Paradise Prison Pt. 04

[Part 4 of a 5-part story.]

A few weeks into my captivity it seemed like everyone was feeling good. I gotta admit I was kind of getting used to being surrounded by five naked, beautiful women all day and night. Sometimes, it was more like being at a nude beach or something, just bodies and skin. Then I'd notice a very nicely bouncing breast, a stiff nipple, a cute little jiggle in a butt cheek, the perfect curve of a hip, and it would set me off. My dick would get hard again.

The girls got somewhat used to having a naked man around too. It mostly wasn't too different than if I'd been wearing clothes. And then maybe I'd catch one looking at my dick, just her eyes straying to check me out, and I'd be off again. I guess you could say my dick was enjoying all the extra attention.

Of course I did swim out to the wall around our enclosure and take a look for myself. I broke off a piece of a bush and threw it at the black gap high up on the wall to see that it was, in fact, solid. I stared at the dome above us and looked around trying to figure out how the air was recirculated, the water filtered, the heat kept constant. I examined the door in the rock where our food bowls appeared. But I didn't see anything the girls had missed. I couldn't find any clues about our captors or see any way we might make our escape.

And even if we did escape our enclosure, what would be out there? If we really were on another planet, there could be things in that planet's environment that might kill us instantly. Or if we were in some kind of zoo, what good would it do to escape into a society where it seemed extremely likely we would only be captured again in short order? But still we had to try, and we all agreed that we would try, if we found a way, if we thought of a plan.

The sex slowed down a little after the first few days, but somewhat to my surprise, it was only a little. I had some kind of sex, with someone, at least twice every day, and sometimes three or even four times. I thought I was doing a pretty good job of keeping things equal and not playing favorites.

But I'm only human. I did have feelings, even though I tried to keep them to myself. I really liked Kris. She was kind of like the popular girl in high school that all the guys want, but could never get. Not like my personal high school crush, exactly (Kris didn't look anything like Amy Waleski) but that was definitely her general type. And here, with no competition, I finally got the popular girl. The crazy thing was she made me feel like I could have had her no matter where we were.

I really liked Kari too, and the more I got to know her, the more I liked her. She was smart. She had layers. I never knew exactly what to expect, but nine times out of ten it seemed like I was going to be at least a little bit surprised and delighted. She got sexier the more I got to know about her. She seemed like the girl who could probably have whatever she wanted, if she ever decided exactly what that was, and also like she might never, ever decide. But in this place, and at this time, she kind of wanted me, and I more than kind of wanted her.

Elena had a rare beauty. She could have been a pageant queen, or a major porn star, or even both. I had never known anyone so completely comfortable with their sexuality. I didn't dislike her at all, she was just very different from me. She was all feeling and emotion. It's not just that she wasn't an analytical person, it's that she didn't have any patience for analysis. She was all impulse and of the moment. But when you were with her in the moment she could be completely charming, and if you and she shared a moment sexually she could totally knock your socks off.

Jade had fantastic tits, I mean almost certainly the best set out of the bunch. They were nicely sized and held their shape almost miraculously--and they were all natural. When it came to sex, she liked it rough and she liked it raw. If I was in that kind of mood, then that was great. But I wasn't always in that kind of mood. None of us were happy all the time, but Jade was probably in a negative mood the most often. Maybe she just saw the reality of our situation more clearly and had trouble getting past it. She and I got along, but we didn't "click."

Syd was kind of like my bud. She was almost like one of the guys, even though there weren't any other guys around. I felt like we understood each other. Our relationship could probably be best described as "friends with benefits." She and I could have sex and I didn't have to give a second thought to worrying about any emotions from her, or from me. It was just for fun.

Syd really had taken it upon herself to be the group leader, and she was constantly sacrificing herself to maintain harmony. In a way, as the oldest and most experienced, I could have taken on more of a leadership role. And I kind of did in some ways, but it was in partnership with Syd. I respected the hell out of her. She was the leader before I got there. She was doing a great job. For me to try and lead all these younger women would probably be too patriarchal. Without Syd I could easily see how all our relationships could break down into conflicts and petty squabbles.

Since I was also fucking her, it seemed kind of funny to think this, but it also occurred to me that if I'd had a daughter--and I certainly could have had one who would be about Syd's age--I couldn't be prouder than if she'd turned out like Syd. In fact, I thought so highly of Syd, that I even decided to confess a few of my private doubts and feelings.

Syd was, not uncharacteristically, totally straight with me. "We can all see that Kris likes you, and that you like her. Kris might be the only one that's not sure about it, because you're also fucking other girls. But you've gotta keep playing it the way you've been so far, trying not to play favorites."

"Damn. I wasn't sure it was that obvious."

"Jesus, Ben. How old are you? Women know. But what good would it do anyway, to do anything that blew it all into the open? We're trapped here and it doesn't seem like anything's going to change any time soon. Maybe if we got out of here, maybe then you could do something about it, but for now, feelings or no, it's better to keep it all under wraps, at least under that level of surface deniability."

"And Kari?"

"Yeah, what is it with you, Dude? Can't you make up your mind?" She was teasing me. "Kari understands completely what is going on. She knows you and Kris are attracted to each other, and she knows she and you are too. And she also knows nothing good could come out of changing anything up right now. She can handle it. And hopefully you can too. You better handle it. If you can't, she might even lose respect for you."

"Do you think the other girls can see it with Kari and I, the way they can with Kris?"

"Not as clearly, that's for sure. Kari's harder to read, and she presents a little bit of a different front to each of us. They might suspect. I suspected. But I don't think they 'know.' Kris is more of a threat to all of them. They're all jealous of Kris. Kris is the kind of girl they lose a guy to, and the kind of girl they can never be."

"Thank you, Syd. You really are great for this group. I don't know what they'd do without you, or what I'd do without you."

"Well don't speak too soon. You haven't heard my idea for what I think we should try next."

"Oh." I laughed. "What's that?"

"I've been thinking about what Jade suggested, how we should 'torture' you, and by that I mean no girl does anything with you sexually, then we see how long you can hold out."

"Oh great!" She could tell I was being sarcastic.

"No, I think it will help to sort of re-bond us girls. But I wanted to run it by you first, because you have to promise me you won't cheat. I like to think nobody would, but if one of them tried to do something with you on the side, I want your word, just between you and me, that you won't allow it. What do you think?"

"I can see the appeal, but how long do you think we might be talking about here?"

"Oh, not more than a month or so." She waited for my response. I didn't give her one, so she broke. "I tease! Seriously, probably not more than a few days. Really, you can control it. If one of the girls tries to cheat with you, just make sure you make enough noise about it that we can all join in. Or, if that doesn't happen, but you just feel like you've had enough, then you admit defeat and jack off in front of all of us, kind of like a little show."

"Okay. That's a deal. I can see where that could be kind of fun, and change up the dynamic a bit too. When do we start this?"

"I'll put it out there tonight after dinner."

True to her word, that's exactly what she did.

"Ben," she started out by talking to me, but in a voice that let everyone know she was addressing the entire group. "I bet you think we're all just a bunch of horny little sluts who can't keep our legs closed no matter what--and I can see how we might have given you that impression--but I bet you that any girl here, every girl here, can hold out without sex longer than you can."

"Speak for yourself, Sydney!" Elena offered. "I for one am proud to be a horny little slut." The rest of the girls laughed.

"But even you, Lena, could hold out longer than Mr. Man here, couldn't you?"

"Longer than Ben? He can't go two hours without getting a hard-on! I'd give him two days, at most, before he'd be begging for some relief."

"What do you think, Ben? Do you think you can hold out longer than two days, surrounded by all this irresistible beauty, all this raw, untamed sexuality? Syd gestured at her own gorgeous body, and the others, and twirled around.

"I'm sure I could do at least two days. Remember I didn't have sex for 8 months before coming here."

"I'm not just talking about no sex. This includes masturbation. And no touching, no kissing, no licking, nothing. And that goes for both boys and girls. Who can hold out the longest, us or you?"

"I say me, definitely." Honestly, I wasn't that confident, but I was playing my role for the team.

"Hahahaha." Peals of laughter spread throughout the group.

"What does the winner get? What does the loser lose?" Elena wanted details.

"It's all against all, not just boy vs. girls. But we know it really kind of is boy vs. girls. So the loser has to put on a private masturbation show for the rest of the group, no help from anybody, just get yourself off while everybody watches. But we all know that's going to be Ben, don't we girls?"

"That's right." More laughter.

"How do we know nobody will cheat?" asked Jade.

"Well this is a pretty small island. There aren't many places to hide, and we've all got pretty good ears, so if you cheat a lot, we're probably gonna know, but there is a little bit of the honor system to this too."

Elena then said, "You'll know if I cheat, because without sex, I'm gonna be bitchy. If I turn back into my normal, sweet self, then you'll know I cheated." Everyone laughed at that.

"I'm in," Kari said.

"Me too," said Kris. Lena and Jade agreed, and then so, officially, did Syd and I. We all pinky swore on it.

"Starting when?" someone asked.

"Starting now."

As the contest progressed, the girls really enjoyed teasing me. They would try to catch my eye by stretching to show off their breasts, or just generally make sensual movements whenever possible. They bent over in front of me to "pick things up," or played with their hair or with their fingers around their mouths. Then they'd giggle at each other and at me, conspiratorially. They loved to make me squirm, and if they could see my dick getting hard, then they just dialed up the pressure even more.

Their verbal assault was relentless too. "I'm hungry. I sure wish I had something to suck on," or, "My pussy is so wet today. How 'bout you, (Jade or Lena or Kris or Syd or Kari), isn't your pussy wet right now?" Then they'd follow that up with something like, "Oh yes, and so hot and tight too!" And then there was, "Kris, (or whomever) what do you like most about Ben's cock?" which they would then follow up with these long, detailed descriptions about how big I was, or how hard I could get or how much they loved the taste of my cum or to feel me cumming inside them. It went on and on, and they could get me hard every time. Any woman talking like that would probably get a man hard, but when there's five of them, and they're all naked and gorgeous, I had basically no chance, and they knew it.

I called foul when they tried to squeeze their own breasts while washing up. I won that battle, but lost the one where they decided to all practice their yoga poses. I made it two days, but I was climbing the walls. My dick was basically hard all the time. Everyone could see it. It was torture to be honest. They must have been adding something to our food. I should have been able to make it longer. But the morning of the third day, after a completely sleepless night of fighting it, I conceded defeat.

"Woohoo! A show, a show, we're going to get a show!" Elena was excited.

Syd said, "Time to put up, Ben. Do you want to do it now, or wait until after breakfast?"

"Now is good. I fucking can't stand it anymore. Then maybe after, I can enjoy my breakfast in peace."

"And we can all get a little protein supplement," added Jade.

"So do it, Ben. Do it and we'll watch. Show us how you make yourself cum."

"Where do we want him to cum?" asked Kari.

"You can cum right here, Ben." Jade opened her mouth wide and stuck out her tongue.

Kris commented, "Oh you'd like that, wouldn't you. I think he's got to cum all over himself, all up his chest, and we can lick it off, like that time Kari jerked him."

"Yeah, that's good. But take turns this time, so nobody gets more than anyone else," suggested Syd.

"Yeah, turns is good." Elena agreed.

Syd brought it back to me. "Okay, Ben. We're waiting..."

So I did it. I put on a show for them. I sat on that step where I could lean back. I spread my legs. I let my cock stand up straight and hard, trying to show for them as big as I could. "I'm sorry ladies, you've all done such a great job of priming the pump, I don't expect this will take very long," I said. I had a drop of precum showing, so I spread it around the crown slowly, and edged myself quickly up to maximum hardness. I pressed down around the base and waved my cock in the air. I watched their eyes. Mostly, they were glued to my cock.

Five naked women, all staring at my cock, and all up close, each not more than two feet away from it. That gave me quite a charge. I started to stroke, slowly at first. I stopped to squeeze and edge some more. Enough of that. The urge told me to go for it. I started stroking again, a little faster, a little harder. No need to go super-fast. Nice and steady. I felt it building. I looked around me. I'd kissed each one of them. I'd eaten them. I'd fucked them. All of them had sucked this cock. All of them had tasted my cum. Mine was the only cock left in their world now. This was all for them. I closed my eyes and let it fly.

I heard them all gasp with delight. I felt my body relax as hot, heavy drops fell on my forehead, my cheek, my collarbone and chest and belly. I didn't open my eyes until it was almost done. I let my cock fall, half limp, and set my arms down by my sides. I just laid there, and waited for them. Each in succession, they licked it all up. I don't even know who was first or who got which. I only saw that Kari got my cheek. She kissed me after. And then it was done.

"So Ben, you have to tell us. When you came, who were you thinking of?" Jade was teasing me.

"All of you," I answered. "The five most beautiful women in the world."

"Liar... suckup... we don't believe you." I heard the accusations flying, but they were good-natured, still teasing me.

"I bet it was..." Somehow, I knew Elena was going to name Kris. But then she gave it a second thought, and paused. "Me," she said.

"You wish!" said Syd. There was more laughter. "How long 'till you can go for two?" she asked.

I started to answer, then said, "Wait, I think you've all been holding out as long as I have." Almost instantly, it seemed like everyone was on everyone else. Every mouth found a nipple, a clit, my cock, something to lick. Every pussy found a finger or a tongue. Hands and tits, asses and legs and arms were everywhere. It was a huge tangle at first, and then it sorted itself out. I ended up kissing Syd, and massaging her breasts while Elena ate her out. Kris was sucking my cock. Everybody came, and then we shifted around, and everybody came again. Me too. I came in Kris's mouth, and then Jade's. I got Kari off with my fingers. I got Elena off with my tongue. We all had breakfast late that day.

After breakfast Kari grabbed me and led me around to the other side of the waterfall. That's where we were most likely not to be overheard by the others.

"Well Mr. Man, Ben, I'm pretty sure you've gone and done it."

"I have? What have I done?"

"It was probably only a matter of time, and it looks like I'm the winner." She looked straight into my eyes. "It's only fair that you should know first. Ben... I'm pregnant. I'm pretty sure I'm pregnant."

I was surprised, of course, but not completely shocked. "You're sure?"

"Pretty sure. I'm at least two weeks late. I'm usually very predictable."

"Wow... Kari..." I kissed her. I waited half a second. I kissed her again. Finally she kissed me back. Then she really kissed me, and I could feel the hope there, and the fear, and maybe a little happiness too.

"Maybe it's stupid to say. I know this is far, far, from the ideal situation. But I'm actually kind of happy. And I'm glad it's you. I'm really glad it's you. Don't take that the wrong way. I'm sure you know I have special feelings for you, different from the others. I had to work to hide them. I had to work so hard. But now maybe I don't have to hide it anymore."

I tried to read her, but she still had that deep veil of mystery. I was getting a little scared, but I tried to project confidence. "We can do this. I know it won't be easy, but also I know everyone will help. We can do this, together, you and I. We can do this."

"What about Kris?"

"What about her?"

"You love her too. I know that you do."

"I don't love her." I started to deny it, but then I thought better. "Maybe I do, in a way, but certainly not any more than I love you. And I do love you. You must know it. You must feel it."

"I do. I know it's complicated here. It's weird. And I'm in love with you too. Honestly, I don't know if I would still be in love with you if you weren't the only boy in the world, but you are, and I do. God help me I do. I do love you. And now I'm going to have your baby, our baby, here!" She started to break down. I held her tight.

We had broken away from the group without explanation. I could feel their prying eyes were on us. They kept their distance, but they were looking. Then Kari felt them too. "We have to tell them."

"I know. Can you do it? Please, Ben? Do this for me, please?"

"Of course." I grabbed Kari's hand and we walked through the shallow water back over to the other side of the pool, where, standing by the bank, everyone was waiting. Nobody said anything. They didn't know what this was, but they knew it was no joke."

"Kari's pregnant." I simply announced it. Nobody said anything as we watched reality sink in for each of them. I looked at Syd, thinking she would be the one, but she didn't say anything. I don't know where it came from, but then I said the first stupid thing to lighten the mood that popped into my head. "And you're all invited to the shower."

That got a smile at least, and a couple of chuckles. "Wow," Syd said. "Kari, Ben, congratulations."

Then everyone else echoed it. "Congratulations... congratulations... wow... a baby... a baby!" It seemed like everyone was, at the same time, happy, and also sad. And I gotta say, I think that was the right reaction. I looked at Kris. She smiled at me. She smiled at Kari. She said the same stuff as the others, but I could tell she was at least partly faking it. My heart broke for her.

Everybody repeated the same dance of "are you sure?... how do you know?... and don't worry, we'll help you." They also added in "it could have been any of us," and "it still might be." We had all kind of wondered if maybe we'd been sterilized or something when they did whatever they did that took our pubic hair. We had all known this might happen. But we had all also just thrown caution to the wind. "Live for today" had been our ethic, even if nobody stated it. Why not? We had no reason to believe in tomorrow.

But now maybe we did. Things were going to change. That much was certain. But what would change, exactly? How much? Why? I felt like I had to talk to Syd, but also I had to talk to Kari. Also, I had to talk to Kris, but definitely Kari and Syd first.

"I don't know what kind of life this is, to bring a child into," I said when I got to talk to Kari, "but it's what we have, and we've got to make the best of it. We still have hope. We don't know what the future will bring, or when, but we still have hope, and until then we just make the best of what we've got and do the best we can."

"I know you're right," she said. "You've got to keep an eye on me, Ben. Don't let me get too down if I start to get depressed. It's going to be so hard, but we just can't give in to that, for the baby we just can't. Even if this is some kind of a zoo, and even if they're trying to breed us, we can still build and hope for some better future, somehow, someday when we'll have freedom. And if we don't live to see it, then maybe our child will. We could even be starting it all over here, like Adam and Eve, or more like Adam and Eve and Kris, and Syd, and Elena and Jade." Kari gave a little laugh.

I laughed with her, a little. "I won't let you down. I promise. I can do this. We can do this." Yes, I had some private doubts, but I knew at this moment it was important to stay positive for her.

"I've been thinking about something else, too," Kari said.

"Oh. What's that?"

"This doesn't mean you have to stop having sex with the other girls. I know that probably sounds weird, but we're in a weird situation here. It's not fair to them if I try to keep you all to myself. You'd probably resent me if I tried to. And for all we know one of them might already be pregnant too. In fact I hope another one does get pregnant. Our baby is going to need someone to play with."

"I hadn't been worried about what would happen with the others. Really I hadn't."

"Well I'm pretty sure you would have thought of it sooner or later. I know they probably already have." Kari laughed again, and again I joined her.

This was all super fucking weird. But this was my life now. Just gotta try and get through it the best way I can, for myself and for those around me.

So after a few days, that's basically how it settled in. We had a kind of honeymoon period where Kari was pregnant, but still not showing. She felt good, no morning sickness or anything. We each gave her a small bit of our food so she'd have extra, and then soon they started giving us two larger bowls, as if somehow they knew.

The sex went pretty much back to normal, back like it was before. Syd agreed with what Kari and I had decided. It seemed like the best way, really the only way. As for how the sex might change if at some point in the future we had little kids running around, well that was still far enough in the future that we decided we didn't have to make any decisions about it yet. The girls took good natured bets on who would be the next to get pregnant. They settled on Elena, because she had "child bearing hips."

One day the girls decided they wanted to have a blowjob contest, to settle a more or less friendly, good natured argument over "who sucks best?" I didn't want any part of playing favorites, or causing resentment, at least where I was concerned, so I suggested a pussy eating contest instead.

"Been there, done that," they said. They'd held those before I arrived, both blindfolded (hands over eyes), and eyes open. Lena won both. I could tell that losing still kind of miffed Syd, and she liked contests, so she suggested a different one.

"We've all sucked your cock, anyway, and we've all seen each other do it, so how about if we do it blindfolded (with a girl holding her hands over your eyes), but this time each girl has to try and duplicate somebody else's technique? And your job, Ben, is to try and guess who it really is?"

"So like you try to do it Kari-style, try to make me think it's Kari, and if I guess it's Kari, do I win or do I lose?"

"You lose, unless you guess that it's me. Then you win. If you guess it was Kari, then I win. If you guess anyone else, it's a draw. So mathematically at least, everyone has a one in six chance."

"Blindfolded works against Kari, her game is all in the eyes," said Jade.

"Maybe not ALL in the eyes..." teased Kari.

Everyone laughed. "Okay. Let's try it!" Elena said.

"Sitting or standing?" Kris asked.

"Sitting, so Jade can reach his eyes."

Everyone laughed again, and without further ado, it was on.

I sat down with all five behind me, so I couldn't see whose hands were supplying the "blindfold." My cock started to get hard in anticipation.

"Do we have a time limit?"

"Let's do the song again."

"Good idea."

I felt hands cover my eyes. I didn't even try to peek, though. I felt someone kneel between my legs. The rhythm started up, three pairs of hands clapping it out. I felt another pair of hands around my cock and balls.

I was thinking the first girl was going to probably be either Syd, or Lena. They were usually the quickest to jump into things. As the song started I heard Lena's voice right behind my head for the first few words, until she caught herself and stopped. The girl in front of me took my cock in her mouth. Only three were singing it, but they were so practiced, so together, that I couldn't make out individual voices.

So I gave up that effort and tried to focus on my cock. This girl was giving long licks up the shaft, from base to tip. Kari and Kris both did that. Then she took the head in and teased under it with tongue while her hand twisted and stroked on the shaft. Elena and Kris both did that.

Suddenly it was over. The girl in front got up, and as soon as she had a chance to move away, the hands came off my eyes.

"Do I guess now, or wait until the end?" I couldn't be sure, but I was thinking it was Syd who had blown me first.

"You have to wait, or else you'll be able to narrow it down."

"Oh yeah. Okay. That makes sense." Everyone knew that Jade had the most "aggressive" technique, and she could deepthroat almost effortlessly. I was wondering if any of the others would be bold enough to try to imitate her.

No sooner had I thought it than the second girl was on me, and she was going for it. Maybe a little bit slower than Jade, but she tried to take me all in right from the start. She almost made it, but gagged on that last push deeper into her throat. After that she just wrapped her fist around my shaft and started jerking while she sucked my head.

So number two was probably not Jade, but other than that, I wasn't sure.

Then the third girl tried the same, she also went straight for the deep throat, and she got it! After her head sucking and shaft jerking, back to back with number two, I was feeling it. One more of those and I thought I might cum, and not even make it to number five.

Number four went back to the twisting motion with her hands, and a lot more kissing, teasing approach around the head, ending with her tongue teasing the underside while she sucked just the tip.

These were only two minute samples. Usually I can hold out longer, but for some reason that had me going. I was feeling it pretty good. Then number five came in. She cupped my balls in one hand, not an unusual move, and then as she took my head in her mouth and started bobbing, Kris, that beautiful little cheater, gave me a little one finger tickle down toward my taint. Nobody could see it, but we both knew that was something that only she did.

I decided to join in the conspiracy, and I gave myself permission to cum. She jerked on the bottom half and sucked on the top with a steady, rapid pace. I could feel it building as the song drew to a close. They came to the ending chant, "go get it, go get it, go get it.." and then I gave it to her, all of it.

There were gasps and then laughter as I continued to spasm, and she continued to suck to get it all even after the the chanting ended and the game was over. Never before in one of our games had anyone broken me on round one like that.

"I guess Ben wins that game!" I heard Lena joke, and the hands fell away from my eyes. I opened them to see Kris, backing away from me, laughing too as cum escaped her mouth and rolled down her chin.

"Kris too!" added Jade, and the laughter continued.

"Okay... well, Ben, how about guessing one through four?" Syd asked once the laughter had died down.

"Wow. I don't know. I really don't know, but I'm going to have to guess... Syd number one, Kari number two, Lena three, and Jade four. How'd I do?"

"Oooh. Loser!" Syd exclaimed.

"I was first," said Jade, with a smile.

"Me second," said Lena. "Sorry Ben, not my best effort. I know I can do it. YOU know I can do it!" Everybody laughed. We all knew she was right.

"Me three, Ben," said Kari. I should have known she could deep throat, even though I don't think she had ever done that to me before then. I smiled my appreciation, which she seemed to graciously accept.

"And I was four." Syd closed it out.

"Sorry for ruining the game, girls," Kris said.

"No worries. It's all in good fun. Did you have fun, Ben?"

"So much fun."

Everyone laughed again. Kris gave me a little winner's kiss. We shared a conspiratorial glance, and a tiny little secret no one suspected. Those were good times.

And then our world changed again.

Kris might have found me on my first day, but it was Jade who found Eddie.

It happened in basically the same way. We woke up one morning. Everything seemed normal. Jade had wandered down to the beach, then we heard her call us. "Girls! Ben! It's a man. It's another man!"

We ran to her voice and as we got there she was bent over him and we heard her say, "Or is it a boy? My God, how old IS he?"

Eddie had just turned 18 about three months before. He was about an inch or so shorter than me, and I probably outweighed him by 50 lbs. I was about 190. This kid was skinny. Being skinny made his dick look bigger. The girls noticed that right away, but in fact with time we came to learn I had him by almost an inch there too. No matter. The new kid was in pussy paradise.

He didn't seem like a bad kid, just young and kinda dumb. That's really not fair to him. He wasn't dumb, but he was basically pretty average. As the default "father figure" I had to kind of take him under my wing and help him get situated with us. Syd was only too happy to pass this part off to me. Truth is, all the girls were a little wary of a naked 18-year-old guy. They had experience with dumbass young guys. Kris was only about a year-and-a-half older, but she seemed far more mature. In fact, she kind of almost immediately gave Eddie the cold shoulder.

"Hey, what's with this girl, Kris, man?" Eddie asked me late on his first day. "I mean, she's super hot, just like the rest of 'em, and she's closest to my age, but she's not nice like the others."

"I don't know, Eddie. Who the hell can say why a girl likes you, or doesn't? I'm 48 and I still can't always figure it out. Just be cool. Don't come on too strong. If it happens, it happens. If it doesn't, you still got at least three that I can almost guarantee are going to fuck you like you never even dreamed."

"No shit?"

"No shit." I laid it out for him. "It's like this: We're all naked, all of us, all day, every day. We think there's something in the food that makes us all extra horny. First they had no cocks here, then they had me. Now they have two of us. They still got us outnumbered by a lot. Basically, the girls are running the show here. But if you play it cool, don't come on too strong, and don't play favorites, you're gonna get all the pussy you can handle."

"Hey I don't need no drugs, man. I can get it up anytime I want. With my girlfriend back home I can cum like five times a night." I figured he was probably exaggerating, but I remember 18, and had no doubt he could probably out do me.

"Like I said. It's in the food. We've got no choice. And we don't know if it's drugs or whatever. We've got basically nothing to do here except fuck. And just so you know, Kari is pregnant."

"Whoah. So are you saying she's like, yours? Hands off?"

"You can take that up with her. That's her decision, but if she tells you no, I wanted you to know she might have her reasons, OK?"

"Sure, man. Lady's choice. I got my girlfriend back home pregnant too, but she took care of it."

"Well that's not an option here."

"Cool."

"Look, Eddie. We're all of us stuck here, together. We have to get along, OK? Despite lots of stresses, it's been OK, so if it all goes bad now, everyone's going to blame you. I'm telling you, play it cool."

"I got it, boss."

"I'm not your boss. Think of me more like a much older brother, OK?"

"Sure Ben."

"And here's another little tip. You'll figure this all out eventually, but Jade likes it hard, even a little bit rough. That's not my natural speed, so you've got a real chance to make a good first impression with her. And Elena, if you pay attention, she'll teach you things, you hear?"

"Yeah. Thanks for the tips. And Kris?"

"Kris is a real sweet, real nice girl. She's probably most like that girl in your high school that all the guys wanted, but nobody got because she had a rich college boyfriend. You still might not get her."

"And Sydney?"

"Syd is super smart. She can be fun if you keep it casual. Let her know you're in it just for fun. At least that's my experience. I mean, you do you, but that's my best advice."

Later that night, after dinner, Syd, Elena, and Jade all took Eddie down to the camp and broke him in. Kari, Kris and I stayed away. We went and slept on the beach to be as close as possible to being out of earshot. I was happy Kris wanted to be with us, and I was maybe even more happy Kari seemed just fine with it.

I told both girls they were perfectly free to go and sample Eddie, but I don't think they really believed I felt that way. They both said they weren't interested at all in Eddie, and they'd rather be with me. I tried to play it cool but sometimes I'm a bad actor. I'm pretty sure they could tell that I was pretty damn happy about it.

So that's how it happened. Just like that our group was split. When it came to group sex, our group had been a fragile, special thing. Syd had done a great job of keeping us all together, even though there were strains. How much longer could we have kept it going if Eddie hadn't showed up? It's impossible to say.

Kari, Kris, and I still got along with the others, we just didn't have sex with them any more. The girls didn't cross over at all either. I guess it took a whole set of weird, improbable circumstances for six people to sync up sexually. Then things changed. None of us regretted what we'd done together, but it was time to move on.

I was happy with my 40% of the island female population, and Syd, Elena and Jade seemed to keep Eddie pretty well occupied. Jade for sure was the happiest any of us could ever remember seeing her. The doggystyle jackhammer was Eddie's favorite way to fuck, so that suited Jade just fine. I heard them go at it a few times. Even at my peak I don't think I could have fucked a woman as fast and hard as Eddie. Jade almost ignored me after Eddie showed up.

Even after Eddie arrived, Elena sometimes came up and kissed me. She'd swat me on the ass or grab my cock playfully now and then. She was still, of course, damn sexy when she turned it on. She could get me hard. She was letting me know the door was still open, but I never walked through it.

Eddie did try to make a play for both Kris and Kari and one time or another, but both shot him down, and then let everyone know about it. Eddie knew he had to stay in line or else risk complete ostracism. It wasn't really a threat, but I did happen to drop the thought that no single one of us could ever get too far out of line, because if it got bad enough, the other six would certainly be strong enough to drown the one.

Syd was kind of the bridge between the two camps. From Elena I got a sense, but Syd basically confirmed that Eddie was just a fucktoy to them. He could get it up and cum six times a day, but they could easily get tired of him. Sometimes he just went down to the beach and sat in the water alone. I kind of felt sorry for him a little. He couldn't really help being young and dumb.

Syd was still my bud. We still talked. We just didn't fuck anymore. That was OK by me, and I think mostly OK by her too. Although I would occasionally flatter myself into thinking she probably liked me more than Eddie it might be more accurate to say she liked us differently. She took me more seriously, but as just a good time, Eddie was probably less demanding, easier to forget reality with.

The last time we fucked it was as kind of a bridge between the two camps. Syd told us it was her birthday. Of course we had no way of knowing when anyone's real birthday was, but we decided to humor her. She said what she wanted for her birthday was to get spitroasted. Kari and Kris said it was OK. They said I didn't need their permission. I knew I didn't need it, but it was nice to have it anyway.

Syd sat down on my cock, reverse cowgirl, while she blew Eddie, standing in front of her. Then we switched and she bent over the highest step for support while Eddie railed her from behind and she sucked my cock. After Eddie came inside her, he and Elena switched and while Elena sucked the cum out of her, Syd jerked me off into her mouth, and then swallowed it all herself. It might have been the first time I saw her take something for herself without sharing. Kris and Kari watched us, but it felt weird, for everyone.

The very next morning our world changed again.

Next: The captives get some answers, and a new beginning.