Substitution Fucked The Cat

Curiosity sometimes didn't kill the Cat. Instead, it led to a much worse outcome. Or was it really a worse outcome?

In this submission, Cat's curiosity and rampant use of her superpower urged her to uncover her uncle's long-time secret behind a mysterious door. But when she saw what the secret was, she couldn't help but be surprised, embarrassed, and... Intrigued? Yet, before she could explore more, her uncle arrived unexpectedly, which led to a shocking encounter between the uncle and niece.

What would Cat do? To what extent would she do just to not be caught? And, would she keep her uncle's secret as well as that secret encounter between the two?

*****

Hi everyone! Welcome to my sixth submission!

Long time, no see! It feels like a really, really long time since my last submission. How are you? Me? I'm fine and busy with work.

I've been reading your comments though, and I agree that I'm still lacking in my verb tenses. Maybe, I should get an editor? Will you recommend someone good and nice? Also, can you help point out my weaknesses, such as inconsistencies, grammatical errors, plot holes, etc.? Just put them in the comments below. Appreciate your help! And now for the thanks:

Thanks to twisted99703, TGod113, Gothbitch, lillerin77, Hornylittlebugger, Pacz, Da1Bubba1086, Loonytune, cassie69a, CCRidgeFord, Harrrg, staredecisis, and those anonymous users who have left comments and added my stories to your favorite list. You're the best! Your engagement and constructive feedback motivates and helps me grow as a writer. I hope you'll continue to support my work in the future!

Please visit my profile for my other works--you might find something you like there!

As always, don't forget to rate, follow, favorite, or comment before leaving. Appreciate y'all!

*****

Superpower

Substitution Fucked the Cat

(TMI One-Shots)

Wearing your favorite white tee and blue jeans, you sat at a secluded corner of the most popular coffee shop in the city. The bitter scent of coffee and the sweet smell of desserts wafting in the air loosened your tired body. Slowly, the stress you'd accumulated throughout the week melted away like ice in summer. Along with the low hum of nearby conversations and the soft music drifting from the hidden speakers, you knew your latte and cheese cake would taste particularly divine today.

Slouching against your seat, you took a sip of your coffee. The bitterness spread throughout your palate, a pleasant contrast to the beverage's subtle nutty undertones. And when you followed it up with a bite of the cheese cake, the blend of sweet and bitter made your taste buds dance in joy. You couldn't help closing your eyes and savoring every bit of it.

'Ah, is this heaven?'

You couldn't avoid this thought every time you indulged yourself in that coffee shop. At any rate, the experience had never turned stale.

You swallowed. When you decided to have another bite, a voluptuous lady barged into your happy space from out of nowhere. She suddenly sat at your table, on the vacant seat next to yours, without asking. Her long blonde hair sparkled under the lights when she moved, and her eyes were strikingly blue. A frown tugged at your lips when you noticed her discourtesy.

'How rude! Do good-looking girls have no manners nowadays? Can't she see someone's already occupying this table?'

To your surprise, that was not the end of it. She even scooted closer. Your elbows were almost touching, a gross violation of your private space!

'Ah, come on. What the heck is this?'

In this world of supers, her action was tantamount to a blatant provocation.

Loudly, and with undisguised annoyance, you cleared your throat. You fixed the gorgeous specimen of femininity with a pointed stare, demanding her to give you appropriate space. However, the woman refused to take notice. Instead, she leaned close to you, giving you a glimpse of the shadow between her sizable peaks, and whispered to your ear.

"I have something to share." Her breath tickled your ear.

Shivers ran down your spine. Before you could lean away though, her next words froze you on your seat.

"I had sex with my uncle."

* * *

Her name was Catherine, Cat to her friends and family, and she got a superpower.

If she willed it, Cat could steal a thing's identity and be perceived by everyone as that thing. Whether in looks, scent, or feel, she was no different from the original. As long as she didn't act too outrageously from the identity she stole, no one would see through it. This led her to the habit of sneaking into off-limit places.

Once, as an experiment, Cat snuck into the backseat of her teacher's car and stole the identity of the briefcase he placed there. The forty-year-old educator remained oblivious to his student's reflection, clear as day in the rear-view mirror. He just started the car and drove for twenty minutes, while she went along for the ride. In the front of a produce store, Cat took the chance to get out. Her teacher, on the other hand, bought something for dinner inside.

Since then, she slipped in and out of any place that intrigued her without holding back--the offices of her school's faculty, a famous local mall, and even the inside of the local police station. Unbeknownst to her, too much curiosity would soon put her in a difficult situation, and that incident happened to occur at her Uncle Troy's house a month after her eighteenth birthday.

After school, in the family car...

Cat slumped against the backrest of the passenger seat. The foil of the sandwich in her hand crinkled in her grip as she moved. "Dad, where are we going?" Cat asked when she noticed the unfamiliar street outside the vehicle.

A day of nothing but tests made the teenager tired and listless. Even now, the rustle of test papers and the swish of pens still haunted her. The motivation to bite into her sandwich waned a lot. Missing her trip to the nearest hospital, she felt her day was wasted.

Today, her target was supposed to be the nearest hospital's operating room. She'd seen a documentary about doctors operating on patients posted online, and she was curious to witness what it's like in person. But because of the sudden school work, she couldn't do it. Glancing at the orange sky above, she knew it was too late to do it today.

She sighed.

'Should I move it tomorrow instead?'

She was unsure. The surprise tests wouldn't happen two days in a row, right?

Across the street, while their car slowed down at a red light, Cat caught sight of a shop selling household appliances. Various brands of TV's were displayed in the clear window overlooking the street. Each of them were turned on and tuned into a news channel. Inadvertently, Cat read the subtitle running at the bottom edge.

'... The number of cases involving people with supernatural power is increasing nationwide. The authorities warn the public to be vigilant and prioritize their safety. Please report any suspicious activity you may encounter at...'

"To your Uncle Troy's house," her dad finally replied. "I have to collect his payment for the last month's shenanigans."

When she processed what her dad had said, she perked up and faced him in curiosity. She instantly forgot the news from the TV at that moment. "Shenanigans? What kind of shenanigans?"

Eyes still on the road, her father waved his hand in dismissal. "Never mind. Young girls like you have no business prying on adult matters."

She crossed her arms and pouted. "But I'm already eighteen. I'm already an adult. Come on, dad. Just tell me. If not... I-I won't talk to you anymore."

The older man gave his daughter a half-amused half-doubtful look. The word 'Really?' almost manifested.

Seeing it, she lifted her chin. "I-I will do it. I'm serious. I won't talk to you from now on." She averted her eyes, aggrieved.

The inside of the car went silent, but Cat's curiosity was killing her. It only took a short time before she gave up. She couldn't help herself.

"Really, what kind of shenanigans was it?" she finally asked.

Amused, her dad just shook his head. "Just eat your sandwich." It was a clear refusal.

She slumped in defeat. "Alright," she grumbled and took a big bite from her sandwich. "How stingy."

Her dad just chuckled, but the mystery kept bugging her.

* * *

They stopped at Uncle Troy's front drive. Across a well-maintained lawn, a two-story house stood alone. Attached to it on the right was a garage, and on the left was a small path to the backyard. Cat watched as her dad stepped out of the car.

"Pumpkin, want to come with me inside?"

She shook her head and pushed the car door on her side open. "Nope. I'll just stay at the backyard."

"Alright, I'll be quick."

Her dad stepped on the porch and pressed the doorbell. Meanwhile, Cat took the narrow path on the left. Tall iron fence overgrown with vines and the closed windows bracketed the path. She checked those windows one by one as she passed by.

On the window overlooking the kitchen, a door suddenly swung open. Cat didn't know what got to her, but she leaped out of view before she peeked her eyes over the lower part of the window. There, she saw her uncle locking a nondescript door. Since she could remember, that room was off-limits to anyone but her uncle. Her curiosity was peaked.

'What's that door for? Why is it off-limits? What's inside? Should I check it out? Well... that's a good idea!'

At the moment her uncle placed the keys in the cupboard above the sink and left the kitchen, Cat had already laid down a plan. She quickly detoured to the backdoor and checked if it was locked. Finding out it wasn't, she pushed the backdoor slowly as she listened for any footsteps coming her way. Well, there weren't, so she slipped in, gently closing the door behind.

Her gaze immediately zeroed on the cupboards. Heading straight to it, she grabbed a stool nearby and used it as a foothold. She pushed her hand into the cupboard and felt for the keys. Her expression lit up when she pulled them out.

"Got it!"

She landed on the linoleum with nary a sound and stood in front of the mystery door in a few seconds. Holding her breath in, she inserted the key... and turned it. There was a soft click, and the door was now unlocked, a signal for her to explore.

All of a sudden...

"Cat, your dad's leaving!" her uncle called out.

Cat was startled. Footsteps were coming her way.

Not a minute later, the door leading to the living room opened. Her uncle's massive frame invaded the kitchen, making the space small with his presence. The feeling went stronger when his six-foot stature loomed over her five foot and four inches at the counter. Thankfully, the mystery door had been locked, and the key was already returned to the cupboard.

Shifting on her seat, Cat gave him an innocent smile. "Hi, Uncle Troy!" She waved, feigning nonchalance.

In his tight-fitting shirt, the man squinted down at his niece. "You look guilty."

"Wh-what? But I didn't do anything."

"Hmmm." He scrutinized her from head to toe.

"Really."

His furrowed brows didn't relax though. Cat began to sweat. Thankfully, her dad called her from the front lawn.

"Alright! I'm going, Uncle Troy! See you later!"

Without waiting for a response, she immediately stood and made herself scarce, but the mystery door still lingered in her mind even after she and her dad left.

* * *

Over a month had passed since then. Cat, wearing her favorite skirt and matching flats, stood before her uncle's house once again. The house was quiet, and the lights were out. She reread the message she forwarded from her dad's phone:

'I'm out until the twenty-third. I'll settle the total next month when I return.'

After reading it for the third time, she turned the screen off and headed to the front door. It was the nineteenth today, so there were four more days before Uncle Troy returned home.

Fishing out the spare key she pilfered from her dad, she unlocked the door. Quickly, she entered the dark interior. She didn't want to be seen by the neighbors if ever there was one.

Her uncle's living room was typical. There were the normal TV set, the couches, the rug--the usual. The only thing different was the walls of family pictures near the stairs to the second floor.

As far as she knew, Uncle Troy didn't hang those. It was her grandmother who'd decorated the place. His uncle was such a bachelor that his house had no color at all.

She crossed the living room to the open door leading to the kitchen. After she passed through the doorway, the same kitchen during their visit a month ago greeted her. The same window, the same counter, and the same cupboard and mystery door waved at her. Finally, here she was!

Excited, she again dragged the same stool and got the key from the cupboard. Traversing the short distance to the mystery door, she could feel her heart lob-dubbing in her chest. When the door swung open, Cat couldn't wait to enter. Feeling for the switch on the wall, she flicked it on, and then her jaw dropped in shock.

The room was filled with life-sized dolls in different poses. Some were standing, chest out.

Some were on all fours, butt up. And still, some in sultry poses, sporting their best assets. The shocking part was, everyone was naked. With how real they looked like, a shameful feeling bathed the room.

Cat immediately closed the door behind her and locked it. Something told her to keep that spectacle a secret. However, accompanying that shameful feeling was intrigue. Her curiosity was cranked to the max. She really wanted to check every single one of the dolls just to look for a flaw.

She crept further inside. She first scrutinized the doll in all fours nearest to her. Its red long hair hung on its side as it arched its neck, showing the delicate throat. Its heavy breasts dangled below, and its position was so suggestive it made Cat blush in embarrassment.

Next, she turned before a doll standing, breast forward. A peculiar thought entered her brain as she cocked her head. Why didn't this doll topple forward with how big its breasts were? She shook her head, chalking it to the good craftsmanship of the doll.

Finally, she went near a blonde doll on an armchair. Its hands rested on the armrest, while its back leaned against the seat in a forty-five-degree angle. Its pink nipples stood erect. She didn't understand though why it spread its legs like that to the point that its sex was exposed. But then, that part too was so real, the folds were obvious and the clit was engorged.

Cat felt surreal looking at it. "Why do Uncle Troy have these many dolls? What are these for anyway?"

Then, she heard a disturbing sound from outside.

"... Yeah, I'm back. I've just landed an hour before. No, no, I have no more business away from home. Yes, I could take care of it tomorrow. Yeah, I promise. Don't worry."

It's uncle!

Panicking, Cat looked around for a place to hide. However, the room had nothing but those dolls. No cabinets, compartments, or anything remotely she could use as a hiding spot. But then, she got a brilliant idea.

Hurrying, she removed her clothes and hid them behind some dolls. She placed her palm on the head of the blonde doll on the chair, stealing its perception through her trusty superpower. Exactly after she removed the doll and took its place, the locked door swung open.

Her Uncle Troy stood at the door. His huge build filled the doorway. Immediately, Cat noticed his confused expression. His head raised up and gazed at the lit lights.

'Crap! I forgot the lights!'

She felt cold. Praying her uncle wouldn't discover her, the fact that she was buck naked completely slipped her mind.

His uncle's eyes swept around the room. Seeing nothing, he frowned. His confusion worsened.

He entered the room and began to walk around. After he made a full circuit, the same confusion appeared in his expression. Then, he shook his head and smiled wryly to himself. That was when he locked the door.

In the corner of the room where a small table was, he fiddled with something, and a projector appeared on the far wall. Her uncle walked toward her. Cat gulped in nervousness--although her power never failed her once. However, her uncle's next action shocked her. He took off his clothes in front of Cat, leaving only his boxers behind!

Cat's eyes widened. Inadvertently, her gaze fell down on the eye-catching bulge between her uncle's legs. It was his cock. Realizing what she was staring at, Cat turned red and averted her eyes quickly. Yet, even as she looked away, the vision of that bulge ignited a strange heat in her belly.

Before she could think more though, her uncle stopped in front of her. Not a second after that, his big hands cupped her sides and lifted her off the chair. Surprised, Cat almost struggled, but thankfully, refrained her impulse in time. With ease, her uncle picked her naked ass up and took her place on the armchair. And then, he plopped her butt down on his thighs.

When their skin touched, and her uncle's warmth penetrated her skin, Cat exhaled in surprise. She couldn't help her reaction. She'd never experienced being this close to the opposite sex before, not even with her boyfriends. Moreover, she had no clothes on.

The video began to play. Cat looked at it, curious of what it was. A man and a woman in their birthday suit then appeared in the screen. From the speakers sounded lewd moans as the two started to have sex. Cat's eyes opened wide when the man's huge cock entered the woman's sopping pussy from behind. Amidst the moans of the two, the sounds of flesh hitting flesh were interspersed.

Cat flushed. She really wanted to get off her uncle's lap, but she couldn't. Her power would dissipate if she did so. By that time, watching sex was more preferable than the consequence, so she endured.

Then, something hard, thick, and long pressed her butt from below. The thing followed the crease of her butt, sandwiching it between her ass cheeks. The feeling was uncomfortable, and she really wanted to adjust her position. Yet, it was then that she noticed her uncle's hand slowly making its way to her thigh. Cat gulped as she watched those fingers reached for her crotch.

When those fingers stroke that spot where no man had ever touched her before, a jolt ran down her spine. She bit her lips as the unfamiliar but pleasurable sensation hit her for the first time. She knew, at the moment her uncle touched her there, she had to get out of that situation. Letting her uncle fondle her pussy more would be incest. It was wrong, very wrong.

But why? Why couldn't she let her superpower dissipate? Why did she open her thighs wider instead, and let her uncle spread her juices more? Now, her dazed eyes just looked at those glistening digits as they roamed freely around her sensitive flesh. Why couldn't she? Why?

Her breathing began to get deeper. Those nimble fingers slid up and down her labia and paused above her engorged knob. The moment her uncle circled her clit, she turned rigid, her breath stuttered, and her moan stuck halfway up her throat. Moreover, when her uncle's finger penetrated her sopping pussy, she could no longer hold it in, and a small squeak passed through her lips.

All that time, the sensation inside her was building up more, as if a spring being wound. A bit more and the pressure would explode. The straw that broke the proverbial dam was when her uncle stroked her g-spot.

With a suppressed moan, Cat went taut, and her vision dimmed. Electric pleasure burst out from inside and reverberated throughout her slender body. If her superpower wouldn't allow small movements, that would have caused her to be found out by now.

Blinded with orgasm, Cat felt her uncle guiding her forward. When her sight recovered, her uncle already put her in all fours. The carpet felt soft under her fingers. He then took hold of her hips, and from behind, after a short rustle, a rigid length parted her quivering pussy in one swift motion.

There was pain, too much pain. Cat inhaled sharply. Her hymen was torn. For a moment, it overshadowed the pleasure coursing through her. Yet, when her uncle slowly pulled out, the pleasure returned, and it doubled in intensity. Every time he plunged in, her pussy would tighten around his cock, as if it never wanted to let go.

Cat panted, just like her uncle behind her. Her juices and his pre wetted the spot between her thighs and down to her legs. The pungent scent of sex filled the air.

After a while, her uncle's movement began to turn erratic. The familiar pressure was building inside Cat once again. Finally, when the pleasure within her was almost to bursting, the rigid member between her legs sunk fully in her, and it spewed a big load inside Cat. The warm cum pushed her over the edge. Her pussy contracted, milking her uncle's incestuous seed and painting every nook and cranny of her unprotected womb.

Cat lost conscious after that intense orgasm. When she woke up, she was back on the chair, alone. Her uncle was no longer in the room. Although she was still naked, the stains from the sex had been cleaned up. Yet, she knew her having sex with her uncle had happened. Her sore pussy was the best proof.

Before her mind could wander more, she quickly looked for her clothes and put them on. She should take this chance to leave. She came near the door and listened for any sound outside. Hearing the silence and no sign of her uncle, she tiptoed out and locked the door behind her. She went out the backdoor and left her uncle's property.

Logically, she should be disgusted by what happened. She and her biological uncle had sex, and he even released his seed inside her. Yet, she wasn't. Instead, she was wondering if she could do it again.

With a glance full of confusion at her uncle's dark house, Cat hailed a taxi and went home.

*****

This work is copyright © 2025 by imprisonedindarkness. All rights reserved.