Which Hole is Better?

"He was like, I've never had sex with a guy..."

It was Sunday, and Rosie's boyfriend was telling her a story over breakfast.

"So I was like, you wanna change that?'"

They had stopped for a bite while on the way to court. He had a fine to pay. So really who knows how or why this was brought up. Surprising, but it had her attention. She was listening intently. More so than normal compared to how much she pays attention to him normally. This was new to her. Information like this never came out of him prior to today. She knew he had had intercourse with men before, but the details were left out... until this moment.

"Then he met his friend and we were all hanging out. We got drunk..."

Rosie was a good audience, especially when it came to facts about her boyfriend's life. She took inspiration from his prior sexual adventures and used them for... her own purposes.

"... and next they took turns fucking me in the ass."

"That's wild," "Wow," "That's insane," were things she said during the conversation. But inside, it was way worse. Or better...! Either way, the impact was sexual. Blatantly, it was dazzling how much it turned her on. Hearing his dirty secrets with the thought of him getting rammed by two fellows was right on the mark of sexy. She couldn't stop thinking about it until she climbed in the bed while he was playing Xbox and took it upon herself to masturbate to what he told her. Release was the only option for getting the fantasy out of her head. Her mind-theater rampant, it began with the guy who fucked her boyfriend and his friend peering over him. His back stretched out, the dimples around his pelvis showing, his ass exposed. She was aware her love had a nice big butthole, capable of taking many inches. It was also hairy. He didn't manscape. It was part of what attracted her to him. She liked his rugged look. She could picture him and his genitals perfectly from experience. She also knew he could take a big cock, so said his collection of massive dildos for pegging and stuff. In her mind, he was bent over a bed. The first guy sank his dick into her boyfriend's ass slowly, talking the entire time to his friend, having his own commentary. Describing how he was fucking him. He would say, "you like this big dick, you like this big dick?" and make him admit it.

"Mmhm... mhmmm... I do, I do..."

His struggle to talk while taking dick was sexy.

"Yeah, I bet you like it. Like it and like it more then. Bad self."

The second guy would ask for a turn. "Let me at this junt. Tight ass," and the first guy would pull out, and the second bigger dick would push against her boyfriend's ass while the other guy would stroke to what was happening. His friend hesitantly stretching the orifice out to accommodate his size, her boyfriend moaned, groaning from having his prostate stimulated. She moaned, too. At the thought. Cupping her pussy, trying to come from pressure, the fantasy carried on, and took a dastardly turn. What if she was there, too? She coached her thoughts to stay with her. What if. What if after her B. F. was done getting fucked, he fucked one of the guys there in the ass? And furthermore, she could be tied up in the corner, face down, ass up, hearing the sex taking place. The thought of force spikes her blood pressure in an exhilarating way.

Yeah, he could fuck one of the other dudes anally. Then since this was her fantasy, he could take it upon himself to see which hole felt better. He could get done with fucking one guy, then relentlessly he could shove his dick straight into her pussy, fresh out of the dude's ass. This turned her on even more, and as her orgasm mounted to climax, her legs started to shake. She let the dread seep into her mind. At her peak, she was hoping to God that he loved her hole more.

Finally over, like a dying explosion, she was better, sober, sane. Coming down, his words rang in her head: "I prefer women," and settled her. It was reassuring after the fit of pleasure she had found herself in. She could hardly believe she had risen to climax over something as obscene as two random dudes fucking her boyfriens, then fucking her pussy straight out of another person's ass, but it happened.

"Whatcha doing in there, baby?" Rosie's mate asked.

She walked out of the room, dizzy from cumming. "O--nothing! I was just thinking about what you told me today."

"Which was?"

"To be honest I just masturbated to that story about the two guys you recanted."

"Oh really?" he laughed. "Had a good time?"

"The best. Probably not as good of a time you had during, but it was enjoyable."

He laughed. "You're so funny, baby. Let's make dinner. Don't forget to wash your hands."