A Witch’s Revenge Ch. 01: The Polaroid

Everyone in this story is 18 years old or older.

Chapter 1: The Polaroid

Jack wrapped a towel around his waist and stepped out of the bathroom, still damp from his shower. Without missing a beat, his younger 18-year-old brother hurried in, eager to use the shower next.

Jack proceeded to his bedroom and grabbed a pair of white briefs. But before he put them on, he sat by his desk, scrolling through his phone as he came across a photo of Lucy, his crush. Almost immediately, his face turned red, and his body reacted to the photo, forming a tent beneath his towel.

'A guy's best features are his body and his dick,' Jack remembered. This was something that Lucas, the soccer team captain, frequently said. Jack and the rest of the soccer team players were all pretty well built. Just last week, he lifted his shirt in the middle of a game in front of Lucy, pretending to wipe off the sweat from his forehead, but she barely noticed his six-pack. Jack kept thinking about Lucas' words, and he got an idea.

He got up from his chair, checked the hallway, and closed the bedroom door before taking off his towel. His seven-inch dick bounced as it hardened, curving towards the left to his dismay.

Jack's heart began to race, afraid to get caught. He grabbed his polaroid camera and quickly took a shot of his dick before it started to soften up.

He heard the bathroom door open. Jack quickly ran to put on his briefs, just in time before his brother came into the room. Jack's brother grabbed a pair of white briefs from the closet and put them on before removing his towel and lying down on his bed.

The camera had printed Jack's photo, now clearly showing his well-endowed appendage. Jack grabbed the photo, keeping it out of sight from his brother and wrote his name on the back, along with a winky face. This would surely get Lucy interested!

***

The next day, Lucy was walking in the hallway of her community college along with her twin brother Eric and her best friend Mandy. As Lucy opened her locker, a polaroid picture fell out. She grabbed it and gasped at the sight.

"What is it?" Eric asked.

Lucy showed him the picture, and Eric scoffed, "Are you serious right now?" Eric said, squinting at the photo.

Mandy leaned closer. "Please tell me that did not just fall out of your locker. Who would do that?"

Lucy swallowed. "If I had to guess? Vlad. I mean, he has had a crush on me for a while."

Eric snorted. "What? That's not Vlad."

"How do you know?"

"Look, whoever took this photo is circumcised, at least I think because he hardly has a scar," Eric pointed out. "This doesn't rule any guy out. Every dude here is circumcised, except Vlad. He's from one of those eastern European countries. I remember cause your boyfriend and I give him hell for it every shower after practice."

Mandy and Lucy looked at each other, not knowing why Eric thought that was funny. Lucy grimaced. "You're awful."

"We have this shower tradition that the last guy who finishes has to chase the others for his clothes. I got so busy picking on Vlad that I didn't know I was the last one. Your boyfriend gave me a challenge."

Mandy and Lucy rolled their eyes.

"All I was saying before is that it has to be... literally any other guy," Eric continued.

"Well, that's a big help," Mandy replied sarcastically. She snatched the photo from Eric and looked at the back. "We don't even need to guess; he left his name, Jack!"

"Jack?!" Lucy and Eric looked confused; they never suspected him of having a crush on Lucy or being the type to send these kinds of photos.

Mandy stared at the photo a second longer than necessary, then smiled.

"You know," she said, checking to see if anyone was nearby, "some people only learn when they're embarrassed."

Lucy narrowed her eyes. "Mandy."

"What?" Mandy shrugged, taking out her magic wand from her pocket. "I didn't say how."

Mandy was secretly a witch, unknown to everyone else except for Lucy and Eric. Lucy pondered the idea of using magic, but knowing Mandy, it was best to see what idea she had first.

"Jack clearly likes showing off," Mandy said, "he can show off at next week's pool party."

"What pool party?" Lucy asked.

Mandy winked, "The one I'm setting up for you. You still like that new swim park?"

"Yeah?"

"Nothing a little convincing of the staff can't achieve," Mandy laughed, "and a little magic to punish your admirer."

"Hold on," Lucy cut in. "We're not ruining someone's life over this."

Eric couldn't control his smile. "That's brilliant, I love it! I'll get to punch Jack in the face and-"

"NO!" Lucy and Mandy said in unison.

Mandy shook her head, "It's your choice in the end. What do you think, Lucy?"

Lucy exhaled, unlike her brother, she's not one to enjoy harming others, even when they do her wrong. "I don't know..., maybe something less embarrassing? How about you put everyone else in a trance?"

Mandy shrugged, despite hating Jack she knew full well how this would affect Lucy's conscience, "Sure, if that's what you want."

***

Lucas stepped into the shower room of the community college along with his teammates. He was an incredibly sporty guy, having just finished basketball practice and was soon heading off to soccer practice. The soapy water flowed over his hairless body, past his rosy pink nipples and down to the crevices of his six-pack. Next to him was Steve, equally as muscular, and attractive. As Lucas washed off the sweat from his muscular chest and back, Steve was telling him about a prank he had pulled on the girls by setting a bomb full of dust and sticky glitter near their club house. Lucas laughed and then the two talked about the party. Lucas could already imagine how hot Lucy would look in her bikini, and damn, he was starting to get a huge boner, not something uncommon in the showers. He grinned, trying to refocus on the fun he'd have at the swim park.

As he finished off, Lucas realized he was the only one left in the shower. 'You know what that means,' he told himself. Lucas grabbed the nearest towel to dry himself off and put on a pair of white Y-briefs. Not that it did much to conceal his size. He reached for his soccer uniform and... as expected, he couldn't find it.

Lucas looked over to the left and saw the rest of the basketball team smirking at him and holding his shorts and shirt. Lucas smiled back. It had always been the shower tradition that whoever finished last had to chase the others for his clothes. Lucas chased the team, but each member had thrown the uniform at each other, too high for Lucas to catch. They rushed outside and threw his uniform on top of the lockers, just high enough for Lucas to catch.

"I'll see you tomorrow," Lucas laughed as he stepped outside to grab the uniform.

As soon as Lucas grabbed his uniform, he heard someone calling his name behind him. Lucas turned around and jumped.

"Mandy!" Lucas covered his underwear with his uniform.

His face turned red with embarrassment. Seeing his teammates was one thing, but being seen by a young woman was a completely different story.

"Oh, please," Mandy rolled her eyes, "I've seen you wear swimsuits with less fabric."

"What do you want?" Lucas answered her, wanting desperately to get this conversation over with as soon as possible.

"Lucy received a pretty nasty pic from one of your soccer teammates," Mandy said, "let's just say she ended up seeing more of him than she wanted to."

"Nice," Lucas smirked, leaving Mandy in shock, "looks like someone's shooting their shot."

Mandy took a step forward, and Lucas held his uniform tighter.

"Nice?! She's your girlfriend, how aren't you upset?"

"Relax, I want my teammates to feel confident," Lucas explained, "besides, Lucy's beautiful, it was bound to happen."

She stared at him, not knowing what to say.

"Now, can I please put on my uniform? I feel like everyone's eyes are on me."

Mandy bit her tongue; her jaw tightened, but all she let out was, "Lucy deserves better!" before storming off.

Turns out there was someone else she hated more than Jack.

Mandy felt her wand in her pocket. She'll definitely teach him a lesson.

***

A week had passed, and it was finally time for the pool party. Lucy's heart was racing. What did she get herself into? Was this too far or...

The doorbell rang, and she didn't have time to think. Lucy went downstairs to open the door. Mandy had arrived in her sweet new car. Eric rushed downstairs as well in his swimsuit and t-shirt.

The three of them sat on the patio to discuss their plan carefully.

"Don't worry, Lucy, I've taken into account what you asked," Mandy assured her, "if you don't want him humiliated in front of everyone, well, you're a better person than me, but I respect your decision."

Lucy let out a sigh of relief, "Thank you. I just want to teach him a lesson, not ruin his life."

She wondered if Jack would feel the same shock she felt when she saw the photo.

"You don't even have to be there," Mandy continued, "you've already seen too much with the polaro--"

"I'd still like to punch him in the face," Eric cut in.

"No! Stop punching people that upset you, you're going to get in trouble," Lucy huffed, her face was red.

Mandy's eyes narrowed. Eric was making this about himself again. She could see that Lucy was upset. "Why don't you wait for us in my car?" Mandy suggested.

Lucy knew what Mandy meant; she was going to straighten her brother out. She rushed to the car; better get out of the way!

"What's your problem?" Mandy demanded, "You can't just go around punching people!"

"He deserves it!"

"It doesn't matter. It's Lucy's revenge, not yours. Think of what she wants!"

Eric stood up and threw his hands, "I'm not going to hold back over a guy like him."

Mandy huffed. There's no getting through Eric when he has made up his mind. But one thing is for certain, Eric can't come to the party.

She thought about her magic; any spell she made would certainly put Eric in an awkward position for the next six hours.

Mandy drew her wand and pointed it at Eric.

With a quick spell, she turned his swimsuit into water, and it splashed onto Eric's feet!

"What the-!"

But before he could react, Eric's heart began to race, and his weiner suddenly hardened. A full eight inches and lacking any foreskin. Eric quickly took his shirt off and covered himself.

"What did you do?!"

Mandy gave a sly smile, not looking away, further embarrassing Eric. "Oh, didn't I tell you magic has this... effect on men?" Mandy laughed, "Don't worry, the magic will force its way out by tomorrow morning."

Eric was shocked, "Tomorrow morning?!"

Before he could react, he heard his mother's footsteps approaching! He rushed to the backyard pool, dropping his shirt on the way.

"Hey there, Mandy, is Lucy not down yet?"

"Oh, that's alright, I told Lucy to wait in the car. I forgot my purse," Mandy answered.

Lucy's mom smiled. She turned to the left and faced her son, "You're not going, Eric?"

Eric looked away; he couldn't face his mom. He felt like she could see right through the water.

"He decided to sit this one out," Mandy chimed in, "besides, it's going to be mostly Lucy's friends."

"Ah, I see, well, you two enjoy."

Lucy's mother stepped inside, and Mandy went in shortly after.

Mandy turned back and saw Eric climbing up the pool, the sun shining on his wet, hairless body. His dick was slapping his sides with every step. With her magic, she pulled Eric's shirt inside and locked him out on the patio!

His face dropped, dick still hard. Eric struggled to hide himself behind the plant he had just grabbed. He looked around, afraid someone might see him from their windows. Embarrassed, he turned to Mandy, almost pleading to get inside.

"That's for bullying Vlad," she said coldly as she walked away, "now your sister and I are going to get the party started.