Beating Avni in Her Own Game

For context and history read the previous parts "Stuck Hiding with Avni", "Avni's Acceptance", "Baby" & "Break Up with Your Boyfriend Avni". This is story #5 in the 'Adventures and Avni' Series.

We were all hanging out on the terrace next day. I was sitting beside Avni and Riya was sitting on my other side. We were playing dumb charades. Suddenly while everyone was trying to guess the film, Riya's hand grazed over my dick. I paid no attention to it, thought it a mistake. A few rounds later, it happened again. I looked at her but she was looked focused on the game.

Later, Avni and me came down to my apartment. She was wearing a pista green top and a black skirt with a white border. As soon as she entered my house, I took her pink panties off. I sat her on my lap and started playing with her neatly shaved pussy.

Avni: "I need to talk to you."

Me: "About?"

A: "My boyfriend."

I took her top off, unhooked her bra. With my left hand, I twisted her left nipple.

Me: "Don't you mean ex?"

A: "AAAAAHH! Please spare me."

Me: "Spare me, what?"

A: "Please spare me, sir."

I let her left nipple rest, circling it with my left hand but I lightly twisted her right.

Me: "Why haven't you broken up with him?"

A: "I have, today. I just wanted to tell you, sir."

Me: "Good girl, now suck my cock like it's the last lollipop on earth."

I loved hitting the back of her throat with my cock. She gasped. Made a sloppy mess of her mouth. I stopped her before cumming. I took her hand and guided her to my bedroom, lay her on my bed and spread her legs wide. Then, I got in between her legs, kissed her, sucked on her nipples, kissed her neck and on her chest, between her boobs. I worked my way down the stomach leaving a trail of kisses until I reached her mound. I placed a kiss there and then on the inside of her thigh. I could feel her warmth from where I was. She was softly moaning in pleasure.

Me: "This is what good girls get."

I sucked on her clit while driving two fingers inside her, slowly. Exploring her insides with an interest so deep, she came within 30 seconds. I made her cum thrice, taking my time, slowing building up her orgasms. By the time I was done, she was spent.

"If you want to be treated like a good girl, be a good girl to me. And yeah, that time you told me about when somebody came inside you? Not gonna be your only time."

Avni: "No. No. I have to take the emergency pill after that. Messes up my cycle and I don't want the scare either."

Me: "Okay."

Honestly, I never felt okay about those things. She said the same thing about public sex and now this. She'd done this stuff with other guys but not me.

"Also, did you and Riya talk anymore about our stuff coz she kept giving us teasing smiles today."

A: "Well... you know right? Sometimes we talk and stuff just comes out."

Me: "Well, how much does she know?"

A: "Bits and pieces, you know?"

Me: "Did you tell her everything we do, how we do it etc.?"

A: "No, not in detail like that."

Me: "Okay."

After Avni left, I went up to the terrace. It was dark and I sat by the water tanker which is a flight of stairs up. The view is all high rises, so small flashing lights, and airplanes going by.

I texted Riya that I was there. She didn't reply but showed up after 5 minutes. She sat beside me, a little too close.

Riya: "Why'd you call me up?"

Me: "Just coz I wanted to talk to you about something."

Riya: "What?"

Me: "Avni told me that she talks to you about our stuff. I feel weird but don't know who to talk to about this either, given no one else knows about us. So, basically, here's the thing. I don't really like the fact that Avni tells you such private stuff."

R: "I understand. She didn't tell you that she's gonna. But it's a simple thing, girls talk about this stuff."

Me: "Yeah. Are you still mad about what I said?"

R: "No, in fact that reminds me that today me and Avni were talking about it in class when all of a sudden her boyfriend walked in. We had to pretend to talk about something else but it was so funny."

I had a bad feeling about the next question I was gonna ask.

Me: "Yeah. How long have they been together now?"

R: "Couple of months as far as I know. She didn't exactly tell me when it started. You know Avni. In fact, don't tell her I told you this, but I saw her by football ground, in the small lane with some other guy, making out."

Not only hadn't Avni not broken up with her boyfriend but now a third guy? And is that the extent of it? And why was Riya telling me this? Didn't she know I wanted a relationship with Avni not just a fling?

Me: "You wanted to know my size right? I can shove it down your throat for you to measure."

R: "What? Ew, no. Don't even try with me, okay? Did you forget about Avni?"

Me: "And despite her, I find you more attractive. That's why when you were 'accidentally grazing' over my dick today, you found an erection. I was thinking how your pussy walls would stretch around my dick and how it'd taste."

R: "You... would go down on me?"

Me: "I'd do that for you for hours. BUT only if you satisfy me. And from the little tales Avni's told you, I think you know that takes some work. Are you up for the challenge?"

R: "This is crazy."

Me: "I think you know how sweet the offer is considering you have my... performance review."

R: "There'll be no one in my flat for a couple of hours."

Me: "Give me your keys."

We rushed down to her flat and into her room. I locked it.

I sat Riya on my lap. She smelled but I didn't care right then. I kissed her for really long. Then I unbuttoned her jeans and took it off along with her black panties. Her panties were drenched. I took the panties and tasted them while looking at her. I threw her on her bed. She spread her legs voluntarily. She felt warm and tight. I pushed slowly till she could adjust all of me inside her. Her depth was more than Avni's and her boobs were smaller but none of it mattered then. I fucked her, hard. The bed was shaking with every thrust. Riya's head even hit the headboard but I kept going. Riya bit my neck to stop from screaming cause of the orgasms she got. I went harder and deeper inside her. Her legs were shaking. I couldn't hold out any longer and didn't care. I kept fucking until I came inside her. Two women in that family, fucked both, creampied both. Riya lay down breathing heavy. It's only then that I noticed my cum flowing down her pussy.

I kissed her neck, caressed her face and then told her to go clean herself off.

Riya: "What the fuck! It was such a mistake to do it with a loser like you."

I persuaded her. She gave up and went into the bathroom a while later. She came out and sat beside me, all clothed up. I pulled her jeans down again while she kept resisting.

R: "NOT AGAIN!"

I slapped her mound.

Me: "Shut up and lay back down. If you don't, I'm gonna show you what rough sex really means. Trust me, just lay down."

She listened to me and I started going down on her. The moment my tongue touched her most sensitive skin, she shuddered. She stifled her moans, I stopped.

Me: "If you stop yourself from showing the pleasure I'm working so hard to give you, it's not gonna be worth it to me."

R: "Sorry, sorry, please continue."

I kissed her pussy. She moaned. I started frenching her down there, sucking on the clit, tongue running wild all over. She grabbed the bedsheet hard in her fists. I gave her clit little bites. She came, groaning. And again, and again. Her hands on my head, pushing me into her. She asked me to stop then.

R: "No more, no more, my parents must be coming back."

Me: "I told you to trust me. You should always trust me, will always turn out well for you. I wish I could take a picture of you naked, so that when I thing of you tonight in my room, I don't only have to imagine... this..."

R (smiling): "Shut up, get out. NOW!"

I walked home and into my shower. When I took my clothes off, I realised that I smelled like Riya.

I texted Avni "Wanna meet tonight?"

A: "How?"

Me: "Sneak out after everybody's asleep. Meet on the terrace?"