Catching My Sisters Ch. 07

Ali eventually rolls off of my arm, giving in to sleep. As wild as she is, great sex seems to take a lot out of her, or it relaxes her so much all she wants to do is close her eyes. A few minutes ago, Addie had excused herself to the bathroom, so I remained in bed, thinking about how to help Krystal. I know Ali and Addie have some sort of half-cocked plan in their heads right now, but what can I do? I already beat the shit out of him the night it happened, so that might not be the right move, as good as it might feel with my new reason for it. If she really had been coerced in some way, he needs to be dealt with so he doesn't do it again. And how many other girls has he done this to?

I think back about all the girls he claimed to have hooked up with and wonder if he'd done the same thing to them. If I remember correctly, some denied ever meeting up with him, having no memory of what happened, but also admitting that they'd gotten pretty drunk at a party. Has he been slipping things into girls' drinks for this long? Maybe that's somewhere I can start. Try talking to some of these girls he claimed to have hooked up with and get their story. Or maybe that's something Krystal can do. Perhaps I should reach out to her.

"Hey, stud," Addie says flirtatiously from the bathroom door, leaning against the doorway still completely nude, her incredible tits jutting out from her chest invitingly. "You should see how huge this tub is."

My investigation can totally wait, I think to myself and quickly scramble out of bed. Addie giggles and retreats playfully into the bathroom. I shut the door behind me so we don't wake Ali up.

"Finally, some alone time with my baby brother," Addie says, pulling me in for a deep kiss, molding our bodies together once again.

"Should I lock the door?" I ask, breaking our kiss.

Addie shakes her head. "No, it will break the one rule Ali and I have about wanting alone time with you," she says bringing up rules once again. "We have to say something to each other first, like on Saturday when she came to your room and I didn't even come see you until I heard her leaving your room."

"Oh," I say and kiss her again.

"This is totally impromptu, so if she happens to want to join us, she's automatically welcome to," Addie explains.

"Can I make requests like this?" I ask.

"Of course!" she answers with a sweet smile. "All three of us are equal in this relationship. No one has more power than the other."

"Good," I say and then I grab her ass and lift her up.

Her legs wrap around my waist and her pussy traps my cock between us, both of us still too sticky for an easy entry. However, I step into the nearly full tub and lower us down into the center where the water is deepest and we simply make out, our limbs wrapped around each other, our bodies connected as if we're one beast with two backs. We kiss deeply with no rush to do anything else just yet. Both of us hoping that Ali will stay asleep and let us finish together again. I want to fill my sister up again with so much cum. I love how it feels when I blast my loads inside of her and the connection it brings us.

"Let's turn the water off before we cause a flood," she giggles, breaking our kiss.

I reach behind her and turn the knob, shutting off the water and thrusting us into silence. All that can be heard now is the vent fan that turns on automatically with the light and our deep breathing as we continue to make out. The hot water loosens up the dried fluids from our bodies and washes our skin clean as we grind against each other. Then, as if reading my previous thoughts about being inside her again, Addie lifts herself up just enough for me to grab my cock and guide it back into her slick tunnel. She slowly settles back down onto my lap, keeping in that same embrace as we slowly make love. I gently thrust my hips forward into her as she grinds down onto me, her pussy muscles squeezing and massaging my throbbing cock.

Neither of us says a word, allowing our bodies to speak for themselves this time. Our heartbeats even seem to sync up as the warm water relaxes our bodies, despite the excitement of the sex we're now having. I begin to kiss down her neck and she gasps appreciatively as I suckle on her skin, right at the base where her shoulder and neck meet. I even trail licks and kisses along her collarbone, traveling across the top of her chest to the other side of her neck, working my way up to her cheek. I gently nibble on her ear and she sighs and giggles, especially when I flick the lobe with the tip of my tongue.

"I know you're not a virgin anymore," she says quietly, "but you learned so fast how to please a woman."

"I've had good teachers," I tell her and then plant my mouth on hers again and we let our tongues wrestle and dance slowly. Sliding together in each other's mouths, fully connected at both ends of our bodies.

"Porn doesn't count," she jokes with a cute giggle, breaking our kiss briefly.

"It gave me ideas," I admit and then kiss her again.

Reaching up from behind my back, she runs her fingers through my hair, lightly scratching my scalp while I run my hands up and down her back, massaging the muscles there and in her perfect ass. I spend extra time there, seeing as it's nearly the exact same size and shape as Ali's. My two favorite body parts of theirs seem to be the one identical thing they share as fraternal twins.

Her pussy continues to milk my cock with very minimal movement of her lower half as we remain in that same, locked position that neither of us wants to leave. This is the most connected I've felt to her since the first time I came in her Friday afternoon. As much as I enjoy the fun side she lets out, I prefer this side of Addie most. The loving, passionate side.

We continue like this for what seems hours, but is likely only minutes. Time escapes us as we make love to each other in that one position until she breaks our kiss and presses her forehead against mine as her orgasm begins to build. The evidence is clear in her face as she focuses her shockingly blue eyes onto my dark brown ones. Her breathing becomes labored and sweat beads up on her forehead, mixing with mine, whether from the heat of the tub that has fogged up the giant mirror over the sinks across from us, or from the hot, slow sex we've been having, I have no idea, but I'm ready for her orgasm to rake through her body as mine beings to follow after hers.

How are we so connected that our orgasms even communicate with each other, wanting to exist at the same time just like our hearts, minds and souls? She plants her mouth onto mine again as she rises and falls with small crashes on my cock. I help her by squeezing her ass while lifting and pulling her down onto my rod. Her arms wrap tightly around the back of my head as she probes my mouth with her tongue, trying to stifle her cries as our orgasms grow together. They build and build, never seeming to come to an end. I lose track of how long it lasts before they finally reach their end, but it's the longest build up to blowing my load that I've ever experienced. I feel like I can let it all loose at any moment, but all it does is build and build, both of us moaning, desperate for release, waiting for some unknown power to give us permission until, finally, I blast inside my sister again, painting her insides with hot, white, sticky cum while at the same time, I feel her pussy gush all over my rigid rod. She continues to bounce, coaxing more and more cum out of me until she finally slows down, breaking our kiss and staring me in the eye.

"Fuck, that was my biggest O yet," she whispers.

"Mine too," I tell her. "I kept waiting for it to happen, but it just kept building."

"Mine, too!" she says and then kisses me. "I love our connection," she says. "I love you."

"I love you, too, Addie," I say as we continue to kiss, my cock still twitching and releasing small spurts of cum inside of her.

"I can't believe how much you've cum inside me," she says with a grin from ear to ear.

"You don't think that there could ever be too much cum for your birth control pills to handle, do you?" I ask her curiously.

Addie giggles. "That's not how they work," she says. "It's not like it sterilizes your swimmers. It just makes it so an egg can't attach to my uterus and grow."

"Oh," I say, unsure of how I feel about that. I wonder if I've fertilized an egg that she'd just piss out one day.

"What's wrong?" she asks, running her fingers through my hair sweetly, so I tell her what I'd just thought. "Are you saying you'd rather me be pregnant?" she asks, and I can see that there's no judgment in her eyes, no matter how I answer.

"I don't know," I say. "I just... I don't know. I'm not, like, secretly religious or anything, but it just feels wrong that a life might start and it just get flushed away."

Addie stares at me, cocking her head to the side. "I can always stop taking them, or just have you not cum inside me anymore," she says. "If it makes you feel this way."

I shrug. "I don't know," I say. "You don't have to do anything like that, not yet anyway. Maybe I just need to figure out where my line of morality is."

"Fucking your sisters crosses a pretty big one," she giggles sweetly.

I grin at her. "Yeah, it does, but that's not hurting anyone," she says.

"Except every other girl at your school who wants you," she teases.

"Yeah, well, my relationship with Krystal did that plenty," I tell her and then my mind goes back to her again.

"That's the real issue in your mind," Addie says, but it's not an accusation so much as an observation. "We really need to solve this, don't we?" she asks.

I nod slowly. "Yeah, I think we do," I tell her. "I was thinking of trying to talk to some of the girls he'd bragged about hooking up with and seeing what they remember if anything."

"That might be difficult," she says. "A lot of them might be too scared, hurt, or ashamed to say anything."

"What if both Krystal and I talked to them? Or just Krystal?" I ask.

"I'd prefer if she did it herself," Addie says, a hint of jealousy in her voice this time. "But that might be hard for her to do alone."

"You know I don't have feelings for her," I tell Addie. "This has nothing to do with that."

Addie smiles. "You're a good guy who wants to do the right thing for a girl who was taken advantage of. And if I'm being completely honest, she is the only girl you dated that I didn't hate."

"Really?" I ask amused. "Why's that?"

"Because she was the only one who seemed to actually care about you and not just want to try and hook up with you," she says. "Yeah, I wanted to fuck you, but I've always just loved you because of who you are. It's always been about love for me first. The sex is just the most fun way to express it."

"It definitely is fun," I admit with a wide grin as well and then kiss her. "And I feel like we connect more and more every time I finish inside you. It's like-"

"Your cum is like glue sealing our souls together?" she finishes my thought.

I laugh. "That's exactly what I've thought!" I tell her.

Addie laughs with me. "I've thought the same thing," she says and then sighs to bring us back on topic.

My cock slips out of her, now completely softened after our incredible love-making.

"Aww," she says, making a cute pouty face.

I kiss her. "He'll be back in there soon enough," I assure her.

"Yeah, he will," she says. "Anyway, I guess what I was trying to get at with Krystal is, if you weren't going to be with me and Ali, I'd approve of her. She's sweet, she loved you, and she was willing to wait until you were both ready. Honestly, now that I say that, she's probably better than me and Ali because, we seduced you. You were still kind of vulnerable and heartbroken, though you didn't act like it, and we took advantage of that. I'm sorry, Andy," she apologizes.

"Don't apologize," I tell her. "I was mostly over her and you two pulled me to the end and have truly loved me my whole life. Even before we all, well, started fucking," I chuckle and she giggles as well, "you've always looked out for me. You didn't take advantage of me. Do you know how many girls from school, granted none nearly as hot as you and Ali, but still pretty fucking hot, tried to hook up with me and I turned them down? I couldn't resist you and Ali because, I think, deep down, I've always wanted you both."

"So, when you saw us together..."

"I would have jerked off so hard to you two if Mom hadn't called," I tell her.

"Right there in the doorway or in your room?" she asks playfully.

"Good question," I say. "I mean, I could have been a completely typical porn cliché and I do it there, thinking you wouldn't have seen me until I was caught, but I more than likely would have just gone to my room and locked the door."

"Good thing Mom called, then," she says.

"Good thing," I say and lean in to kiss her. "I love you, Addie. Nothing will change that."

"Good," she sighs and then turns around to lean against me in the tub.

I scoot us back and recline against the back of the tub, holding her in my arms, my flaccid cock nestled against her lower back. She rests her head on my shoulder and we breathe deeply, simply enjoying the closeness of being together in that spacious tub.

"There really is enough room for at least three of us," I marvel quietly.

"Yeah, we'll have to get Ali in here when she wakes up," Addie says.

"It's about time you remember I exist," Ali says suddenly appearing in the doorway, stark naked with her arms crossed in front of her. Her blonde hair is completely disheveled and her green eyes are glaring at us both.

I gape at her fearfully as if I'd done something wrong, but then I remembered that Addie purposely left the door unlocked so Ali could come in whenever she wants.

"Hey sis!" Addie says. "We left the door unlocked for you."

"I know," she grins and I let out a relieved sigh.

"Don't scare me like that, Ali!" I complain, shaking my head at her.

Ali giggles. "I'm sorry, baby bro," she teasingly patronizes me. "Did your crazy big sister scare you?"

"A little," I admit as she walks towards us, her beautiful tits jiggling enticingly.

"How was your nap?" Addie asks as Ali steps into the tub.

"After a dicking like that, it was hard NOT to sleep," she says. "I always get sleepy after getting good and fucked."

"Good to know," I say. "You know, in case you're ever having trouble sleeping, all I have to do is shove my dick into one of your holes."

Ali sighs at me. "You know me so well," she says sweetly sitting down in the warm water and stretching her legs out towards us. Addie gently gives her a foot rub while I continue to hold her close to my chest.

"Did you hear what we were talking about?" Addie asks her, changing the subject back to the plan to get a possible confession out of Kyle.

"About Krystal," Ali rolls her eyes.

"Ali didn't like her as much as I did," Addie informs me.

"Stuck up, goody-two-shoe, bitch," Ali lets her true feelings show.

"Whoa," I say. "Is that how you saw me, too?"

Ali stares back at me for a moment. "Of course not," she says. "You just had-"

"Morals and boundaries that our parents instilled in me?" I question her.

Her mouth drops open. "I guess they didn't really take with us, did they?" she asks Addie.

"Nope," she says, switching to Ali's other foot. "Especially you," she teases.

"Oh, just because I ASKED to be put on birth control when you promised Mom you didn't need it," Ali calls her out. "At least, not until Andy broke up with Krystal," she says her name as if it leaves a bad taste in her mouth again.

"Anyway," I interrupt their pending fight. "Krystal respected my morals and boundaries and even agreed with them. We were waiting until we were ready and I was considering after graduation to being that right time. We were done with high school, so if something happened to go wrong, at least we wouldn't be in school with a bunch of immature teenagers who would make fun of her for being pregnant," I say. "You know, worst case scenario."

The girls stare at each other guiltily, as if they'd stolen something from me that I hadn't given up freely to them both.

"Kyle tricked her or forced her into it somehow, and I just want to find out how and get him into trouble for it," I tell them. "I'm not trying to get back together with her at all. If we did, she'd find out about the three of us."

"You know," Ali says thoughtfully. "Even though I thought she was a stuck-up bitch," she continues, "she is pretty fucking hot."

"Oh Ali," Addie says shaking her head. "Always thinking with your pussy."

"More like my tongue," she winks at Addie, flicking her tongue at the air.

"Whore," Addie calls her out.

"Slut," Ali throws back at her.

"Girls," I say with a warning tone. "If you want this dick again, start being nicer to each other."

"Or you'll withhold dick from us?" Addie asks sadly from my arms, craning her neck to looking up at me.

"Yes, I will," I threaten.

"Ali, I'm sorry for calling you a whore," Addie quickly apologizes, taking me seriously.

"He wouldn't withhold his dick from us," Ali calls my bluff. "He's had too much fun with his sisters. He'd never be able to give it up."

"I don't know," I say. "Krystal had that look in her eye that made me think she'd get back together. And now that I've fucked my sisters, there's nothing to stop me from fucking her."

Ali's jaw drops this time. "You're such an asshole!" she insults me, knowing I'm fucking with them. "I kinda like it," she adds with a mischievous grin. "Maybe after we help her get Kyle into trouble, we can seduce her..." she says thoughtfully.

"Ali, knock it off, the three of us are enough," Addie says and then grins at me after seemingly considering the idea. "Actually, I kinda like her idea."

I roll my eyes at her. "You girls are insatiable," I sigh.

"Don't act like you don't like it," Ali calls me out.

"Oh, I love it," I fully admit.

"And so does someone else," Addie says shifting as my cock begins to harden quickly. "Ali, it's your turn. I'm going to make a phone call."

"Who are you going to call?" I ask curiously and a little concerned.

"Ghostbusters," Ali jokes quietly and I snort in laughter.

"Don't you worry about that," Addie says kissing me. "Have fun with Ali," she says before kissing Ali and exiting the tub, the water dripping off her picture-perfect ass.

Ali scoots all the way across the tub quickly to get in close with me, lifting her legs up over mine to wrap them around my waist. She takes hold of my cock, aims it for her pussy and we connect in the same position Addie and I had just fucked in. She's not wasting any time.

"I watched you two in the mirror," she admits quietly. "I want some sweet time again with you," she says.

"Anything you want, Ali," I say and then kiss her as we pull our bodies together like Addie and I had just a little bit ago.

In total Ali fashion, though, we start off sweet and loving, but her wild, horny side soon takes over and we decide to drain the tub, turn on the shower so I can take her in any position she asks for. First, she turns her back to me to take her from behind, but says to stay out of her ass because it's still sore. Then she sucks on my cock for a couple of minutes. Then, she has me sit on the edge of the tub with the water pouring down on us while she wraps her tits around my cock. But the final thing that puts us over the edge is when I lift her off her feet, slamming my cock into her pussy as I pin her against the wall, ramming her as hard as I can while she hangs onto my shoulders for dear life with her legs also wrapped firmly around my waist. She screams at the top of her lungs as I pound into her pussy, but all she does is beg for more, no matter how hard I fuck her.

"Fill me up again, Andy," she demands. "Cum so deep inside my pussy it can't drain out," she pleads.

I rail her pussy with my spear, fucking her as hard and rough as I can until I'm ready to explode inside of her.

"I'm gonna cum, Ali," I warn her a minute later.

"Good, fill me up," she begs. "Give me your cum, baby bro. Pound me hard. I want all of it. All of your seed," she begs and pleads until I can't hold back anymore and I burst inside of her, depositing as much baby batter into her womb as my balls can provide. "That's it, Andy," she continues as I continue to thrust into her even after my cock is spent, not wanting the sensation to stop, because then that means, I have to deal with all the thoughts going through my head. "That's it," she whispers this time, stroking my hair as I keep her pinned against the wall for a few more seconds, trying to hold back the noise. Why can't I get Krystal out of my head when I have these two, perfect, amazing girls who love me more than anyone?

My legs feel shaky, so I set her back down. Ali immediately kisses me deeply, sensing the mix of emotions swirling around in me. All of them centered in love, though. Love for my sisters, love of the new and beautiful relationship I have with them, love of the mind-blowing sex we have together. There's even some love for Krystal in there, too. I tell myself that it's just to seek out justice for her because she deserves it, but I'm not so sure anymore.

"What's troubling your mind, Andy?" Ali asks as she takes a wash rag and lathers it up with the hotel-provided body wash in the corner.

"Will it offend you if I say Krystal?" I ask her.

"Maybe just a little," she says but winks at me with a sweet smile. "You learned something horrible about what happened and that she never wanted to cheat on you," she reasons like Addie would.

I'm momentarily amazed at her sudden change in tone about Krystal. Maybe fucking her relaxes even her thoughts and opinions. I stare at her almost bewildered. Almost. I know she has a softer side, but for it to come out about Krystal is definitely a shock to my brain.

"Don't look at me like that," she rolls her eyes. "I'm not a heartless bitch. I like to get railed like a slut, but that's not all I'm capable of."

"I know that," I say. "I guess I'm just shocked that you'd have any sympathy for her at all after what happened."

"Well, did you have any before she talked to you today?" Ali asks.

"No," I say. "I guess not."

"Things change when you find out the truth," she says as she gently scrubs my chest, working her way down to my stomach. "God, I love your abs," she says flirtatiously. "I know in your mind right now you just want her to get the justice she deserves, and so do I."

"But?"

She grins without looking up at me. "But," she says. "I think deep down, you still love her, and she obviously still has some kind of feelings for you, or else she wouldn't have apologized."

I think about what she said and it makes sense to me, too. "I'm sorry for underestimating you, Ali," I tell her.

Ali shrugs. "I sucked at school," she says. "But I've always been able to understand people. Addie always helped me with school and I always helped her with the social stuff. It's why she and I make such a great couple."

"You two are amazing. You really are like two puzzle pieces that complete and complement each other," I tell her.

"And you have the glue," she says briefly gripping my sensitive cock with the wash rag, "that brings us all together."

I chuckle as I kiss her. "Were you serious about what you said about Krystal?" I ask her. "Do you really want to seduce her?"

Ali laughs. "I don't know," she says. "I say stupid things sometimes, but if Addie likes the idea, too, then who knows what could happen? Honestly, as long as the three of us are always together, that's what matters to me."

Ali turns me around and scrubs my back as I think about what she just said. I'm not sure where to take things now. Before my mind can wander to our threesome turning into a foursome (and a borderline harem), I keep my mind focused on just getting the truth out of Kyle for Krystal.

One thing at a time, Andy, I tell myself.

"I wasn't being facetious, though," Ali says. "Krystal is pretty hot."

I grin and shake my head at her. "Just as I'm trying to focus on just helping her by getting the truth out there, you have to throw something like that at me," I chuckle.

"I'm sorry, were you trying to stop thoughts of growing a harem?" she teases. "Fuck, that would be hot, wouldn't it?"

"Ali, my dick is actually kinda sore from the way we just fucked, can you stop trying to stir him up again?" I plead.

"Fuck no! If he rises, I'm giving him attention!" she replies and then squeezes one of my butt cheeks.

I spin around and pull her tight against my body again, my cock definitely rising to the occasion. I plant my mouth on hers and she reaches down to jerk me off. I pull back and shake my head as she's too rough with him with how sensitive he still feels.

She smiles at me knowingly. "I know what he needs," she says and then drops to her knees and takes me into her mouth instead, sucking me off until I give her a small deposit. I definitely haven't had enough recovery time, so there isn't much cum to give, but it's enough to satisfy him and my always-hungry sister.

"Thanks, sis," I say as she stands up again, swallowing the few small globs I'd fed her.

"Ahh," she sighs like she just took a refreshing drink. "So yummy," she winks at me.

"Give me that, you silly slut," I say, taking the rag from her so I can wash her body as thoroughly as she washed mine.

A few minutes later, we dry off and return to the bed where Addie is dressed in a sexy, floral sundress, hanging up with someone on my phone. Wait, my phone?

"Who did you call?" I ask her.

"Kyle," she says. "You still have his number in your phone."

I gawk at her. "What did he say? What did YOU say?" I ask completely floored.

"Well, he remembered who I am and I told him Ali and I were going to get him into the VIP section at the club tonight," she says.

"But we're not working," Ali says, looking at me like a small child about to lose her favorite toy.

"No, but I thought we'd go as customers instead," Addie says.

"I really don't want to go to the club," I tell her.

"You don't have to," Addie says. "In fact, I made two calls, and she should be here about..."

Three knocks sound at the door. Ali and I whip our heads around at each other. We're both completely naked still.

"Be right there!" Addie says. "Give us two minutes!"

"Addie, what the fuck is going on?" I demand.

"Just get dressed and let me do the talking," she says.

Ali sighs and does what Addie said. I find my clothes and pull them back on as quickly as I can and then hurry to the bathroom to quickly comb my hair so I can be presentable for whoever is at the door. I have a sinking feeling I know who it is, and I'm not sure what Addie is planning, but there's not much I can do about it now. Also, how the fuck long was this Senior Breakfast supposed to be?! If it's who I think it is, she was definitely still here at the hotel when Addie called her!

"I think you fucked some screws loose in our sister," Ali grumbles as she brushes out her blonde hair, looking frustrated that she doesn't have time to really do anything with it, so she pulls it into a tight, wet ponytail.

"I think you're right," I agree with her. "What the fuck is she planning?"

"I'm not sure, but I have a counter-proposal already. I don't want to go into work on my day off," she tells me.

"And I really don't want to go to that club again," I tell her. "It was fun for one night, but I only want you two," I tell her and then go to kiss her on the cheek, but she turns her head to give me a brief peck on the lips.

"And we won't make you," she smiles at me.

"Thanks, Ali," I say and pinch her butt under her thin, white sundress as I leave the bathroom, making her yelp and giggle.

When I return to the room, which Addie had quickly straightened up by putting their sexy lingerie away and half-ass making the bed, I find her and Krystal sitting on the small sofa to the left of the bed. I swallow down my mild shock as best as I can even though I'd had a feeling that's who Addie had invited up here.

"Hi Andy," she says sweetly, but also looking nervous.

"Hey, Krystal," I say and then grab a chair from the desk built into the wall, and drag over the one next to the door as well so the four of us can sit together and talk about whatever crazy idea is going through Addie's mind.

"Okay, Addie, what is-" Ali stops dead in her tracks, obviously more shocked than I'd been at the sight of Krystal. "Oh, hey Krystal," she says startled.

"Hi, Ali," she says as sweetly as she can. "Addie called me from your phone," she adds, looking at me. "You said you were meeting your sisters, I guess I didn't put it together that they were here when you left the breakfast."

"Yeah, that was the first part of the surprise," I tell her.

"From how, uh, humid it is in here and a familiar smell that usually comes from my brother's room," Krystal continues, "I think I might have an idea what the big surprise was."

I gawk at her completely speechless.

"Look, what you do in your family is your business," she raises her hands, but I can see a look in her eye that looks like a mixture of disappointment with a little bit of angry jealousy at the same time. "I guess this is who you meant when I noticed you'd met someone and said that they're pretty great. I didn't realize 'they're' was plural."

"Don't be upset with Andy," Addie speaks up. "It was all me and Ali," she says. "We seduced him."

"Together?" Krystal asks.

I look from Addie to Ali to gauge their responses. Addie nods confidently while Ali continues to stare in shock. I reach out to her and she takes my hand so I can guide her to the chair next to mine. I think both of us are starting to realize just what a mastermind our sister really is.

"Yeah," Addie continues to keep the conversation going. "Growing up, we both had big crushes on Andy, so when you two broke up, we kind of took advantage."

"This has been going on that long?" Krystal's eyes grow wide.

"NO!" Addie says quickly. "Just since Friday when he got home from school."

"Oh," Krystal says, her voice a little smaller now. "So, you really didn't just move on right away?" she asks me.

I shake my head. "No," I tell her. "We were together too long for me to do that."

"And it took the both of us, and him catching us... together... for it to even work," Addie takes over explaining.

"You set him up," she states.

"Yeah, kinda," Addie laughs nervously and a little ashamedly as well as her cheeks flush pink.

"Wow," Krystal says. "I don't know whether to be appalled or impressed."

"I'd totally get it if you were the former," Ali shocks me, not just by speaking up but by what she said as well. "This is obviously not a normal type of relationship."

"Relationship?" Krystal asks. "Like, you're planning on this being a permanent thing?"

That's when she eyes me still holding Ali's hand as we sit close together. Ali is hiding it well, but her hand is actually trembling, which surprises me until I realize, her wild side is strictly for sex and work (which once consisted of sex with her friends). But in a normal, real life situation, she's actually much more down-to-earth. But she was the one who suggested seducing Krystal, wasn't she? Had she been all talk earlier? Or did she really find my ex-girlfriend that attractive?

"It's definitely what we've talked about," Addie says, speaking up since Ali and I have suddenly gone quiet.

"Have you thought about what could happen if you end up pregnant? I mean, it's incest, it's illegal in California, isn't it?" she asks. "What about birth defects?"

"Well, the LGBTQA+ group keeps adding more and more to them," Addie says. "Maybe they'll add an I or F for incest or family," she giggles.

"Oh my god, Addie," Ali says embarrassed but all Addie does is continue to giggle.

"As far as the other thing," Addie says. "We'll deal with that if it happens."

"So, you said you had a plan to get, like, a confession out of Kyle?" Krystal smartly changes the subject back to why she's there to avoid any more awkward comments from Addie.

"Yes," Addie says firmly. "I invited him to the club tonight, or," she says, her eyes growing bright. "What if we get Cherry to help! She works a day shift at Disneyland some days and then works nights at the club!"

Ali's eyes grow wide as well. "That's actually really smart. She knows the secret passages around there that she can use to seduce the information out of him," she says, finally sounding like herself again. "Plus, she talks about how much of the security team lets her get away with shit because she'll hook up with them when she's feeling like it."

"Wow," Krystal says, still a mixture of emotions in her face. "I'm not sure how I feel about this."

"Didn't he basically rape you?" Addie asks. "Or were you lying to our brother earlier?"

"I didn't lie," she says, shrinking down fearfully. "I just... I don't know."

"Krystal," I say gently, stopping Addie from attacking her again, since I can see the anger and protectiveness growing in her eyes. "Kyle did something to you that made you unable to resist him. He did it to break us up because he was jealous. I was naïve and didn't take the comments he would make about you seriously. I took them as compliments that I was able to..." I hesitate as I look at each of my sisters, feeling guilty for what I'm about to say.

Ali squeezes my hand and nods at me to continue, assuring me that everything is fine. I squeeze her hand back appreciatively.

"I took his jealous comments as compliments for being able to get a beautiful girl like you to like me," I tell her.

Addie stares daggers at me, but I ignore her for now. This is about Krystal, not the three of us.

"I should have paid better attention to what he was saying," I say apologetically.

"You're a trusting guy," Ali says. "You always try to see the best in people. And that's something I love about you, Andy."

"And you always try to do the right thing," Addie adds, looking at me again, though this time, her eyes are softer and a little repentant. She even mouths the words, "I'm sorry," to me.

"So, what will your friend do?" Krystal asks, bringing us back on subject.

"Cherry has her ways," Addie says with a mischievous smile.

"Yes, she does," Ali says fondly with a reminiscent sigh.

Krystal's eyes are wide at Ali's comment.

"Oh, we're totally Bi," Addie says, patting her hand.

Krystal blushes as she subtly pulls her hand away. "I kind of assumed if you three were a thing," she says. "Which is definitely weird to me, but... who am I to judge, right?"

"Krystal," Ali says. "I have been so wrong about you."

All three of us stare at her in shock. My shock is a little more on the pleasant side, but Krystal looks curious and concerned about what Ali is about to say.

"I'm sorry I never took the time to actually get to know you," Ali continues. "I was jealous and just thought you were a stuck-up bitch and a prude because you wouldn't fuck our brother."

Krystal swallows hard, her cheeks flushing pink as she looks away awkwardly.

"I'm sorry for misjudging you," she says. "Andy actually set us, well me, straight by pointing out how you respected and agreed with his morals and standards and that's why he loved you so much. I really thought you were a bitch after what he told us he walked in on at Prom, but hearing the whole story," she breaks for a moment and Krystal looks at her again. "You didn't deserve that, and out of love for my brother, I really do want to help you."

A warm smile spreads across Krystal's face. "Thank you, Ali, that really means a lot coming from you," she says. "I never knew why you didn't seem to like me, but," she looks at me again, "I think I understand. Love can make us think and do crazy things sometimes."

"Like, come to a hotel room where your ex-boyfriend has been fucking his older sisters?" Addie asks.

"I didn't know that was what was going on in here until I got here," Krystal says in defense.

"But you stayed," Addie says, scooting closer to her.

"Addie," I say firmly and she whips her head around at me. I simply shake my head at her.

Addie sighs. "Fine," she grumbles and scootches away pouting with her arms folded in front of her.

"Hold on," Krystal says, smiling at Addie. "Were you trying to make a move?"

Addie's eyebrows rise as her smile spreads wider. I gawk at Krystal and she smirks and shrugs at me.

"Hold on," I say and both girls look at me, right before they move closer. "This... this isn't happening," I continue, standing up.

"Why not?" Addie asks. "You still love her, I know you do."

I glare at Addie. "That's for me to decide, not you," I tell her.

Ali grabs my hand to calm me down, but doesn't say anything.

"Do you?" Krystal asks me, looking up at me with hopeful eyes.

"Krystal, can we talk outside?" I ask her before we have a very private conversation in front of my sisters.

"I think that's a good idea," Ali encourages us. Somehow, Ali and Addie have switched personalities again. It's almost as if they're actually identical twins who happened to end up with different hair and eye color. Is that possible?

I squeeze Ali's hand and then move for the door, holding it open for Krystal. She follows me into the hallway and I wait for the door to close before I say anything to her. But before I can, she grabs me by the back of the head and pulls me in for a kiss. A kiss we haven't shared in weeks since before the Prom incident. After a few seconds, I realize I'm kissing her back and have to stop, because guilt is twisting up my gut. It feels like cheating on my sisters, which I also realize is a fucked-up statement on its own.

"Krystal, stop," I say, taking deep breaths. I'd actually really missed her kisses. She's an excellent kisser.

"Why? Isn't this why Addie called me up here? To seduce me into your little harem?" she calls me out, but I can't tell if she's doing it out of anger and jealousy or because she actually likes the idea.

"I didn't even know she was going to call you. I don't even know how she opened my phone," I tell her.

"Is your pin still 040707?" she asks.

I gawk at her. "Yeah," I say, realizing I hadn't changed it since we broke up.

"So, you're still using my birthday as your pin and she knows my birthday," Krystal says. "You may think you've moved on, but you haven't totally."

Is she right? Am I still somewhat hung up on her but have been distracting myself with school and now with fucking my sisters on the regular? I look into her soft, yet sparkling, brown eyes. She's too damn smart for me to argue with, too.

"Look," I say. "There may be some truth to that, but like you said earlier, we never pressured each other into sex because we were both waiting until we were ready, both of us."

"Well, you were apparently more ready than you thought since you let your sisters seduce you," she says.

I look around to make sure no one was around to hear that. I pray to God that no one in any other room is listening. I doubt He'd listen since I'm definitely committing a huge sin by fucking my sisters. So, if anything, He'll just let me get caught. Hell, it's what I'd do to someone.

"Have you seen them?" I ask her and she grins at me with a small giggle. "Not even the Pope in Rome could resist them together."

Krystal giggles more and it's like music to my ears. We used to laugh together all the time. Even though we'd never had sex, we had so much fun together, no matter what it was we were doing.

Fuck, I'm still in love with her, aren't I? I ask myself.

"Let's say that I still have feelings for you," I tell her and her eyes begin to sparkle more. "I love my sisters, too."

"I know that," she says.

"So, what is that supposed to look like?" I ask her.

"Well," she says and then stares at the door to room 304 as she considers her next words. "Most girls have a secret lesbian fantasy, right?"

I gawk at her again. I can't believe what I'm hearing.

"And I've always thought your sisters were hot," she says.

"Bullshit," I say. "You're just saying that."

Krystal laughs. "When have I ever lied to you?"

Never, I think to myself. The answer is definitely never, not once.

"I guess this would be the first one since you hid this from me for the past two years," I tell her.

Krystal's cheeks turn pink again. "Okay, but I'm telling you now," she says. "And I promise, it's the only thing I ever kept from you. How exactly do you tell your boyfriend that you have a secret crush on his super-hot, older sisters?"

Fuck! What is happening right now? What's the saying? You can't have your cake and eat it too? Well, this is pretty fucking close to that being a fucking lie!

"Maybe we should slow this down," I suggest. "I think they were planning to use their passes to join me at Disneyland tomorrow. So, what if we do this? What if the four of us spend the day together and see how things go? I don't want to rush straight into a fucking orgy and one of us freak out or get jealous or feel neglected somehow."

Krystal smiles at me and then reaches up and strokes my hair over my ear. "Okay, Andy," she says. "We'll do that. But, can I make one request first?"

"Anything," I tell her, taking both of her hands in mine.

"I want my first time to be with you," she says. "My first REAL time. One where I'm lucid and I know what's happening to me."

I suddenly feel eyes on me, so I look over my shoulder to see the door suddenly shut. They've definitely been listening in.

"I saw the door open when we got a little quieter," Krystal tells me.

"We have to discuss this with my sisters," I tell her. "Are you okay with the fact that it won't be my first time?"

Krystal sighs. "It's a little disappointing, but-"

"We're family! It doesn't count!" Addie shouts through the door.

"Dammit, Addie, get away from the door," Ali says and I hear Addie giggle as she gets pulled away.

I look down at Krystal again.

"You know what? I'll go with Addie's logic," Krystal says and then she kisses me again before placing her hands on my chest and looking into my eyes. "I'm really sorry for what happened at Prom. I just hope I can make up for it."

"You have nothing to make up for," I tell her. "We're going to get the truth out of him one way or another, and he'll pay for what he did."

"He definitely paid for it a little that night," she says out of the corner of her mouth. "Honestly, I thought it was the sexiest thing you'd ever done when you beat him up like that. I just didn't expect you to ditch me the rest of the night, though I get why."

"I'm sorry," I tell her. "I should have at least taken you home."

"I had a ride," she says. "You needed out of there, and your sisters came to your rescue."

I nod in agreement. They really have, in more ways than one.

"Tell your sisters that they can do whatever they think will work to get the truth out of Kyle, and I like your idea of spending a day together," she says. "I think I'd like to get to know them a little more, too."

"Okay," I tell her and then lean down to kiss her goodbye.

"See you in the morning," she says. "Have fun tonight," she smirks at me.

I watch her leave, completely blown away by the turn of events. How in the fuck did things end up this way? Are we back together now? Does she really want to be a part of what I've got with Ali and Addie? And what the fuck is going through Addie's head? What the hell happened to her?

I turn and walk back into the room, since one of them had propped it open with the brass piece that keeps the door from opening more than a crack.

"So, we're going to hang out at Disneyland all day tomorrow?" Ali asks, keeping Addie quiet by sitting on her face while still wearing her white sundress.

I chuckle. "That's one way to shut her up," I say.

Both girls giggle which elicits a moan from Ali as Addie's giggle sends vibrations into her pussy.

"Anyway," I say and put the "Do Not Disturb" sign on the outside handle. "You heard everything," I continue, pulling off my shirt and dropping my shorts.

Addie's lower half is right at the edge of the foot of the bed, so I slide her sundress up, spread her legs and lube up my cock with her juices already seeping from her pussy.

"And she really wants to get to know us better and see if we can work as a foursome?" Ali asks, shocking me because she's the last one I would have thought would go for this, despite her comment on how hot Krystal is.

"She sounded like it," I say as I casually enter Addie's slick pussy. "She just has one request, though."

"Oh, fuck, Addie, right there," Ali moans. "What's that?" she asks me.

"She wants her first time to be with just me," I say as I slowly bottom out inside of Addie and I hear her groan into Ali's pussy.

Ali breathes deep as Addie eats her out, enjoying our sister's tongue lapping at her cunt.

"That's fair," Addie says pulling her mouth away from Ali's pussy to speak and then places it right back inside again.

"Oh, shit!" Ali says. "Can we finish this after we cum?" she requests and then lets out a small, high-pitched scream.

I reach out to her and she leans forward as I meet her halfway, creating a fuck triangle with both girls, and I kiss her deeply before lowering her down to lick Addie's clit while I fuck her pussy.

"FUCK!" Addie screams.

I pull my dick out of Addie's pussy a minute later and Ali takes it into her mouth, humming appreciatively as she sucks Addie's juices off of me. Then I return to Addie's fuck hole and resume thrusting into her. In a few minutes time, I blast inside of Addie, then Ali feeds off of the cum, which then brings both girls to a screaming orgasm together in a beautiful 69, with their thin sundresses still on their bodies.