A Visit from Cindy Pt. 05

Melissa...

I really didn't intend for things to work out they way they did. Honestly, I was just going to fool around and tease Cindy's boyfriend which is something I felt sort of entitled to do. Jeff is off on vacation enjoying himself and he has his flirting relationship with my little sister. Can't I have some fun too? Some back room kind of sneaky fun too?

But "one thing led to another" and they next thing I knew I was on my knees before Andy, his intended 'gift' panties for Cindy pulled to one side and all of his big cock loaded into my helpless little asshole!

The only way out of the lewd act of sodomy that I was being subjected to was to take his prick out of my forbidden little hole and move it to my tight and already well lubricated pussy. Andy had no objection to that and then I felt the mushroom shaped head of his hardened penis surging into my vagina which brought a gasp of pleasure from me. At that point I just gave up and surrendered my body and my mind to experiencing the thrilling pleasure that only illicet sex can provide! It was just so dirty! Shopping for panties with my little sister's boyfriend, then dancing while the cool jazz played. Trying to tease him and succeeding in doing so. Until I pushed it a bit too far and then he took over. A man is bred to take what he wants. And Andy wanted my pussy and asshole and, goddam it, he got them both!

Yet, somehow, I realize Jeff is back early from his golf trip and Andy and I are just about caught dead to rights. I barely managed to get my clothes on while

Andy scrambled out the back door and I was in the extremely awkward position of trying to compose myself when my husband walked in the door.

******

Jeff...

It had been a great trip to Bandon, It always is really. The beautiful Oregon Coast and the great golf at the complex there. But when the rains come to the Oregon Coast, well, You can still go out but it might rain really hard for the rest of the day. Nothing is fun in that weather.

So we bailed a day early and I was looking forward to sleeping in my own bed.

So, what's this? Isn't that Cindy's boyfriend's car parked out in front of the house? Sure looks like it. But Cindy has school all day, doesn't she? I enter the house from the garage and walk through the kitchen to the living room where Miles Davis is playing on the stereo. And here's my sexy wife, her face all flushed. She has that easy to detect "fake smile" that she gets when she's up to something. Like, she got a ticket. Or her parents are coming for a visit.

But what's that smell? It smells quite a bit like pussy. Melissa's pussy. I glance out the living room window and see Andy's car pulling away from the curb. Melissa does her best to greet me and gives me a big smooch but with my arms embracing her it's only obvious that something is really strange here.

"So how was Oregon? My wife begins. She's got her body glued to mine but behind her I see a "Victoria's Secret" bag. Sometimes two and two equals four.

"It was great until the rain started." I replied. Melissa was gazing into my eyes and I think she was hoping I'd come home horny. My eyes were gazing around the room. I wondered if the Victoria's Secret bag was left over from Christmas or something but it appeared to be full of... of something.

"How was Andy?" I asked very directly.

Melissa was at a loss for words. She knew there was just too much incriminating evidence for her to explain her way out of this situation. Cindy was not home. Her boyfriend just drove away and there's a bag of sexy something right there on the sofa.

"I... I mean we... I mean, um, we didn't do anything Jeff." she started. "I know what it must look like but, well, he wanted me to go to the mall with him to pick out some sexy panties for Cindy. For Valentines day, you know."

"Uh huh." I dryly replied. "So you went to the mall and you went to Victoria's Secret and you shopped for panties."

"Right." Melissa answered.

"Then you came home and you guys put on some Miles Davis and just chatted a bit and then he went home." There was clearly a lot of space to be filled in. I broke our embrace and walked to the sofa and checked out the panties. They were all pretty sexy.

"Odd. The receipt says that you bought four pairs but there's only three in the bag." I looked up at Melissa. "What happened to the other pair?" Then, it was quiet. I looked at my wife, well aware of her promiscuous sexual past. I knew she wasn't going to answer me.

"Jeff... Jeff, I..."

I guided Melissa to the sofa and gently laid her down on the cushions. I knelt in front of her and, taking the hem of her little skirt in my fingers, I lifted her garment exposing the fourth pair of panties. The price tag was still in place.

"Gee! Very nice Mel! Did Andy like them?

"Jeff, I know what it must look like but I..."

"Look like and smell like, Melissa." I reached for her panties and she attempted to prevent me from touching her there. I just grabbed her knees and pulled her legs apart and then it was unmistakable: The fragrant smell of female lubrication and male sperm was filling my nostrils.

Melissa's eyes were full of fear now. "Jeff, I just gave him a little 'free pussy show.' You know, like we do sometimes. He wanted to dance and so we did a little of that and..."

"Goddam it Mel, how dumb do you think I am?" I fired back. I knew my wife now wanted to just leave the room and get into a huff and find some way to be pissed off at me. She'd done it before.

But, I wasn't going for that. "Shouldn't Cindy know about this Mel?" I asked with a smile. "I mean, it was all in fun wasn't it? Just a little trip to Victoria's Secret to buy underpants and then a free pussy show? I think Cindy might like to hear about this first hand."

Now Melissa knew she had a problem on her hands. Of course she could deal with me the way married women have always done: She has the pussy and therefore she can play by her own rules. But her little sister. Of course she didn't want Cindy to know about this messy little affair.

"Jeff, I... Jeff we..."

"Yeah, Melissa. 'We' is the right word. isn't it?" I glared at her. "Now, what did you do? You owe me honesty!" It was quiet, the jazz album having ended. It was just me and her. "What did you do?"

Knowing she had no way out, Melissa began to confess her indiscretion.

"Andy, he wanted to go shopping for panties to give to Cindy for Valentine's day. I eventually agreed. Yes, I knew he wanted more than just a shopping trip. But we went to the mall and he got real animated when we got in the store and saw all the salacious panties they had on display. And so he bought several pairs."

"Yeah, and then what?"

"We came home and... and he asked me to try on a pair and model them for him. I said no. But he was persistent. He kept asking about a 'free panty show.' and..."

"Mel, how did he know about that?" I couldn't help but ask. This was private information between just me and my wife. That somehow Andy knew about one of my sleazy little kinks indicated a deeper relationship between the two of them.

"He came by one day to pick up my sister and she wasn't home yet. I was putting my panties on the clothes line and he saw me. We started talking. I... I ended up describing what a 'free panty show' usually involved."

"So, you just went ahead and gave him a 'free panty show' but that's all?" I glared at my wife. The room was quiet for a few moments. Then Melissa shot the only card she had to play.

"So, Jeff, did Cindy give you a hand job like we agreed that night?" She looked directly into my eyes. "Did she take off her panties for you Jeff? Did you get to see her pussy?"

Sometimes the best defense is a good offense. I saw where this was going and so I got up and shook my head at her.

"Melissa, I think Cindy should know what her boyfriend is up to, don't you? I mean, she's getting serious about him. Shouldn't she know he likes to fool around behind her back?"

Pissed off now, and behind the eight ball, Melissa got up and angrily left the room leaving that critical question unresolved.

******

Melissa

What a mess. I really didn't expect I would end up in this big of a fix. Of course I didn't want my sister to know I'd fucked her boyfriend. No, I didn't intend for it to happen but I easily could've avoided it if i'd tried. But, I didn't really try. Playing around with that huge cock had managed to get my pussy wet. Yes, I liked teasing Andy thinking it would be a one and done thing. And, undeniably, it was a thrill to take his big hard cock into my pussy. Every time I thought of it in the days that passed I got wet with the memory.

But I knew Jeff was pissed. He had a right to be. We know how to 'get along' and so our lives returned to some degree of 'normal.' But without sex. No, the glue that keeps you together was missing now. I knew It was only a matter of time before Jeff told Cindy about my shameless encounter with Andy. I kept hoping for some solution to come to me but nothing appeared.

Finally, I decided I needed to speak to my sister. I would play it by ear and hope for the best. I was well aware that Jeff loves my sister and maybe, just maybe, there was a way to even the score (so to speak) with my husband by getting Cindy to help.

My little sister returned from school one afternoon while Jeff was gone and I fixed a pot of coffee for the two of us to share. We settled in for a little 'girl talk.'

"So, Cind, how're things with Andy these days?" I offered.

She gave me a knowing smile and answered "Pretty good Meliss. He gave me some panties from Victoria's Secret for Valentine's day and he likes me to wear them before we, you know, do it."

Ah, my little sister! She loves to fuck but doesn't like to say the word!

"All men like that Sis." I returned. Jeff likes a 'free pussy show' where I stride around the room and show him the goods. This gets him good and worked up and then we have good sex that we both enjoy."

"Does he do it with your panties still on?" She innocently asked.

"Yes he does." I frankly replied. "Have you... have you ever given Andy a 'free pussy show?" She lowered her eyes, embarrassed to answer such a salacious question.

She nodded her head up and down. "He likes me to kneel with just a little thong on so he can see all I have back there. It's so nasty!" We both chuckled. I saw an opportunity arising and decided to go for broke.

Cindy, maybe you could help me with something that's been troubling me. Jeff found out about a secret credit card I got and ran up a rather large balance. He insists we owe each other honesty and now I'm caught sneaking around borrowing money behind his back. Money he has to pay back. And now Sis, we haven't been doing it. You know, the glue that holds you together? Yeah, that glue." Cindy was quiet.

"Well, how can I help?" She asked.

When she said that I knew I was finally close to fixing this ongoing problem. I quietly proposed my plan to my sister and she didn't seem to have any problem with it. Tomorrow was Saturday and I bought barbeque fixings and a couple of bottles of wine.

I told Jeff that Andy was out of town and so Cindy would be home Saturday night and I'd planned a little barbeque for the three of us. He eyed me suspiciously. It's not like we weren't on speaking terms but there'd been ice between us since that day he got back from Oregon and caught me wearing my sister's gift panties.

"Can you fire up the grill?" I asked. Now, Jeff has the hots for my sister and I knew an event involving both of the McGregor sisters would appeal to him. I didn't say any more but I gave him a look that I hoped he would be able to interpret.

And so the jazz was playing and Cindy and I were enjoying our wine and flirting with Jeff and, after being angry at me for weeks now, he seemed to be finally thawing out a bit.

******

Cindy...

I'm happy to help my sister out and her plan for this evening seems a bit much over a money thing but I also got the impression that there could be more to the story than she's letting on. I've always admired Jeff and my brief but memorable sexual encounter with him has stayed on my mind ever since. Jeff's barbeque skills are unmatched and the food was really good.

Melissa went into the house with the dishes and leftovers and so I got right next to my brother-in-law, like touching him and I began to softly speak to him.

"Jeff, Andy got me these really sexy panties for Valentines day..." he gave me a kind of funny look when I said that. "Would you... would you like to see them?"

He had a weird expression on his face and I think he expected me to go bring the Victoria's Secret bag with my new panties for him to look at. That was not the plan at all!

"My sister says that you like a 'free panty show' where she models sexy panties for you. Would you like that? Would you like for me to model my new panties for you? Melissa said she's willing to help out..."

When Jeff heard that he began to understand that the two McGregor sisters had apparently cooked up some entertainment for this evening. "They say 'pay back is a bitch'." He thought to himself. Maybe this will end up being fun. Cindy offered her hand to her brother-in-law and she led him into the living room. Jeff took the opportunity to dig up some classic jazz in the form of Wes Montgomery playing "Bumpin'."

Now he was ready for a new and extraordinarily sexy 'free panty show.' Cindy had retired to her bedroom to change and jeff sat in his easy chair, glass of pinot noir in his hand. Melissa entered the room and quietly sat down on the carpet next to her husband. "Jeff, I hope you can forgive me. I was wrong. I can't take back what I did but I'm hoping to make it up to you the best I can tonight. I love you and I want to be your girl, forever." With that, she went off to help her sister get dressed.

Jeff knew what he was getting when he married Melissa. She was hot blooded and he knew it good and well. Still, he was shocked and disappointed to discover what she'd been up to while he was gone. The smooth sound of Wes Montgomery's guitar had a soothing effect on him and he eagerly anticipated seeing his red haired sister-in-law wearing sexy panties... any time now.

Just as Wes began "Here's that rainy day," Cindy tentatively entered the room. She wore French cut burgundy panties with a matching bra. Yes, she was to die for! The bra didn't last long as Melissa soon appeared also briefly dressed in a lavender teddy I'd bought her a while back. She knew it was my favorite. My wife helped her little sister undo her bra strap and then Cindy's gorgeous young tits were on display! She made a lot of eye contact as if to say "how do you like them?" I liked them a lot! She turned around to give me a good look at her butt. Both of the McGregor sisters have world class rear ends and Melissa proudly stood next to her sister allowing me to compare the two. I had to give a slight edge to Cindy. Maybe just because I'd seen Melissa nude quite a bit by then. Both girls retreated to the bedroom to prepare for round two. I was sporting serious wood by then. I was wondering how far this would go?

With Wes's guitar continuing to serenade me, Cindy appeared wearing lacy white panties. They were sexy and I love white panties but I thought they covered a little too much.

"They're hot Cindy!" I complemented her. Cindy smiled and then turned around and bent over, putting her hands on her knees. Oh, yes! A great 'rear view' of her panty clad ass! Now my cock was rock hard in anticipation of what was to come. Hopefully it would be me!

Just then, Melissa entered the room wearing just a tiny white G string. Her sizable tits bobbed free. She just glanced at me and then approached her sister. "Let's really give him a good look!" With that she reached for the waistband of her little sister's panties and proceeded to tug them down. Cindy didn't seem too thrilled with this action but she didn't stop Melissa. Soon, Cindy's gorgeous teen aged ass was gloriously mooning me!

"He probably wants to see a bit more Sis..." My wife encouraged Cindy.

Knowing what was now expected of her, Cindy took the cheeks of her butt in her hands and slowly drew them apart. Now her tiny pink asshole and pussy were on display!

This was good and getting better! The two sisters gave me a few moments to savor the ludicrous panty show they were putting on and then retired to the bedroom.

It was a few minutes before the McGregor sisters reappeared. Cindy sporting see through white panties with saucy pink lace trim. There was no cotton liner and the delicate lips of my little sister-in-law's pussy were easily visible. Melissa wore a white thong and nothing more.

Having just seen Cindy on her hands and knees I was wondering what could possibly follow that? I didn't have long to wait. Melissa quietly embraced her little sister and then they shared a kiss. And not a peck on the cheek. No, Melissa pressed her lips to Cindy's and the two of them enjoyed a deep soul kiss. I was reasonably sure that they had discussed this in the bedroom beforehand but still, it was sexy as all hell to watch.

Melissa then pushed her sister gently onto the sofa and then pulled her over onto her knees. With me watching intensely, she reached for the waistband of Cindy's panties. Instead of pulling them down, my wife began to softly caress Cindy's ass cheeks, looking back at me for my approval.

Yes, I approved! She then whispered something I couldn't hear to Cindy. The pretty redhead shook her head 'no.' This response provoked a sturdy 'SLAP' right onto Cindy's rear end. She continued to shake her head 'no.' Melissa then turned to me and beckoned me with her finger to join the two of them.

By now, I was rock hard and eager to get involved.

"Go ahead Jeff." Melissa told me. "Go ahead and pull down my sister's panties."

Cindy lowered her head, refusing to acknowledge what was about to take place. I still was wondering about the secret message exchanged between the two of them but I was too excited about the upcoming reality of pulling Cindy's panties to worry about that. With trembling hands, I took the waistband of Melissa's sister's panties and slowly pulled them down exposing her glorious teen aged ass!

I was transfixed by the incredible sight I was presented with and I was hoping to have an opportunity to fuck Cindy's bare pussy even though my wife was watching. Melissa knew her sister and I had shared an "intimate experience" a while back but I was hoping she didn't know everything that transpired that unforgettable night.

"Take her panties all the way off." My wife directed me. I was quick to follow her instruction. I slowly slid her scandalously brief panties down and off leaving Cindy completely nude before me.

Right about then I was wondering what was next. Melissa had committed a major sin in our relationship and allowing me to look at her little sister's naked body, while a thrill to be sure, it wasn't enough to even the score.

Melissa pulled Cindy over onto her back and again whispered something to her sister to which Cindy shook her head 'no.' Melissa then took the initiative and pulled Cindy's legs open completely exposing her tender young pussy to my view. I think it was the presence of her older sister that was making Cindy reluctant to follow whatever it was that Melissa was asking of her. At least I hope that, in private, Cindy would be pleased to show me her pussy.

Melissa then removed her G string leaving both McGregor sisters naked. My wife didn't hesitate and she joined her sister on the sofa, climbing over her until both women were joined. Cindy continued to shake her head 'no' but Melissa was rubbing her sister all over and managed to slide her leg under Cindy's and soon they were joined at the vagina! Melissa began to sensuously rub her pussy against her sister's much less experienced sex and, although unwilling to begin with, the younger sibling began to respond. Melissa continued to rhythmically drive her pussy into Cindy's loins and then I saw the pretty redhead close her eyes as the pleasure began to build in her.

Cindy is by nature, a very sexual being and even though this was, in her mind, a perverse and unnatural coupling, the physical stimulation overpowered her instinctive modesty and she began to moan in spite of herself.

"Mmmm... No Melis!" She gasped, "No, please... not in front of Jeff!"

Her pitiful begging seemed to inspire her older sister and Melissa redoubled her efforts, rubbing her pussy more forcefully into young Cindy's helpless vagina.

Then... then Melissa looked to me and, with a little gesture with her head, she summoned me into this exciting encounter. I quickly dropped my shorts and briefs and my cock was ready for action.

Melissa moved off of her younger sibling and told me to "Go ahead! Kiss her pussy!"

I moved immediately into Cindy's widespread legs and, taking the desire swollen lips of her pussy in my fingers, I opened her teen aged cunt until all of her girlish charms were laid out before me! I wasted no time and slid my tongue all over Cindy's wet and ready pussy which brought a cry of joy from her lips. Over and over I lapped her excited young cunt and, with her eyes closed now, she spread her legs even further apart, encouraging me to spear my tongue deeper and deeper into her cum striving hole.

"She's ready Jeff." Melissa said quietly, "Go ahead and fuck her!"

Cindy was momentarily disappointed when she felt my tongue leaving her horny young cunt but she was eager to be fucked and reached for my cock as soon as I was in position to take her. She touched my cockhead to her vagina and begged: "Please Jeff! Please fuck me now!"

As excited as I was, I couldn't resist just a touch more salacious perversion.

"Melissa, go ahead and put my cock in your sister's pussy."

Not thrilled at the prospect but unable to refuse me, my wife took my cock in her fingers and then opened Cindy's pussy. With me looking on in excited anticipation, she gently touched my cock to her little sister's open pussy and then touched my ass cheeks spurring me to penetrate Cindy's waiting sex.

Cindy moaned when she felt my cock head beginning to slide into her desire swollen cunt. I gave her all of my cock shoving it in hard until my balls slapped her little asshole. Then the two of us went at it like there was no tomorrow. Slap Slap slap! the room was filled with the noise of two lovers just proving their love with intense physicality. I was gasping for breath as I rhythmically fucked Cindy's horny little pussy, her wonderful little tits jiggling all the while.

Melissa watched and then quietly moved to the sofa and climbed onto it until her pussy was just above her sister's head. Clearly, she didn't want me to forget about her even though I was enjoying her little sister's body. No, my wife, knowing what I like, reached down and opened her lips so that I could enjoy looking at her pussy while I was fucking her sister.

Somehow, I had both of the McGregor sisters at the same time. Of course I thought about pulling out of Cindy so I could fuck Melissa too but the reality of it was that Cindy's pussy was so exquisitely tight that she managed to coax the sperm from my balls before I had a chance to act on my thought. I could sense that Cindy was close to an orgasm herself and I redoubled my efforts, pounding her helpless little pussy while she moaned in pleasure.

Have you ever had a woman like that? A woman whose pussy was so salaciously tight that you were helpless to do anything but cum? That's what it was like that night with Cindy. Suddenly, I felt the seed rushing from my balls and I jerked my cock free of Cindy's pussy. Moving quickly, I intended to shoot my sperm onto Melissa's open pussy but I didn't make it. No, my seed spurted out onto Cindy's astonished face as she complained in frustration.

"Jeff, No!" She gasped. "Not on my..." but it was too late. Streams of hot sticky jism splashed lewdly all over her pretty young face, drizzling down onto her chin and then her breasts.

At first I thought maybe she was ticked off but then a sly smile came over her face. She eyed me intensely and then shook her head slowly from side to side.

"You... you're just so... so nasty Jeff!" She dryly commented as she began to wipe my copious emission from her cheeks.

Melissa gave me a knowing smile. We've been married long enough now to survive some rough patches. We locked eyes and we both knew our 'problem' was now over.

They say 'payback is a bitch' but, I don't know. That was pretty fun.