Seducing Shay: More Sexy Times

"Pizza's here!" Mason shouts from downstairs.

I finish licking Shay's cum off my lips and smile at her shy grin. I love how she's so demure and quiet until we start fucking around. God, she's so sexy.

"Are you hungry, baby?" I ask her. "I just had a delicious appetizer, but I could go for a slice or two. Maybe some dessert later..."

"I could eat." Shay blushes. "Now and later."

Her cheeks are flaming red, almost the color of my hair, and I smirk.

"You can have whatever you want, baby," I say, dragging her to me by her delicious ass. I squeeze, groaning when she gasps.

"Kiss me," I demand.

She complies without question, pushing her lips to mine and plunging her tongue in my mouth. Once again, her shyness floats away, and she kisses me in a frenzy.

Her tongue twists around mine, and I moan. I bite her lip, and she gasps.

I squeeze her ass again, dipping my fingers into the sweatpants I let her borrow and gripping her bare cheeks.

I slyly run my finger over her back hole, and she gasps again.

I pull back. "Did you like that, baby?"

"Yes," she blurts, blushing again.

I bite her ear. "Maybe we can play with that later," I whisper.

I go to kiss her again, desperate for her taste, but my brother calls out again. "Hurry up! We're going to eat it all before you get down here!"

I roll my eyes. What a fucking pussy blocker.

I kiss Shay gently one last time. "To be continued."

Shay smiles. "Yes, please."

Taking her hand, I lead her downstairs. I let go of her right before we enter the kitchen.

"Shh," I say with my finger over my lips. "We don't want the boys to get jealous."

Shay giggles and mimes zipping her lips.

Jesus, she's fucking cute.

I let her walk ahead of me so I can admire her perfect ass. She sways like she knows what I'm doing, and I want to spank her for teasing me.

When we enter the kitchen, the boys are seated at the high-top counter devouring the pizza like a bunch of savages. I swear they've only been eating for five minutes and it's already almost gone.

"Thanks for leaving us some pizza," I snark.

Mason responds with food in his mouth. "Of course, sis."

I roll my eyes, grabbing the two empty plates from next to the pizza boxes. I quickly put two slices on each plate, then move to the remaining empty chairs and sit down, patting the seat next to me. "Come on, Shay, I got you some pizza."

Connor smiles widely. "You're so nice, Mel!" He turns to Mason and punches his shoulder. "Your sister is so sweet--why are you such an asshole?"

I laugh and wink. "I got all the good genes."

Connor runs his eyes over me appreciatively. "Yes, you did."

Mason slaps him upside the head. "Fuck off, bro. That's my sister, remember?"

I smirk, but my lips flatten when I see Shay staring at her plate in silence.

I nudge her with my shoulder. "You okay?"

"Fine," she says.

I frown. Fuck, what did I do? Does she think I'm flirting with her brother? I mean, I was, but it didn't mean anything. I flirt with everyone. It doesn't mean I want to fuck them. Although, I did technically fuck Connor.

But I also fucked Derek and Liam. Honestly, I've messed around with everyone in this house right now except for my brother.

Is Shay mad? For some reason, I don't want her to be. She's sweet, and I don't want to hurt her feelings. I'd also really like to keep hooking up with her. My mouth waters remembering the taste of her pussy. Fuck, she was tasty.

The room is quiet for a few minutes while we all finish our pizza.

Derek swallows the last bite on his plate, then turns towards me. "Are you really not going to play with us, Mel?"

There's a little innuendo in his voice, which I ignore. As I said before, I'm not into repeats.

Except with Shay, apparently.

I give him a false pout. "I'm sorry, Derek. Shay and I really want to watch a movie." I turn towards Shay. "Right?"

Shay gives a thumbs up, which doesn't reassure me that she's not upset. I'll have to fix that later.

Liam sighs. "Fine, but you owe us a round of Smash next time. I need redemption."

I laugh. "Sure, Liam. Although I don't think you're going to beat me."

"I still think you cheat," Liam mutters.

"I literally just smash buttons. I wouldn't even know how to cheat," I say.

"Fine, keep your secrets."

Mason pats Liam's shoulder. "It's okay, buddy. Mel is just really good at that game."

My god. These boys are so dramatic.

I finish off my last slice and peek over at Shay. Her plate is empty. Perfect.

"Are you ready to go back upstairs, Shay? We can watch in my room since the boys will be playing their game in the theater."

"Yeah, I'm ready."

"Okay, let's go." I wiggle my fingers at my brother and his friends. "Bye, boys! Have fun."

"Be good, sis," my brother calls out.

I smile. "I'm always good, brother."

All the boys snicker. Assholes.

It only takes a few minutes to get back upstairs to my room. It's a huge space with a giant bed, an enormous TV, and a seating area complete with two chairs and a loveseat. There are floor-to-ceiling windows on one wall, showing a gorgeous view of the mountains.

I pick up the small remote next to my bed and press the button to lower the blinds. "Let me just close these. For the movie, of course."

Shay snorts. "Right. For the movie."

After the room is dark, illuminated only by the string lights hanging from my ceiling, I drag Shay to the bed. We're both in tank tops and sweatpants. No bras. No underwear. Just two pieces of fabric separating our naked bodies. I nearly pant with desire.

Shay is a little subdued when I pull her to the center of the bed. She doesn't make a move to get under the thick, fluffy blanket, choosing to remain on top.

"Are you alright?" I ask her. For some reason, I really want her to say yes. My gut churns at the thought that she might be upset with me.

"Did you fuck my brother?" Shay asks bluntly.

I take a deep breath. "Yes. Last year. Full disclosure, I also fucked Liam and Derek."

Shay frowns. "Just once or multiple times?"

"Just once," I answer. "I've never had a repeat with anyone until you."

Shay's gaze shoots to mine. "Really?"

I smile. "Really."

"Why me?"

I shrug. "I don't know... There's just something about you. You're special." I laugh. "That sounds so corny, but it's true."

Shay laughs and her body relaxes.

I bite my lip. "Come under the covers with me?"

She blushes and smiles. "Okay."

While she snuggles under the covers, I reach out to pick up the TV remote. I'm not planning on watching anything, but I might as well put something on for the noise. I'm hoping to pull some screams out of Shay, and I don't want the boys to hear. Even though the theater is in an entirely different area of the house, my girl can get loud. I love it.

I turn on the TV and toss the remote back on my bedside table. I honestly don't even know what's playing.

I turn to Shay, inching closer until our bodies are almost touching. She shivers.

"Hi," I whisper.

Shay laughs. "Hi."

"Do you want to play?"

She nods, and I jump into action, grabbing the band of her sweatpants and yanking them down in one move. I squeeze her ass, then move on to her tank top.

"This needs to go," I say as I rip it over her head until she's completely naked.

I stroke her hips, run my hands up her flat stomach to her full tits. Squeeze gently. Fuck, fuck, fuck. I'm already wet.

"Undress me, baby?" I ask.

Shay nods and reaches for my clothes, pulling them off in slow, gentle movements that have me vibrating with anticipation. She's effortlessly sexy. I don't even know what it is about her, but I can't get enough.

When we're both naked, I slide my leg between hers until we're touching everywhere. Our breasts are pressed together, my nipple rings catching on her nipples as they rub together. Our pussies are flush. I feel some of her wetness drip onto me and I moan.

I pull her lip between my teeth. "Are you ready?"

Shay nods frantically. "Yes, please fuck me, Mel. I need it so bad."

I raise up on my hands and move until I'm positioned directly on top of her, with our pussies pushed together.

Slamming my lips to hers, I grind my hips in a slow, sensual movement that makes Shay whine into my mouth.

I slow down our kiss to match the pace of my thrusts--sucking her tongue, biting her lips, and rubbing our pussies together until we're both sweaty and sliding against each other with ease.

I rip my mouth from her as I speed up. Leaning down, I whisper in her ear. "You're so fucking sexy. I love the way your pussy feels against mine." I squeeze her tits. "God, your tits are fucking perfect."

Shay leans her head back and moans, loud and long.

I pick up speed until our bodies are practically slamming together. The sound is deliciously obscene.

"Twist my nipples, baby," I command, and Shay instantly complies.

"Fuck," I groan. "That feels so damn good. I love the way you play with me."

Shay leans up and catches my mouth with hers, kissing me wildly.

I go faster until she's groaning with every thrust.

"Fuck, fuck, FUCK," she screams.

"Shh," I whisper, biting her ear. "You don't want your big brother to know his little sister is getting fucked, do you?"

I slip a finger in her pussy and it clenches around me.

Shay gasps and moans. "More!"

Two fingers, thrusting in time with the way I'm rubbing our pussies together.

"Yes, yes, yes," Shay shouts.

I slip in another finger and Shay screams. "Mel!"

She's panting, a sweaty mess. But she's still fucking beautiful. I slow down to admire the view.

"No," she whines. "Go faster. I want to come so bad."

I smirk. "As you wish, baby."

Then I start frantically thrusting my fingers in her pussy and scissoring our pussies together.

"Yes, oh, god, yes. Mel, yes, please."

"Are you ready for it?" I whisper.

"FUCK yes. Please, please, please. I want to come all over you."

My pussy clenches at her words. God, she's a wet dream.

I slip in a fourth finger and squeeze her clit with my other hand, all while I'm sliding our pussies together.

She screams and cum squirts out of her, landing all over me and soaking the sheets beneath us.

When she stops trembling, I remove my fingers and kiss her lightly on the lips. "How was that, baby?"

Shay sighs. "Amazing." Then her head pops up. "But, what about you? You didn't come."

I shake my head. "I was waiting."

"For what?"

"Want to lick my pussy, baby? I'd love to feel you eating me out."

Shay licks her lips. "Yes, god, yes. I want that."

I throw the blankets off of us and point to my wet pussy. "Have at it."

Shay dives on me, licking my clit like she's starving and I'm a lollipop. Her tongue moves in quick circles and flicks.

I moan, and she sucks my clit into her mouth.

"Yes, baby. Fuck, yes. Keep going."

Shay doubles her efforts, twisting her tongue expertly around my clit before shoving her tongue inside my pussy.

"Yes! Just like that!"

Shay doesn't disappoint. She alternates between licks, sucks, and flicks on my clit with fucking her tongue into my pussy.

I'm so fucking wet, I know I'm going to come soon. I moan and start to shake. Shay keeps her head buried between my legs. I'm in heaven.

The unmistakeable feeling of my orgasm rises and my legs twitch.

"I'm about to come. I'm going to come all over your fucking face," I pant.

Shay moans.

One more suck of my clit, and I'm gone. "FUCK!"

It feels like it goes on for ages. When I'm finally slumped back in a puddle on the bed, Shay's laying next to me with her head propped up on her hand. She's blushing.

"How was that?"

I sigh. "Fucking amazing, baby." I smirk. "I think you need a reward."

She bites her lip. "What were you thinking?"

I reach over the side of my bed and pull out a large, black box. I open it, search around, and grab an object from the bottom.

Bringing it up to the bed, I show her my prize.

Shay's eyes widen. "What is that?"

"Double dildo, baby."

Shay's mouth drops open, and I smirk. Oh, fuck, I can't wait to play again.