Wife Plays Guessing Game

My wife Marie and I took a vacation at Hilton Head for a much-needed getaway. We had been here several days but tonight was different. We had been drinking at the outdoor bar for several hours. There was a band playing music and people were dancing, including us. My wife was wearing white jean shorts with an "off the shoulders" blouse, without a bra. Her nipples poked through her blouse slightly which had me so excited. She was also wearing her anklet like she always does when we go on vacation. Although she has never had sex with another guy besides me, she knows how much it turns me on for her to wear an anklet, as if she is a Hotwife. We were both having a great time and feeling a light buzz. I saw a group of guys walk in; there were 8 to be exact. I'm guessing their ages were in their mid to late 20's. With the help of alcohol my wife didn't hesitate to start talking to them. They bought us a round of drinks and asked us to join them.

One of the guys named Bill grabbed my wife's hand and said, "Can I get you to dance with me?"

My wife looked at me smiling and said, "Do you mind?"

Of course, my wife knew I wouldn't mind, in fact I've been fantasizing about her having sex with other guys for years and she's well aware. I smile back and said, "Of course Babe, enjoy yourself!"

Bill said, "Don't worry, I'll take good care of her" and then gave me a wink.

It was as if he already knew I wanted this to happen. I watched as she started dancing with Bill. I felt a little bit of jealousy, but yet I was turned on at the same time. It was a weird mixture of feelings as I watched my wife enjoying herself. She would glance my way every so often to see if I was watching and when she did, I always made sure I was smiling at her. She must have taken my smiles as a sign because it was then she started getting more adventurous with Bill. I watched as she turned away from him and rubbed her ass in his crotch. The next thing I watched was him grabbing her by her hips as if he was fucking her from behind. I couldn't help but get a hard-on as I watched him touching her. Then she turned to him and he pulled her in close and wrapped his arms around her, resting his hands on her butt. She looked my way for approval and I again smiled at her. I saw her lean into him and whisper something in his ear, he smiled. Seconds later the two of them were kissing. Their lips were locked as if they were lovers. Bill reached to the front of her and grabbed one of her tits. Meanwhile Marie grabbed his butt and pulled him in tighter. They continue to kiss and his hand had pulled down her shirt until he had her bare breast in his hand. My cock was about to explode watching her.

One of Bill's buddies came up to me and said, "Damn, are you OK with Bill kissing and touching your wife, because if you are, I want to be next?"

I wasn't sure if I was ready to admit my fantasy to this stranger but I felt we already crossed the line so I replied, "Yes, it's fine, I'm actually enjoying watching her with him. This has actually been my fantasy for a really long time!"

He said, "Then please tell her I'd like the next dance."

Finally, the kiss ended and Marie walked straight to me. My cock was sticking straight up not being able to hide the fact I had a hard-on from watching her. She didn't say a word, just leaned in and kissed me. As she did, she grabbed my cock and squeezed it, feeling my stiffness.

"From the looks of your cock it appears you enjoyed watching Bill kiss me and play with my tits," Marie said as she smiled at me.

I couldn't hide the fact I had a hard-on and said, "Part of me was jealous but yet you looked so sexy, my cock got so hard when I saw him grab your bare tit."

"Are you OK if I dance with another guy?" she asked while smiling mischievously.

I knew I was going to see more kissing and touching and said, "One of the other guys already asked if he could be next. I'll sit here and watch!"

She leaned in for another kiss and said, "I'll put on a good show for you!"

She went on to dance with 4 different guys while I watched. Each of them took advantage knowing they could kiss her and touch her. At one point one of the guys had her blouse pulled down below both her tits, leaving them exposed to the crowd. She just looked at me with a mischievous grin on her face.

She came back for her drink and said, "Would you be OK if we invited these guys back to our room for drinks?"

My heart stopped beating because I knew what was about to happen. This is what I've been asking for. Nervously I smiled and said, "Are you wanting to fuck these guys?"

She bit her lip and said, "I'm not sure but I'm so horny I'm considering it."

I said, "OK, let's invite them for drinks and we'll see what happens."

Once inside our room the conversation immediately turned sexual, mostly directed at my wife for her to answer. They were asking questions about condoms, sex toys, oral sex, anal sex until one of them asked about size of guys cocks and if size mattered? She told them my cock is the only cock she has ever had sex with. Another guy asked if she has ever touched another cock or gave anyone else a blow job besides me.

Marie responded saying, "I have only touched one other guy's cock before I met my husband."

The guys couldn't believe it, one of them said, "A woman as sexy as you, you could have sex with any guy you want, besides your husband has given you permission, so why not have sex with other guys?"

It was at that moment a light bulb went off in my head, until now I had just been listening.

I spoke up, "Guys do you think if my wife was blindfolded and she had the opportunity to touch and rub all of our cock's that she would know which one is mine?"

Several of them said, "No way she would know, there's not that much difference in dicks."

My wife chimed in, "That would be easy, 20 years of the same penis I can guarantee I'll know which one is my husband's."

I said, "Alright here's the deal, we will blindfold you and 1 by 1 we will walk up to you and you will get 30 seconds to touch, feel and rub each of our cocks and balls. After you have done this with all 5 of us you will then guess which one is mine."

She said, "This will be easy. So, what do I get if I'm right?"

I said, "Since you're so confident you'll guess my cock, whoever you guess gets to undress you and have sex with you while you're still wearing the blindfold. It shouldn't be a big deal since it will be easy to guess me, right?"

She looked at me and smiled and said, "Let's get started, this will be easy."

I went to my luggage and grabbed a tie to blindfold her with. As I was tying it, I whispered, "I Love You no matter what happens tonight."

Once blindfolded I told the guys to get out their cocks and get ready. Then I told my wife, "It would be really nice to give the guys something to look at and maybe even touch while were doing this. Let's take off your shirt for this challenge."

I grabbed her blouse and started sliding it down her body and she even helped slide it off until her bare tits were exposed. I threw the blouse to the side leaving her wearing her white shorts and nothing else.

I said, "OK, guy #1 you're up."

He walked up to her and grabbed her hands and moved them to his cock. His cock was similar to mine I thought. This might be tougher than she realizes. She grabbed it and rub her hand up and down the shaft. Her other hand grabbed his balls and rubbed them. She rubbed over his cock head as if she was really studying his cock trying to guess if it was mine. I was looking at the timer and 15 seconds had passed. Then all of a sudden, she leans forward and takes his cock in her mouth. I was shocked, surprised, had a slight bit of jealousy but yet my cock was about to explode watching my wife suck off another guy. For the next 15 seconds she sucked his cock while grasping his shaft and rubbing his balls. I hated it but the timer went off, she kept going for a few more seconds until finally pulling her lips off his cock.

She spoke saying, "I think I'm going to like this game, where is guy #2?"

I tapped one of the other guys and he walked forward and offered his cock to her. This time it only took a few seconds before her lips were wrapped around his cock. She was really into a full blow job mode as she sucked and rubbed. I was almost wondering if any of them would shoot their load in her mouth. The timer buzzed again and another guy stepped forward. She repeated the same process not even waiting to start sucking him. She was in full blow job mode as if it were her goal to suck a guy off. This guy was moaning and she was sucking hard and fast. I could tell he was close to cumming. The timer went off and she kept sucking and then it happened, he started shooting his load down my wife's throat. She swallowed as much as she could, although some of his cum was dribbling down her chin. Once the two of them calmed down she pulled her lips off his cock.

She licked her lips and said, "Hey Honey, do you want to kiss me and taste the cum on my lips?"

I stepped forward and leaned in for a kiss. As we kissed, I licked his cum off of her cheek and I could fully taste his cum in her mouth. I pulled back from her.

She said, "So, did you like tasting another guy's cum on my lips?"

"Yes, I did Babe, are you ready for your next cock?" I replied.

Guy #4 stepped forward and he was getting the same treatment. Right at the 30 second mark he started to orgasm and shoot his cum in her mouth too. This time she pulled off too soon and he shot his last bit of cum all over her face and even some on her tits.

She asked, "Babe, would you please lick this cum off of me?"

I stepped forward and licked his cum off her breast first and then licked his cum off of her face. I leaned in again for another wet kiss. Her lips were salty from his cum. It was my turn, I was wondering if I would be able to hold out? As he stepped away, I took my place. My wife had sucked my cock 1000's of times, only difference this time was the fact she just had 4 other cocks in her mouth and just swallowed 2 loads of cum. I held out past the timer; she kept sucking as if it were a challenge to get me to cum. Slowly she pulled her lips off my cock.

I stepped back with the other guys and said, "Time to guess which one you think was my cock and remember which ever one you guess gets to fuck you."

She hesitated and smiled and finally said, "Can I have a 2nd taste of Cock #2 and Cock #5?"

I said, "Sure that sounds fair."

I motioned to the other guy and we both stood in front of her, I grabbed her hand and guided it to my cock and he did the same. She grabbed my cock and held it while she pulled his cock into her mouth. I noticed his cock was slightly thicker and slightly longer than mine. Her lips so good wrapped around his cock. She slowly pulled her lips off of him and moved to my cock and took me in her mouth. She gave me the same treatment as she stroked him. I still watched her stroking him as her hand looked so tiny wrapped around his cock.

"I'm pretty sure I know which cock is my husband but maybe I should pick a different one, that way I get to fuck one of you," Marie said while smiling. After a slight pause she says, "I'm going to have to pick Cock #5, I'm sure that is my husband's cock."

I stayed back and said, "Cock #5, looks like you get to fuck my wife." I was hoping to trick her, I wasn't sure if she realized it or not.

I moved back over to her, grabbed her hands and stood her up. I then grabbed her shorts and pulled them down her legs. Next, I grabbed her thong and pulled them down as well. I had my wife naked as the other 4 guys watched us. This was exciting in itself. I moved her to the bed and laid her down. Moments later I climbed on top of her and didn't waste no time sliding my cock insider her. I started fucking her hard and fast and luckily, she started having an orgasm right away. It was a good thing because I started to cum also. After our massive orgasms subsided, I grabbed her blindfold and slipped it over her head.

Marie smiled at me and said, "It was easy to guess which one was you, the hard part was deciding if I was going to let you fuck me or let one of the other guys."

I smiled at her and said, "There are still 2 guys that have not went off yet, why don't you let them fuck you?"

She smiled again and said, "Thank you."

I pulled out of my wife and told the other guys they could take turns and have sex with her. The first guy wasted no time and was naked in seconds and crawling on top of my wife. It was a surreal moment as I watched another guy slide his cock in my wife. The two of them fucked until they both had an orgasm and he started filling her pussy with his cum. The next guy jumped in and took his place burying his cock in her pussy. By now the other 2 guys were naked and their dicks were hard again, as was mine. The next couple hours were a blur. Each of the guys took several turns with my wife.

At times she would have 1 guy fucking her while she was sucking another guy off or just be holding another guy's cock while a guy was fucking her. She tried a variety of positions as well; from being on the bottom, to being on the top, to doggie style, to reverse cowgirl and a few others. She acted as if she couldn't get enough cock, as soon as one would pull out of her, she would ask who's next. During this I mostly just watched. I took lots of pictures and even some videos. Every so often I would go up to her and give her a kiss on the lips telling her how beautiful she is. After about 2 hours it seemed as if everyone had worn themselves out. My wife laid on the bed and had a look of complete satisfaction and seemed more relaxed than ever. The guys had agreed it was time to go and started dressing. I was still naked as was my wife. As they were about ready to leave, my wife still naked, gets up off the bed and gives each one a hug and kiss thanking them for the wonderful night. As they leave, she stands naked in the open doorway and watches as they walk away.

After shutting the door, she walks up to me and says, "Now I want my favorite cock inside me."

We slowly started fucking and she was telling me how each of the guys felt different and what positions she liked best and also which guy she liked best. We both had 1 more orgasm before passing out from such and awesome night. My wife slept till almost noon the next day, the sex must of wore her out. She was so beautiful lying there. All I could think about was how beautiful it was to watch her being pleasured over and over by those guys. I was also wondering what we were going to do the next 2 nights of our vacation?