Truth, Dare, Twin?

My fraternal twin brother, Luca, is just a few minutes older than me. He is very much the protective big brother and reckless when it comes to his own safety.

Regardless of our age, we've been connected at the hip. As teenagers, we've separated a little more. Making friends and spending time apart.

And sneaking away to text each other that we'd rather be somewhere else together.

I enjoy my time with friends. But. There's just something about being a twin that I can't explain. A deeper bond where everything is understood without explanation.

It's a huge reason why we chose to attend the same college. We'll be 12 hours from home and that's easier to do together.

Luca's best friend Corbin was accepted to the same college. I'm convinced he's in love with Luca. He'd never admit it unless Luca expressed his undying love first. Which will never happen.

We've been an awkward platonic throuple for a while. Obviously, Luca and I look alike. He's a lot taller. I'm 5' 6" and he's 6'1". Our features are the same. Brown eyes, full lips and brows, long eyelashes, curly brown hair, dimples, and an identical, up to no good grin.

Corbin is 5'10". Golden straight blond hair, hazel eyes, and what he likes to call a "sleeper build". He's slim and muscular. Standard hockey player build.

Luca and I turned 19 shortly before graduation. I spent most of the summer with my friends. A few are headed out west for school. Beach days, riding tubes down the river, smoking weed with guys in the woods, and going to parties.

One Saturday night in late June, I'm home alone when Luca and Corbin come in through the garage.

"Hello?! Layla?! Laaaaay-laaaaaaaah."

Their voices are echoing down the hallway as I rush to get up. I can hear Luca taking off his shoes. If I don't answer, they'll both be in my room before I can shut the door.

"Coming! I'm... just stay out there!"

I whip around the corner to the kitchen just in time to stop Luca in his tracks.

"Where is everyone?"

I point to the calendar on the fridge. Our parents took our younger siblings to their travel games. James is 13 and Tegan is 11. Our parents put all of us kids in sports. Never had a calm weekend my entire childhood. They'll be home tomorrow.

Luca and I aren't playing sports in college. We were awarded academic scholarships. Our parents said we can still play sports but academics is the main focus.

I played volleyball. It kept me busy and in great shape. I found a club on campus that meets twice a week. Which leaves me so much time for other things. It's a relief to have free time.

"Did you guys find out who your roommates are?"

Corbin is beside himself that his request to room with Luca wasn't approved. Even worse. They're not in the same dorm. It's a travesty.

"Honestly, Corbin. I'm shocked you're feeling okay enough to bring it up. You'll be three whole buildings away from Luca."

Luca grabs a pillow and quickly whips it at my head. I catch it and smile. It's all for show. Even Corbin knows I'm priority.

"It doesn't make any sense why your dorm is right behind Luca's and mine is on the other side of the hill."

"Corbin, it makes perfect sense that you're in the hockey dorm. You're on an athletic scholarship. Makes sense they put you with the rest of the freshman players."

Corbin's head drops slightly. And people say I'm the dramatic one.

"Dude. It'll be fine. We have classes together."

Corbin perks up as Luca pats his shoulder.

"Ahhh bromance. It's so sweet."

Luca shoots me daggers as I shrug. Couldn't help it. I rarely hold back when I have a shot at Corbin.

We make some food and head downstairs to the basement. Our parents created the ultimate teen hangout in our basement. Entertainment center, pool table, foosball table, movies, games, PS5, Xbox and more.

Our house is the hangout house.

Corbin is no stranger to our home. He's been friends with Luca since 5th grade. We slip out the back door of the basement and get high before watching a movie.

Tonight, is the night everything changed between the three of us.

As the indica is hitting, Corbin has a smirk on his face that I don't like. Means he's got an idea. I've seen this look countless times. 50/50 shot I'll hate whatever he's going to say next.

"Do you guys want to play a game?"

Luca and I look at each other and shrug.

"Truth or dare?"

Luca gives me a curious glance. I pull a stink face. This is the game you play at a party. Not with three people who spend too much time together.

"Why? There's only three of us and we know too much about each other."

Corbin sighs in frustration.

"When will you two just trust me?"

I cross my arms and roll my eyes.

"When your ideas end well. Which has yet to happen, Corbin."

I sink into the sofa and turn on the TV.

Corbin sits on the coffee table opposite me.

"One last time, Layla. It's been so long since we played a dumb game."

"It's not the game. It's the fact you want to play it."

Luca places the food on the coffee table behind Corbin and hands me a water.

"Why can't we just watch a movie? Layla already has some lined up."

Corbin groans as he stands in front of the TV.

"You guys are so boring! 20 minutes is all I'm asking for."

He gives us a pleading look. Silently looking back and forth between us until Luca breaks the silence.

"Okay..."

I nod. It can't be that bad if he only needs 20 minutes.

The first couple rounds are typical. Regrets, embarrassment, silly dares, and so on. We've lost track of time as the weed makes me giggle every time Luca and Corbin make the tiniest joke.

It's Corbin's turn and his eyes change. His hazel eyes darken. I knew he was up to something. Is he sober? More sober than us?

Luca and I are sitting closely on the couch. Corbin on the loveseat to our left.

Before I can warn him, Luca picks dare. Corbin smiles a nasty grin.

"I dare you to kiss Layla."

Luca laughs for a moment. Puts his arm gently on my shoulder, and kisses me on the cheek.

"That doesn't count."

Luca sighs and kisses me quickly on the lips."

I turn to Corbin and see the mischievous look is still there. It's not over yet.

"Layla, truth or dare."

My heartrate increases. Luca gently squeezes my arm as he waits for me to answer.

"Truth."

Corbin looks at my brother for a few moments.

"Have you and Luca ever crossed the line sexually?"

I freeze and Luca's hand stops. I look at my brother out of the corner of my eye. His breathing increases slightly.

"We promised not to..." I say softly.

"Layla don't."

Corbin leans forward and tries to soothe the rising panic.

"Hey, come on. It's been nine years! I've kept secrets for both of you. Whatever happens here tonight, stays here. Promise."

So far, that has been the deal with our friendship. The major secrets have stayed a secret. Luca and I swore to never talk about a few things to anyone. Especially, when we have crossed some lines.

Corbin sits back as I ponder how to answer the question.

"Yes. We have."

"What happened?"

I look at Luca and our twin stare does all the talking. We have to give him something. I refuse to tell him the most damning story. We're taking that to the grave.

"Freshman year of high school, Luca and I got home from school. Our mom took James and Tegan to an appointment. So, we were alone for a couple hours."

I can't tell if this is enough for Corbin. The room still feels tense.

"There was a party coming up that weekend. Everyone was talking about it. I was nervous and Luca was trying to help me calm down."

I had a crush on the guy throwing the party. Devin. He was shy, nerdy, and wicked cute. He had no clue just how attractive he was until years later.

Luca was my first kiss and I was his. Practicing evolved to making out pretty quickly. This party was more than just kissing and making out. I wasn't that experienced. Of course, I talked to my twin about it.

"I was so nervous Devin would pick me and I'd do something stupid awkward. So, Luca offered to practice. Things just..."

I trail off and Luca takes over.

"Things went a little further than we planned and we touched each other in places we probably shouldn't."

"Where?"

We both look at Corbin. He's genuinely curious. Even if he's up to no good.

"My boobs and I touched his dick. Okay?"

Corbin thinks for a few moments and gets up. He's tossing his phone in the air and catching it. He does this a lot.

"Would you do more? Have you?"

He cocks an eyebrow as he catches his phone and waits.

"Why do you want to know about this?"

"It's kinky."

Luca sighs heavily.

"We haven't had sex, dude."

"Why not?"

I can't believe we're having this conversation. Corbin has had some interestingly bad ideas. This is completely unexpected.

"Corbin, she's my sister!"

"Yeah, but she's your twin. That's different."

"Please, explain how it's different."

Corbin's turn to sigh as he plops himself back on the love seat.

"Well, you're twins. Not identical. But it never crossed your minds that you might be "made for each other?" You know, since so much is the same."

The room is quiet for a while. Corbin is picking his nails as he waits for a response.

This might be checkmate. Especially, when my brother looks that guilty.

"Luca, have you ever thought about that?"

"Umm..."

"Luca!"

"What? I haven't thought about it like that. Just the sex part. Which you have too. You told me you have."

My face goes red. That was a secret between us. I'm equally parts disappointed and furious.

"Way to go, Luca. Now she won't talk to us for the rest of the night."

I'm ready to storm out. Normally, I would until Luca talked me into coming back. There's one thing I like a little more than the storm out.

Getting even.

"Corbin, do you remember Jenee's pool party last year?"

Luca perks up at the mention. I have all of Corbin's attention as he nods enthusiastically.

"Well, you lost beer pong because Luca was too busy going down on me in Jenee's parent's bathroom."

"What the hell, Layla?!"

Luca quickly turns to Corbin to apologize. Pleading gestures included.

"Dude, I know that sucked. I'm sorry. I still am. I told you I'd make it up to you."

"You can."

Luca and I share a confused look.

"If you want to make it up to me, do it again."

Corbin is calm and collected. That mischievous look still in his eyes. It makes his eyes almost completely brown.

"Luca, you can make it up to me by going down on Layla and I'll watch."

Shit. We should have seen that coming. Corbin can be an idiot but he's actually intelligent. When he applies himself.

"Can you promise you will only watch?"

"Oh, Layla. I meant it when I said what happens tonight, stays a secret between the three of us."

The shock on Luca's face is priceless. I'm pretending I didn't see his dick move in his pants at the thought of this happening.

I take my brother by the hand and pull him to me. He kisses me softly. Almost hesitant.

I pull back to play with his hair. It calms him down.

"Just focus on me. Pretend he isn't here."

Luca nods and kisses me deeply. His hands going down my back. Slowly, until he finds my ass. One of his favorite things that he can't touch often.

I moan into his kiss and that's all he needs. Suddenly, I'm being picked up. Luca lays me down on the couch and pulls my leggings off easily.

"You've done that before, too."

There's a lusty look in Luca's eyes. I bite my lip in anticipation. He holds eye contact with me as he gives Corbin his only warning.

"It's probably in your best interest to not remind us you're here."

Luca is rock hard but he won't let me any where near his dick. Not when I spread my legs and my pussy is on full display.

Corbin silently leans over the arm of the loveseat to see as much as possible. As long as he doesn't speak, I can focus.

I prop myself up on my elbows and watch Luca slowly drop to his knees. Lowering his face between by legs.

He kisses around my lips, starting at the top and going down the sides. I feel his tongue softly lick before kissing again.

My moans start soft until I feel his tongue finally glide across my clit. My head falls back as his tongue swirls around my swollen clit.

"Mmm you tease." I moan

He increases the pressure and mixes in licking up and down with the swirls. I feel his hand reach up under my top. Using his thumb to play with my nipple.

I can't help rolling my hips as my brother softly sucks my clit. I've taught him everything he knows. Didn't take long. Quick study.

"Yes, Luca. Just like that. Please... don't stop... please... yes."

My legs are shaking like crazy. Luca holds me down and keeps going. Watching him brings me even closer to my orgasm.

I feel the tingle starting in my pussy and belly. I look up and lock eyes with Corbin. I've never seen him so happy.

"I'm close."

He smiles and I turn my attention back to Luca. He places his hands on the inside of my thighs. He knows what's coming.

My back arches and my legs try to slam shut. He's pushing down on my thighs to keep them open as my legs shake uncontrollably.

My moans fill the room until Luca finally stops. He kisses my clit one last time before he gets up and sits on the couch next to me.

"Layla?"

I sit up as I take my leggings from Luca.

"Yes, Corbin?"

"That was hot. Just... yeah, hot."

I laugh and see he's genuine. His eyes are less dark. More lust and excitement now.

"Can you guys fuck, now?"

"Dude."

Corbin quickly stands. Furrowing his brow in frustration.

"Look. I'm hard, you're hard, and she's wet. I promise I won't leave the couch and I'll be quiet."

I put my leggings on the coffee table. The boys bicker back and forth. Both standing. Erections on full display.

"I didn't touch myself the entire time you went down on her. I should be able to jerk off while you fuck."

"Bro, it's weird."

"I'll never ask again."

Here's the thing about when I have an orgasm. I usually want another one.

I reach out and wrap my hand around Luca's cock still in his pants. I run my thumb over the head a couple times.

He looks down at my hand and holds my wrist.

"Layla, we don't have to do this."

"Just this once. We've done plenty. It's kinda the only thing left."

I'm slowly stroking and rubbing as we talk. I feel precum dampen his shorts. He hasn't stopped me and already let go of my wrist.

"Take your pants off, Luca."

"Oh, fuck yeah!"

We look over and Corbin is sitting on the love seat with his hand in his pants.

I point at him and give a stern look.

"You. No more talking. Minimal noise. Got it?"

He nods and sits back. A satisfied grin on his face. He's slowly stroking waiting for Luca to accept what's happening.

Luca drops his shoulders and his head falls back. He sighs heavily.

"If you want to do this, you have to take them off."

He gives me a wink and his pants are on the floor. Along with his boxer briefs. He takes care of his shirt on his own.

"Someone is eager."

I lay back on my elbows and spread my legs.

"I'm still sensitive. This will feel amazing if you hurry up."

Luca kneels over me and leans in for a long kiss. Our tongues caress each other as I feel the head of his cock spreading my lips.

I moan into his mouth as he slides his cock up and down my pussy. Bucking my hips forward hoping he'll slip in.

"Please, Luca." I moan into his ear.

He moans back as he pushes inside me. I take all of him and barely have a chance to react before he thrusts into me again. This time, a little harder.

I ignore the moans from the loveseat. That's easy to do when Luca's cock stretches my pussy with every thrust.

He lifts my top and my nipple is quickly in his mouth. I wrap my legs around Luca as he thrusts deeper. Running my fingers through his hair. Gently pulling when he sucks my nipple.

He moans as I dig my nails into his back. My pussy grips his cock tighter in response.

"Fuck, Layla. You feel so fucking good."

I can see Corbin over Luca's shoulder. Eyes drunk with pleasure. Stroking his cock and massaging his balls.

I'm enjoying his soft moans as my brother reaches down to gently rub my clit with his fingertips. He leans back on to his knees and puts my legs on his shoulders.

Corbin increases speed to match Luca's pace. My legs are starting to shake.

"You going to cum for me again?"

"Mmhmm." Is all I can manage among moans and heavy breathing.

"Be a good sister and cum on my cock."

That's when everything hits me.

Oh my god. I'm fucking my brother. And his best friend is stroking his cock while watching us. And that is making this hotter.

My back arches as he thumbs my clit and fucks me harder.

"Don't stop. Make me cum, Luca! Make... your little sister... cum."

Luca leans forward, slamming deep into me, and that's all I need to completely fall apart.

My pussy tightens around his cock as my moans get even louder. He's holding me in place as I lose complete control.

I'm too connected to Luca to notice Corbin is cumming too. Cum is shooting onto the floor as he strokes.

Luca isn't far behind. His moans growing louder and I feel his cock swelling.

"Cum for me Luca. Cum inside me."

My words are the last thing he hears before letting go. I feel his cock throbbing and then the warm cum filling up my pussy.

"Fuuuuuck, Laylaaaaaaaah."

His thrusting slows and then finally comes to a stop. He gently moves hair out of my face before kissing me one last time.

He slowly slides out and watches as his cum leaks out of me. He uses his shirt to clean things up.

I see Corbin with a satisfied grin on his face.

"See, doesn't everyone feel better?"

I'm about to tell him to shut up when I hear the garage door opening in the distance. I scramble for my phone.

"FUCK!"

Luca grabs his phone and has the same reaction.

"Mom and Dad are home!"