The Witch and the FTM Transforming

My name is Naomi. Or at least, that's what people call me. I've never been a fan of my name, but I can't quite pinpoint why. It's alright though, I'm used to things not making sense. I live in a small town where nothing ever really happens. It's always a surprise when we get someone moving here, and that's why I've been surprised today. One of my brothers said that the new person was an ugly old hag that literally had big warts on her nose and lived in a cave. That piqued my curiosity because who the hell can survive down there?

My current mode of operation was to visit her. Maybe it's delusion, maybe it's intuition, but maybe something can change in my life. Obviously though, I'm not going alone. I'll bring Nicky and Carrie, the former being my twin brother and the latter being my best friend. Well, at least I think she's my best friend. We've been trying to learn magic together at a community college but she's way better at it than me. At least, with the teleportation spells. I'm kind of dispassionate and that's a big part of summoning enough mana to be able to cast spells.

I called her over to teleport here.

"Hey, Cassie, wanna meet the new witch?"

"Fuck it, I got nothing else to do," she said.

In the snap of an eye, she came over and was in a short crimson red dress that showed off her cleavage well. It might be inconvenient for meeting someone new, but fuck if I cared.

"Where's Nicky and Steve?" she asked.

"Steve didn't want to come," I said.

At that moment, my brother opened his room and stepped out. He was quite tall and had a broad body, with a short boyish hairstyle. It was black like mine, except I had medium-length hair. I don't like to pay attention to my appearance.

"Okay, here's what we'll do," said Cassie, "I can scan the area outside of the cave for perils with my mind's eye. I'll teleport you guys a bit outside and we'll go in then. Does that sound like a plan?"

"Actually, Steve said he wanted to go to the fish market, he said he wanted to try out catching his own but he wants my help," said Nicky.

"It's alright," said Cassie, "So it's just us two then," she asked, tapping my foot with her ballet shoes.

"Yeah, sure," I said back.

Cassie closed her eyes and starting humming a bit. Nicky looked at me, I could tell he wanted to protect me in case something went wrong. It's weird though, we're both 21, and yet when we were little, he was a soft sensitive boy who cried a lot. Now he's a big burly man... I wish - no - nevermind that. I cannot allow myself to continue that train of thought. I looked back at Cassie. She kept twitching, obviously trying to concentrate on the landscape. It seems like a cool use of magic but I don't want to take her niche.

She gasped a bit as if she was asleep and water was being poured on her face.

"What happened?" I asked.

"Nothing," she said, "I was just very focused on it that it took a bit to get me out of it."

"Are we ready yet?" I asked..

"Yes yes, I've learned that it's a bit less jarring if you close your eyes," said Cassie.

"Alright," I said.

I closed my eyes. After a few seconds, I felt the air suddenly get colder. I opened my eyes and we were on a trail road with a crossroad sign pointing one way labeled "Town", and the other way labeled "Egra's Cave." That's where we needed to go.

"I wonder how many visitors she gets," I said.

"I wonder if they're kind to her," said Cassie.

We traversed the trail to Egra's Cave, mostly silently with little irrelevant comments along the way. We found that the entrance to the cave was polished with amethyst jewels all over it.

"Damn, this is hot," said Cassie.

I wanted to say she was hot too but resisted. Looking back at her, I wonder why she chose that sort of clothing for a cave. My clothes were simply a black jacket with black pants, with rain boots in case there were puddles. I said nothing else and followed her as she swayed her hips to see Egra. I don't think I sway my hips when I walk - or do I?

After a bit, we were inside. I saw Egra admiring a topaz gemstone from behind. She was hunched back and had graying skin and completely grayed out hair.

"Hello, ma'am," I said.

Egra turned back and looked annoyed.

"Who dares to disturb me?" she asked in a croaky voice.

"Gee, I bet you think you're so scary," I said, only to feel danger in the ambient.

"Naomi, I don't think you should fuck with her," said Cassie, "Let's go back."

"Yes, yes, young lady. I do not tolerate disrespect," said Egra. I was starting to get scared, but I decided I'd stand my ground.

"What are you going to do? YOU started it!" I said.

I heard Naomi stepping back, but I stayed, wondering if Egra's threats were empty. It may have been a mistake when I started to feel nauseous and as if my body was transforming. I was scared I'd get turned into a frog or something, but I started to get bigger and bigger, especially in my clitoris. I felt my tits shrink and my throat get heavy, then I felt my entire body become more muscular.

"Hey, what are you-" I said, only for the shock to come in. My voice wasn't just very deep, it sounded like a man's voice. I could feel the testosterone flowing through every inch of my body, my mind felt sharp and full of masculine vitality. This felt... like a dream... come true.

"Naomi?!" shouted out Cassie.

"It's Carter now," I said in a baritone voice.

"Oh.... damn, Carter... you're - you're, a man now," said Cassie.

My body barely fit into my feminine clothes so they were ripped open and extremely tight.

"FUUUUUUUCK," I said, with my voice vibrating through my chest. Man - that felt good as hell.

"What's wrong... I hope you're alright" said Cassie.

"I need to take off these clothes, I hope you'll be alright," I said.

"Um um ummmmm," she stammered, clearly blushing. She hasn't even seen my cock yet - and I haven't. I feel my erection poking my pants and it felt so powerful.

I started to unzip my pants and dropped my panties to show off my erect girthy cock. Seeing my hard dick made me so horny and gave me an urge to fuck NOW! I've been horny before but it was so slow and sensual, fuck that shit. With my newfound male urges, I can clearly visualize Cassie's nude body in a way I was always embarrassed to imagine before. Her supple boobs on her beautiful body going down to a slim slutty waist and her big ass on the back got me going. Her shaven or unshaven pussy being wet for me and my cock got me so insatiably horny.

"This is my first time seeing a dick up close," said Cassie.

"No need to thank me," said Egra.

"W-what do you mean?" asked Cassie.

"Carter has always wanted to be a man, and you've always wanted a good boyfriend you get along with well," said Egra.

"O-oh well, I'm not used to this... yet, but I definitely can - very soon even," said Cassie.

"I can make you so happy, my beloved," I said.

"O-oh, w-w-w-hat do I do?" stammered Cassie.

"Take off your dress and panties," I said, "Your pussy is a good pussy, I'd love to make love to it."

"You're so confident," she said.

Obeying me, she unzipped her dress. It may just be my imagination but the cave started to illuminate in a much more fitting direction. The floor was much cleaner now and it stopped looking like a cave. Cassie smiled, dropping her dress to the floor and exposing her boobs fully and then doing a little jiggle with them for me to see. She then moved her hips to the left and took off her lacy red panties, the same color as her dress. Her pussy was trimmed, and I was ready to give it some love.

"Hey, Egra, could you leave us to be?" asked Cassie.

"I could become much more beautiful if you guys are up for a threesome," she said.

"I don't think I swing that way," said Cassie... "I'm not sure though."

"I'll show you," said Egra, "I know you aren't the jealous type."

Egra started to concentrate and her face softened into a young woman's. Her hunchback straightened and she became a pretty redhead with a slightly wider body than Cassie's.

"Oh fuck yeah," I said.

"Call me Olivia now," said Egra.

"So Olivia, can you jerk me off while I lick Cassie's cute little clit?" I asked.

I bent down and Cassie laid on her back, spreading her legs. I started to lick her little clit gently and she breathed heavily. Olivia struggled to position herself in a way to jerk me off, so she looked up at me.

"My arms would get a bit tired, but you know what wouldn't? My mouth," she said.

"I'd love to feel you wrap your cute lips around my cock," I said.

Olivia opened her mouth and started sucking me off. I kept circling my tongue around Cassie's clit while she rubbed her boobs and nipples. This made them a lot more round and perkier, with her areolas changing a bit to make them look nicer for our pleasure.

"I think I'm gonna cum," said Cassie.

"Wow, I'm that good?" I asked.

"Yes... it might be our emotional connection," she said back.

I kept circling her clit without changing my speed or rhythm and she started to moan and move her head to the left, closing her eyes from the orgasm while gripping her hands together. I started to feel my penis building up cum ready to be released.

"Now I think I'm gonna cum," I said, becoming excited at the prospect of something shooting out of my cock and being contained in a beautiful woman's mouth. Olivia gave me eye contact and at that moment, I came hard. I felt the fluid exit my dick and Olivia kept sucking, making my knees weak from pleasure.

"So THIS is what a dick is like," I said, trying to keep my moans in but failing, letting out little moans in the mean time.

"Of course, I've experienced this too with my transformation magic as well. I'm not the biggest fan of it though, and I don't think Cassie would like to be a man at all," said Olivia.

"Oh no, no way. I love my pussy and having a dick would feel so weird," said Cassie.

"This feels... right though," I said, "I don't know what my brothers would think."

"Who cares what they think?" said Olivia.

"I can just be... Carter?" I asked.

"Of course. I can teach you better magic to protect yourself from dangerous enemies if you must," said Olivia.

"Awesome, I'd love to learn too," said Cassie, "but I'm a bit exhausted right now."

"Wow, it seems that having sex turned this dimly cave into an extravagant tiny palace," I said.

"Yup, I could teleport you tow back if you want," said Olivia.

"Sure!" said Cassie and I.

With that, we went on our way. I'm not a virgin anymore and neither is my best friend... or maybe even girlfriend. I'm so, so happy. I just hope my brothers are happy too.