Horny Subaru (BL)

Natsuki Subaru was out in the city today. Alone.

Emilia wanted to come along for the shopping trip but Subaru had other plans.

Ring!

The bell above resounded as he entered the pub.

He scanned the entire room. Wooden chair and tables. Not many patrons. But one man stood out. Red hair, a white uniform and that handsome face.

Reinhard.

"Drinking so early in the day?" Subaru said.

Poking facial hair. Unkempt hair. His white uniform... wasn't that white today.

Reinhard didn't answer. He just drank a bit more wine and sighed.

Something had had happened the other day and Reinhard was a tad depressed. He spent most of his days in the pub, doing absolutely nothing.

Normally, Subaru would have just let the man be. His sadness was his problem, not Subaru's. However, letting someone as strong Reinhard rot away wasn't something Subaru could afford either.

"I know just the thing that would cheer you up!" Subaru said.

"And what is that?"

"Women. Let's to the red light-"

"I'm into men."

Of course, Subaru had meant it as a joke. A joke to get the righteous young man fired up and focus all his anger on Subaru. However-

Subaru's face dropped and just stood there gaping like a moron. "M-men?" He laughed. He laughed hard, dragging all the attention in the room. "Can be arranged, for sure."

Reinhard let out a half sigh. "Actually, I think it has to be you." He knew Subaru had the hots for the elf. If he pulled this card, Subaru would finally leave him alone and he'd-

"Okay!" Subaru said. And mostly as a bluff. A huge bluff he didn't know how to get out of.

"Just stop acting. Go home. Emilia would be worried-"

"I'm also worried. I'm worried about you. Please. Just tell me something I can do and together we'll --"

"I told you, didn't I? If you spread your legs, I'll reconsider your words."

Subaru gulped. And although he agonized it for a couple of minutes, he struck his pose. "Alright. They have a room up there, right? Let's go."

"You can't be serious. I was joking. Go home."

"Too late now. Either you go upstairs with me, or you come home with me. The choice is yours!"

"You know what. Let's go!" Reinhard slammed the mug and stood firm.

"YEAHH!!!" The patrons clapped as Reinhard princess carried Subaru straight up the stairs, into a room.

He dropped the damsel on the bed and locked the door.

"Now what?" Reinhard said.

"You tell me, you're the gay one."

"I'm telling you, I just made that up. I don't feel anything for men."

"Maybe you'll feel something more me?" Subaru winked.

Of course, he was bluffing. It was actually kind of fun teasing that powerful guy who-

"Okay," Reinhard said, taking off his shirt, revealing that semi-muscular build.

Hot... Subaru shook his head. He couldn't he undone. Reinhard had to be bluffing too, so he took off his shirt and while he wasn't as muscular as Reinhard, he wasn't really that lacking.

Reinhard took off his pant and stood there in his underwear. The vibrance of his flesh, contrasted with the shorts.

Subaru too took off his pants.

The two kept staring at each other, neither giving up.

Reinhard finally took off the last piece of clothing and his family jewels just hung in the air, definitely not erect, almost hidden in that hazy cheery mess.

Subaru too took off his and he wasn't erect either.

"Well, we're not-"

Reinhard sat down by the bed. "Lovers kiss before sex," he said slowly reaching for Subaru's lips.

Subaru's breath sped up. His heart beast fast. Fuck, fuck, fuck....

This couldn't go on.

This just-

Yet, he didn't want to lose. Stopping right now was going to be embarrassing and he didn't want to lose against this perfect guy.

Which was why- he pressed his lips against Reinhard's. That should have been it.

However, Reinhard's warm lips parted and his tongue entered Subaru's mouth. In a moment, their heat and taste were exchanged. A faint connection, formed.

Heart pounded.

Breath caught fire.

A reaction. A reaction perhaps neither, and certainly not Subaru, could foretold.

Fuck, what the-

And now... Subaru had an erection.

"Effective," Reinhard said.

Subaru breathed heavy and he knew this was going a bit too far into the dangerous territory. "Sorry. I really wasn't-" he stopped. Not just him. Reinhard also had an erection. And the man wasn't brooding. He was clearly staring at Subaru. "You actually want to have sex with me?"

"I suppose my body does want that now, yes."

"I've never had gay sex. I don't know how it works."

"Me neither. Does this go into your ass?"

"I don't think it'll fit."

While Subaru's cock was the typical Japanese average, Reinhard's wasn't. He was larger and heftier. And Subaru wasn't looking forward to taking it up his ass right now.

And yet, his ass almost itched. Lots and lots of heat rushed there, ridding the small hole of its wrinkles and puffing it up just for the event.

But- "Then what about other activities? Lovers kiss. Lovers also have oral sex, yes?"

"No- no, that's..." Subaru groaned. "I'll just give you a handjob, okay?" He sat by Reinhard and stroked his cock. So warm, thick, and... and the aroma almost drove Subaru insane. It smelled so good. He almost wanted to taste it. Actually, he instinctively reached for it but stopped at the last second.

Meanwhile, Reinhard stroked Subaru's cock and the two just stared at each other, staring.

Subaru's cock got all tingly and it felt good. It kept feeling good and soon the good feeling spread to his balls and his prostate and concentrated there. "AH!" He came and slowly released all his cream in bursts.

Meanwhile, Reinhard was yet to cum. He just sat there, letting Subaru stroke his meat over and over again until vibrating and shooting a hot load on the floor.

"Even your cumshot is perfect," Subaru sighed. "But I hope you feel good now cause I'm never doing that again!"

His hand was full of the stuff. And it wasn't even his.

God it was so embarrassing. Now that he'd calmed his head and the post nut clarity settled in... he knew just how fucking stupid this was. He wasn't gay and this wasn't okay. He'd given into the situation and didn't want to lose and all that crap but that was stupid.

"So," Reinhard said. "When do we take this a step further?"

Huh? Is this dude serious? Subaru almost brushed the whole thing off as another big joke but paused. The man wasn't kidding.

He was actually serious and he wasn't brooding anymore.

I can actually get him off his butt and-

"You better not avoid your duties anymore. We can meet again in a couple of days."

"Then you'll let me fuck you in the butt?"

Subaru gulped. "I'll give you oral."

"It's a deal then." Reinhard said. "And... Subaru?"

"Yes."

"What do I do about this?" Reinhard bent himself forward, pressing up his butt towards Subaru. His butt was perfect. The perfect pucker. The wrinkles were symmetrical and the hole was soft and-

"What do you mean?"

"It's itchy and kind of wet."

"Wet? Asses don't get wet. Are you having an upset stomach or something?" Subaru almost cringed.

"No. It's just- look-"

Subaru, to his better judgement, pressed a finger on Reinhard's ass and his finger actually went into the tight cavity easily. It was mildly wet. Not as wet as he'd imagine a vagina to be. He hadn't had sex and he hadn't seen the real thing up close but he'd seen a lot of videos and read a lot about them.

But asses were different.

Surely Reinhard just had a bad case of food poisoning and when Subaru was going to pull his finger out, it'd be a bit yellow and he'd have his perfect excuse to never do this again.

Yet- when he pulled his finger out it was clear.

And the smell... was kind of nice. A little musky but not like ass, at least not entirely.

Why... Subaru gulped. Why does this smell nice? He couldn't help but smell it more and more and even smell the damn butt. Actually, at some point he'd pressed his nose firmly in Reinhard's ass and Reinhard's cock just shot back up.

Subaru's too.

Fuck, am I gay?

Subaru reached the Mansion with a lot of odd feelings.

On one hand he'd done something he never thought he would. On another, it actually felt good. Reinhard, the man Subaru always thought as chivalrous and beyond his reach... actually showed interest in Subaru.

Fuck! He shook his head.

"Hmph," Ram said. "He's finally lost it."

"Calm down sis, are you okay Subaru-kun?" Rem said.

"Oh, I'm fine."

"Lady Emilia was looking for you," Rem said.

"I'll go see her."

"What is up with him?" Ram said.

Subaru of course had a lot on his mind but for now, he didn't focus on the thoughts and instead focused on Emilia. Ah yes, Emilia. All the worries, all the bad thoughts would vanish the moment he saw her. All his doubts, would melt.

Right?

"Emilia- tan!" Subaru entered, jolly.

There was someone inside, on the sofa, sipping tea.

But it wasn't Emilia.

"Ah, Subaru-kun. Welcooome back." White on that face, almost like a joker.

Subaru sighed and was about to leave but... but he didn't. Instead, he sat down on the other side of the sofa. "So, I think Reinhard has mostly bounced back."

"That is wooonderful," Roswaal rolled his tongue and kept sipping.

"What?"

"You seem different, Subaru-kun. Has something happened?"

"Oh, not really." Subaru laughed.

Roswaal smiled. "You can tell me anyyything!" He spread his arms around, laughing loud.

"I'm good. I'm telling you-" Subaru didn't get to finish. Roswaal was already in front of him, so close. In an instant.

Sniff!

"Oya, what is this scent..." He sniffed again. "Subaru-Kun..." Roswaal glared into his eyes. "Did you and Reinhard..."

"What are you even talking about?"

"Hmm... nevermind. You wouldn't." Roswaal chuckled and moved back, finishing the last sip of his tea. "Lady Emilia is waiting for you in the garden."

"Right," Subaru quickly took his leave.

"Do come by this evening," Roswaal yelled.

The hell was that about? Did he... no, he couldn't. Unless Reinhard tells someone- wait, didn't the people at the tavern... Subaru's face heated up but he managed to keep the welp in. Even if the people had seen him, they clearly didn't know him so it was fine, right?

Right!?

"Subaru?" Emilia said from the distance.

She'd been sitting pretty on the bench. Waiting.

Flowers all around. Grass swaying. Leaves dancing.

Emila smiling.

"Emilia-Tan!" Subaru's thoughts vanished and he quickly scurried off the girl of his dreams.

Yet, his heart didn't flutter as usual. He didn't stare into those deep purple eyes. He hardly glanced at her before realizing Puck was sleeping peacefully on her lap, so he couldn't make up an excuse and lie down.

Sigh.

"Did you finish shopping?" Subaru said.

"I was done a while ago. You were supposed to meet me back. But you never arrived. So, I was a little worried but Puck said you'd be fine and so we came home. Are you okay?"

"Oh yeah, I'm fine." Subaru too sat down on the bench, right next to the elf. Her elven ears slowly turned redder but Subaru hardly noticed it.

Instead, he was more focused on his chest.

Why?

Why isn't it beating the same way it beat around Reinhard? Why... why don't I feel the same intensity...

How come he was next to Emilia but he didn't feel half of what he felt when Reinhard was sitting next to him?

No, something must be wrong with me. Something must... But he couldn't say it. He couldn't think about it.

He couldn't- no, didn't want to acknowledge it.

Was he, really... gay?

He sighed. "Emilia, I need a favor."

"Yes?"

"Can I kiss you?"

Emilia's cheeks flushed. "What! But... won't I get pregnant..." she mumbled.

Subaru ended up laughing. "Of course not. You didn't, the last time, remember?"

"But.... Okie..."

Subaru closed in, their lips inches apart. Emilia closed her eyes, and Subaru closed in the distance, pressing firmly on her soft warm lips. The faint warmth reignited a connection with him. That wonderful tingly feeling.

However-

It's not enough. It's just not the same... damn it! The flutter and tingle, neither could compare to when he kissed Reinhard.

In the end, Subaru had to acknowledge it.

I'm gay.