ok babes, dont worry, we have all night" I said.

Although I felt frustrated I didn't mind as it was only 6:30 in the evening and this meant he could recover and give me a second go later like a stallion. Plus I kinda like the energy of being horny. Something was clearly developing here and we needed to talk about it.

"Babes, what actually just happened?" I said, "we couldn't control ourselves then, why did talking about what happened with Dave turn us both on so much?".

"I don't know" he said, "it's the thought of you liking it and being turned on that turns me on so much, the idea that I could give you the freedom to explore and live out a fantasy without any cheating or deception and actually watch you cum makes me rock hard, the thought of you getting pure emotionally disconnected primal pleasure just for fun is super hot".

"What are we going to do about it then John. Would you actually like to watch Dave make me cum?" I said whilst struggling to swallow from the face flushing and arousal of actually saying this out loud.

"Shall I ask him to come around?" said John,

"What now?" I said.

"Yeah why not. Lets not say anything to him and just see what happens, if something happens it happens if not then nothing ventured, nothing gained" he said

"Umm ok, are you being serious now? What should I do" I said.

"Nothing" said John. "But you should make it easy if something were to happen, why don't you go put something with easy access on and a bit revealing, but not too obvious" said John.

I took myself upstairs, cleaned up and put on a nightdress. I had plenty of options to choose from, from sexy silky and lacey ones to big comfy fleece ones but I opted for a suitably understated light cotton option that hugged my figure, showed a little cleavage and fell to about half way down to my knees.

I came back down and said "this ok John?"

"Perfect" he said, "Ive called Dave and said to come over so we can properly break the ice and move on from last weekend. Ive said we are having a movie night and drinking wine so hes going to bring over a bottle".

"Im nervous babes, what should I say or do" I said.

"Don't worry, let me lead it, just go with my flow, take off your panties before he comes though, I have an idea."

I did what John said. he sat in the corner of the sofa and I sat in the middle seat cuddled up towards him with my wine.

The front door opened a jar and Dave shouted, "Only me, shall I come in?"

"Come on in Dave, we are in the front room buddy" replied John.

Dave walked in wearing a loose t-shirt and a pair of sports shorts. "Ive brought wine" he said.

"Sit down Dave, let me get you a glass" I said and I stood up and gave him the welcome hug I always did.

I could tell things felt a little awkward as he embraced me more lightly than normal, probably out of respect for John and uncertainty with me this was the first time we had been together since what happened.

I took the bottle he was carrying and went into the kitchen. I could hear John and Dave chatting like no problem had ever existed and this put me at instant ease. I poured Dave a glass of wine, took a deep breath and walked back into the room.

I felt fully aware that I wasn't wearing any panties, and I wondered if he could see the shadow outline of the little bit of hair I had on my pussy. I was completely shaven except for a small landing strip at the top.

Dave was sat on the opposite end of the sofa, it was a big 3 seater sofa but could easily seat 4 people.

I handed Dave the glass of wine and sat between the two men, tucked my legs up and rested my knees on Johns thighs whilst I gently leaned into him and took a gulp of my wine. I was consciously keeping my legs tucked up tight to make sure my nightdress wasn't gaping at the back and revealing all to Dave.

"We have just started watching this film Dave but we are only 15 mins in, ill start it again buddy, its pretty steamy but good so far.

John restarted the film and the three of sat there in silence for a good 20 mins. The sexy scene that John and I had watched earlier had passed and we both looked at each other with a smile.

I was nervous, where was this going, what would happen. I wasn't going to start anything, I was in the hands of my husband tonight. I was up for anything and hoped for something and I felt increasing horny as I sat there just waiting for John to start something and I was imaging all sorts which was making me wet.

John put his arm around my shoulder and gently pulled up the back of my night dress a little, not too much but I could feel the back rising, I could feel the air now changing temperature on my butt and groin and I knew I was exposed somewhat. I wasn't sure how much or if Dave could even see anything but I went along with it and relaxed my legs a little so I wasn't tucked up into a tight ball.

Another 10 mins or so passed and a further steamy scene came on the TV. The film was about a party girl in Manhattan and told of her life, and how she was building her career whilst trying to juggle relationships and there was lots of sex in it.

This particular scene showed the women fucking this young guy in the toilets in a club. It was rough and showed her using this guy for her own pleasure, she came pretty quickly and showed how confident she was in getting what she wanted.

"So Dave, did Liz cum that hard mate?" said John.

Out of instinct I shouted, "John, stop!!" even though I knew I should be playing along with what he was doing.

"Its ok "said John, "look we all know whats happened and if we cant talk and laugh about it'll be a never ending awkward situation and I know I instigated the whole thing so we are all good".

Dave looked at him said nervously "umm I don't know what to say John"

At this point John said, "look to be honest Dave its been a bit of a turn on for us so don't feel awkward, just speak openly about it. I don't hold any grudge and its gotten us quite excited mate, there is no need to worry about any of it. In fact Liz was hoping she might get some action tonight"

I buried my head into John with embarrassment and whispered "oh god thats embarrassing".

John Pulled my nightdress up so there was no mistaking what was on view. He reached around and lifted up my butt cheek giving Dave a big eyeful of my entire pussy and said with a playful tone. "You like the look of that Dave? Look the same as last week buddy?"

"ummm I didn't actually get a proper look at it last week mate" Dave said.

I could hear the nervousness in Daves voice.

"Touch it" said John as he let my butt cheek drop, put his hand on my tucked up knees and spread me open towards Dave.

For some reason I couldn't speak, it was a combination of not knowing what to say and feeling so apprehensive, nervous, aroused and excited.

"Can I? is that ok Liz?" said Dave,

"Sure" I said with a broken voice like a teenage boy.

Unexpectedly Dave just reached out and used his thumb to open my pussy and pushed it inside me deeply and slowly and gave me a few slow pumps with his thumb as the rest of hand engulfed the rest of groin.

"oh my god" he said out loud with a gulp and an equally broken voice.

I automatically repositioned myself with my head led back on Johns lap and my whole body now led facing Dave and my legs spread wide open. We had gone from 0 to 100 miles per hour in 0.1 seconds.

"What do you think Dave?", said John.

"Really wet and soft" said Dave as he turned his thumbs attention to my clit. He masterfully transferred my juices from inside me right onto my clit, rubbing it firmly with the soft pad of this thumb.

What the fuck was happening, this feels amazing. Considering what was happening i felt so relaxed and excited.

"Do you want to fuck her Dave?" said John.

"umm yes!, I really would". Said Dave

"I tell you what, make her cum right where she lays and then you can fuck her brains out" said John. "I want you to make her cum whilst I hold her"

I looked up at Johns face and he gave a smile and a wink and said "that ok?"

I nodded and smiled and whispered back "yes babes".

Dave stopped massaging my pussy and got onto his knees. Resting on his elbows he put both hands either side of my pussy and spread me open with his fingers and started to lick my fully exposed clit. The pleasure i was feeling was insane.

John leant over and passionately kissed me. This was crazy, with my eyes closed I couldn't compute what was happening, I was being passionately kissed and my pussy was being pleasured by a strong second tongue and I couldn't make any sense of it. It was so naughty and wrong in all the right ways.

I loved it and the arousal and energy in my pussy was building to a new level already. I felt him push his fingers inside me, very gently but deeply he eased them in and out of me whilst he licked my clit in a way that was completely new. I couldn't hold on for much longer. I thrust my hips into face and grabbed his head with my hands. I was fully aware that I had two men with me and it was driving me wild.

John continued to kiss me as my orgasm built. I stopped kissing him and looked at him, "im gonna cum babes, im gonna cum" I said with urgency.

"Let it go babes" he said as he put his hands down the front of my nightdress and exposed one of my breasts. My nipples were rock hard and as he grabbed my breast and squeezed my nipple between his thumb and finger I moved into a level of arousal and sexuality that ive never been before. This wasnt just my pussy that was gonna cum, my whole body fealt it was going to orgasm.

I looked deep into his eyes as the orgasm took hold of me. It was uncontrollable, untamable. I fealt like I was cumming like a wild animal, like nothing could stop me.

He looked with awe at my face as the most intense waves of pleasure passed through my entire body. My mouth open wide and my eyes even wider and I groaned and gasped with pleasure as I felt the soul leave my body, all the time our eyes fixed on each others as if we just shared the orgasm as one person. Dave increased his pace and intensity and edged out every last moment of pleasure until I had to pull away as the sensitivity in my clit was unbearable after I had just cum so fucking hard.

Dave sensing that I could take any more said "Was that ok?"

John and I just started laughing as I put my flushed face in my hands.

"Yes Dave that was amazing, for fucks sake, oh my god, yes it was" I laid there for a moment totally satisfied.

"I promised him he could fuck you if he made you cum, is that ok?" said John

I smiled at him and said "Id really like that, but I need you there and part of it." I was really looking forward to the feeling of getting fucked. I always love getting fucked after I cum, it just hits like nothing else.

I flipped over onto my front onto all fours on the sofa and undid Johns trousers. I pulled out his cock that was hard as fuck and super juicy, so much pre-cum. I didn't say anything to Dave and I started to kiss my husbands dick.

I felt Dave positioning behind me, his hands on my butt and around my pussy and then I felt his wet dick come into contact with the back of legs and I knew he would be entering me soon.

Dave had finally managed to get himself into position and I could feel his dick at the entrance of my pussy. He rubbed the head of his dick up and down me a few times, lubing it up with a combination of my juices and his own pre-cum and started to push it into me. It didn't slide right in like John did earlier, it was thick and although not too thick it was taking me a while to absorb his full girth.

He went slow and steady giving me a few centimeters at a time. Each time he pulled out he pushed it back deeper with every thrust. The pleasure was incredible, I had never felt so full and with each push the intensity grew as I felt more and more of it every time.

I tensed my pussy to grip it even tighter which sent waves of pleasure through my entire body. After a minute or so he was fully in and fucking me slow, rhythmically and deep. He was bottoming out against my cervix and had me stretched around him just enough that I couldn't help but scream and groan with pleasure with every thrust. I dont know why but I kept thinking over and over that im getting properly fucked for the first time and it was driving me crazy.

I don't think he had that much more to give as I could feel his balls against my clit and with his hands on my hips he continued to increase his pace and he drove himself into me, fucking me gradually harder and harder.

I continued to suck Johns dick but it was hard to concentrate so I would take it out of my mouth to scream and gasp for breath and wank him for a minute whilst I clenched my eyes shut and focused on the big dick fucking me senseless.

John could see I was trying my best to pleasure him but he knew I had to focus on my own pleasure. Ive never cum from pure vaginal sex although the pleasure is always intense and although I absolutely love it, ive always needed some clit action to finish things off. This time though, to my delight I could feel an orgasm building but it was different, more inside me, like right inside me.

I don't think it was to do with Dave as such but rather the whole physical and mental stimulation of the situation in the same way ive woken up once on the brink of an orgasm from a dream. This was a mental turn on as much as anything, the whole situation was driving me wild and my sensitive clit could feel his balls banging against it.

I could feel Dave fucking me faster and faster, he was losing control and searching for his own orgasm. This pushed me over the edge and I looked up at John and the orgasm erupted inside me, "Fuck John, im cumming again!!"

I screamed so loud and almost growled at him as I just uncontrollably tensed up and screamed, my pussy was exploding, a tidal wave of pure orgasm pleasure was pumping through my entire pussy right up into my stomach, I must of cum 3 times in a row, either that or it was just extra long orgasm as it just didn't stop, it couldnt stop.

I then felt Dave, with one final thrust pump deep inside me and he let out his own primal grunt. He pulled me onto him as far as he could as he erupted his spunk into my pussy. It felt like ive never been fucked so deep. I swear could feel the cum hit me inside as his warm juices filled whatever space was left in there.

He slowly pulled out and collapsed back onto the sofa with a deep breath. I was dripping with cum and had a glow of pleasure emanating from my entire body. I wiped as much cum as I could with my night dress, straddled my John and said "your turn my darling".

I fucked him with every inch of my being, holding him tight with my arms as we kissed. John is capable of giving me incredible pleasure but this was different, there was a connection between us of love like never before.

He held my butt, stood up with me and turned me around onto the sofa so he was on top of me. He looked deep into my eyes and cradled me with his big arms as he fucked me, and as he came hard inside me he said "I fucking love you so much Liz".

"I love you too" I said as I held him even tighter.

Oh my god, this was the most pleasurable and emotionally connected night all in one. Afterwards the three of us just sat there in silence and drank our wine for a moment whilst we all recovered, it wasn't an awkward silence, we all just needed a minute.

John broke the silence by saying "holy fuck that was intense"

We all nervously laughed as we looked around at each other. Both men were slumped on the sofa there with their limp dicks out, I was all deshevelled with my nightdress around my waist, one boob out and my hair was everywhere and we were all panting like we had just run a marathon. Everyone totally sexually satisfied.

"Right lets get some food" John Said as he put his dick away.

We sat together for the next few hours drinking wine and eating. During the 2nd film we watched, John disappeared for a few minutes and returned with 2 of our favourite clit toys from the bedroom and delighted in showing them to Dave.

Both of the men did have a good play with my pussy and I did cum twice more as they took it in turns to finger and masturbate me with my toys like a tag team duo but there was no more sex.

I loved being their plaything and was happy to surrender myself to them for the pleasure they gave me. It was a beautiful second and third orgasm and just what I needed to end the night as a very happy and satisfied girl.

This was super hot and our new formed friendship gave me many more orgasms from both men over the next few months. Most of the times were similar to this story so not much new to tell apart from a couple of occasions and an accidental 1 on 1 with me and Dave that almost caused our whole situationship to fall apart. Ill put these stories together as soon as I can for you all.