Catching My Sisters Ch. 05

"Get up, Andy," Addie's sweet voice breaks through to my consciousness as she gently runs her fingers through my hair.

I was having this incredible dream where I had been fucking my sisters and one of their coworkers at this club where they work. I'd cum inside Addie again. Ali took a huge load down her throat after I'd almost nutted in her pussy. Then, their work friend, Cherry, pounced on me and I fucked her good and hard, too. I'd almost nutted in her as well, but pulled out right before my first blast. I hadn't even had to touch myself for the cum to start flowing out onto her belly and tits.

"Good morning," I murmur tiredly. "I had a crazy dream," I manage to say, unable to open my eyes.

"Oh yeah?" Addie asks me, still in her sweet voice. "Did you come close to cumming in Cherry?" she asks.

My eyes pop open. Addie's gorgeous blue eyes are looking down at me as my head rests in her lap. She smells of sex, sweat and spilled alcohol. She's in her work uniform consisting of a micro-miniskirt and a tied off top, all in black. I sit up and look around. I'm still on the couch Cherry and I had fucked on.

"I guess it wasn't a dream," I say and then yawn.

"It sure wasn't," Addie says. "We're ready to leave now, but you look too tired to drive."

"I don't know how much longer I can keep my eyes open," I admit.

"Well, then, Ali can drive our car and I'll drive yours. We still don't want to wake Mom and Dad up, but it's also Saturday, so they're not going to work," she says. "Unfortunately, we have to get you back into your bed alone."

I look at her sadly. "That sucks," I say.

"Maybe they'll have plans we don't know about yet," she says encouragingly. "And if they leave, the three of us will do whatever we want until Ali and I have to come back to work."

I nod. "That sounds good," I say and then stand up. "Oh, Cherry cleaned me up. I hope that's not a rule violation."

Addie smiles as she joins me, hugging my arm as she leads me out of the breakroom to find Ali so we can leave.

"No, it doesn't break our rule," Addie assures me. "You'd already cum all over her and she was just cleaning you up like a good girl."

"You act like you guys are in charge even though she's older than you guys," I say inquisitively.

"It's not that we're in charge," Addie says. "You're just OUR brother, so they have to abide by our rules out of respect to our relationship. Just like if any girl brings her boyfriend here, she does so, knowing the girls will likely try to seduce him. So, she'll set up rules like, no cumming inside any or certain holes, or no kissing, or only blowjobs or something like that. Each girl is different."

"So, this is a normal thing with the club?" I ask skeptically, unsure of how I really feel about this place, or the fact that my sisters work here for that matter. I think my conscience is starting to kick in. That or I'm struggling with jealousy and might possibly be feeling a little possessive of them. Either way, I'm beginning to see why Dad doesn't like them working here and I begin to wonder what he knows about this place.

Addie nods. "Totally! We're like a family here and share! We just set boundaries!" she says brightly.

"And no one gets in trouble?" I ask.

"It's just a dance club, and as long as no drama breaks out, and the place makes money, the owners look the other way and let us do things our way," Addie explains. "No money is being exchanged for sex, so it's not a whorehouse. It's just people sort of sneaking around and fucking. Nobody calls it out, nobody reports it. It just is what it is! A sexy, fun place to get drunk and get off!"

I grin sideways at her. "You are such an interesting person, Addie," I tell her.

She smiles at me. "How so?" she asks.

"Well, you're like... innocent, but not," I say. "Your outlook on life and the world is almost too pure to be..."

"A total slut?" she asks with a giggle.

"For lack of better term due to my exhaustion, yeah," I admit.

"Well, like Ali said, you're the only one to finish inside of me," she says. "And I really haven't been with many guys at all. Maybe three or four. I've been with more girls than I have guys," she admits. "If nothing had happened between us, I'd probably just be a lesbian."

"So, you're saying that I'm the only guy you really want?" I ask her.

We stop at the bar where Ali is receiving hers and Addie's tips for the night and Addie looks up at me.

"That's exactly what I'm saying," she says. "And Ali feels the same way."

I look at our blonde sister as she counts out the wad of cash in her hands before sticking it in her top.

"How'd we do?" Addie asks her.

"Fucking great!" Ali says. "Two hundred each!"

"No shit?" Addie says amazed. "That's our biggest night yet! And we spent extra time with our little bro!"

"You look rough, Andy," Ali says concerned reaching up and brushing my hair with her hand. "Did you have a lot to drink?"

I shake my head. "No, just the one Seven and Seven Cherry made me and then I had a water and a coke after that," I tell them. "I'm just tired."

Ali smiles sweetly like Addie had earlier. "Let's just get you home and into bed," she says.

"I'll drive Andy's car," Addie volunteers quickly.

Ali sighs. "Okay, fine, but next time, I drive him home," she says, apparently too tired to argue.

"Girls, please don't fight over me," I plead in my exhaustion as I feel it beginning to take over again.

"Andy's right," Ali says. "And there's no way he's going to make it home like this."

We finally leave and Addie drives my late model Honda Accord and Ali drives their Civic home. It's about 4:30am when we pull up to the house and quietly enter. The girls, due to my exhaustion from such a long day, not to mention the emotional afternoon with Mom and Dad dropping the family bomb on me, help me into bed, stripping me down to my boxers and pulling back the sheets for me. They even curl up on either side of me, stroking my hair lovingly until I pass out again. Which takes a whole, thirty seconds probably.

It's noon when I finally wake up later. I look around, almost wondering how I'd gotten into my bed. Then, everything comes rushing back to me. Catching my sisters scissoring each other when I got home from school yesterday, them seducing me into some awesome, oral sex, then actually fucking them both like crazy and almost getting caught in bed with them by Dad. Then, I remember the truth bomb Mom and Dad dropped on me about Aunt Laurie really being my biological mother, my sisters being my cousins, but ultimately, deciding that nothing had changed. I've gone eighteen years knowing them as my sisters, nothing, not even DNA, will change that. I love them both so much. In more ways than one.

I smirk at that thought, and my cock also responds. Despite being a little sore from getting more use yesterday than he has in the past few months combined, he's stiff and needs to be dealt with. I smell the stench coming from under my arms, so I get up and stumble to my bathroom. I brush my teeth and then get into the shower to finally clean up and deal with my morning wood. I try to think back about the events of the previous night to help myself get off, but I suddenly sense someone entering my bathroom.

"Can I join you?" the visitor asks and for a moment, I can't tell if it's Ali or Addie, so I pull back the curtain to find Ali standing there completely naked and waiting.

"What about-"

"Mom and Dad are gone for the day," she interrupts me. "They apparently are meeting some friends to go out on their yacht in Newport."

"Oh," I say brightly and then grin at her, pushing the curtain open further.

Her face lights up happily and she quickly joins me in the shower, planting her mouth on mine as I close the curtain.

"How's he feeling?" Ali asks, reaching down and gently stroking my cock, resuming her kisses.

"Better, now that he's in your hands," I tell her between kisses.

"He's not sore from last night?" she asks.

"Oh, he definitely is. Between you and Addie fucking me so much, and then Cherry fucking me so wildly last night, he's really sore, but he feels good in your hand," I tell her.

"Maybe he needs some oral healing," she says and I nod as she lowers down to her knees and begins to slowly suck my cock.

I believe this is the other side of Ali I've been hoping to see. The softer, warmer side. I got to see Addie's wilder side last night at the club, and now, in my own private bathroom, I'm finally witnessing the sweeter side of my wild sister. Even as she's sucking me off, there's tenderness to her that I just knew was lurking beneath the surface.

After a couple of minutes, Ali stands up again and we embrace, kissing each other deeply and passionately. Her arms wrap around my neck while my hands roam up and down her smooth, silky back, giving extra attention to her beautiful, bubble butt.

Ali giggles in our kiss. "You really like my ass, don't you?" she asks, still in her sweet voice.

"I love all of you, Ali," I tell her and then resume making out with her.

Then, Ali breaks our kiss and looks up into my eyes with longing. This is definitely another side of her she hasn't shown me. I can't say that the wild side isn't her true self, but this tender, loving side is just another cog in the wheel that makes up who Ali is. Just like when I got to see Addie's wilder side at the club last night.

"Can we go to your bed?" she asks quietly.

I can feel her heart beating rapidly in her chest. I caress her face with the back of my hand as I nod at her without taking my eyes off of hers. She reaches behind her and turns off the shower. Then I open the curtain and we step out, find two towels in a drawer along the lefthand side of my sink and then we dry off, tying our towels around our bodies. Why? Just to have something to take off.

"First," she says softly and then goes to my door.

I look at her curiously. "What's going through that brain of yours, sis?" I ask her.

"I just want some alone time with my baby brother," she says, and I can tell it's the honest truth.

"Does Addie not know about this?" I ask.

"She does," Ali says. "I just don't want her to show up too soon."

"Oh, there's plans for all three of us?" I grin at her.

"Obviously," she says irritated, no hint of a smile. Her eyes look away from mine for the first time since she surprised me in the bathroom. I'd said something wrong.

"Ali," I say gently. "I didn't mean to hurt you by saying that."

She forces a smile. "I know," she says and even sniffles. "I guess you and Addie just have more of a special connection than we'll ever have," she continues, sounding like her mind is changing.

When she turns for the door again, I hurry to her and grab her by the shoulders, my towel falling off in the process. I'm only half-hard now, so he's just swaying back and forth, partially jutting out towards my sister.

"Ali, wait," I say and she looks up at me, her eyes still sad like she might cry. "The past twenty-four hours have been a crazy whirlwind for me. You coming in so sweet and... tender this morning... I wasn't expecting it. I love you and Addie equally."

"Prove it," she challenges me. "Make love to me instead of just fucking me this time."

"I would love nothing more, Ali," I tell her and finally, she smiles again. "I saw where this was heading, and I'm sorry for ruining things with a silly comment," I continue and then push her damp hair behind her left ear before cupping her cheek in my hand.

She sighs. "I guess I can't fault you for being excited for more threesome action," she says with a twinkle in her eyes this time. "I want to have fun again, too, but first, I need some true love from my brother."

"You have it," I promise her.

I lower my face to hers and she opens her mouth to receive my kiss. I give her a deep, passionate kiss again, holding her face in both hands. She lets her towel fall away and then presses her body against mine, my cock already re-stiffening as I feel her against me. I break our kiss long enough to pick her up with my left arm under her legs and my right supporting her back. She wraps her arms around my neck and pulls herself up to continue kissing me. She giggles softly as my stiff rod pokes her butt cheek a couple of times, but she continues to kiss me as well.

Then, I lay her on top of my bed, pull the sheets back the rest of the way and then climb on to join her. She immediately spreads her legs and I lay on top of her, resuming our deep, loving kisses. Our bodies meld into one, her breasts mashed against my chest, my throbbing cock pinned between our abdomens, though neither of us is in a hurry for me to enter her. I begin to kiss down her neck and she gasps quietly, stroking my hair as I make my way to her beautiful tits. I give them both ample attention, sucking, nibbling, squeezing and massaging them. I pinch and twist her nipples just enough to get her to gasp and react, but not to hurt her as I don't want to dissuade this gentle loving from her. She wants her own special time with me.

After slathering up her tits with my saliva, I move down to her taught tummy and kiss her cute bellybutton. Her stomach flexes and stretches as she alternates between giggling from how much it tickles to moaning from how stimulating it is for her eventual orgasm.

"I love how you lick my bellybutton," she says in such a sweet voice it makes me fall deeper in love with her.

"I love your bellybutton," I tell her. "It's so cute."

She giggles softly again until it turns into another soft moan as she smiles down at me while I look up at her while still flicking my tongue. Then, I give her a wink to tell her I'm moving further down and her smile grows. She nods her approval and I kiss my way down to her pussy. I take in the scent of her love tunnel and then let out a deep breath before I begin to slowly lick up and down the puffy lips of her pussy. The familiar, saltiness I remember from yesterday stimulates my brain and makes me hungry for more, so I work my tongue deeper and deeper into her, tasting her with every part of my tongue that I can. I feel her pussy already beginning to contract, but I also feel her hips slowly grinding into my face. I look up at her, but from this far down, her face is blocked by her perfect tits.

I hum into her pussy and that surprises her enough to make her prop herself up and look down at me. I wink at her again and begin to hum, sending vibrations into her cunt as I continue to work my tongue. She leans back on her arms, her head falling back and jutting her tits farther up into the air as she begins to breathe deeper, longer, ragged breaths. Then, she falls back down and her hands grip the back of my head as she tries to hold herself back from fucking my face. I help her remain still by gripping onto her tanned, slender thighs that are completely smooth with not even a hint of stubble. She and Addie must stay up on shaving or waxing or something. Their legs always look perfect and smooth.

"Fuck, Andy, you're so good at that," she says. "How are you so good already?"

"I got some practice in yesterday," I joke and she laughs.

"Yeah, you did," she sighs and then props herself up again to watch me eat her out.

I move up to her clit, flicking it with my tongue until it comes out of its little hood and then I attack her. Ali lets out a high-pitched yelp and falls back onto the bed again, writhing as I lick, suck and nibble on her little nub.

"Fuck, Andy, yes! YES, ANDY! Oh, keep doing that!" she cries out. "Eat my pussy, baby bro," she says, though her voice still sounds sweet as she speaks. "Oh god, yes!" she continues to cry out as if getting emotional or desperate rather than horny for a ravaging. "Oh, Andy," she whines. "God, I love you, Andy," she says and I believe her.

I plunge my tongue back into her pussy while giving attention to her clit with my thumb this time, hoping to bring her to an orgasm before I enter her. She came to me wanting something special, so that's what I'm going to provide for her. Ali grinds her pussy into my face harder and harder, unable to stifle the wild girl completely, and I wouldn't want her to. She's fun and crazy and I wouldn't want her any other way. Even as she desires a deep, loving connection like she's seeking now.

"Fuck, Andy, that feels so good!" her voice grows louder. "You're going to make me cum so hard," she tells me.

I continue what I'm doing because it seems to be bringing her closer and closer to the edge, and then I have an idea I want to try. I have to time it right, though. I listen to her words, while at the same time, feel her body's promptings that she's about to let loose her orgasm. As her words grow more unintelligible, I know she's getting close. Then, as her pussy begins to contract as if pulling at my dick, I know she's nearly there. I wait a few more seconds and then stop.

"What are you doing? I'm about to explode!" she complains desperately and then I move quickly, getting on my knees and lining my cock up with her pussy. "Oh," she says with curious surprise and then watches as, in one swift motion, I quickly slide into her until we're fully connected. "FUCK!" she screams as her arms and legs instantly wrap around me as her entire body seems to contract around my cock. Warm fluids gush from her like tidal waves as her orgasm rakes through her entire body. She trembles and shakes even though she has a death grip on me.

I don't begin to fuck her just yet, though. I let her ride out her orgasm for a few moments until she seems to start coming down again, and then that's when I begin pumping into her slowly. Her grip on my shoulders and my waist never subsides the entire time I slowly fuck her with long, slow thrusts. I'm a long way away from cumming still, so I know this will take some time, but I want to see just how long I can make her orgasm last.

I feel her body convulse one more time as a second orgasm seems to sweep through her.

"Oh, fuck!" she cries loudly. "That's two," she says. "The other one barely even stopped!"

I keep pumping in and out of her slowly, allowing her pussy to feel every inch of me. Then, I bring our mouths together once again and kiss her deeply as I continue to slide in and out of her. We breathe heavily through our noses, not wanting to separate any part of us again until we know we're done. Then, I return my mouth to her neck and she moans long, soft moans into my ear as I lick and suck her neck, right where it meets her shoulder. She pushes on my shoulder, telling me she wants a change of position, so I roll onto my back without pulling out of her and then she sits up with me buried deep inside her still.

Ali begins to slowly ride me, unlike yesterday when she wanted to fuck hard and fast. She rises up and down on my cock with long, slow strokes. I reach up and fondle her beautiful tits, massaging them firmly with both hands until I sit up myself. Her legs wrap around me again and hold my head to her chest. I take up sucking and licking her tits again as we continue our slow, passionate fuck. Ali then leans back and gyrates her hips, pressing every wall around my cock slowly as she does.

"Fuck," I gasp. "That feels so good, Ali," I tell her. "I might not last much longer if you keep that up."

"Good," she says. "I want you to cum. Cum for me, Andy," she coaxes and encourages me. "I want to feel it inside me. I want to feel you erupt inside my pussy. Fill me up, Andy," she continues to say and I gawk at her in shock.

"Are you sure?" I ask her.

Ali nods. "I was waiting for it to be like this," she says and then plants her mouth on mine again as we continue to fuck.

Knowing she wants my seed inside her is enough to bring me to my fall. I roll us back onto her back and plow into her, not any faster, but definitely harder, until my balls begin to boil and send my troops up my shaft, building and building.

"Yes, Andy," she cries. "Fill me up," she begins to beg. "Cum inside me!"

Finally, I let loose, sending millions of swimmers in search of an egg.

"YES!!" she screams again, over and over as I continue to thrust inside of her with each blast of my cock, panting as her chest heaves beneath me.

When I finally finish, after losing count of how many globs of cum I unloaded into her, I look down at her and she strokes my hair. "That felt so good," I tell her and then suddenly shiver.

Ali giggles at my post-coital reaction. "Yeah, it did," she says and then kisses me as I still slowly pump inside of her, continuing to make small deposits as my cock finishes the job. "Thank you," she says sweetly, stroking my hair again.

"I should be thanking you," I tell her. "I enjoyed that more than anything else we've done."

She cocks her head with a sweet smile. "You're not into the fun stuff?" she asks.

"Oh, I definitely am," I tell her and then kiss her. "But I love this so much more. The crazy stuff is a fun bonus."

Ali hugs me to her tightly. "No one has ever talked to me like this before," she says sounding satisfied. "I think I can get used to it, though."

I kiss her neck and then drag my tongue along her salty skin.

"I can get used to that, too," she says. "Be careful, you might get me going again."

"What if that's what I'm trying to do?" I whisper.

"But he just finished," she says. "He already feels softer."

I push myself up and look down into her smiling green eyes. Then, as if on cue, he begins to stiffen and grow again. Her eyes grow wide and her mouth forms into a perfect O in pleasant shock.

"That felt so... crazy!" Ali giggles. "Feeling him grow inside of me! Addie's gotta feel that too!"

"She will, but this is still your time," I tell her and then kiss her hard on the mouth.

"Andy," she breaks our kiss. "You still need an actual shower," she says. "And now, I could use one too."

"Shower sex?" I ask her.

"Shower sex," she agrees.

I pull out of her and we run like little kids to my bathroom, her tits bouncing wildly the whole way. Ali beats me (because I let her so I could watch that perfect ass jiggle) and then turns the shower on again. I stop, turn back and grab our towels really quick and unlock the door. You know, just in case Addie wants to show up at some point. I drape the towels over the counter and then join Ali in the shower. We don't waste time getting to the fucking. As soon as the curtain is closed, she turns and sticks her ass out towards me.

"Take me, baby bro. Fill me up again," she commands.

"Anything for you, big sis," I say and then line my cock up with her pussy, which is still soaking wet with her juices, and then I slam into her.

"FUCK YES!" she screams and I proceed to fuck her hard and fast. Ali screams profanities and lurid comments that bring me to a second orgasm of my own extremely fast. We cum together in a wild fuck, my pelvis slapping against her perfect ass as I slam into her cunt over and over until I fill her fuck tunnel with my seed once again.

When we come down from our blissful high of our shower quickie, Ali turns and giggles in her cute way before kissing me.

"Thank you for giving me space to share both sides of me with you," she says.

"I like this backside a lot," I joke.

Ali laughs. "I meant emotionally, dummy," she slaps my arm playfully and then she grabs my bar of soap and proceeds to wash my body thoroughly, being gentle with my cock as he's extremely sensitive and extremely spent right now.

After our shower, I get dressed while Ali leaves in the towel she used to go back to her room to get dressed as well. Addie arrives just as I'm pulling on a pair of knee-length denim shorts.

"Hey, baby bro," she says, leaning against my doorpost.

"Hey sis," I say happily and then grab a plain, gray T-shirt out of my second drawer and pull it on over my head.

"Ali is simply glowing," she says happily.

"Is she?" I ask, a big smile on my own face.

"So are you," she swoons a little. "Aww, I love seeing my two favorite people look so happy."

"You're not jealous?" I ask curiously.

"Why would I be? We started this as a threesome yesterday, Ali and I are aware that there will be times when either of us will want some alone time with you, and you need to be aware that there will be times when we need alone time with each other," she explains.

I consider what she said and nod. "I think that's totally fair," I say.

"Those times will probably be when you're at school," she adds. "So, you'll probably hardly notice us needing time alone," she giggles. "And if you walk in on us, most of the time, we'll probably just let you join. You'll know not to try if the door is locked."

"You like to set rules and boundaries," I point out.

Addie shrugs. "It's the only way something like this works," she says. "It's the only way you can be passed around at our work and there not be any jealousy from me and Ali," she adds.

"About that," I say and she cocks her head. "Last night was fun, and Cherry is smoking hot and I'm glad I got that one time with her, but I don't know that that's something I can do often," I say. "Or much at all."

Addie frowns at me, but out of curiosity, looking for an explanation.

"After I had sex with you and Ali, and especially now after the way Ali and I connected so much deeper than before, like you and I had yesterday," I explain. "I don't want any other girls."

Addie stares at me with an expression that's hard to read. "Do you want us to stop hooking up with the girls at work?" she asks.

I look past her to think without being distracted by her beautiful face. She's hard to say no to or to defy with those bright, blue eyes. Why do both of my sisters have to be so fucking perfect?

"I don't know," I answer honestly. "You can make your own decisions, but I really only want to be with you and Ali."

"No, this is an equal, three-way relationship, Andy," Addie says fairly. "We don't dictate anything. You have an equal voice."

That's when Ali suddenly materializes in the doorway, just behind Addie's left shoulder, beaming at me.

"I can give it up," Ali says making Addie jump with a start.

"Fuck, Ali!" she screams at her. "Sneaky bitch!"

Ali giggles at her. "Sorry, sis," she says pinching her ass.

"Goddammit, Ali!" she screams and then laughs this time. "Fucking cunt, I swear!"

"Were you serious, Ali?" I ask her.

She nods enthusiastically. "Yeah, if the only cock and pussy I ever got again was from you two, I'd be more than happy," she says, knowing her speaking up will help me galvanize my thoughts and feelings.

I expected that more from Addie than Ali, if I'm being completely honest. Maybe I had them wrong. Maybe I don't know my sisters as well as I thought. Yes, Addie is the calm, sweet, loving one and Ali is fun, wild and crazy, but they both have their counterpart personalities just sitting below the surface. Maybe those were their true personalities and I just got a taste of who each of them really is. Addie's actually struggling with the idea-

"I'm in," Addie interrupts my train of thought.

I blink at them both, completely stunned. "Really?" I ask them.

"Yeah," Addie says.

"Of course!" Ali says. "The girls at work might be a little bummed, but they'll get over it."

"They won't get upset with you for not hooking up with them anymore?" I ask concerned. "I don't want to hurt your work relationships."

"You only saw a handful of the girls who work there," Addie says. "There are a lot that don't go around fucking everybody," she giggles in her innocent way.

"We can stop being sluts and just be sluts for you!" Ali says.

"I don't think sweeter words have ever been said," I say sarcastically, winking at her as she laughs to herself.

"So, should we celebrate?" Addie asks.

"Yeah!" Ali says excitedly.

"How do we want to do that?" I ask rhetorically and the girls answer by yanking their tops off and chasing me onto the bed.