Persuasion Check - Critical Success

**DISCLAIMER:

All characters in this story are over 18 and purely creations of fiction. Everything depicted is intended to be consensual acts involving adults. This is meant to be a fun story with only a loose connection to real life. It is not meant to be realistic. This is meant to be read for enjoyment, so hopefully you have some fun reading it. Thanks!**

**This story was written for the 2025 Literotica Geek Pride Story Event**

To a portion of society, the terms geek and nerd mean very different things. The label nerd is more often directed at the academically focused, and geeks were just people who obsessed about hobbies and entertainment on the fringes of culture. To other people though, the terms are basically synonymous, to be used interchangeably.

The difference never bothered Simon much, since he had always been both the biggest geek and the hugest nerd in whatever room he was in. His passion for learning and education had started early. His interest in things like tabletop wargames, epic fantasy books, and roleplaying had grown strong in his youth as well. Simon dove headlong into all sorts of geeky hobbies regardless of whatever stigma was placed on enjoying them.

Simon was called both a geek and a nerd, and he received many other less kind labels like dork and dweeb. In his youth his interests weren't culturally relevant, and they were often maligned. So when he got into his thirties and began to see the culture shift, he was amazed. He couldn't believe that comic book movies became mainstream, or that tabletop role playing games gained wide acceptance. He was shocked at how what once was ridiculed started being trendy.

Some of his peers that had grown up being mocked for their passions grew bitter at the sudden change, but Simon took a different attitude. He just loved that the things he enjoyed were being loved by more and more people. He accepted the newcomers, and he used his decades of knowledge and experience in all sorts of topics to help educate those brand new to his favorite hobbies.

Tabletop roleplaying games was one of the faster growing hobbies of Simon's, and he soon found himself DMing for several groups who needed someone experienced with the rules and skilled in crafting a story. He had a deep passion for worldbuilding and strategy, so this made Simon ideal for the role. One of the groups he led was made up of several young women, and they played at a local library where one of them worked.

The game sessions were always lively and full of fun. His players had taken up the game with enthusiasm and a surprising amount of skill. They pushed him to build even greater worlds to explore and adventure in, and dared him to create the most dangerous challenges for them to face. One on late Saturday night, the game got even more energetic than usual.

They were sitting in some comfy couches around a coffee table in a corner of the library that had been made into a reading nook. The library was closed, and the group were the only ones in the building. The players were at a crucial point in their adventure, so both the excitement and the tension was high. They had just finished defeating an enormous monster, and had only narrowly avoided losing the whole party. Now they were negotiating with potential allies for help in their final strike against the big bad evil guy. Simon was mostly taking a backseat as the players decided what strategy to use to best convince the npcs to assist them.

The girls were pouring over their stats, picking out which character had the best expertise. During the discussion the talk became sidetracked, and the conversation switched to theorizing what each persons' real life stats would be. This sparked an even more lively discussion as the girls argued about just how skilled they were. Simon was happy to let the conversation go off on a tangent, since that let him prepare more for the adventure's climatic battle. But after a few minutes of listening to them he knew he would soon get dragged into the conversation.

"I know that I would have proficiency in history, maybe even expertise." Mandy declared.

Mandy spoke with complete confidence, and she wore a smug smile. Across the table, Zoey rolled her eyes and let out a dismissive chuckle. She smirked at Mandy and shook her head.

"No way, you barely know anything about history. Just last week you admitted that you thought Belgium wasn't even a real country and that you believed it was made up like Atlantis. Your major is business marketing, you'd be proficient in... deception, or maybe athletics since you're so flexible from being a cheerleader." Zoey offered.

Mandy glared at Zoey because of her challenge to Mandy's claim, but there was no hostility between the two at all. Some of the girls in the group might argue, but they were all extremely close friends. All of their bickering was playful, even if it occasionally looked heated and tense from an outsider's perspective.

"No way, Mandy's right. She and I have played Civ 5 together since we were kids, and we've probably put hundreds and hundreds of hours into that game. That would make us history experts, absolutely." Catalina suggested as she chimed in.

"That doesn't mean anything. Video games can't teach you about history." Alexis argued, adding in a warm laugh.

Alexis, Catalina, Zoey, and Mandy were the four girls of the group. Mandy and Catalina had been best friends since childhood, and they were both first year students at the local university. The two girls were outspoken and headstrong, and they were always bursting with vibrant energy. Though they were half the age of Simon, they had ignored the age difference and readily accepted him as their games master and had always been friendly with him.

Zoey was just a few years older, and she was the one who worked at the library and allowed us to use it after hours for our gaming sessions. Zoey already sometimes acted like a stuffy old librarian, even though she had only just started the job and was in her very early twenties. She was quiet and reserved than the younger girls during work hours, but her demeanor changed completely during their gaming sessions. She had a wild and mischievous streak, and she could be just as stubborn and determined as the college girls.

Lastly there was Alexis. She was closer to Simon's age, nearing her thirties, and she was the glue that held the whole group together. She had been the one to connect everyone together to form the group, and she played the 'mom' role quite often. Her attitude was always upbeat and positive, and she had a knack for soothing and comforting people quite easily.

Alexis usually played the negotiator whenever there was a disagreement, even in friendly arguments, but this time she placed herself with Zoey squarely against the college girls. With two on each side, they quickly turned to Simon to be the tie breaker.

"What do you think? Would Catalina's and my extensive experience with Civ 5 be a good enough reason to give us proficiency in history?" Mandy asked.

"Come on, you've probably put more hours into video games than the rest of us combined. I'm sure you know that they can't teach a thing about history." Zoey said.

Simon took in a deep breath and ran a hand through his hair as he deliberated how to answer. He knew that the argument was all in good fun, but he wanted to give a well thought out and considered response anyway. He had a great interest in both history and video games, so he had more than a few thoughts on the subject.

"Well, I'm sure video games can teach a lot if they present the information in the right way. Interactive media has a great opportunity to educate people in a very engaging manner. I know that I've learned a lot, or at least got interested in certain historical topics, from some games." Simon admitted.

Mandy and Catalina both smiled in triumph when they heard Simon's words. They winked at each other and then gave their game master encouraging smiles since they thought he was fully agreeing with them. They then turned their smug and self-satisfied smirks to Zoey and Alexis as they prepared to gloat. But before they could start boasting Simon continued his thoughts.

"But, I'm not so sure Civ 5 would be the best teacher, nor would it be enough to make you an expert in history. It's got some historical flavoring and theme, but unless you're spending hours just reading the descriptions and then doing more research on your own, I don't think you will actually learn much history from it." Simon added.

Catalina's and Mandy's victorious smiles turned sour, but Zoey and Alexis didn't look fully pleased by this answer either. Neither felt their side was fully supported, which only deepened their desires to argue their points. The two pairs of girls soon launched into an even more vigorous debate, but they mostly ignored Simon.

The four women dove so strongly into their exchange of claims and rebuttals that they nearly started shouting. Simon was glad that he knew them well, since it could very easily be assumed that the two sides might actually start getting angry and grow resentful of each other. But the girls all adored one another, and they all fully enjoyed their lively and heated discussions.

Even though there was still no hostility, Simon eventually got somewhat tired of hearing them trade accusations and wild assertions back and forth. He waited for a lull in the conversation, which was hard to find, and then tried to offer a resolution. Thankfully the girls all noticed his attempt to make peace, and they were respectfully silent and attentive to him as he gave his proposal.

"So, I don't think we all are going to come to the same conclusion anytime soon through just simple debating. So why don't we put the idea to a test?" He asked, looking between the girls.

Each of the women immediately perked up at the idea, and they grinned with enthusiasm. They loved challenges, and they had played with Simon long enough to know that he usually came up with ones that were fun to do. And they were also wanting to prove their claim the true one, and this seemed a better option than convincing the other side with words. They looked to Simon and waited to hear the details.

"We could do a short quiz. Mandy and Catalina on one side, me on the other. Alexis and Zoey can ask questions about history. That way we can see if the young ladies actually learned some history from their Civ games, or if I have learned more through more traditional methods." Simon proposed.

The girls took a moment to consider the idea. Alexis looked fine with the plan, and she nodded confidently to Simon. This sort of idea fit very well with Alexis's nature, since it wouldn't leave much room for any further arguing and the group could move on from the issue. Zoey was a little less sure, but she didn't argue. She nodded as well to Simon, but she also had a mischievous light in her eyes that warned she was coming up with a roguish plan of her own. Zoey often enjoyed putting twists in plans, and her pranks were far more devious than one might expect out of a quiet librarian.

Catalina and Mandy both were uncertain about the plan, but it wasn't because they disagreed with how it might turn out. Instead, they both looked a little bored by the simplicity of it. The college girls preferred ideas with more risk, more adventure. Having a dull quiz was too plain and basic, and they quickly voiced their concern.

"That's way too boring. We should do something more exciting. If I'm going to prove Alexis and Zoey wrong I want to have fun doing it." Catalina said with a chuckle.

"Catalina's right. We need higher stakes, winning an argument isn't a good enough reward. There should be some sort of betting involved, or at least a penalty for a wrong answer." Mandy offered as she pondered the idea.

Simon wasn't surprised by Mandy's suggestion, and he wasn't against having the quiz be more exciting. But he wasn't immediately sure how to accommodate it. Alexis was less certain, but once again she didn't argue. She was happy enough to go along with whatever plan if it made everyone happy.

Zoey however was thrilled by the addition of more risk and more reward to the quiz. The mischievous light in her eyes grew brighter as she grinned wickedly. It was clear that Zoey had an idea that she thought would be perfect to raise the stakes and make the challenge more exciting. She giggled and then stood up from the table.

"I think I have just the thing that will make this great." Zoey declared.

"Just wait one sec, I'll be right back." She added quickly.

Zoey gave the group a wink and then rushed off towards the back of the library. Simon and the other girls glanced between each other as they waited. They were slightly confused, but they were also very interested in what Zoey was doing. Though Zoey's tricks and schemes were often outlandish, they did always provide a whole lot of fun and amusement.

Zoey reappeared after just a few minutes, and she was holding a large liquor bottle and several shot glasses. Alexis's eyes went wide with shock at the sight of the alcohol, and a worried expression passed over her face. Catalina and Mandy however both grinned eagerly, immediately liking whatever Zoey was planning. Though they were early in their college careers, they both had quickly taken to the partying lifestyle a lot of students adopted in university. They knew that some booze made just about everything better.

"Where was that hiding? Don't tell me the library has started lending out liquor now?" Catalina teased, smirking at Zoey.

"No, we'd be overrun by crazy college kids in no time if we did that." Zoey replied with a warm laugh as she set down the bottle. "This is from a supply we keep to celebrate when we work late and do sorting. It helps motivate us through the tedium, but I thought it would work just as well to spice up this game a bit."

Mandy rubbed her hands in anticipation as she grinned at the alcohol, and Alexis started to come down from her surprise. Simon was still a bit stunned, and he looked at it curiously. He ran a hand through his beard as he turned his gaze to Zoey.

"So, how are you wanting to use this?" He asked her.

"It's simple, whenever a team gets a question wrong, they have to take a shot. Mandy and Catalina will split theirs, since they are just tiny little things. That'll make it even since you really bulked up once you started hitting the gym." Zoey explained.

Without waiting for anyone to agree or even just ask for more clarification, Zoey took her seat next to Alexis and then poured out two shots. She nudged one glass towards Simon and the other to Catalina and Mandy, keeping the bottle next to herself. Zoey then turned to Alexis and gave her a playful nudge.

"We can have a few too, if you want. But not too much, we need to come up with the questions. So why don't you start us off." Zoey instructed Alexis.

Alexis paused for a second as she considered the bottle of liquor warily, but she gave a resigned sigh and pulled out her phone. She tapped and scrolled for a little while before she came up with the first question of the quiz. Catalina and Mandy waited with excitement, and it was clear that they felt completely confident that they were in a good position to win this challenge. The first question was directed at Simon, since he had proposed the game in the first place.

"What year was the Norman conquest of England?" Alexis asked, glancing in between her phone and Simon.

"God, that's way too easy." Simon said with a relieved laugh. "1066. I think the battle of Hastings was in September of that year, or maybe October."

Zoey leaned over to Alexis and peered at her phone to check the answer. She looked back at Simon and gave him a broad smile as she told him he was correct. Both Mandy and Catalina looked worried, since they knew they wouldn't have even been able to guess that answer. They suddenly felt far less certain that they could win this if that was how hard the first question was. They gave each other nervous glances as they waited for their question.

"Okay girls, what was the German state that led the unification of Germany in the late 1800s?" Alexis asked.

Both of the college students furrowed their brows and leaned in close. They whispered hurriedly back and forth, frantically trying to come up with an answer. Their faces showed their utter lack of confidence, and when Mandy put forth an answer she sounded like she didn't have any faith in what they had come up with.

"Uh... Is it Bavaria? That's a German state... um, right?" Mandy ventured.

Zoey didn't even need to check Alexis's phone before grinning with delight and telling Mandy that she was wrong. Catalina let out a defeated sigh, and Mandy gave a soft curse. But their disappointment was quickly lessened as they took their penalty. They each downed their half of the shot with relish, drinking the liquor straight without any hesitation. Right after they looked eager to face the next question.

Instead of Alexis, Zoey provided the next round of questions. She pulled out her own phone, and her smile grew even more devious and full of mischief as she searched for a good question. Simon immediately knew that she had some sort of trick planned. He wasn't bothered by it, and in fact he was eager to see what her scheme was. Simon always enjoyed her plans, no matter how wild they were.

"Okay, here's your next question Simon. What was the birth name of the Pope that set off the first crusade?" Zoey asked.

Zoey giggled as she gave the question, and her laughter grew when saw how baffled Simon was at it. He scratched his head, not having anticipated this sort of difficulty at all. This type of question was far past just being a good piece of trivia, and it seemed impossible to him to know the right answer.

"Uh... I don't know. I'm pretty sure that it was Urban II, but I have no idea of his birth name." Simon confessed.

"Aww, too bad. I guess that means you need to drink." Zoey replied, smirking and giving Simon a playful wink.

Alexis looked a little shocked at how hard the question had been, but she smiled and nodded towards the shot glass in front of him. Mandy and Catalina both looked thrilled that Simon had gotten a question wrong, and they quickly started to encourage him to down his drink. With all the girls cheering him on, Simon laughed and downed the shot, not letting himself be bothered by the impossible question. He got cheered on while he drank the liquor, and Zoey then turned to face the younger two girls.

"Okay, your turn now. What country was Napoleon from?" Zoey asked, not even bothering to pull out her phone before giving the question.

Simon was confused, as was Alexis by this question. It was as easy as Simon's had been hard. But Catalina and Mandy both didn't waste any time pondering the sudden change in difficulty. They whispered eagerly to each other to make sure they both had the same answer before shouting it out.

"France, he was from France!" Catalina declared, a confident smile on her lips.

And just like that Simon and the two students were tied, in both points and penalties. The next few rounds went nearly the exact same, and Alexis and Zoey continued to trade off giving pairs of questions to the two teams. Alexis gave fairly normal questions, with none of them too hard or too easy. Zoey however stuck to her plan, giving Simon questions nearly impossible to know, and giving the younger girls softball questions that most grade schoolers could answer. The only time she changed from her formula was when Mandy and Catalina got one of Alexis's questions right. Then she gave the girls a question just as hard as the ones she provided to Simon.

It was clear that despite the challenge having arisen from a disagreement between Zoey and the younger girls, Zoey's goal wasn't just to see them proven wrong. Instead, her plan was to have both sides get fairly equal points, and to get everyone equally drunk. And it worked quite well. She also started pouring shots for herself, and she gave more than a few to Alexis as well. In a short amount of time everyone was having enormous amounts of fun, no matter how uneven the quiz was. It became just a good excuse to drink with friends.

The liquor wasn't too strong, and no one got badly drunk. But at the same time everyone definitely felt the effects of the alcohol. Mandy and Catalina were almost constantly giggling and sharing giddy smiles. Alexis became more relaxed and carefree than she normally allowed herself to be, and she started pouring her own shots instead of relying on Zoey to encourage her participation in the drinking. The more Zoey drank the more devious her smirk became, and the burning light in her eyes forewarned that she was crafting even more mischievous schemes. Simon just let himself enjoy the high spirits of the group, not caring that they had completely abandoned their roleplaying game.

Everyone was at a good amount of tipsy and merry when Mandy requested a change in rules. She and Catalina had just accidently incorrectly answered one of Zoey's easy questions, mistakenly saying Australia instead of Austria. They shared their penalty shot and then Mandy interrupted Alexis as she prepared the next set of questions.

"If we keep this up, I'm going to get blackout before we figure out if Catalina and I actually know any history. Maybe we should change up the rules, make the penalty something else" Mandy suggested, only barely slurring a few of the words.

Simon was interested by this proposal, and so was Alexis. The quiz was a surprising amount of fun, and they didn't want to end it too quickly by getting drunk enough that nobody could ask or answer coherently. Zoey was also intrigued, but she was most interested in if she could use this change up to add in one of her schemes and make the evening even more wild.

"Well, whatever we do, we still have to have some stakes to the challenge. There has to be something risky about answering wrong." Catalina chimed in.

Zoey nodded, and a wicked smile spread across her lips. She pulled back the shot glasses, and leaned forward in her seat. It was clear that she had a new idea that she thought would fit perfectly. The rest of the group watched her carefully, wondering what the idea might be.

"Okay, if we're not going to penalize wrong answers with shots, then the team that gives an incorrect answer should lose something. And since I'm pretty sure none of us want to be handing over cash, I think that when a team gets a question wrong they need to take off an article of clothing." Zoey proposed.

Both Alexis and Simon went wide-eyed at Zoey's words. They were stunned by the thought of anyone in the group stripping. Simon was especially shocked, as he couldn't imagine taking off clothes in front of girls half his age, or having them do it in front of him. But before either of them could say anything to express their shock, Mandy leaned in to speak.

"Okay, but shoes and socks and that sort of thing counts as one article. And we aren't using rings, watches, hairpins, or anything like that. Only actual pieces of clothing." Mandy demanded.

Catalina leaned up and nodded, agreeing to all of what Mandy had suggested. Zoey considered what the younger girl had said for a moment, and then nodded as well. Catalina, Zoey, and Mandy were usually the most argumentative of the group, but in this case they came to an understanding in just moments.

Simon was nearly as surprised that they all agreed to it as he was that Zoey had suggested it. And he was shocked that the only thing Mandy seemed concerned by was clarifying the rules. She showed no issue with the fact that she was being asked to possibly strip, and she didn't seem bothered that she was expecting Simon to strip as well. In fact, after hashing out the rules she and Catalina seemed quite excited by it.

He didn't know if it was the alcohol that made them so willing to agree to potentially taking off clothes, but they acted completely nonchalant about it. And after the initial shock of hearing the idea passed, Simon felt more comfortable with it himself than he expected. The combination of what he had drank, and how casually Zoey and the college girls accepted it, made him curiously calm. Not being able to stop himself, he nodded and then voiced his agreement to the idea.

Simon didn't let himself think too much about his third reason for agreeing, or at least he tried not to consciously think about it. His subconscious however was exhilarated by the chance to see some of the girls in his group with less clothes. All of them were incredibly sexy women, and just the idea of seeing Mandy or Catalina stripped down to their underwear was wonderful. Even though he shoved these thoughts down, Simon still felt his heart begin to race as powerful desires stirred within him.

With all four of the others agreeing to this wild idea, Alexis didn't voice a single protest. She was uneasy about the new rule, but she set aside her concerns. If everyone else seemed to like it, then she didn't want to be a downer and ruin the fun. And just like in Simon, there was a piece of her deep inside that was quite thrilled with the idea of having some of the people around her get partially naked. But she didn't dwell on that part of her, and instead just pulled up a new set of questions on her phone.

The first round of the quiz with the new rules left Mandy without her sandals and Simon with all of his clothes. Zoey quickly corrected this, giving Simon an extremely hard question that made him forfeit his sneakers. Zoey's question to the girls was also quite hard, and Catalina lost her heels as well.

Now that they were playing for clothes, rather than being given shots of liquor when they answered wrong, Zoey started playing hard on both sides. It was apparent that getting Simon and the college girls half naked was a big part of her plan, and she grinned wider each time something was taken off. Alexis still gave questions that Simon could usually answer and the girls couldn't, but since there were two people on the girls' side it still meant they all got undressed at an equal rate.

Zoey wasn't the only one enjoying seeing their friends take off clothes. Catalina and Mandy both giggled with joy when the other had to strip, and they helped each other strip. Even Alexis was delighted by the game, to the surprise of everyone else. She even gave Simon extra hard questions whenever he happened to get one of Zoey's right, just to make sure he continued stripping at a consistent pace.

With jewelry and extraneous pieces of clothing excluded, both sides got down to their underwear in just a few rounds. With the liquor flowing in everyone's body, no one complained when it was their turn to take off a piece of clothing. And the alcohol also made everyone more eager to openly watch their friends strip down. And even though the game didn't require it anymore, everyone took a few more drinks during the next few rounds. The quiz remained fun and exciting, and everyone's spirits were high and cheerful.

Simon got far more excited than he wanted to show each time one of his opponents took something off. It became harder and harder not to leer at their young bodies the more of them they exposed. When each girl pulled her shirt off, his eyes were drawn magnetically to their chests, and the alcohol in his system made it difficult to pull his gaze away. His heart raced when Mandy tugged off her shorts, especially since she turned around and bent over to do it. She pulled them down slowly, gradually revealing her plump and juicy ass barely contained behind a skimpy pair of panties. Catalina removed her skirt by letting Mandy unzip it with her teeth, which was as tantalizing and teasing a sight as Simon had ever seen.

As exciting as it was to watch Catalina and Mandy undress, Simon's heart beat even faster when he had to strip. Simon had spent most of his life as a skinny and fairly wimpy nerd. He was tall, but he had also been built like a twig. It was only during the last year or so that he had finally changed. A friend had started inviting him to lift weights, and Simon had made remarkable improvements to his physique. Simon had bulked up considerably, and now had an impressive build, but he was still quite conscious about his body and appearance. He was also nervous about how much older he was than his opponents. He was twice their age, though the girls had never made him feel old.

He might have been hesitant and nervous to show off his new figure, but his friends were eager to see it revealed. They cheered him on each time he took something off, and they gave him loads of compliments on how good he looked. Simon felt like they were just trying to be nice, but all of their girls did actually enjoy his body the more of it they saw. They didn't care a bit that he was older than them, and in fact for some of them it was quite an additional turn on.

Alexis started to stare longingly at his newly developed muscles, especially his pecs. Zoey had a hard time taking her eyes off his broad shoulders and thick forearms, and she started to bite her lower lip as she gazed at him. Mandy and Catalina were even more open with their hungry stares, and lust started to shine in their eyes. Catalina licked her lips as she marveled at his toned thighs, and Mandy looked dreamily at his visible and well built abs.

Though each of the girls focused on different parts of his body, they all found that their eyes kept moving back down just below his waist. Simon was trying not to ogle his half nude friends too much, but the sight of two amazingly attractive girls in their underwear was impossible to not get aroused by. A bulge grew in his tight boxers, much to his annoyance. But the girls loved it, especially Mandy and Catalina. The students grinned and whispered to each other as they noticed how big it was getting. Their smiles grew brighter and they giggled when they noticed it twitched and moved each time Simon looked at them.

With three of the five people now almost naked, and with everyone fairly tipsy, the sexual tension in the room grew quite high. And now that Simon, Mandy, and Catalina were just in their underwear, that meant the next question someone answered wrong would mean removing a bra, a pair of panties, or Simon's boxers. It was Alexis's turn to ask a question, but everyone just looked at each other.

Simon felt the tension most strongly, and he felt the tension of his cock pressing against his underwear quite keenly as well. He was so nervous about showing so much of his body that he didn't notice how eagerly the girls were staring at him. He also didn't spot how happily Catalina and Mandy received his hungry stares, even though he attempted to keep his glimpses at their bodies brief.

The college girls did spot how nervous Simon looked, and how he awkwardly tried to sneak peaks at them. They thought it made him even more sweet and adorable, and they already thought that he was extremely cute. Turning to each other they whispered together for a short moment before Catalina broke the silence and the heavy tension that had descended over the group.

"Well, I guess that settles things. I wasn't keeping track perfectly, but I'm pretty sure Simon has a bunch more points than Mandy and me. That just proves that we were wrong about being proficient in history." Catalina said with an exaggerated sigh.

"But that still leaves us wondering what our skills might be. Maybe our veteran games master might be able to use his vast experience and enlighten us?" Mandy suggested.

The girls grinned with wicked delight and stood up from their seats. They giggled deviously while they crossed over to Simon. As they walked towards him, Simon couldn't help but stare more directly at their incredible bodies. He took a few moments to admire just how good they looked.

Both girls were quite short, especially compared to Simon, and Catalina was the shorter of the two. Mandy was as thin and slender as a supermodel, though she still managed to have an amazingly plump butt. She was currently showing almost all of her pale skin, and every inch looked as soft as silk. Her strawberry blonde hair was currently loosely styled around her shoulders, and it was thick with bouncy curls.

Catalina was far more curvy, though she also had an incredibly narrow waist and flat stomach. When she walked over to Simon, her large breasts bounced as her bra barely contained them. Her long reddish brown hair was in a tight braid, and her gorgeously dark tanned skin looked smooth and delicate.

Taking in both girls' beauty made Simon's heart race faster, and his arousal skyrocketed. He got even more overwhelmed as they settled in beside him, one on either side. They leaned close, brushing their bare legs against his and putting their hands softly on his chest. Mandy's bright blue eyes and Catalina's vibrant amber eyes were both smoldering with fiery desire as they looked at Simon. After getting a tiny bit drunk, stripping down, and seeing Simon do the same, their lusts and passions had been highly inflamed.

"Is there anything you think we might be good at, games master? Anything you think Mandy and I are experts in?" Catalina asked, whispering her words in a sultry voice next to Simon's ear.

"I was thinking that perhaps we might be skilled at persuasion. But we couldn't persuade you that we were good in history. Perhaps that's because we tried persuading with words." Mandy sighed to him in a seductive and low voice.

"I think we are far more skilled at persuading people with our bodies. I can promise you that, games master. We should have just skipped talking and gone straight to touching." Mandy said as she teased a hand up and down Simon's abs.

"Can we show you how good we are at using our bodies, master? Can we prove how we can be good little girls for you?" Catalina asked, leaning even closer and pressing her chest into his side.

Simon was frozen, too overwhelmed by what was happening to act. Catalina had a hand on his chest and her lips were a fraction of an inch away from his neck. Mandy's hand had moved down from his abs, and her fingers were brushing over the bulge in his underwear as she stared into his eyes with urgent desire. Simon stared back, and he immediately started getting lost in her brilliant blue eyes. After a moment he found enough willpower to start piecing together a sentence, but he was stopped before he could get the first word out.

Mandy leaned in and pressed a passionate kiss to his lips. Catalina joined in by kissing his neck. Both girls started pawing more freely at his body, letting their hands roam over his strong muscles. Mandy kept one hand below his waist, though she only barely teased her fingers against the erection pressing against his underwear. Catalina reached with one hand to grab one of Simon's, pulling it to her chest.

The sudden press of lips and the groping hands made Simon feel even more overwhelmed, but his own desires and lusts soon rose up to overcome that. It was something better than his deepest fantasies to be in between two horny girls half his age, and he couldn't deny how good it felt. Letting himself give into his urges, he kissed Mandy back with equal passion. He eagerly squeezed the tit Catalina had moved his hand onto, and he felt pleasure fill his senses. The delight he found in kissing, touching, and being touched, made him even more eager to pursue greater pleasures.

Catalina and Mandy responded happily and willingly. Mandy lifted her lips from his and let Catalina kiss his mouth. Catalina also moved a hand down and started rubbing up along the inside of his thigh. Simon brushed his hand down Mandy's back, loving the feel of her soft skin. He loved the feeling of her ass even more when his hand reached it, and he gave it a soft spank before squeezing it. Mandy giggled in delight when she felt the spank, and she gave Simon a gentle moan when he moved his other hand up onto her tits.

"Oh, just like that master. You can touch my body however you want. I need you to figure out just how persuasive I can be with it." Mandy urged him.

Simon soon got lost for a few minutes. His mind was assaulted by pleasure as he kissed and was kissed by both girls. They playfully fought over his lips, and when it wasn't their turn they kissed his neck, chest, and shoulders. They tugged at his hands, guiding him to explore their bodies, making him squeeze their luscious curves and grope their tits and asses. They touched his body even more eagerly than he touched theirs. Mandy and Catalina savored the power and strength of his well built body, moving their hands over his biceps, his abs, and his thighs. Heavy moans, breathy sighs, and low groans quickly filled the air as the three enjoyed each other.

The only place Catalina and Mandy didn't touch Simon without restraint was his crotch. They teased their fingertips over his bulge, and they giggled in lustful delight as they felt it throb with aching urgency. But the college girls didn't grab his dick or stroke it, despite how it pressed and strained against his underwear. They had wanted to whip out his cock, but they had agreed to a plan on how they were going to seduce their games master. And the plan involved plenty of teasing to start off with.

All three stayed in their underwear, though the girls had to work hard to not let their bras get tugged aside. This was especially difficult when the girls started touching each other. In between strong kisses Simon watched the way Catalina and Mandy touched one another, and it was obvious that they were very familiar with each other's body. He saw that they struggled with not tearing off each other's clothes, and had to hold themselves back to just sneaking their fingers underneath bras and inside panties.

"Are we doing a good job, master?" Catalina asked as she lifted her lips from Simon's, ending a particularly intense kiss.

"Please tell us we're being good girls for you, master. Please." Mandy pleaded, looking at him with wide desperate eyes.

The two girls had switched from calling Simon their games master, and now were just calling him master. The change had a surprising amount of effect on Simon, and each time they said it he felt his heart skip a beat and a surge of powerful lust run up through his body. And the way they so earnestly were begging for his attention and approval was intoxicating. He looked at the two young women and felt a strong urge to tell them what they wanted to hear.

"God yes. Oh, you are both being such good girls for me. You are doing an amazing job." Simon assured them with a confident grin.

Catalina and Mandy beamed bright smiles at his praise, and the lust in their eyes burned even brighter. They giggled and then looked at each other and shared a passionate but brief kiss. When their lips separated, Catalina slipped off the couch and got onto her knees. Mandy put a hand on Simon's cheek and gave him a teasing smirk while her friend moved in between his legs.

Simon looked down at Catalina with a huge grin, and his heart raced faster as he imagined what she was preparing to do. And while he was looking down, he also spotted what Zoey and Alexis had been doing while the three others had been busy making out and fondling each other. They had started off just shocked by what the college girls were doing with Simon, but that surprise had faded away rather quickly.

They got incredibly aroused seeing the sexy girls press their bodies into Simon, and the alcohol in their systems had fueled their lust even more. They had turned their growing desires towards each other, falling into one another's arms. The two had started passionately kissing each other, and Alexis's shirt had come off at some point. Zoey's dress was hiked up around her waist. Simon was delightfully surprised to see Zoey and Alexis tangled together and partially undressed as they kissed each other. He wanted to watch what else they might do, but Mandy pulled his attention back to her.

"I'm glad you're enjoying us, master. Because we have a lot more to show you, and we hope you like everything we offer to you." Mandy told him.

"And I hope you have something special to offer us," Catalina added with a playful smirk.

Catalina reached for his underwear, and slowly pulled them down. Mandy and her both looked with heavy anticipation down at his crotch, and even Zoey and Alexis ended their kiss long enough to glance over with keen interest as well. Simon felt his nervousness return as the four girls focused below his waist, anxious to see his cock.

Simon had no reason to be nervous however. When his boxers were lowered down enough his dick sprang out, and each of the young women grinned at it with unbridled joy. They had expected it to be big because of the size of his bulge, but they were delighted to see that it was even larger than they had predicted. Alexis and Zoey both gasped in awe at its length and girth, while Catalina and Mandy stared with wide eager eyes.

They all took a few moments to wordlessly stare in admiration at his cock. Eventually, Catalina worked up the courage to reach out and touch it. Her fingers didn't even get close to being able to wrap around his thick dick. When she touched him Simon's cock immediately throbbed response, and Catalina grinned happily as she felt it pulsing. She started to slowly stroke it, running her fingers from the base all the way to the head. Simon moaned in a low and quiet voice, loving how her hand felt as it rubbed up and down his length.

"God, what a perfect cock. We would have done this earlier if we knew how pretty your dick was." Mandy admitted, still staring longingly at his dick.

"I know I can't match that magnificent reveal, but I still hope you like what I have to show you." Mandy added as she turned to look into Simon's eyes.

Her words made Simon move his full attention from Catalina over to Mandy. Biting her lower lip a degree of nervousness passed over Mandy's face as she leaned back away from Simon a little bit. She blushed, which showed brightly on her pale skin, as she reached behind her back and unclasped her bra. Letting the bra fall off her chest, Mandy tossed it away. She stuck out her chest, presenting her breasts to Simon.

Mandy smiled anxiously at him as he stared intently at her chest. Her smile lost all of its apprehension when she saw just the adoration in his eyes. Mandy's breasts weren't as large as some girls, but to Simon they looked perfect. They were perky and round, capped by small pink nipples. After taking a moment to admire them Simon lifted his hands up and found that her tits fit perfectly in his palms.

"You are wonderful, god you are so amazing." Simon confessed as he touched her.

As he squeezed her breasts lightly, Mandy sighed out in a soft voice. His praise had made her smile with joy, and his touch made her grin grow even more. She gasped a little when he brushed his thumbs over her nipples, since they were extremely sensitive. A shiver of pleasure ran up her spine as he continued to gently play with her tits, so she had to force herself to grab his wrists and lift off his hands. She was deeply enjoying his touch, but there was still more of her that she wanted to show him.

Moving off to the side a little more, Mandy turned around as she knelt on the couch. She looked over her shoulder to make sure Simon was still focusing on her. And even though he was moaning in low and heavy as Catalina kept slowly stroking him, his eyes were fixed on her. Mandy grinned with delight and then pulled down her panties, revealing her soaking wet pussy and juicy ass.

Simon licked his lips as he looked at Mandy, and his lust burned even hotter within him. He couldn't help himself as he reached out and brushed his hand over Mandy's bare ass. He inched his fingers closer to her dripping pussy, but his hand was stopped when Catalina reached up and grabbed his wrist.

"Not so fast. You can't play with her anymore until you unwrap me." Catalina protested.

Mandy giggled at her friend's words, and she shook her ass a little to tease Simon a bit more. After that Mandy quickly got down onto her knees in front of Simon. She gave Catalina a quick but intense kiss, and then shoved her friend up to encourage her to move over to Simon. Catalina did so with a giggle, and she approached Simon with a bright and eager grin. But her eyes flickered with anxious energy, and she hesitated as she lifted her hands to her bra.

"I know Mandy is so fucking pretty, I hope you aren't disappointed by my body." Catalina said, speaking far more softly and meekly.

Catalina hesitated for another moment, and she looked down to her friend for support. Mandy was staring mesmerized at Simon's cock, but she snapped out of her awestruck stupor to look up and give Catalina an encouraging wink. As Mandy started to gently stroke his cock, Catalina looked at Simon with more assurance in herself.

Catalina had no reason to be nervous about showing her body, and she proved it as she took off her bra. Her tits were amazingly big, and Simon's jaw dropped as he saw them revealed. His reaction made Catalina even more confident, and when he eagerly reached to touch them she beamed a bright smile.

Her breasts looked far too big to fit in his hands, and Simon happily put that to the test when he squeezed them as much as he could. Catalina's nipples were large and dark, and they were so tempting that he had to lean his head in to suck on one. Catalina moaned heavily as he licked her nipple and sucked on it, and her sweet sounds of pleasure made him even more eager to touch her. He lifted his lips off her breast and looked up with a sparkling grin.

"You have both been such wonderful gifts, god I feel like the luckiest man in the world. Can I push my luck and ask to unwrap the last bit of my present myself?" He asked Catalina as he teased his fingers down her sides towards her waist.

"Ha, that won't be the last part of your present, not by a long shot." Catalina told him with a giggle, "But go ahead, I'll take any chance to have more of your big, strong hands on my body."

Chuckling, Simon grinned wider as Catalina implied that their fun would only continue to escalate. His cock throbbed in Mandy's hand, making her giggle in delight as she stroked it slowly. Simon was filled with so much urgent anticipation for what might come next, that he looked down and quickly tore off Catalina's panties.

Catalina brushed her hands down her body and helped Simon fully take off her underwear, making Mandy, Simon, and her fully nude. She had a small neatly trimmed bush, but even with her hair Simon could see that she was just as wet and aroused as Mandy. And Mandy's lustful desires were becoming quite intense. She stared at Catalina and Simon with impatience as she knelt in between Simon's legs.

"Finally, you're naked." Mandy told her friend, "Now get down here before I start sucking him all by myself."

Catalina laughed and rolled her eyes as she hurried to get down and join Mandy. Simon's eyes went wide once again, and he was filled with a joyous delight. His heart thundered faster, and his cock ached for what was about to come.

As soon as Catalina had got onto her knees next to Mandy, the both of them leaned their heads in. Mandy started to lick up and down Simon's shaft, starting from the head and working her way towards the base. Catalina covered the tip of his dick with soft kisses. Each of them looked up at Simon with wide eyes that looked far too innocent for how skillfully they were teasing his cock.

Simon looked down with adoration at the girls, and on the other couch the other two girls were watching closely as well. Zoey had lost her dress, and now was just in her underwear. Alexis had her hand down Zoey's panties, and her fingers were rubbing gently as they both enjoyed what the college girls were doing with Simon. Each felt a desire to go and join the three, but they felt a greater need to explore where their lusts would lead them with each other. For the moment, they were happy just to watch while they pleasured one another.

The two younger girls were amazingly skilled at teasing with just gentle kisses and soft licks. Their lips and tongues were nimble and dexterous, and they were very accomplished in working as a well functioning team. In no time at all they had Simon groaning low and heavy, and he was desperate for more. His whole body ached with urgent need, which made the girls only more eager to keep at the edge by just teasing him.

But as much as they were enjoying it, the girls had lusts and desires of their own. The moment Catalina had seen Simon's cock, she knew she needed to worship it by sucking it as good as she could. She gave into that need, raising her lips and wrapping them around his thick dick. Simon let out a loud groan as Catalina sucked on the head of his length, and his moan grew rougher and more primal as her lips descended down a few inches. She bobbed her head up and down, lavishing the tip of his cock with flicks from her tongue every time she raised her head.

Mandy took a moment to admire how sexy it looked to see Catalina sucking such a big dick, and then she lowered down her head. She wrapped her lips around Simon's balls and began to suck on them. Simon felt so much divine pleasure that he needed to shut his eyes, and he came close to being overwhelmed. On any normal day he would have cum right then and there, but something about the night gave him the endurance to withstand the delights. It might have been the liquor he had drunk, but Simon suddenly felt like he had enough stamina to receive endless amounts of pleasure before reaching his limit.

The girls put his new endurance to the test. Catalina moved her lips down further along his length each time she bobbed her head, slowly taking more of his inches down her throat. Mandy switched between licking and sucking on his balls, and she teased her fingertips up and down his thighs. When Catalina could take all she could of his length down her lips she held herself down for a moment before fully pulling her lips off with a loud plop.

Mandy quickly raised herself up and started sucking his dick as soon as she could, replacing Catalina's lips with her own. Catalina took a second to catch her breath, and smiled wickedly at Simon before leaning down to start teasing his balls. Simon gave them both bright grins.

Simon groaned heavily, and the rough sounds of his pleasure motivated the girls to give all they could towards pleasuring him. Mandy was able to take nearly all of his length into her mouth, showing off her impressive deepthroating skills. When she reached her limit, Catalina moved a hand to the back of Mandy's head and pushed down. That proved to be enough to make Mandy swallow Simon's entire dick, and her lips were pressed against the base of his cock. Simon let out a deep and thunderous moan, loving how it felt.

Mandy was able to hold herself down for a few moments before needing to pull herself up and off his cock. She coughed a little, and strands of her spit connected her lips to the head of his dick. When she recovered, Mandy and Catalina joined together to press their lips around his dick. They sandwiched his cock in between them as they kissed, and they moved their lips up and down his length.

Simon brushed his hands over the girls' hair, marveling at how good they were making him feel. His cock throbbed and pulsed, and it twitched every time they reached his head and used their tongues to tease it. The pleasure was immense, but somehow he felt a strong need for more. The passion that was burning hot inside his chest demanded even greater carnal delights.

"God damn it, you are both fantastic at sucking cock, but I need to fuck one of your pretty little pussies." Simon grunted out.

Mandy and Catalina both giggled in mischievous delight at his words, and they looked up with eyes full of the same urgent lust that he was feeling. They gave one last kiss to the cock and then got up from their knees. Both girls quickly got up onto the couch and laid down on their backs next to each other. They spread their legs and looked expectantly at Simon.

"Finally, I was wondering when you would be ready to use that monstrous cock to stretch out our slutty cunts." Mandy confessed as she brushed her fingers over her pussy.

Simon chuckled while he hurried to get onto his feet. Both of the college girls were looking eagerly at him, and they were spreading their pussies with their fingers. Catalina was using her arms to squeeze her big tits together. Simon stared entranced by how sexy she looked in that pose, and even Mandy was staring lustfully at her friend. Moved more by impulse than by conscious decision, Simon got in front of Catalina and lined up his cock against her pussy.

Catalina started to moan and sigh in a high voice as Simon teased his dick up and down her pussy. Her pussy was dripping wet, and she got even more aroused as he rubbed it. Mandy looked down enviously that Simon had picked her friend first, but she was also enjoying the sight. Mandy rubbed her pussy and leaned over to give her friend a quick kiss on her cheek.

Taking in a deep breath, Simon slid his cock inside Catalina. As his dick was thrust into her pussy, Catalina's eyes rolled back and she let out a gasp. The feeling of his thick cock stretching her out was intense, but so was the pleasure that accompanied it. Simon moaned deeply as well, feeling how tightly her pussy gripped around his length.

He thrust half his length inside her before sliding it back and out and then thrusting in again. His pace quickly built up, since the lusts that were burning inside of him were too demanding to go slow. Catalina moaned louder with each thrust, loving how good it felt to be filled by his big dick. She looked at Simon with pure and passionate adoration, and when he leaned in she welcomed his kiss hungrily. Her passion was increased by how much she adored being fucked by an older man.

Simon groaned against her lips as his hands reached for her bouncing breasts. He squeezed her large tits, making Catalina sigh into their kiss. When he pulled back he smiled with delight at the young girl, which she returned happily. He was awestruck by how good it felt to be fucking a girl half his age, and how much she seemed to be enjoying it.

Though fucking Catalina felt amazing, Simon felt the eyes of Mandy staring him. She was enjoying herself as she waited by eagerly watching the two and rubbing herself, but Simon knew that Mandy was desperate for his cock. He shared her desire, longing to fuck her tight little pussy as well. He gave Catalina one last grin before sliding his cock out of her.

Catalina sighed as she was emptied of his dick, and she immediately pouted. But her lips turned to a smirk as she watched Simon move over in front of Mandy. She quickly started to rub herself and grinned happily as she waited for her friend to get the same divine pleasure as she had just had.

Mandy looked down with heavy anticipation as his large dick was pressed against her pussy. She held her breath, and her eyes sparkled slightly with nervousness. She had never had such a big cock inside her before, but she still wanted him to fill her up badly. Simon saw her anxiety, and he held a gentle hand on her cheek as she thrust into her.

As his huge dick squeezed into her tight pussy Mandy gasped out and then cried in a high voice full of ecstasy. Simon grunted as well, needing to shut his eyes as he processed the waves of pleasure. He rocked his hips more slowly back and forth, but he gradually built up to the pace he used with Catalina.

When he opened his eyes he found Mandy staring at him with eyes full of adoring passion. She somehow looked so sweet and innocent as she moaned with each thrust of his cock into her pussy. Her cries of joy grew louder as he reached for her breasts, especially when he teased his fingers over her sensitive nipples. She loved the feeling of his cock inside her so much that she wrapped her legs around his waist, inviting him to press deeper inside her.

Simon gave her a few more inches, and he grunted hard as he felt more of his length tightly gripped by her pussy. Leaning close he pressed his forehead against Mandy's as he thrust a little faster as well. Mandy's moans grew louder, and she continued to stare with wide eyes at him.

He fucked Mandy for a little while longer, and then switched back to Catalina. The other girl giggled with delight as she was filled by his cock once more, though her laughter was soon muffled by Mandy as she pressed a passionate kiss to her friend's lips. Simon kept trading between the young girls, fucking them each for a few minutes before moving to the other.

While the three fucked, Alexis and Zoey continued to tease each other and enjoyed the sights. By the time Simon took a pause in between moving from Catalina to Mandy, he saw Alexis was completely nude with Zoey's head buried between her legs. Alexis was calling out in a loud voice as Zoey licked her pussy, and she had her legs wrapped around Zoey's head to keep her there.

Simon grinned wide at the sight, totally amazed and aroused by it. Mandy and Catalina noticed what their other friends were doing as well, and they quickly smiled with carnal delight. The college girls turned to look at each other, both of their eyes shining with devious plans.

"God that looks so fucking sexy." Mandy said, licking her lips with obvious enjoyment.

"Hell yes it does," Catalina agreed as she looked hungrily at Mandy. "It makes me want to have you lick me while I get to watch Simon fucking you with his big fat cock."

Simon's eyes went wide at the suggestion, especially when he watched Mandy and Catalina quickly scramble to make the idea happen. Catalina moved to the edge of the couch and leaned her back against the armrest. Mandy laid down on her belly in between Catalina's legs, sticking her ass up high. Both girls looked to Simon expectantly, and motioned for him to join them.

He laughed with eager delight as he got on his knees behind Mandy. Catalina was already moaning heavily as Mandy teased her with her fingers and planted kisses up along her inner thighs. By the time Simon got his cock pressed against Mandy's pussy, she had started licking her friend with even more skill than she had sucked his cock.

"Fuck, oh just like that. Oh damn, you always do it so well. I fucking love how you eat my pussy!" Catalina moaned.

Simon grinned, happy to hear evidence that this was not the first time the girls had fucked. It made him glad to know just how slutty the horny girls were, and he was astounded that they were willing to share their pleasures with him. It would have shocked him to know just how long the girls had wanted to fuck him together, and how esctatic they had been to be able to steer this evening into a sexual fantasy for them all.

Before thrusting his cock into Mandy's pussy, Simon gave it a firm spank. Mandy took a break from licking Catalina to giggle in response, and she shook her ass for Simon. He laughed and gave it another spank as he drove his cock into her.

Grabbing her hips tightly, Simon started to strongly and deeply plow his dick into Mandy's tight pussy. He grunted hard, fucking her far harder in this position. Mandy loved it, moaning freely and gasping in between sighs of pleasure. She had to focus hard in order to keep licking Catalina, but she loved pleasuring her friend so she poured her energy into both receiving and giving carnal delights.

"Oh yes master, pound my tight little pussy with your big cock. Fuck me hard master, make me your slut." Mandy begged, gasping out in between licks.

Her pleading words sent thrills through Simon's body. He grunted hard as he thrust even more powerfully into Mandy, fucking her harder and faster. She moaned happily at his increased power, loving how deep his cock was being driven into her. Her eyes rolled back and a blissful expression spread across her face.

Simon was thrusting too strongly for Mandy to be able to focus on licking Catalina, but Catalina was loving the sight of her friend getting fucked even better than being licked. She looked at Simon with burning lust in her eyes, encouraging him to pound her friend's tight pussy even harder. She started to rub herself while Simon looked back at Catalina with equal passion.

"God yes, oh this is so fucking good. I can't get enough of it." Simon grunted out in a ragged voice.

Mandy's cries rose up into the air, filling the room with high moans of deep pleasure. Her gasps got even louder when Simon moved his hands up her sides and to her chest. He squeezed her breasts, pressing her sensitive nipples into his palms. When he moved his fingers to pinch her nipples, Mandy's eyes opened wide and she let out a breathless scream of ecstasy.

"Yes! Fuck yes! I'm cuming, god damn I'm cuming!" She cried out when she found enough breath.

Her body spasmed and shook, and her legs quivered while the orgasm worked through her body. Simon felt her pussy clench like a vise around his cock, and he groaned hard and low. He kept thrusting hard, which made Mandy's climax even more powerful. She slumped forward and moaned in a high voice, hardly able to control her breath. Catalina brushed her hands over her friend's face, holding her head gently.

"Yes, pound my slutty pussy. Fuck me like the good whore I am! Make me cum around your big cock, master!" Mandy screamed.

Mandy's cries continued until she was out of breath, and her body trembled until she was completely overwhelmed. When she collapsed into Catalina's lap Simon finally slowed down and then stopped his thrusts. He panted out hard and wiped a bead of sweat from his face, and he grinned in awe at Mandy. Her orgasm was the most intoxicatingly beautiful thing he had ever experienced, and his pleasure was elevated to new heights because of it.

Catalina looked in awe at Simon, amazed at how strongly he had made Mandy cum. She had seen, and made, Mandy cum dozens and dozens of times, but her orgasm with Simon was something grander and more special. Catalina immediately knew she needed Simon to fuck her like he had Mandy, and to give her the same incredible experience. She looked down to Mandy and then pressed a gentle kiss to her head before sliding Mandy's head off her lap. Catalina stared intensely at Simon as she got to her feet.

"Get on your back, right now. I need to get on that perfect cock, and I need you to fuck me while I ride you." Catalina demanded, her voice full of iron resolve

"Uh... please, master." She added more meekly with a giggle.

Simon laughed at how determined Catalina was, and how intense her lust for him was. He gave Catalina a wink and then quickly moved back on the couch and laid on his back. As he got situated, he turned and saw Zoey and Alexis staring at him. Both of them were now fully nude, and they had their fingers buried in each other's pussies. But they had slowed down their fingering to gaze with amazement of Mandy's orgasm. They were still a little astonished by the majesty of her climax, and were deeply impressed by how hard Simon had got her to cum. Their eyes were full of hungry lust, and it seemed like they wouldn't be satisfied with just each other forever.

As much as Simon was eager to fantasize about fucking both Alexis and Zoey, Catalina pulled all of his attention to her. She climbed over him, kneeling above his waist and hovering with her pussy brushing against his hard cock. Her eyes met his, and she wore an expression of pure devoted passion. Taking in a breath she pressed down and slowly sank down his length.

Both Simon and Catalina moaned hard and loud as she impaled herself on his large dick. She slipped down his entire shaft, taking his full length all the way to the hilt. She gasped as she felt herself completely and utterly filled, her pussy stretched in ways she had never felt before. It took Catalina a few moments to even attempt trying to get used to the sensation.

Catalina soon started to move her hips up and down, slowly building up speed. She moaned out deeply with each movement, and Simon joined her with low hard grunts. He stared up with eyes full of fiery desire at her, loving how good she felt riding his cock. Reaching up he pressed his hands into her tits, making Catalina smile with delight.

As Catalina established her pace, Simon started to lift up his own hips. He matched her rhythm as he thrust his cock into her, making them both groan and sigh even louder and more frequently. Catalina's tits bounced despite Simon squeezing them, since they were too large to fit in his palms.

"God, oh fucking hell. Your cock feels like it was meant to be inside me. I love how deep it goes, god it's so good to ride it, master." Catalina moaned to Simon.

By the time Catalina was riding Simon fairly fastly, Mandy had mostly recovered from her powerful orgasm. She watched her friend bounce up and down on Simon's cock for a little bit, loving the sight. But as good as watching was, Mandy still wanted to participate some more.

She grinned as she moved to the other side of the couch, getting up right near Simon's head. Kneeling over him, gave him a wink and then lowered her pussy down towards his lips. Simon grinned and licked his lips in eager anticipation, and when she got into range he lifted his head and happily started to flick his tongue over her.

"Yes, oh hell yes! Just like that." Mandy sighed out, shutting her eyes for a moment.

Mandy moaned happily, and Catalina cries of pleasure were growing increasingly loud. From in between Mandy's thighs, Simon eagerly listened to their sweet sounds. But their sighs of joy were soon muffled when the two girls leaned towards each other and started to passionately kiss. Mandy reached down to rub Catalina's clit, and Catalina squeezed her friend's tits as they made out.

Seeing the intense threesome had gotten Zoey and Alexis aroused enough that they intertwined their bodies to lick each other. Zoey laid on top of Alexis as they both took frequent glances over to their games master and the two college girls. Both moaned just as heavily as any of the other three, adding to the chorus of voices filled with carnal delight.

Having Mandy kiss her made Catalina fill with pleasure all the more quickly. She moaned hard into her friend's lips, and she kept riding Simon faster and faster. Simon continued to match her pace, thrusting hard and fast up into her pussy. He slammed his hips into her each time she slid down his thick cock, driving them both crazy with pleasure.

Simon was still maintaining his incredible endurance, and didn't feel close to his edge. Catalina however surrendered herself to the pleasure. Breaking away from the kiss with Mandy she screamed out in a wordless cry of ecstasy. She sat down fully on Simon's dick as her pussy clenched tight. Her legs trembled and her toes curled as the orgasmed washed over her with powerful waves of delight.

Catalina's orgasm was just as intense as Mandy's, and when it was over she slumped forward into her friend's arms. Mandy held her and whispered sweetly into her ear, her words interrupted by moans as Simon kept licking her. Catalina caught her breath rather quickly, and when she had recovered enough she gave Mandy a deep kiss. When their lips parted, both girls lifted themselves off Simon. They got onto their feet, though Catalina's legs were a little shaky, and faced the man.

"God, you are fucking amazing." Mandy said, still looking at him with awe and lust.

"You made me feel so damned good, I've never cum so hard." Catalina admitted as she stared with adoration at Simon.

Their praise made Simon's smile grow wide and bright, and he felt a surge of confidence and delight arise within him. Standing up he leaned in close and kissed Catalina. He savored the taste of her lips before turning to kiss Mandy with the same passion. Both girls accepted the kisses happily, and they pressed in close against his body.

"But now we need to make you feel amazing too." Catalina whispered as she leaned in to kiss his neck.

"We have to make you cum for us, master. We want you to use us like fuck toys, to treat us like your personal sluts and then shower us in your precious cum." Mandy told him as she stared intently into his eyes.

Mandy held his gaze for a few moments before she turned to Catalina. The friends shared a knowing look, and then they turned the coffee table. They quickly brushed aside the scattering of character sheets and dice, clearing a space. Mandy leaned down first, kneeling in front of the table and laying her chest on the newly open area. Catalina then climbed on top of her friend, laying her back. Both girls angled their hips up, sticking out their asses. Their wet pussies were presented to Simon, stacked one on top of the other.

"Fuck us, master. Slam your dick into our tight little pussies, please." Mandy begged as she turned her head to look at Simon.

Catalina added her own pleading words, urging Simon to use them both until he was ready to blow his load. Simon grinned eagerly, marveling at the sight for a few moments. The girls' encouragements were too sweet to resist for long, and he soon lined his cock up with Mandy's pussy.

When he slid in, Mandy sighed out deeply, loving how it felt to be filled once more by his huge dick. She shut her eyes and rested her head against the table, gripping its edges with her outstretched hands. Catalina looked back with wide eyes, impatiently waiting for her turn to be fucked again. Simon met her gaze, staring deeply at Catalina as he fucked Mandy hard and fast.

When he pulled his cock out of Mandy, Catalina grinned with eager anticipation. She let out a happy sigh as Simon pressed his cock against her pussy, and then she moaned out as she slid inside her. He thrust just as fast and as powerfully into Catalina as he had Mandy, and he groaned out loud as well.

Simon switched back and forth between the two girls, fucking them both with strong and deep thrusts. He also freely moved his hand over their bodies, pawing at their sides and curves. Mandy and Catalina delighted him with high pitched sighs and heavy moans, sweet sounds of how much they were enjoying his big dick being driven into them and his hands on their bodies. They glanced back frequently, looking at him with eyes wide and full of desperate lust and desire.

He had previously felt like he had endlessly stamina, and that his endurance was infinite. But after having both girls cum around his cock, Simon started to feel his edge approach as he fucked the two girls. His moans grew heavier and deeper, and his breaths became rough and ragged. His body tensed, and his cock began to throb in urgent need of release. Simon recognized how close he was to cumming, and he stared hard down at Catalina and Mandy as he pulled his cock out and took a step back.

"God, I'm so fucking close. You are going to make me cum. Get off each other and lay on your backs, I want to shower you with my jizz." He ordered them in a hard voice.

Both Mandy and Catalina grinned with delight at his instruction, and they hurriedly moved to obey. They tossed aside a few more papers and errant dice, laying side by side on their backs on top of the coffee table. Catalina squeezed her tits together, and Mandy spread her pussy wide. Both girls smiled wide and looked expectantly at Simon.

"Cum on us, master. Shoot your jizz all over our slutty bodies. Baptize us in it." Mandy begged, licking her lips in anticipation.

"Please, master, please. Cover us in your cum. We worked so hard for it." Catalina pleaded before opening her mouth wide and sticking out her tongue.

Simon grit his teeth and looked down at the girls as they made themselves the perfect targets for his cum. He stroked himself just a few times before his jizz exploded out. Thick streams landed heavily across their bodies. His balls had been achingly full, and he unloaded more jizz than he thought was possible over the two girls.

Both girls had their faces covered in thick globs of sperm. Mandy's belly was coated as well, and Catalina's tits were crisscrossed with heavy loads. A huge amount had landed on their lips and tongues, which delighted the girls. In fact, they giggled in joy the entire time Simon was cumming. With each hit they grew happier, ecstatic that he was emptying his balls over them.

When he had finally finished cumming, Simon panted out heavily and took a look at the mess he had made of Catalina and Mandy. He grinned, loving how perfectly sexy they looked covered in his jizz. The two girls were beaming bright smiles as they admired each other, looking up and down one another's bodies. When their gazes met, they smirked and then leaned in for a passionate kiss, sharing the jizz still on their lips.

While Mandy and Catalina made out, Alexis and Zoey grinned mischievously at Simon. Zoey was reclining in Alexis's arms as they laid together. They glanced hungrily at the cum covering their young friends, and seemed incredibly aroused by the sight. Zoey turned her head to kiss Alexis's cheek before turning back to Simon.

"Well, I think we can agree that the girls are fairly proficient in persuasion, at least with their bodies." Zoey announced with a giggle.

Mandy and Catalina broke their kiss and laughed at Zoey's joke. Catalina looked down at her cum covered tits and smiled before craning her neck down and licking some of the jizz off. Mandy brushed a hand through her hair and looked over to Zoey.

"Now we just need to figure out what you and Alexis are good at. Perhaps next time you two can have a turn with Simon, or maybe all five of us could have fun together." Mandy suggested.

Everyone chuckled at the joke, but there was honest and eager desire in the laughter. The five friends looked around at each other, eyeing one another's nude bodies with passion and lust. Their smiles grew wider as they also realized together that this was only the start of a very lewd new chapter to their adventuring party.