Fetish App with Little Sister Pt. 03

Kelly and I walked back to the house, pits in our stomachs, both on the verge of throwing up. What was waiting for us in that house? Who was watching us from Kelly's room window? Was it really someone watching? Or was it just the A/C unit blowing the curtain? I'd never seen our A/C do that to my curtains before, but maybe there was a vent right under Kelly's window that I never saw before? And even if it was just the A/C, how quickly would the Michaelsons send a text to mom and dad letting them know what was on their security camera? I wanted to trick myself into thinking the camera quality was poor enough that I could lie to my parents and say that it was me and Jessica, but it was the same system I had helped dad install this past summer... and I had seen the video quality of those cameras before. They would be able to make out, very clearly, the two faces of the siblings who live next door - fucking each other in their jacuzzi.

I looked at Kelly as we snuck back into the house. She was shaking and crying. I grabbed her hand.

"It's going to be ok Kelly" I lied. "I promise. Everything will be fine."

We quietly walked back up the stairs and I followed Kelly into her room. I had to see if there was a vent or something that could have moved that curtain. I had to know, before I got back into bed with Jessica, if she had been watching us. The pit in my stomach sunk even further down when, of course, no vent was anywhere near the window. The heater was on and the vents in her room were blowing hot air out of them, and the curtains were standing perfectly still. Someone had seen us.

I grabbed Kelly, and brought her in for a hug. I stroked the back of her head and kissed her on the cheek.

"Everything is going to be ok sis."

I pulled back and gave her a loving kiss on her lips, not knowing if that would be the last time we could do that. Our little incestuous affair was potentially about to blow up this family, and I wanted one last moment of peace and love with Kelly. She kissed me back, hard and firm, not wanting to part. She knew what I knew - that when this kiss was over, we would have to face reality.

I snuck out of her room and back into mine, my hand shaking at the door knob. The room was dark and quiet. Jessica laid in bed, appearing to be asleep, so I quietly got in next to her and laid there, eyes wide open, for hours.

- - - - - - - - -

The sun came up, and I had been able to get maybe an hour of sleep. I looked over at Jessica, who to my surprise was no longer laying in bed with me. I sat up quickly, wondering if she had grabbed her bags and left in the middle of the night. They were still there in the corner of the room. I got up and checked the bathroom, but no Jessica. I went to the other side of the Jack and Jill bathroom and opened the door to peek into Kelly's room. Kelly was sitting on the edge of her bed and looked over at me when I opened the door.

"Do you know where Jessica is?" I whispered.

"No...?" She replied. "Did she say anything last night?"

"No..."

We both made our way downstairs and found mom making breakfast in the kitchen.

"Mom, have you seen Jessica?" I asked.

"Yes, she went for a run, I believe."

Kelly and I took a breath. Maybe that was a good sign? Going for a run sounded perfectly normal... something I know Jessica did often. Maybe she actually didn't see us... I hoped.

"How about dad?"

"He's in the shower. Breakfast will be ready soon!"

I walked past Kelly and uttered under my breath, "I'm going to go check his phone."

I ran down the hall to the master bedroom and quietly snuck into mom and dad's room. I could hear dad in the shower in their bathroom. I walked up to the dresser and grabbed his phone. No notifications. I knew his passcode, so I helped myself into it. No messages from Mr. Michaelson. Ok, I thought, still in the clear there. My heart was racing. What would be the first domino to fall?

As I walked back down the hallway, I just missed Jessica returning from her run and heading upstairs. I had to bite the bullet. I had to go talk to her. I walked past Kelly and we gave each other a look, as if she was saying 'good luck' to me. I thought I was about to throw up. I hadn't felt like this since I got sent to the principal's office in grade school for getting in a fight, knowing the school had called my mom.

I walked upstairs and into my room. Jessica was just pulling off her panties and was butt naked, covered in sweat, all red from her exercise. She was about to jump into the shower. She made eye contact with me and pulled her earbuds out. There was no smile... no smirk... no real emotion whatsoever. Something was different.

She walked up to me and stopped, tears forming in her eyes.

"Babe...?"

Before I could continue, she slapped me across the face. Hard. She turned and went into the bathroom and closed the door behind her. As I heard the shower turn on, I knew the storm had hit.

I slowly made my way into the bathroom, head down and full of shame.

"Baby, let me explain, please."

"Get out!" She barked. "I don't even know what to say to you!"

"I get that..."

"You get that?" She yelled. "Which part do you get? The part where my boyfriend fucks his little sister?! Or the part where my boyfriend, who I thought was my whole world, cheated on me."

I opened the shower door and grabbed her to look at me.

"You have every right to be mad... and I'm assuming... freaked out. This all just happened. I don't know how to explain it. It just... was a freak thing that just happened a couple days ago and... it's crazy! I know! And I'm sorry."

"Sorry!?" She pushed me away and closed the shower door, turning back to the stream. "Fuck you! I should leave. I should leave YOU! You know what? I should tell your fucking mom."

I saw red. It was all ending. Not just me and Jessica... but my life as I knew it. I couldn't reason with her... how could anybody reason with finding their partner fucking their sibling. This was insane! I only had one card to play, and I decided to play it. The thing Jessica couldn't resist... being dominated. I stripped down naked and got into the shower.

"Get the fuck ou...." I shoved my hand over her mouth.

"Listen to me right fucking now." I took control of her and the situation and held her firmly against the tile wall. "I'm sorry. The last 48 hours... dammit... I can't fucking explain it. Everything about my relationship with Kelly exploded into this insanity, and it drove us both wild, and I'm sorry. I know it's fucked up. And I know it's probably the thing that destroys this relationship. But..."

I stood there, still holding her against the wall, her breathing elevated and her eyes looking at me, almost scared.

"Dammit, Jessica. I don't know what to tell you... I can stop. We can stop. I'll never touch her again and I can still be yours. Or..."

Her breathing seemed to pause as she looked down. I hadn't realized it, but I was fully erect, driving my cock into her belly. She looked back up at me. I let go of her, defeated - not sure what I could, or even wanted to say.

"Or what?" She asked.

I looked deeply into her eyes. She could see the pain in mine.

"Or... you could give me a chance to explain this to you, and maybe..."

"Maybe what?" She asked, curious where I was going with this.

"... maybe share it with you."

"What do you mean?" She asked, clearly intrigued enough to hear me out.

"You know... maybe... like Lillian."

Lillian was a girl Jessica and I met at a bar some time ago. She was a senior in high school and newly 18. She had snuck into the bar with her boyfriend, who broke up with her and left her there alone. Jessica and I took her under our wing, bought her a couple more rounds to cheer her up, and eventually took her home with us. That night, we made Lillian our play thing. Something primal came out in Jessica - and myself - that was completely unspoken and never premeditated. We just both understood, in that moment, that this little innocent girl was ours to do with what we wanted. Ever since then, we referred to Lillian as our pet "unicorn"... almost as if we owned her in that moment. Jessica would tell her to perform certain acts on me. I would tell her to perform certain acts on Jessica. She was wildly obedient. That night, the three of us fucked for hours and Jessica and I used her in any and every way we wanted. It felt like we were royalty in the olden days, playing with some peasant girl we found on the side of the road... like the rules didn't apply to us. It was one of the more wild nights Jessica and I ever had together, and we often looked back on it fondly. Tragically, we never saw Lillian again after that night. She was a taste of the forbidden apple that we never found again. Jessica and I would often daydream together about finding another unicorn, someone subservient to our relationship that we could both use for our sexual desires - either together or separately. When I wanted to fuck Jessica on nights when she was distracted or not in the mood, she'd say things like 'THIS is why we need a Lillian!' In this moment with Jessica in the shower... hat in hand and tail between my legs... it was the fantasy of a 'Lillian' that was all I had to fall back on to hope this would work out.

There was a long canyon of silence before she responded.

"You want to make your sister our unicorn?"

"What if we did? Could you see past the sibling aspect? Maybe we can redefine our sibling relationship completely... make her our play thing?"

There was another large silence before Jessica reached up her hand and grabbed my hard cock, still poking into her belly. Her attitude had shifted from furious betrayal to curious arrousal.

"Show me" she said.

She stepped up on the edge of the tub and climbed up around my body. She grabbed my head by my chin, hard.

"Show me how you can make Kelly into aLillian." She looked at me with a level of severity and sternness I hadn't seen in her eyes before. "Show me how this works for BOTH of us... how this remains a secret FOREVER... and show me why I should even CONSIDER something so fucking insane!"

She reached down and pulled my cock up into her pussy and slid down on it.

"Explain it to me" she said as she fucked herself with my cock.

"What?" I asked, confused as to what the fuck was happening.

"Explain to me how this cock ended up in your sister Danny."

Was she getting off to this? Did it work? Did me offering my little sister as a pet for Jessica work? Clearly, she was mad... she didn't hide that emotion. But was she also turned on?

"I..." I paused and watched her close her eyes and get ready to get off to this story. "I saw her masturbating the other night. I went through her phone and... and I found out she's into incest... at least, it turns her on. She admitted she wanted to fuck her brother... and it turned me on to think about... and so I... snuck into her room the other night and... took her virginity."

Jessica moaned as she listened to my confession, humping and grinding on my cock. I held her up with my hands and began to give it back to her, pounding my cock in her wet pussy.

"How did it make you feel... fucking your little sister?" Her breathing picked up. "How did it feel to fuck the girl you grew up with?"

I leaned down and licked her neck and earlobe and whispered, "Fucking... alive."

"Did you cum in her?" She looked into my eyes.

I nodded, terrified, admitting what I had done.

"Did you taste her?"

I nodded again.

"What did she taste like?"

"Why don't you find out for yourself?" I replied, hoping to further plant the seed in her mind that Kelly could become her play thing too.

"Were you scared?"

"Scared?"

"To fuck your sister...? Did it make you nervous? Did it make you shake? Did you get scared?"

She kept fucking me, and I kept sliding deep inside her, feeling myself build up to an orgasm.

"It was... terrifying... at first. Then it felt... powerful."

"Do you want to fuck her in front of me?"

"Yes... I do. I really do" I said, getting closer and closer.

"Are you going to watch me fuck her? Are you going to watch me cum all over your little sister?"

"Fuck yes baby."

She let out a final moan and came all over my cock, holding in her screams so as to not alert the whole house of what was happening in the upstairs bathroom.

"Fuck Danny!" She let out. "Fuck!"

It was my turn, I grabbed her hips and adjusted her slightly to pick up my speed. I started to feel it coming and got weak in my knees.

"Oh baby! I fucking love you! Fuck. Fuck!" I started to yell, about there.

She shoved me off of her and slapped me in the face again, hard. My hard cock pumping full of blood, waiting to be brought to a climax.

"Then you fucking show me Danny" she said sternly, catching her breath. "Show me how you're going to make this happen... how you're going to make this right."

She got around me and out of the shower and grabbed a towel.

"And don't you EVER fuck another woman behind my back! You got that?!"

With that, she walked out of the bathroom and left me on the precipice of an orgasm that had been completely ruined.

"Fuck!" I shouted, frustratingly.

I grabbed my cock and pumped it vigorously until I came all over the shower floor. It was pathetic, but necessary. If this was the extent of my punishment, I was happy to accept. I just hoped there wasn't more.

----------

When I got out of the shower, dressed and downstairs, Mom, Kelly, Dad and Jessica were eating at the breakfast table. Kelly barely touched her food, likely still sick to her stomach in fear and worry. But Jessica acted totally normal, as if nothing had happened. I walked in and Kelly met my gaze immediately.

"Hey babe! Grab a plate" Jessica said with a smile. She was quite the actress.

As we ate, mom asked me to take Jessica with me to the store to pick up a few things she needed for dinner.

"You know what? Why doesn't Danny take Kelly with him, and you can show me all those old scrapbooks you were telling me about!"

Mom's eyes lit up.

"Oh that's a wonderful idea!"

Jessica knew that, based on our conversation in the shower, I had some explaining to do to Kelly, and clearly she wanted to give her and I some space to have that conversation. Dishes were cleared and coffees were finished and I grabbed my keys and Kelly and I made our way to the car. Once we were clear and out of earshot, she finally exploded in questions.

"What the fuck Danny? What happened?"

"Stay calm" I said, pulling out of our driveway. "It's all going to be ok with Jessica."

"OK?! So she didn't see us?"

"No... she saw us."

"What the fuck!" She yelled, pulling her hair and stressing out.

"But..."

"But? But what!? How are we leaving her alone with mom right now!? Isn't she going to tell her?"

"She's not going to say a thing. There's just... one small caveat."

"I'm waiting..." she said impatiently. "What? Is she blackmailing us?"

"Not exactly. Look. Do you want to keep up what you and I are doing?"

"Danny, are you serious? I think we need to focus on our lives not falling apart... and not your fucking dick. Don't you?"

"No... Kelly... listen to me. If you could, would you want to keep this up... to continue to explore this feeling?"

She stared out the windshield of the car not knowing what the hell I was talking about.

"... yes? I don't know!"

"Yes? Or you don't know?"

"Yes... of course I would. But..." I cut her off.

"Have you ever heard of a 'unicorn'?"

"A what?"

"A unicorn... being a unicorn."

"... no...?"

"It's a person... like a 3rd person... in a relationship. Sort of a submissive... sometimes submissive, I suppose... who is essentially a play thing for the couple. Like... they're a part of the couple... the relationship." I was fumbling all over my words.

"Danny, what are you trying to say?!"

"You would be Jessica and my unicorn. You would be the 3rd in our relationship."

"What?!" She yelled.

"Yeah. That's how this can continue. That's how Jessica doesn't leave me and tell mom and dad... and all my friends... and ruin our lives."

There was silence in the car. She was putting this together, quickly. It intrigued her and confused her at the same time.

"So..." she started. "She wants to watch us fuck or something?"

"Among other things."

"What kinds of other things?"

"She'd want to fuck you too. You would be her play thing as much as you'd be mine."

"Is she bi?" She asked.

"Who isn't bi?" I responded.

After some silent reflection, she added, "But what's in this for me? I'm not a fucking pet Danny."

"Kelly, you will be whatever the fuck Jessica wants you to be, or you and I will be cut off and ostracized from society... is that sinking in? You and I get to continue to explore whatever this is with each other... which I fucking want... obviously... and you also get to fuck Jessica who's hot as shit. What is the problem here?"

She looked out of the car, offended.

"Jessica wants this? Really?"

"Demands it, more like."

----------

We finished the errand and pulled back into the house. Mom and dad were sitting in the living room with Jessica, laughing and looking through photo albums and drinking cocktails very early in the day.

"Hey everyone" I said, nervously, still unsure how volatile Jessica was with this new information.

"Hi baby!" Mom shouted. "Oh honey, thank you for doing that. Can you actually put all the meat in the freezer? We're going to use it tomorrow instead."

"Oh? What are we doing tonight?" I asked.

"Well...." Mom said with a grin. "Jessica gave your dad and I a very lovely - and way too generous - Christmas gift. Your father and I are going downtown tonight to the Intercontinental for a little staycation getaway and spa treatment! So you three are on your own for dinner!"

"Is that so?" I asked, pretending to surprised by Jessica's obviously last-minute devious little plan. What did she have in mind for tonight?

"Thank you again darling" mom said to Jessica, hugging her and kissing her cheek.

"Fun..." I said, locking eyes with Jessica who gave me a very stern look.

----------

3:30 rolled around and mom and dad came out of their room with a suitcase and two big smiles.

"Ok kids, we're off! We'll be back in the morning... probably late morning. You know how your dad loves a hotel breakfast buffet!"

"Ok, have fun!" I said.

"Enjoy yourselves! Don't forget to relax and enjoy your massages!" Jessica added as she closed the door behind them.

The door closed and the house stood perfectly still. Kelly and I stood in the living room, quietly looking towards Jessica for permission to move a muscle. She pressed the door shut and slowly turned towards us with a small grin. She bolted the door locked and slowly walked past us and onto the couch. She sat down, crossed legs and made herself comfortable before letting out her first words.

"Show me" she uttered, calmly.

Kelly looked at me, confused. I just looked at her with an apologetic face and did as I was told. I turned to Kelly, grabbed her face in my hands and pulled her in for a kiss. Her eyes widened, shocked that I was doing this in front of Jessica who sat on the couch grinning, watching her boyfriend begin the process of anointing his little sister as their new unicorn. As I kissed her, I started pulling off her top. She pushed my hands away in protest, but I quickly overpowered her and before she knew it, her top was off. I then unclasped her bra and threw it to the ground. She covered her supple, young breasts quickly, ashamed of exposing herself in front of guests. As I continued kissing her, I unbuttoned her jeans and then pulled them down around her ankles. I squatted down and made her step out of them. I held her waist in my hands, her lacy thong under my fingertips, and pulled her into my face, shoving my nose in her mound and breathing in my sister's intoxicating scent. I kissed her body a few times and then slid her panties down and off. She covered her pussy with one hand while trying to cover as much of both of her breasts as she could with the other. I stood back up and looked over at Jessica, almost asking for her next wishes.

"This is your time... don't worry about me." she said to me. "I'll go next."

Kelly, hearing that, looked at me with a very worried face. She didn't know whether to be scared or not. I held her hands in mine and whispered to her, "Don't worry... just go with it... trust me."

I pulled off my shirt, unbuckled my belt and undid my jeans, letting them - and my boxers - fall to my ankles.

"Why don't you get on your knees" I gently suggested.

"Are you serious...?" She started to ask. "In front of her?"

"Just... trust me Kelly." I replied, pulling her hands down and her body with them.

She knelt down in front of my cock, somewhat flaccid in this awkward situation. She looked over at Jessica who continued to watch from the couch.

"Go ahead," Jessica said. "You didn't have any issues sucking big brother's cock last night..."

Kelly didn't say anything, shocked by the words coming out of her brother's girlfriend's mouth. But she understood the position she was in. It was either this or the world finding out her little incestual secret. She turned back to my cock and nervously reached up and grabbed it in her hand. Just the touch of my little sister's hand on my limp cock shot blood directly into it, filling it up and making it harder and harder. She leaned in, opened her mouth and guided my cock into her throat. I closed my eyes and moaned at the feel of her warm, wet mouth around my hardening cock. She didn't waste much time, and began rocking her neck back and forth, sucking my now massively engorged penis.

"Holy shit." Jessica said, clearly surprised by actually seeing this up close.

Kelly hesitated, clearly uncomfortable with the audience. This was something she couldn't believe she and her brother were doing to begin with. Now it was something an outsider knew about. And not just knew about... was actively participating in the room. She had never been with a guy prior to Danny, and the rapid step up from losing her virginity to becoming their performative plaything was unsettling for her. But she kept on going, working her brother's cock with the same passion she had the night before... and the night before that.

"Don't make him cum yet" Jessica uttered, causing Kelly to pull off my cock and look up at me for her next instruction. "I want to see you fill her up."

It was in that moment that I could see Jessica's anger at me for my breach of her trust start to slowly fade. She was getting into this idea now and I could see her salivating at the thought of having a new Lillian... even if that girl was her boyfriend's little sister.

"Come here" she told Kelly as she slid off her yoga pants, leaving her on the couch in nothing but her top, legs spread open.

Kelly reluctantly shifted over to the couch in front of Jessica and knelt between her legs. Jessica spread a little wider and gestured to her pussy, aching to be licked.

"I..." Kelly paused. "I've never... I mean... I'm not a..."

"What? A lesbian?" Jessica laughed. "Baby, break down those walls. They won't do you any good anymore.

Jessica leaned forward and kissed Kelly, deeply and passionately, almost sealing this new relationship with her loving touch. She then leaned back and Kelly slowly lowered her head down between her legs, close enough to where she could smell Jessica's scent.

"Kiss it" Jessica demanded.

I watched as my innocent little sister leaned further forward and locked lips with my girlfriend's delicious pussy. Jessica's head tilted back and she moaned at the touch of Kelly's mouth against her wet, tingling cunt. I throbbed at the sight of my little sister between my girlfriend's legs. She looked up at me and gestured at my sister's ass, instructing me to enter her from behind. I got down on my knees and grabbed Kelly's hips. She pulled off of Jessica's pussy and looked back at me, but Jessica grabbed her head and pulled her back in. I listened to her recklessly slurping up her first tastes of pussy as I lined up my cock to her dripping wet opening. As uncomfortable as this whole moment was for her, she clearly thought it was hot. Her pussy did not lie.

"She's pretty good at this" Jessica said to me, grinding her hips into my sister's face.

"I told you... she's amazing."

I let the throbbing head of my cock, already dripping a web of precum down to the floor, slide into my little sister's inviting pussy. She moaned into Jessica's cunt as I gave her inch after inch.

"Danny..." she muttered, muffled by Jessica's pussy lips.

I grabbed on tight and started fucking her, good and hard, slamming her into my naughty girlfriend's crotch. Jessica squealed with delight at the scene. I never thought, in a million year, that I was going to be able to convince Jessica of something like this. I had hoped and prayed that I'd be able to convince her to keep her mouth shut, but having her get involved in this insane adventure of incest... that was not something I thought would happen. I loved this girl so much. I loved both of these girls... my incredibly naughty and open minded girlfriend, and my sexy little sister, recently made a woman by yours truly.

"Fuck, she feels good." I let out, pounding into her.

"You gonna cum already baby?" Jessica asked me.

"If you want me to" I replied, pairing my slamming cock with Kelly's muffled moans.

"Me first" she said as she grabbed the back of Kelly's head and started pushing herself into her face, harder. "Keep going Kelly! Right there! Fuck!"

I watched her use my little sister's tongue to bring herself to an orgasm, smashing her clit into her tongue and violently rubbing herself on her face. She screamed as she let out a few squirts into Kelly's mouth.

"FUCK!" She yelled.

The sight of her fluids splashing around Kelly's face sent me over the edge.

"God damn!" I yelled, as I pumped an entire load into my little sister.

It felt even better than before... I suspect because this time, there was an audience for my insane sexual deviance.

"Fuck yes, fill her up baby" Jessica cheered on.

"Oh god" Kelly said, pulling off Jessica's pussy, face drenched in her juices, finally getting some unobstructed breaths of air. "Fuck!"

I deposited my whole load in her, every last drop. I pulled out and Kelly bowed her head, almost limp and spent.

"Come here baby" Jessica said to Kelly, pulling her on the couch and switching spaces with her.

Kelly sat back on the couch and nervously waited for what was to come next. Jessica spread her legs open and then started to return the oral favor.

"Oh my god" Kelly said as Jessica's tongue entered her pussy. Prior to only a few nights ago, she had never had another person's tongue in her. Now she had broken that cherry with her brother's tongue, soon followed by her first bisexual experience. She was moving fast.

"Oh baby, you taste good inside your little sister" Jessica pulled off to tell me as she started tasting my cum that had begun to ooze out of my little sister's tight pussy. "Do you want to share?"

"Fuck yes I do" I replied.

She moved aside and I knelt between Kelly's legs. A thick goop of my white cum was about to fall out of her pussy, slide down over her asshole and fall onto the couch. I made sure that wouldn't happen. I leaned down and returned my tongue to its new favorite place, my sister's sweet, fucked pussy. I slid my tongue into her and tasted my cum as it wrapped itself around it. I then slid my tongue up out of her pussy and to her clit where I gently tickled her and spread my cum all over her folds. It was delicious. Jessica pulled me off of her and shoved her tongue down my throat. We swapped the taste of Kelly and my cum back and forth. Out of the corner of her eye, she noticed another massive glob of cum oozing out of Kelly. She left my lips and dove into her pussy yet again, slurping up her boyfriend's cum as it dripped out of his little sister. I savored every second of this whole experience... my sister sucking my cock in front of Jessica... fucking her while she ate her out... filling her up and sharing her deliciously fucked pussy with Jessica. What was happening?!

"I won't lie to you two..." Jessica started. "This is crazy hot."

"See?" I told her, hoping I was out of the doghouse.

"This is insane" Kelly added. "Jessica, are you sure you're ok with this?"

We all followed Jessica's lead putting our clothes back on.

"It's definitely fucked up" she replied. "But I'd be lying if I said I didn't want to see where it leads... I'll keep your secret, don't worry."

"That's why you're so fucking incredible" I said, pulling her in and kissing her.

I could feel Kelly's discomfort, and I assumed Jessica could as well. Our little love affair had quickly shifted into Kelly becoming Jessica's play thing and taking 3rd position in the relationship. Would she be ok with that? Time would tell, but her and I both understood that from now on, the game would be to keep Jessica happy... and our secret safe.

----------

The three of us made our way into mom and dad's room, which had a massive walk-in shower, big enough for all of us. I washed my little sister and my gorgeous little girlfriend together, rubbing my soapy hands over every supple inch of their bodies. Jessica spent most of the shower holding Kelly, kissing her, and developing her own physical connection with my sister. By the time we were drying ourselves off, Kelly seemed quicker to a smile and started seeming more comfortable with the new situation she found herself in.

"So you've got the two of us alone for the night. What did you want to do with it?" I asked Jessica.

Jessica threw a robe around her body and grabbed Kelly by the hand.

"I'll show you" she said, pulling the three of us upstairs, butt naked.

We made our way into Kelly's room and Jessica hopped onto the bed.

"I want you two to give me the story. This just started right? I want the details. How did it happen?"

"Really? You wouldn't rather just play more?" I urged.

"Oh we're going to play... but first I want to hear how you two started. In fact... I want a reenactment" she giggled.

Kelly awkwardly sat on the edge of the bed and I sat in her desk chair. We looked at each other, not knowing where to start.

"You did it..." she said to me. "You tell her what happened."

"Well..." I began. "I came home the other night and heard Kelly... you know... playing with herself."

"Jesus..." she responded, embarrassed.

"No, no, no. Don't be ashamed. I want to know everything."

"So she was playing with herself..." I continued.

Jessica reached over and grabbed Kelly's arm and pulled her to sit right in front of her. Jessica sat up with her back against the headboard and wrapped her arms around Kelly who was made to sit in front of her, between her legs. Jessica grabbed Kelly's hand and lowered it down to her own pussy.

"Show me how you were playing with yourself" she whispered in her ear.

My cock twitched as I watched the two of them begin to play with Kelly's little pussy. Jessica quickly moved her hands up to Kelly's breasts, gently massaging them and playing with her nipples while she rubbed herself.

"And she was sexting someone" I continued. "Later, I looked through her phone and found this fetish app that she was on, and she was sexting with this guy, but..."

"But what?" Jessica asked.

"Her username was the FamilyVirgin and she had listed her interests... one of which included 'incest'"

"Oh fuck..." Kelly moaned as she was now clearly enjoying playing with herself to this story while Jessica pinched her nipples even harder.

"Good girl" Jessica said.

"So anyway, I downloaded the app and made a profile and sort of manipulated a scenario where we would connect and I'd pretend to be some random guy also interested in incest."

"Such a bad boy, your big brother... going through your phone like that" she said to Kelly.

"One thing led to the next and I sort of got her to admit to wanting her brother... me... and I figured that was enough permission to, well, give her what she wanted."

"How did he do it?" Jessica asked Kelly.

"I woke up to him licking my pussy in the middle of the night" she mumbled.

Jessica looked at me with a devious grin.

"Show me Danny."

I got on the bed between them and nestled between Kelly's legs. I thought about that first night... the moonlight creeping through the blinds on my inviting little sister's cunt... the first taste of her sweet pussy... I dove back in and connected my tongue with her wet slit once again. Her hand pulled away and I looked up to see her lean her head back on Jessica's shoulder and wrap her hands around Jessica's hands, still firmly gripping her tits.

"What did you do when you woke up?" She asked her.

"I stopped him at first... but then..."

I interrupted her answer with a firm latch onto her clit, licking her up and down and making her flinch and moan.

"Then what?" Jessica asked.

"Then... I CAME! FUCK!" She screamed as I brought her to another orgasm. She squirted into my face, again, and again I savored every last drop.

I came up for air, covered with Kelly's wet cum. I got on my knees and kissed her, sharing her juices with her, before leaning over her and sharing them with Jessica.

"Did you make her suck your cock after, baby?"

"I did."

"I want you to show me how you sucked your brother's cock for the first time. Show me how nervous you were" she whispered in Kelly's ear.

I laid back on the bed and Kelly knelt over my cock. She raised her hands to her head and put her hair in a ponytail. She looked at me for permission and I gave it to her with no words. She lowered herself down on my cock and started sucking. I could feel she was getting more and more comfortable with this new situation by the way she effortlessly licked and sucked every inch of my cock.

"Could you believe your little sister had your cock in her mouth?"

"It was fucking insane baby."

"I bet you had to do everything to hold back from exploding in her mouth."

"I wish I could say I did..."

"You came in her mouth? Had you ever had cum in your mouth before Kelly?"

Kelly pulled up off my cock, now glistening with her spit and smiled... almost giggled.

"That was the first time I'd ever had a cock in my mouth" she said, embarrassed in the most perfectly adorable way.

"Would you like your big brother to cum in your mouth again?"

She gave another adorable smile and nodded in the affirmative.

"The go get yourself some of that brotherly cum sweetie!"

Kelly got back to work, sucking my cock with a force she had yet to display. I was in heaven. Not only was I continuing to enjoy my little sister's body, but I was able to do it in front of Jessica! I locked eyes with my sexy little girlfriend and she gave me the most devious smile, almost as if to say 'cum in your little sister's mouth you dirty little incestuous fuck!' And so I did. I exploded in her cheeks yet again, watching Kelly's face turn into a chipmunk's as she tried to hold all my cum in her mouth.

"Show it to me" Jessica asked.

Kelly got up on her knees and looked toward Jessica. She carefully opened her mouth to show her the load I had deposited in her mouth, and naturally a big glob of cum slipped out and dribbled down her chin and onto her breasts.

"Swallow" she demanded, and Kelly happily obliged. "Danny, don't waste that drop."

I did as I was told, wrapped my arms around my cum-filled little sister and pulled her breasts toward my face. I licked the glob of cum off her nipple and licked the trail of semen all the way back up to her mouth where we then shared a very cum-flavored kiss. We parted, and sat back down on the bed to collect ourselves. I noticed Jessica rubbing her clit while she watched us finish a very steamy brother/sister blowjob.

"This is going to be fun..." Jessica said.

----------

We ordered in pizza and broke into mom and dad's liquor cabinet to make margaritas. The only time we weren't naked was when I had to answer the door to pay the pizza boy... although he definitely got a glimpse of my naked sister and girlfriend running down the stairs behind me.

Jessica and Kelly were starting to bond and develop more of a friendship. With them spending the evening together, goofing around, drinking, playing with each other's bodies (and mine...), I could see Kelly starting to get much more settled in the realization that this threeway relationship would actually be pretty fun.

We had finished dinner, made another round of drinks and was Jessica and I were just finished making Kelly cum for what felt like the one thousandth time, when Jessica uttered yet another devious idea.

"Why don't we go get in your neighbor's jacuzzi? I'd love to get to experience some of the steamy fun you two got into..."

"Oh... no... we can't do that" Kelly replied.

"Yeah, that's actually a big problem" I replied, having almost forgotten about that little wrinkle in this adventure.

"What do you mean?"

"Well, in addition to getting caught by... you... we also think there's a pretty good chance our neighbor saw us on his new security system that I didn't know he installed."

"You two are so.... fucked" she laughed.

"Ugh" I replied. "We know!"

"Maybe he didn't see us!" Kelly prayed.

"Yeah, maybe we're totally in the clear. But let's not risk it again."

"Or..." Jessica added, a smile on her face.

"Or what?" I asked.

"Maybe we give him another show... maybe as a bribe not to tell anyone?"

"I don't think that will work babe..." I said.

"Come on!" Jessica yelled as she got up and ran out the back of the house.

"No! Jessica! Seriously!" I yelled, but she was gone.

My sister and I looked at each other, worried that perhaps Jessica was too lost in the excitement that she forgot about the reality of the situation... that Mr. Michaelson had likely recorded his neighbor's son fucking his sister in the jacuzzi!

We chased after Jessica who we found standing in Mr. Michaelson's backyard, butt naked, in front of his security camera - blinking red.

"What the fuck are you doing?" I whispered at her from off to the side of the camera's view. "Get back here! This isn't funny!"

"Does he have your phone number?"

"What!?"

"Does he?" She repeated.

"Yeah... I guess so. What are you doing!??!"

"What's his name?"

"Mr. Michaelson?" I asked, terrified what the hell she was doing.

She turned to the camera.

"Ok Mr. Michaelson" she said to the camera.

"Oh god" Kelly said, both our stomachs falling out of our bodies.

"I'm Jessica, Danny's girlfriend. Let's just assume you saw what you saw last night..."

"Jessica!" I shouted. She held up her hand to me as if to shut me up.

"You can do one of two things. You can ruin all the fun and tell on them, OR..."

What in the actual fuck was she doing? Any chance we had that maybe he hadn't seen us on camera was obviously going to be gone now! Two nights in a row of notifications... he definitely would see it now!

"OR... you can keep what you saw to yourself, and get another show.... tonight... right now" she giggled.

The camera continued to blink.

"I'm assuming you have Danny's phone number. Why don't we just get straight to the point and get rid of the suspense. You text Danny a thumbs down emoji, he'll know they're busted and you'll be the asshole who ruined their lives... OR... text him a thumbs up emoji and the three of us give you another little peep show tonight, right here in your jacuzzi. What do you say?"

She stood there, far too confident in this complete and utter insane plan she had come up with in all of two seconds! Kelly held my hand, shaking. We were fucked. Not only did we just give him two nights of security alerts for him to review, but Jessica also just called him an asshole... MR. MICHAELSON! You do NOT call Mr. Michaelson... an ex-Marine... an asshole! I figured it was time for me to pack my bags and get a new identity and move to Europe when....

PING!

Jessica looked over at me with a smirk. I looked at my phone to see a text from Mr. Michaelson. Kelly and I looked at each other, nervous beyond belief.

"Open it!" Kelly urged.

I unlocked my phone and couldn't believe what I saw...

????

A big, yellow, thumbs up. Nothing else. Just that. Our eyes widened. I looked over at Jessica, still standing nude in the lawn.

"Well...?" She asked me, waiting for the verdict.

"Thumbs up..." I delivered, still in disbelief.

Jessica looked back at the camera and smiled.

"Good choice!" She giggled, grabbing at her nipples, giving them a little pull. "Jacuzzi anyone?"

She walked over to the jacuzzi and pulled off the cover and climbed in. I grabbed Kelly's hand and we slowly made our way over to her, walking into the field of view of the blinking camera.

"Hey... Mr. Michaelson..." I uttered, pulling Kelly quickly into the tub with me.

"What the fuck?" I whispered to Jessica. "That was fucking risky!"

"Oh whatever" she said quietly. "Old man... lives with his old wife in this neighborhood... probably has lame old sex barely ever... that kind of guy is definitely going to want to see this. Now sit up here... Kelly and I have some work to do."

I sat up on the ledge, my cock flaccid with nerves. Jessica grabbed my cock and slurped it into her mouth, pulling me out of my distraction and into the moment. She grabbed Kelly's hand and pulled her over.

"Let's give him a show!" She encouraged Kelly as she pulled away and made room for my sister to get to work on my cock.

Kelly very slowly and nervously leaned in and took my cock, now semi-hard, into her mouth. Jessica looked up at the camera and winked. Before long, I was fully erect again, and the two girls took turns slobbering all over my cock.

"Who do you want first Danny?" Jessica asked me.

"Why don't we let Mr. Michaelson decide?" I suggested. Looking up to the camera, I said, "Sister or girlfriend?"

Almost no delay before, PING!

"Kelly" was all the text said. Of course.

"You heard the man" I said as I lifted Kelly up onto the ledge, just as I had done the previous night. I spread her legs open and dove into her pussy with my mouth, making sure to taste her clean cunt before I fucked it. She tasted like chlorine and pussy, and the second my tongue hit her lips, I felt a twitch in my cock... it knew what it wanted. I stood up and aimed my fully erect cock towards Kelly's wet opening and slowly pushed through her lips, feeling the walls of her vagina squeeze around on my cock.

"Oh fuck!" She let out.

"That's right" Jessica encouraged. "Fuck your little sister. Fuck her good."

I picked up my pace and began to pound my cock up against my little sister's cervix. She moaned, louder and louder with each thrust. It became clear to me that she was putting on a show for our neighbor, as was I... as was Jessica. Jessica sat on the ledge next to Kelly and spread her legs for the camera. She began fingering herself and licking her fingers while she watched me fuck Kelly. I picked up my pace even more, feeling Kelly start to tighten around me, knowing full well what that meant. I ravaged her, hard and fast. She squealed and moaned until her pussy pushed my cock out and she began to scream as she squirted all over me, just as she had before. I got down on my knees with my face at level with her cumming pussy and stuck my tongue out as she continued to spray my face with cum. Jessica lent a hend and vigorously rubbed Kelly's pussy, sending a few more aggressive squirts of cum shooting out of her and onto my face. Kelly screamed in pleasure as Mr. Michaelson undoubtedly watched on, seeing his neighbor boy bringing his little sister to an explosive orgasm in his jacuzzi.

"Fuck that is hot Kelly!" Jessica applauded. "I can't believe you can cum like that!"

"Fuck!" Kelly shouted, trying to collect herself, almost hyperventilating. "Fuck, that was good!"

"My turn" Jessica said, still legs spread for all to see.

I stood up, wiped Kelly's delicious cum off my face and scooted over to Jessica to try and give her the same pleasure. I fucked her hard, kissing her and letting her taste Kelly's cum on my lips.

"Oh fuck! Give it to me big boy!" She shouted.

I reached out and grabbed onto one of Kelly's massive tits for dear life and then began playing with her nipples as I pounded my girlfriend seated beside her. Kelly started to moan again at the pleasure of me rolling her nipples around my fingers. Instinctually, she started to finger herself, working herself toward another orgasm.

It wasn't long before Jessica followed suit, wrapping her legs tightly around me as she convulsed and screamed her own moaning orgasm.

"Oh fuck yes!" She yelled. "Fuck! Fuck! Fuck!"

"You like watching me fuck my girlfriend in front of you sis?" I asked Kelly.

"Oh god!" She rolled her eyes back in her head as she rubbed her clit and pleasured herself yet again.

"I want it in my ass!" Jessica said, sure of her request.

She didn't wait. She pushed me off and turned around and threw her ass in the air, bending over the side of the jacuzzi.

"Lube him up for me Kelly? Suck his cock and make it extra sloppy!"

Kelly didn't waste any time. She lowered down to my cock and began choking herself on it, leaving it completely covered in strands of saliva from the back of her throat. Properly lubricated, I pulled her off of me and lined the head of my cock against Jessica's tiny little pink asshole. I grabbed her thighs and began to slowly push my way in.

"Oh my god! YES!" She yelled out as my cock was engulfed by her asshole sucking me in. "FUCK!"

I fucked her ass slowly at first, and then built up to a rough pounding. Kelly leaned over to kiss Jessica while I did, giving me (and Mr. Michaelson) a great glimpse of her little asshole as well. I didn't hesitate. I licked my finger, covering it with spit, and slowly started to finger Kelly's virgin asshole.

"Woah! Oh god!" She let out, feeling this strange feeling for the first time.

I continued pounding Jessica's as while I fingered Kelly's asshole beside her. The sight of both these girl's perfect bodies bent over Mr. Michaelson's jacuzzi... along with the tight, wet feel of Jessica's ass gripping my cock... sent me over the edge.

"I'm gonna cum soon! I won't last much longer ladies. Where do you want me to cum?"

"Cum in your sister!" Jessica shouted. "Fill her up!"

I quickly pulled out of Jessica's asshole, and shifted over to Kelly. She reached back and spread her ass cheeks to present her inviting holes. The back of her pussy opened itself up to me like a flower. As badly as I wanted to replace my finger in her ass with my cock for her first ass fucking, I had the clarity of mind to give her a more pleasurable pussy fucking. My cock slid into her pussy effortlessly, followed by her screaming in pleasure, followed immediately by my moaning as I unleashed an orgasm into her fertile womb yet again. Rope and rope, pulse after pulse, I emptied everything that was left in me inside my little sister as my girlfriend (and Mr. Michaelson) watched on. As far as I was concerned, this jacuzzi was my absolute heaven.

The three of us collectively caught our breaths as my throbbing cock began to slowly wither inside of my sister's cunt. I could feel it swimming around in a pool of its own cum and knew the second I pulled it out, the flood gates would open and she would begin pouring it out.

"You ready to clean her up?" I asked Jessica.

She dove under water and surfaced just below Kelly's swollen pussy. She opened her mouth wide and I started to pull out. Sure enough, a sea of hot, white cum spilled out of her gaping hole directly into Jessica's inviting mouth. She took a mouthful and then shifted to the side to allow me to get down and have my own taste. Kelly remained bent over the edge of the jacuzzi as I bent down behind her and caught a glob of cum oozing out of her. I savored every taste of her, of me, of her cum, and of our combined juices. I then travelled north and, with my cum-covered tongue, began eating her fresh little virgin asshole. She moaned and squirmed... a feeling she had never felt before.

I then stood up and embraced Jessica, giving her a kiss and making sure she knew she was the priority. She pulled me in closer and nibbled on my ear.

"This is going to be fun" she whispered in my ear.

I gave her a very naughty wink, a kiss and playful spank on her tight little ass.

"Thank you Mr. Michaelson!" Jessica cheered up to the camera. "Hope you enjoyed the show!"

We all got out of the jacuzzi and toweled off and headed back to the house.

----------

The rest of the night was pure heaven. I'll admit, I was pretty spent. My cock was sore from the days of attention. But we remained naked all night, bodies on top of bodies, kissing and hugging and sucking and playing... taking full advantage of our inaugural night of our new three way relationship.

I couldn't believe what had happened this Christmas break. I came home, leaving my stunningly hot girlfriend behind for a few days, only to seduce and steal the virginity of my adorably sexy, busty little sister... then got caught by both my girlfriend and my neighbor, only to convince Jessica to join in on my incestuous affair and convince Mr. Michaelson to keep our secret by giving him a little show. Was any of this real? I felt like I was going to wake up in my dorm room the next day and realize this was all some insane dream.

Jessica, Kelly and I decided to spend the night in mom and dad's king bed. We laid naked together and planned out what the future would like for us. Kelly would need to come visit Jessica and I at school. We would need to come see here. We decided we would make sure to set aside one weekend a month where we would spend the weekend together naked, playing, fucking, exploring. Jessica gave Kelly a set of ground rules: when she could hook up with guys, getting permission beforehand and before going on dates, etc. Jessica made it clear to Kelly that she was ours first and foremost - and Kelly didn't seem to mind one bit, in fact I could tell she was fully invested in this. Jessica and I were allowed to play with Kelly one on one if we wanted, and we wouldn't need to ask the other first. Kelly was in the relationship now, so it was no longer "stepping out" on the relationship to fuck her.

We talked about what the potential future would look like, even further out.

"What happens when you two get married?" Kelly asked.

It wouldn't end there. Kelly would still remain in our marriage as our third. She would always have a spot in our bed, in our house, as part of the relationship. And that's when Jessica said the naughtiest, sexiest thing I think I ever heard in my whole life.

"How hot would it be for Danny to get us both pregnant at the same time?"

"Oh my god, are you serious?"

"Why not?" she asked.

There was a long pause. I fully expected Kelly to say something like 'this has gone way too far!', but instead...

"That would be so hot, to be honest... having a baby that's secretly my brothers..." she almost drooled.

Wow. What a life.

We started to wind down, and Jessica suggested she and Kelly try and suck out one more load of cum before we all went to sleep. I was practically in pain, but there was no chance I was going to say no. The two of them shared my cock, taking turns giving me a soft, sensual blowjob. What did I do to deserve this? Just then...

PING!

I looked at my phone. Text from Mr. Michaelson. Shit.... I thought to myself. What could this be? I opened the phone.

'I'll keep your secret... but I want to play too.'

----------

the end