Tails and Temptations

Tails & Temptation

Three couples. Too much wine. And way too little shame.

The night started like a dozen others: drinks, teasing, low music pulsing in the background. They were gathered at Jessie and Mark's apartment -- their go-to host spot for games, laughter, and low-key debauchery. Six in total: Jessie and Mark, Lena and Ty, Emily and Daniel.

They'd already blown through Cards Against Humanity and an aggressively filthy round of Never Have I Ever. Everyone was buzzed. Touches were lingering longer. Tongues a little looser. Glances a little bolder.

They were arguing over what to play next when Daniel, half-joking, suggested, "Pin the tail on the donkey."

The room chuckled.

Jessie raised a brow. "Actually..."

She stood and disappeared down the hall.

Mark sighed, half-laughing. "That look means trouble..."

When she returned, Jessie held up a silicone plug -- long, smooth, black -- with a fluffy tail at the base.

"If we're playing," she said, "we're playing for real."

Ty's jaw dropped. "You serious?"

Jessie untied her robe and let it fall, revealing her nude body -- tight, toned, C-cups on full display, with a wicked smile to match.

She bent at the waist and held the tail low behind her. "Dead serious."

Emily blinked. Daniel looked like someone had hit him with a stun gun. "I was joking..." he said feebly. But nobody was paying attention to him anymore.

Jessie sauntered toward them. "Whoever's blindfolded gets one minute to catch someone. If you catch someone, you plug them."

Lena clapped her hands and started peeling off her jeans. "Let's fucking go."

Emily looked horrified. Daniel coughed. "Wait -- even the guys could get plugged?"

Jessie shrugged. "Equal opportunity plugging."

Lena grinned. "You boys scared?"

Mark raised both eyebrows. "Okay, hold on. I didn't agree to be bent over tonight."

Ty chuckled nervously. "Yeah, not exactly in the mood to have my ass filled."

Jessie smirked. "Then don't get caught, babe."

"Oh, come on," Lena teased. "You have a better idea, or are you just gonna chicken out?"

Mark exchanged a look with Ty. They huddled for a few moments, then nodded.

"We'd like to make a counteroffer for revised rules," Mark announced.

"Oh?" Jessie raised an eyebrow.

"The boys get to opt out of the plugging. Only bare asses can be plugged, and we wear underwear," Ty explained.

"Yeah, I don't think so--" Lena started.

"But if we get caught, you can choose any punishment for us, and we'll take it like men," Ty added.

Lena walked over to Jessie and whispered something in her ear.

Jessie grinned and licked her lips. "Deal."

Emily cleared her throat. "I think... we're gonna call it a night."

"No problem," Jessie said smoothly. "Thanks for playing."

Daniel shot one incredulous glance at the rest of the group before being practically dragged out.

The door closed behind them with a soft click.

Now it was just four of them: Jessie, Mark, Lena, and Ty.

And the air was thick with tension.

Jessie grabbed the blindfold. "Let's play."

Blindfolded, tail in hand, Jessie moved like a predator. Everyone scattered, giggling. Her hips swayed, tits bouncing as she walked barefoot across the rug.

Then she lunged -- and caught Ty.

He was in boxers.

"No bare ass? Coward," Jessie teased. "But I still get to punish you."

She bent him slightly forward, gripped the plug by its handle, and spanked him three times with the tail -- sharp slaps that echoed in the room.

"Mmm... you flinched," she whispered, brushing the tail between his thighs. "Cute."

Ty bit his lip. "You hit like a fucking domme."

Jessie winked. "You'd love to find out, wouldn't you?"

Next, Ty was blindfolded -- and stumbled like a drunk zombie, missing everyone.

Then Mark took his turn. Steady. Focused. He caught Lena, who was proudly bare, hands raised. He could have sworn he heard her footsteps slow down as he approached, but couldn't be certain with the blindfold on.

"Your move," she said, swaying her hips.

He lubed the plug with a practiced hand, pressed the tip to her hole, and eased it in inch by inch until the fluffy tail was swaying between her ass cheeks.

"Fuck," she gasped. "That feels so damn full."

Then Lena was blindfolded -- and caught Mark, who stumbled slightly when trying to avoid her.

He stood tall in his boxer briefs, smirking.

"Can't plug me," he said.

"No," Lena replied, tapping her phone and setting a timer for 60 seconds. "But I can punish you."

She walked to Jessie, dipped two fingers into her wet slit, then turned to Mark and pushed them past his lips.

"Taste your girl."

Mark licked them clean, moaning.

Halfway through the minute, Lena pulled the plug from her own ass, still glistening -- and slid it into Mark's mouth.

"Enjoy, babe," she whispered in her most sultry voice.

His eyes fluttered. At first surprised -- then hungry.

Lena blocked the base with her palm and whispered, "Suck it like you mean it."

Mark groaned, eyes locked with hers as his tongue worked the toy clean.

The flavor hit. Musky. Forbidden. Jesus fuck, it's intoxicating, he thought, feeling himself get even harder.

Jessie purred. "You like the way her ass tastes?"

Mark moaned around the plug, nodding.

"Good boy," Jessie whispered. "Filthy fucker."

Ty clapped. "Jesus fucking Christ."

"Okay," Mark growled after, adjusting his erection. "New game."

He grabbed a wine bottle and set it spinning. "Spin the bottle. Spinner chooses: give or take."

Lena grinned. "Let's go."

First spin: Jessie ➝ Ty.

"Give," he said instantly. "Lena. On the couch. Now."

She crawled over, bent over the cushions, her bare ass high.

Ty kissed her lower back, then eased Jessie's tail plug into Lena's asshole, watching her shudder.

Second spin: Ty ➝ Jessie.

"Take."

Jessie crawled toward him, pulled her own plug out with a sinful little moan, then handed it to Ty.

"Put it back in me."

She bent, legs spread. Ty slid the toy into her ass, firm and slow.

"Fuck," Jessie whispered. "That's perfect."

Next: Lena ➝ Mark.

"Take."

Mark tugged down his briefs. Jessie grabbed a longer plug.

"You ready, baby?"

"No plugging," he said.

Jessie smirked. "I know."

Instead, she circled his cock with lube and stroked him hard -- painfully slow, whispering filth in his ear. Mark groaned, hips bucking.

She paused just short of letting him come.

"That's your punishment."

Next spin: Jessie ➝ Ty.

She straddled his chest, tail still in, and looked down at him over her shoulder.

"Now it's your turn to eat my ass."

She pulled the plug out, let the base brush his lips, then lowered herself.

Ty licked eagerly -- tracing her tight rim, then diving deeper, tongue curling into her hole, tasting her, owning her.

Jessie moaned, grinding against his face. She reached up and grabbed her own breasts, rolling her nipples as she rode his mouth. "God yes... fuck my ass with your tongue..."

The bottle lay on the side, forgotten.

Jessie turned to Mark, panting. "Fuck me. Now."

He grabbed her, laid her on the couch, and slid his thick cock into her dripping pussy -- the plug still buried in her ass.

She gasped. "Oh god, it's so full... I can feel you fucking against the plug..."

Mark grabbed her hips, slammed into her, the sound of their bodies colliding filthy and wet. Every thrust shoved the plug deeper, making her clench around him.

"Harder," she moaned. "Faster--make me come... oh fucking fuck!"

He growled, pounding her into the cushions. "You're so fucking tight..."

Across the rug, Lena pulled Ty down beside her.

"I want it in my ass," she whispered with a glint of submission in her eyes. "Every goddamn inch."

She arched up on all fours. He removed the plug, kissed her slick hole, then lubed himself and pressed in.

Her tight asshole stretched around his girth -- inch by inch -- until he was balls deep.

"Holy shit," Lena moaned. "You're fucking huge..."

Ty held her by the waist and began to fuck her hard, hips slapping, breathing ragged.

Then, without warning, he pulled out for a second -- grabbed the plug that had just been in her ass -- and shoved it in his mouth.

Lena gasped. "You're tasting my asshole... while you fuck it... You dirty fucker. Keep fucking my ass, baby!"

Ty groaned and slid back inside her, balls slapping against her slick pussy as he thrust deep, mouth still wrapped around the dirty toy. He reached up and palmed her heavy D-cup tits, squeezing her nipples hard as he drove deeper.

Meanwhile, Jessie was moaning louder now, fingers rubbing her clit as Mark plowed into her pussy, cock dragging over the plug again and again.

"I'm gonna come -- fuck -- I'm--"

Mark grabbed a fistful of her chestnut hair and fucked her through her orgasm.

They exploded together -- Jessie screaming as her orgasm ripped through her, Mark groaning as he shot deep inside her, filling her pussy while the tail plug rubbed against his cock.

Ty followed seconds later, slamming into Lena's ass with a final grunt, shooting inside her as he sucked the plug, filthy and euphoric.

The four of them collapsed -- sweaty, ruined, tangled.

Jessie was the first to speak, grinning through her panting.

"So... same time next month?"

Nobody disagreed.