Theo and Bishop Ch. 02

Xeni couldn't stop reeling while they walked home from the bar. This evening had turned out very very differently than she had expected. She had started the evening pissed at seeing a picture on Instagram of her two former friend's-with-benefits/exes Theo and Bishop looking like hot besties when she hadn't know they even knew each other. Then while distracting herself at a nearby dive bar, both of them showed up and mentioned that they were dating each other.

Now the three of them were walking to her place to... maybe hook up? She wasn't sure. Her mind was confused, and a little overwhelmed. But her pussy was thrilled and starting to make a mess of her underwear. What had she gotten herself into?

Bishop chattered on about some gossip from their mutual friend Lauren while keeping one hand on Xeni's hip. He was a gorgeous, lithe, blond man with a runner's build and a trickster god personality. It felt like he was constantly in motion, and right now he seemed unable to let her out of physical contact. Her other ex, Theo was a calm, bearded, bear of a man and he was holding her hand, carefully stroking the back of her palm with his thumb. He was built like a tree, looked like a lumberjack and had a carefully manicured beard.

When they got to her apartment, Xeni pulled out her keys and Bishop took that opportunity to press up himself up behind her and kiss along the nape of her neck, his hand stroking along her stomach. Noise came out of her throat as she twisted the key and they fell into her living room. Bishop continued his ministrations, walking her in with his hips pressed to the seam of her ass as he nipped and kissed along her shoulder and palmed her breasts.

Theo took care of the door, and Xeni looked back at him. His face was tender and longing. He moved towards her in slow motion and leaned down to cup her jaw and press his lips to hers, his beard tickling her chin. She loved feeling the sense of peace with him.

"I missed you Xeni," he said. Her arms looped around his neck as they fell together. His lips sucked on hers, she felt like she was coming home.

She pulled back. "I want you both. Is that ok?"

She could feel Bishop silent laugher as he looped an arm around her waist. "Yes pretty Xeni, I believe that is the point. We both want you."

She looked up at Theo, feeling his trustworthy stare. "Yes" He said simply.

Bishop took full advantage then, kissing her mouth. He was fire, while Theo was earth. She felt like water between them, flowing, moving, building up steam. She hooked her leg against Bishop's hip and he growled into her mouth. Theo's hand was on her back and he kissed her neck, holding her steady.

Then, Theo pulled Bishop's face to him by the back of his neck and kissed him. It was the opposite of delicate. He was fierce, almost harsh. She could feel Bishop's body responding to the kiss like a flower towards the sun

Holy hell. This was... new. And really fucking hot.

She had seen two men kiss before, but she certainly hadn't seen these two kissing each other. She also hadn't seen this side of Theo before. He had always had a quiet confidence, but now she could clearly tell he was the top in their relationship. He pulled Bishop to him and took what he wanted.

Watching as Theo's size dwarfed Bishop's body -- all lines and angles. Theo was presence and solidity. She could feel how much they already knew each other's bodies by the way they touched.

"Jesus. Watching you two is a huge fucking turn on." Xeni said.

"I want to show you all of the things. But right now, I want you naked." Bishop kissed her and tugged her shirt over her head. Theo's hands ran along her back and shoulders, then down to her bra strap, pulling them down, un hooking the back. Bishop made short work of her jeans.

They quickly and effectively made her very naked while they were both very clothed. She started to feel overwhelmed. Bishop tugged a nipple between his lips, the sensation zinging right to her clit and making her moan. Theo's hands wandered along her back and ass and towards the split of her legs. She shivered.

"I want... I want..." She felt submerged into their scent, their touch. She couldn't believe they were both here, it was too good. She couldn't stop the heady feeling of having both of their bodies so close, it was like being in a glass case with all her favorite scents and she wanted to just breathe it all in. At the same time, it threatened to overwhelm her.

Theo seemed to understand, pausing and pulling her against his chest. "How about we go into your bedroom?" he said, running his hand along her. Stroking and calming her.

"I want you two to strip too," she said once they made it to her bedroom. She winced that the bed wasn't made and her clothes were on the floor. But neither of them seemed to notice. She yanked off the sheets and sat up by the headboard as they obeyed.

She admired Theo's toned runner's body as he pulled down his pants and the hair on Bishop's broad chest as he took off his shirt. Then she noticed them looking at each other, Theo hungrily eyeing Bishop's cock and reaching over to give his cock a few gentle, grasping pulls. Bishop preened and kissed him, panting slightly and touching Theo's back and ass. He was such a flirt. Theo's cock was stout and straight, Bishop's was long, skinny and curved. Xeni couldn't help but touch herself while watching Theo twine his hands in Bishop's disheveled hair.

Bishop looked over to see Xeni lying back on the pillows with fingers playing with her pussy lips and protested, "Hey, that's my job." Leaving Theo, he crawled across the bed towards her, all predator and pushed her thighs apart, pressing his mouth to her cunt.

She heard him groan while tonguing her pussy lips open. Xeni pressed her hips towards his mouth, arching and keening as Bishop began to slowly pleasure her pussy. He seemed to not care that she hadn't shaved, after all she hadn't known any of this would happen, how could she be expected to prepare?

She felt Theo move beside her on the bed and they kissed without hurrying, his body moving to hold her. He seemed content to let her be pleasured, sucking on the moans coming from her mouth as Bishop began rhythmically flicking her clit in exactly in that way that drove her insane.

Fucking hell. How had he remembered? This man knew the straight line to her pleasure, the rhythm of his tongue, the way to slip one finger in her cunt just to push her over the edge. Her head flung backwards as Theo kissed down her neck and held her, cupping her breasts, urging her pleasure on. She came more quickly than had remembered, clenching hard and seeing stars.

As she came down from her high, Bishop grinned up at her, pulling himself up to her, kissing her with a face full of her own juices and then leaning over to kiss Theo too - who licked at his lips.

"She tastes fucking delicious."

Theo's hard cock was in his hand and his eyes were bright and wanting. Bishop bowed to kiss his sturdy prick. Xeni leaned over to do the same, inhaling as she kissed and licked his cock. Fuck, these men smelled like sex and pleasure. She thought about lilacs.

Xeni had seen two people sharing a cock before in porn and if she were honest with herself, the act had seemed -- not terribly exciting. But this time, inhaling Theo's singular musk and kissing along the smooth flesh of his cock while her other lover did the same? It was magical. She could feel the sensual pleasure of having them both. Besides, she didn't have to wonder if Theo liked seeing a man and a woman licking up and down his shaft -- his face said everything.

Bishop begain fluttering his lips around the top of Theo's cock, using the flat of his tongue to stroke the head while looking up at Theo with a sly look. He kept it up for a while, and Xeni sat back admiring the tableau. She could see Bishop's hard cock weeping along Theo's muscular thigh and she reached for him smearing the pre cum around, rewarded with a moan from Bishop while his lips still teased the head of Theo's cock.

Theo had had enough and slid his fingers into Bishop's hair, pulling his tousled blonde head down on his cock. Theo looked at her. "He likes to think he can tease me." he said "But he really wants to be a good cocksucker and take it down his throat." Bishop moaned at Theo's narration and Xeni leaned over to kiss him, marveling at this side of him.

Theo had always had such steady, calm way of making love to Xeni. He treated her like she was precious, valuable -- maybe not like fine china, but he was considerate and thoughtful about her needs. He always gave her time to accommodate his girth or slowly worked her clit until she was begging for more. He was never pushy with her. But with Bishop, Theo was different. He was demanding, clear about his desires and just put Bishop where he wanted him to be.

If she had thought about it, she might have assumed that Bishop would take the lead between the three of them, with his brashness and seeming endless ability to know what he wanted. But the truth was that Theo's steadiness had a gravity that pulled Bishop in and calmed him down. Theo was the natural top because he let Bishop be his unfiltered self.

Xeni pressed herself against Theo and his fingers found their way between her thighs. He teased her pussy open, slowly circling her cunt lips and arching into his hand. She was turned on again. They heard Bishop's slurping mouth as Theo guided his head.

"I want... Can I..." Xeni couldn't get the words out, but Theo understood. He pulled Bishop's off of his cock by pulling on his hair. "Suit me up and put me inside her" he said as he tugged Xeni across his lap to straddle him.

It was a revelation to see him telling Bishop what to do. She hadn't ever remembered Theo being so bossy before. He had always been so gentle with her.

Bishop seemed to light up with Theo's command and he rustled around in the bed stand to get a condom. Then he tugged on Theo's cock to put him at the right angle and teased Xeni's slit with the head, licking her briefly. When they lined up, Xeni pushed slowly inside. He was thick. They both groaned together.

"Oh my God it's so good." Xeni moaned as she took the tip of him into her.

Theo's eyes were dark and adoring. She leaned back - it was a lot to lower herself onto his girth but Theo stayed still and let her move. Bishop slipped his head along the seam of them and his eager tongue lightly flicked at her clit.

"You're so wet Xeni" Bishop said and she felt herself splitting as she bottomed out. The angle of Bishop's head was hard to maintain, but it was hot to have had his tongue in between them.

She ground against Theo slowly, pulsing her hips slowly up and down and riding him. Bishop moved to kneel behind her, pressing himself against the back of her body as she fucked.

"You two are gorgeous." Bishop said as he cupped her breasts and pulled at her nipples. She made to reach for her clit and Bishop batted her hand to the side as he licked his fingers and put them gently down towards her slick nub, finding a light rhythm that matched the way her hips were fucking.

"I bet she feels good." Bishop said to Theo. He grunted from below her and said "She feels like fucking heaven."

Then to Xeni he said "Ride me sweetheart"

She did and her crescendo began to climb with the consistency of Bishop's long fingers and the solidity of his monster cock. Bishop kept his fingers doing exactly the same thing. She came again, bucking and writhing between them, gasping her pleasure. Theo grunted his cock up into her, hitting the right spot again and again while Bishop gripped her breast and pulsed his fingers against her slick button.

With a cry, she said "too much" as she came down from her orgasm, batting Bishop's hand away and slumping over Theo who kissed her tenderly. Pulling her into the crook of his shoulder while keeping his cock was still hard inside her. He cuddled her. He was in no hurry.

Bishop, fired up from the orgasm they had just given to Xeni slid along beside them both so that his cock was bobbing against Theo's hand.

Theo smirked over at him while cradling Xeni in his arm and kissing her again. "Little brat" he said fondly to Bishop "Such a hard cock that constantly needs attention."

Bishop moaned shamelessly, his energy like a restless tide pressing himself into Theo's side. Xeni turned her head as Theo put his palm up wordlessly. Bishop spit into his palm and Theo began to slowly jerk Bishop's cock, focusing on the mushroom head of his prick. Bishop groaned while his hips moved lewdly.

"Our Bishop here likes hand jobs. He particularly likes being teased during one."

Xeni propped herself up to watch this development.

"Oh my, so that's your dynamic? You tease him?"

"I do. And he loves it." Bishop was panting now as Theo took his time gripping his cock and pumping it up and down in an irregular rhythm. Stopping and starting at his leisure. Xeni carefully pulled herself off of Theo's cock and settled herself on his other side with Theo's other hand wrapped around her waist.

"Sometimes I tell him he has to be still for me to jerk him off. But right now he's so lit up by being with you that I don't think that's possible. He's a slutty force of nature, our Bishop. Always instigating, always wanting to fuck. No patience for this one."

Bishop knelt beside them with his knees spread wide and Theo toyed with him. Every time he tried to push his hips against Theo's hand, Theo stopped touching him.

Xeni was amazed at seeing Bishop so undone. He was whimpering now, mumbling and gasping. Trying to move his hips so that Theo would do more. Xeni almost wanted to hear him beg. She was pretty sure he was almost there.

"Look at him, he's so turned on I can't keep him still. Such a gorgeous slut." Theo turned back to Xeni. "How are you doing darling? I know he wants to fuck you - would you like that or would you like me to fuck him first? He needs a serious rutting, but your needs are important too."

Xeni was turned on, intrigued and also she had just cum twice and was still feeling overwhelmed. She tried to articulate this. "I want to fuck him, but also, I want - I want to see you two together."

Theo smiled. "You got it darling. Let me open him up and give him a ride to get some of this energy out. His slutty cock will happily fuck you whenever you're ready." To Bishop he said "Kiss her and I'll get the lube."

Xeni moved to the middle of the bed and Bishop straddled her, worshiping her with kisses, while keeping his ass up and available for Theo. Xeni lost herself as Bishop suckled her nipples, biting and nipping at her. She heard the lube cap open and felt Bishop moan as Theo began working his fingers into his ass.

"Such a good boy, your little boy pussy is already so excited and open for me isn't it?" Theo said. Bishop moaned into Xeni's left nipple while arching back.

"Fuck yourself back on my fingers. We need to make sure you're opened up enough for my cock."

Xeni could feel Bishop pushing back into his fingers and felt a sharp tug of arousal. She looked over Bishop's shoulder to meet Theo's black eyes and reached down to Bishop's cock. He was so, so hard. She kissed him and ran her fingers through his messy hair.

She felt when Theo entered Bishop. H moaned, kissed her and jolted. Theo stayed still, crooning and telling Bishop how hot it looked to be inside of him, how he loved the feeling of his fat cock opening up his ass.

Xeni kissed and pressed against Bishop's lithe, vibrating body. He was sweating from accommodating Theo's large member and Xeni played with his body, reaching down to grasp his cock. He began to fuck her grip slowly, pressing back into Theo's cock. Theo pressed in a bit more and Bishop gasped and moaned.

Xeni saw Theo's concentration, he wanted to fuck, but was holding himself back so that Theo could take him. Fuck this was hot.

It felt like a slow unfolding, but the rhythm between them began to shift from achingly slow into actual fucking. Theo was now pushing his cock in, pulling out slowly and pushing back in again. He stopped to add a bit more lube and pretty soon Bishop was moaning and moving his hips. Pressing himself back and looking so deliciously disheveled.

At some point, Theo just started to fuck. He grabbed Bishop's hips, and panted: "That ok Bish?"

"Yes..." Bishop moaned. "Oh Fuck yes, fuck me."

The whole thing made Xeni so fucking hot. She had never seen either of them like this - Bishop receiving and accepting cock. Theo taking the lead and pinning him down. There was something about their desire together, so masculine, so fucking primal. She loved the animal way they were with each other. She was still under the two of them and she reached around to touch Bishop's lean thighs, feeling as his body took Theo's cock.

Xeni began to touch herself again, fingers splitting her labia. She was still so wet. And his cock was just right there - not far away at all. She could just... She reached over and grabbed a condom from the bed stand. "This ok?" she showed it to Bishop.

"Fuck yes"

Theo grinned over her head and pulled Bishop back by the hips so she could suit him up, then bent him forward again, thrusting inside so that Bishop moaned.

She wriggled down underneath Bishop and he kissed her again, rutting himself back against Theo. Then when she pushed her hips up to meet his cock, he pressed himself forward.

Theo looked gleeful as he pressed Bishop's hips into Xeni and the three of them clicked together like Lego pieces. Bishop in their middle, Xeni on the bottom and Theo, the bear of a man fucking them both.

"I'm going to fuck Xeni through you, sweet boy." And then he began to thrust and Bishop keened, and Xeni moaned.

They were a beast with three backs, and none of them lasted long. Bishop detonated first, his body writhing underneath the steady fucking his lover was giving him. Xeni arched into Bishop's cock, clenching around him, feeling his long pulsing dick as it creamed inside the condom. Then with a grunt, Theo tipped over into orgasm pulling out of Bishop and gripping himself hard.

As they lay together, panting and sweaty on Xeni's bed. Bishop quirked a smile at both of them. "Fuck that was GOOD."