Hopeful Sin, Bk. 2, Ch. 4

Filliandari

As she sat on the edge of the massive bed Filli was flanked on either side by her demon temptation and her rogue in shining armor, both standing at a corner of the massive bed. They glared at each other across and over her. She looked between them from her seated position, her ankles crossing, and uncrossing in the silence before she cleared her throat. "I don't suppose it would solve anything if I just... told you both to not be jealous?"

They both smirked but Eris was faster, "Why should I be jealous. I was first. I will be last."

But James was quick to retort, "But I am better. I'll be remembered longer."

What they needed, she determined, was a distraction.

Scooting back on the bed, Filli opened her hastily donned robe as she did, very naked beneath as she watched to see if they'd continue to glower at one another as she did, or if she had their attention.

They both immediately went quiet and focused their attention on her.

"I made my choice. I'm not going to give up what I've finally found after five hundred years of waiting and hoping and wishing." She sat against the head board, her ankles still crossed as she felt that flashing them would be a step too far. "It's your turn to choose. Live with my choices and come enjoy the time we have before we're fleeing for our lives again in the morning... or take your leave and find a spot to sleep downstairs. And some cotton for your ears." She didn't single either of them out, but very clearly claimed the bed as her spot for the night.

Eris' eyes brightened far too quickly for her liking. He looked between James and Filli, declaring, "Fine. The last one to cum wins. Last place does whatever I say in bed tomorrow night." He looked at Filli for that. "Second place is the pack mule. And despite what my wife thinks, this IS my house. My rules." He started stripping while laying down the law for the night and while James growled with annoyance, he did the same.

Filli held her hands up, warding them away for a moment. "One more thing. If I wake up in a not-good kind of pain because two men were growling over me like two dumb dogs over a scrap of meat, no one gets anything tomorrow."

Eris considered this for a few moments, before shaking his head. "No deal. This is a first. We don't know how you will wake, your Holiness."

"You're the one who wanted to turn this into a challenge." she retorted, "I don't want to suffer for that while you two compare who's more 'manly'."

"In all fairness, luv. You knew you were going to get double plugged from the start. I hardly think it would be fair to punish us for it..." Oh shit, they agreed...

"Which is why I specified 'not good' pain," Filli sighed, but could already see this was a losing battle. "But... if you're both confident you can make me forget I ever said that..."

"My wife and I already have an arrangement regarding her ass."

"That's fine with me, mate. I like making her wet enough to run down me balls."

"Oh, really? Well, before she starts ranting again, care to see how loud you can make her moan?"

"Dont mind if I do."

Filli rolled her eyes at their exchange, but decided that this was something they should work out for themselves... while working her body to its limit. This would be a fun night. Soon she was disrobed and arranged on all fours. James was behind her exploring her moist slit and Eris was sitting parallel to her head, guiding her mouth to his member. She was quick to move, eagerly taking her husband's shaft into her mouth while her lover settled behind her, finding the priestess already wet with anticipation.

James licked her from clit to asshole, spreading the slickness along her entire length. Then he started probing her insides with his tongue, while Eris guided her head down, reaching under her to play with her breasts. Filli moaned softly around the girthy cock in her mouth before moving in deeper, until it pressed into her throat where she rested for a few moments before pulling back as slowly as she could.

"All the way, my HoneyPot," Eris urged her when just the tip was in her mouth. But James was determined not to let that be easy as he turned his full attention to her clit while sliding two fingers into her pussy. Filli moaned again, deeper and louder as the rogue attacked her sensitive nub, making it throb with pleasure and she was forced to take a moment before pressing back in on Eris, taking him in until her nose touched his hips.

Then the tiefling pinched one of her nipples and pulled down until his hand rested on the bed, forcing her ass up for her lover and limiting how much of his cock she could pull out of her throat. Filli found herself rapidly losing the fight to maintain her concentration already and the addition of light pain to the mix had her struggling to breathe as she shuddered with her first orgasm, bringing forth a new surge of honey for James to taste, while securing her place as Eris's third place loser - not that she minded.

"Pity, Jim. I have not heard much from her at all." James grunted and pulled away. Her men quickly repositioned. James laid down and guided her to straddle him. Eris moved behind her. Her hands on James' chest, butt up in the air, pussy ready to be impaled. If she lowered herself on the waiting cock, that would be it. She would be committed to this.

No way in hell was she backing out. She lowered herself, her eyes half open as the human filled her so wonderfully, and leaned over both to kiss James and open herself to Eris.

He grabbed her shapely ass and parts it to take his saliva moistened cock and align it with her inviting ass. Then he was inside her, sliding in to the hilt as she found herself stuffed, struggling to quantify what it felt like to have two big dicks filling her, forcing her bowels and womb to move to accommodate them.

She arched, lifting her lips from James' as everything in her body tightened. She didn't moan or cry out, but James got to see the absolute, uncontrolled bliss on her face as they filled her. By the time Eris was fully engulfed in her ass, she was physically shaking from the tension in her body, not having breathed through the process.

"Too quiet, luv. Together, mate?" Eris grunted in agreement. As he pulled back her body was lifted off James' cock. Then they both thrust in together, then out, then back again, stirring her insides like a gooey stew.

The tension released in the first thrust along with all the breath in her lungs as she cried out in ecstacy, already cumming at the dual sensation.

"Stop, Jim. I think the Scion needs to put in some work..." Both men stopped their thrusting halfway.

It took some effort for her to follow the direction, pleasure surging through her body as she pulled out more before moving back down until they filled her again, moaning all the while.

Her attempted movements didn't accomplish what they had planned for her. They were positioned in such a way that as she lifted from James she impaled herself on Eris. As she slid down the fiends member James filled her once more, forcing her to alternate the stroking members in her body.

Realizing this made her shudder with ecstasy, and she started to move faster, the dual sensation utterly overwhelming to her as she was stroked on both ends. It was truly pitiful how little time it took for what miniscule control she'd exercised to shatter utterly, making her body contract in her next orgasm.

Eris grabbed her hair and pulled her up, away from James' face, while forcing her hard and deep down on his cock. He thrust into her, double filling her once more as he turned her head towards him. "When I win, I am going to have you on your knees, serving at my pleasure for the next week." He kissed her roughly as they began thrusting again.

Her body shuddered again, the promise alone being enough to drive her to climax, barely registering the light pain from her hair being pulled as they thrust into her body, and she returned his kiss with ravenous fervor, grinding into them at every opportunity.

Her nipples were suddenly pinched and pulled, forcing her away from her husband and back down to her lover. "Denial is overrated. When I claim you for the next week, it's going to be over drive. You will cum so much that you forget the dark princess behind you again." He reached between them and rubbed her clit as he resumed kissing her.

Filli was in a spiral of pleasure, the second promise drawing another shudder of ecstacy from the Scion, accompanied by a muffled wail as she returned his kiss with incredible enthusiasm. Her head was spinning, and it occurred to her cum drunk mind that she could easily have died like this and it would have been the happiest death of her life.

She considered this as long as it took for them to drive another orgasm through her body, before deciding that boys would be boys, and they needed to figure out their places with her... in her... on their own as she fully surrendered to the divinely unholy pleasure.

She spent much of her time sprawled on the chest of James. Eris had much more freedom in moving in and out of her ass. She was frequently dragged up by her husband and promised new sinful torments only to be hauled back down to James and promised equally sinful delights.

But ultimately the Darkness cheated. With both men swelling inside her, long after she had lost count of her climaxes, James stroked her spines... and sent a shocking grasp through her nerves and into her pelvis. While he was prepared for it, neither she nor James were. Her sudden clenching and quivering coupled with the electric tingle had her womb bloating under the flood of his seed.

Eris chuckled as he gushed into her bowels seconds later. James was so wiped from the experience he didn't even comment on "cheating". The three of them were left to collapse into the bed, Filli in the middle.

Filli was unconscious almost immediately, her body humming and twitching as it relaxed. In the night, she'd curl up into James' chest while pressing her rear against her husband.

Then, and for the next week, she was obligated to serve at her husband's whims in the bedroom. And while she could still dally with James through the day, her nights belonged to her Demon. She wouldn't have them together again until their next contest in a week.

She awakened in the bed alone, a hovering suit standing by with a plate of fruits and granola. And water, sweet sweet water. Movement revealed she was partially stuck to the sheets as the effects of last night leaked and dried.

She winced as she detached herself from the bed and sheets. Food. Pray. Shower. That was her simple routine, as established over the last week, and she greedily claimed and consumed the food, still very naked as she did.

Surprisingly she managed to eat, pray, and shower without a single interruption by anyone. While not exactly insulting when she was naked, it was surprising.

Now somewhat wary at the utter lack of having seen either male while going through her routine, she left the bedroom, wrapped in a fluffy, comfortable and full length robe, she left to go downstairs, keeping her ears open for arguing, fighting... blood on the carpet...

None of the red flags appeared and she found Eris alone in the kitchen. "Ah, you are up. The pack mule is already preparing for the journey." He said rather... casually.

She made a face at him. "You know I don't like it when you call him that. Does he get no credit for getting me back to you in one piece?

"He is still here. I let him into our bed. Is that not enough credit?"

She sighed, but didn't push as she went up to kiss her husband softly before saying, "If we're going to head out, I should get ready.

Before her lips touched him he asked, "How long are you keeping the pet around?"

She took a step back, frowning slightly. "He's welcome to stay as long as he likes, as far as I'm concerned. He's trustworthy, vigilant and not inclined to throw me at the nearest inquisitor, which I'm sure is becoming a dwindling state of mind with whatever story they're throwing around of how I've fallen..."

"No discussion, that is simply it? He gets to stay and becomes a fixture in the bedroom forever? And I, of course, should readily accept this?"

She leaned against the wall, crossing her arms. Not confrontational, but disappointed that this had to come up. "If there's something to discuss, then we probably should. Are you jealous?"

"Perhaps a bit. I am not at all opposed to dalliances with other men and women," He paused there to see her reaction to that idea, "But I am not as okay with a live-in."

She blinked at the mention of women, but that's all. If Eve, the lecherous High Priestess, had been younger, more able to handle what Eris had to offer, she would have put true thought into inviting her to their bed for a night. "I suppose if I simply told you that there was nothing to be jealous of, that wouldn't sway you one way or another?"

"Ah, so you won't be spending any moments you are not with me screwing him, well, certainly that would alleviate any and all remaining concern." He chuckled. He did not seem upset or angry. It did seem to be a relatively minor case of annoyance that her attention would be spread.

"Like you wouldn't do the same in my position." she retorted with a teasing tilt to her lips.

"I would happily involve you in all aspects of another woman. However, I am afraid I, personally, would not like to interact directly with another male. A personal flaw, but none the less where I am. Try to conserve your energy today, my dear. It's going to be a long, long night." He rose and went to her to kiss her before heading for the door.

She blinked at the abrupt conclusion to their discussion, returning the kiss while returning to the bedroom to change into something more appropriate for travel. As much as she wanted to keep James around, though, it did occur to her that it would be better to send him away rather than have Eris drive him off.

He led them into the dungeon. And James did not help with Eris' conclusion. After looting the first room for some travel money, he suggested Eris scout ahead, while holding Filli back. Much like their overland travel to get here...

"Capable as Eris is, splitting up in a dungeon would be the height of foolishness." Filli gently rebuffed his attempt. "Once we reach the boss room, Eris can collect the loot and search for anything we may have missed while you and I sort the loot in there."

Ahead Eris snorted. He was very thorough. James sighed dramatically.

Filli shared a sigh, and from her protected position between them, closed her eyes with regret. Maybe this was too complicated for her to try to salvage.

Maybe not, though..? They fought well together. A whirlwind of magic and death sliding and dashing between monsters and cutting them down as she healed and supported. Both took time to touch, kiss, or in one demon's case, slap her ass. There was no open animosity between them. Both seemed equally willing to accept her decision, but both would, of course, be happier if they had her all to themselves. Since neither showed any bi tendencies, it was a rather one sided friends with benefits triangle.

Then... maybe they'd just have to find an agreeable fourth. A thought that had occurred to Filli while talking with Eris, but something she hadn't fully indulged... but the sick feeling that accompanied any thoughts of outright dismissing James brought it to the forefront again. He was hers. She could share, certainly, but she had claimed both men before the Gods, and that was absolutely how she continued to feel. Yes... another woman to take the load off her back and help to prevent any resentment...

After the two headed troll boss fell and Eris finished cauterizing its wounds he announced loudly, "I, the brave scout, shall go forth and scout ahead. BUT! How long will I be gone? An hour? A day? I mean five minutes would probably do it.." he continued quipping all the way to the stairs down.

"I'll be worried if you're gone more than an hour." Filli called after him, giving them all a time limit. Yes, he was probably more than capable of clearing the second floor on his own, but... still. She loved him. And that loving smile was still on her lips as she turned to James, looking to assess his state of mind.

"I really dislike that man," James informed her, walking over to her and taking her hips in hand.

The smile turned apologetic and she said, "I know he can be a bit much sometimes. Or all the time, for you, I guess." she leaned into his lean body and nuzzled her face into his neck. "You know you're under no obligation to stay..." there was a sad note in her voice as she reminded him of this, letting him know that she was not trying to push him into leaving.

"Are you?" He asked, kissing the top of her head even as his hands instinctively moved to the straps of her armor.

She moved hers to do the same for him. "I won't leave him." This was stated as absolute. "Whatever else he is, Eris is the reason I'm here, free to live the life I wish, for the first time in centuries. And I loved him for it."

As her breast plate clattered to the floor he reached up and cupped her soft breasts. "Actually, I am the reason you are here. You should do me a favor and leave him. Come run away with me, like we talked about." He sounded wistful, not serious. Despite invoking his favor.

"You are." she murmured, cupping her hands around the back of his neck, "But you and I would never have met if he hadn't opened my eyes to the Inquisitors abuse of their power. You owe him every bit as he owes you. And I owe you both everything I have." She pulled him down for a deep kiss.

He obliged her, kissing her long and hard. At some point her bottoms clattered to the floor. Then he gently nudged her to go to her knees.

She complied, pulling his pants down with her, letting them fall to his ankles as she began to lick and kiss his member.

He stroked her hair, moaning softly as he watched her.

Once she had gotten him hard and moist with her tongue, her lips wrapped around his thick member, and she pulled him deep into her mouth until he was sheathed in her throat before she pulled back, dragging her tongue along his length as she did.

But he didn't wait long after he was fully hardened. "Hands and knees, princess."

She pulled him from her throat with a gasp as she turned to the side, planting her hands on the floor with her back slightly arched.

He kneeled and slid into her ever willing pussy. He started to fuck her hard and fast.

She arched deeper as he filled her, her eyes closing with bliss as he started to take her roughly, just as she liked, her body tight and warm around his thick member.

He did not hold back for her, driving her quickly to climax... then again, and again. When he paused, it was when he was swelling inside her, holding only himself back.

She gasped and panted for breath as he paused, her body shuddering, as she had fallen from her shaking arms to collapse with her ass up for him to continue plowing into her body.

And he did, ramming into her with renewed vigor and force, rocking her on her hands and knees almost painfully.

She screamed her ecstasy, her body contracting around him in a near constant orgasm, pouring all her will into remaining in position.

Even when she got shaky, he grabbed her hips and held her in place for him to pillage. Stopping only to calm himself, he seemed intent on fucking her raw.

And she loved every second of it, her toes curled and her fingers clawing at the floor beneath them, the time limit she'd given Eris entirely forgotten as she surrendered to the pleasure.

Once she was pleasantly sore, he kept going until the door opened and he grabbed her hips tight, thrusting hard into her as he climaxed.

She shuddered with him, her head already resting on the floor while she gasped, her head turned away from the exit to the room so Eris couldn't see the blissed out expression on her face.

Eris snorted. "If you two are quite done, I have learned the path to the next boss. On the third floor, we can enter the Labyrinth." Eric gave her another petty thrust, squishing out his seed before withdrawing and rising.

Filli groaned quietly, releasing a trickle of healing energy into her body to relieve some of the soreness, sitting up and pulling a rag out of her pack to clean up fully before reequipping her armor.

As her magic coursed into her, she heard a familiar chuckle in her mind. Her 'injuries' healed, tightening and closing any micro tears, but it did nothing to alleviate the soreness. Her goddess did not overrule the Laughing god. Their mutual consensus was clear. She could have her cake, but she was going to feel it too. The smug look on James' face reminded her she was not the only favorite here.

They were ready to go, waiting for her.

Petty. She gave a soft "Hmph" as she fixed her hair, brushing her fingers through it as she walked to the door, giving Eris a kiss as she waited for him to take the lead and guide them in.

He kissed her long and thoroughly until James brushed past, and they descended. The dungeon experience here in this intermediate dungeon was a lot simpler than her and Eris' initial dives. With the enemies unaware of their presence and not all swarming together, they could easily dispatch them in small groups. With more resources, their boss fights were also a breeze. With the malformed hill giant lying dead before them, Eris was already moving to descend and find the Labyrinth entrance as James grabbed her hips. "Mm, another rest stop."

She put her hands on his chest, not pushing, but pressing, waiting for Eris to be gone, before saying, "I wanted to ask you something. With my clothes on, preferably."

"Can you ask quickly?" He reached up to start removing belts and packs from her.

"Alright... do you know of a woman you're attracted to, who would be interested in making our threesome a foursome?"

A follower of the Lord of Freedom and Light he'd met a couple years ago came to mind. An air genasi, the woman avoided cities and civilization during most of the year, but came around for celebrations, festivals and holidays, enjoying being surrounded by the heightened emotions and lowered inhibitions. She also exercised the Freedom aspect of her god in every aspect of her life, including sex, and he was fairly certain monogamy was a gibberish word to her.

Her armor started getting unbuckled. "I might know a certain elemental free spirit. But I wouldn't dream of asking her without her warden." He described the air genasi and her aasimaar friend, lover, and long-suffering conscience whose sole purpose was to minimize the trouble her friend got into, but as often as not being dragged into it. Though she had her race's natural aversion to Eris' kind. Of course he would try to stiff her husband, but then again... Eris decimated her resistance to him and put a ring on her. Her lover may have underestimated Eris' charm by virtue of being straight.

"Two others to share the load with. Even better," she chuckled wryly. "Where can we find them?"

Her armor fell off and he leaned down to suck her nipple as he worked her bottoms. "Vedoris would be the place to start, even if she isn't there, we should be able to find out where they were heading." No sense bothering her with information like the Aasimaars virginity or disdain for carnal pleasures. But on the plus side for him, the genasi would be hard pressed to live underground.

"Good..." she sighed, running a hand over his hair and down his cheek, before murmuring, "You do know the point of a rest stop is to... rest, right?" she still smiled while her legs folded to kneel on the floor, pulling him with her.

He worked on her lower armor, "I'll get plenty of rest tonight," he grumped.

She sighed at the clear implication, pointing out, "This is new to all of us. Eris dictated the terms last week, I won't let that happen this week."

"Good luck with that. It's not too bad..." About as close as he was likely to get to accepting this situation. With her fully disrobed, he laid her down on the floor.

"For you, perhaps." she sighed again as she lay, bracing herself for another rough pounding, "It would be my luck I couldn't find two men who didn't think I was something to compete over."

He smirked. "You don't think you are worth it?" He propped her legs on his shoulders and reached down to stroke her slit.

He found her wet, ever ready for pleasure. "See, that's the thing. It's not about me being worth it or not because that's all in your heads. What it is about is that no one wins when everything is a competition. Not Eris, not you, not me."

He chuckled, "You don't think having us both is winning?" He rubbed her moisture up and down her slit, and then down, lubing her ever ready ass. "Surely you understand men well enough to know that we compete for what we want."

"But I don't have both of you. I have you individually for a period of time that inevitably ends up with me sore as you both think that you can pound your superiority into the very core of my being." She snorted.

"So last night was not good enough for you?" When they both fucked her into blissful oblivion.

"That was very good..." she smirked. "But if things are going to be a perpetual competition between the two men I care about most in the world... I'll be loose as the cheapest whore the Honey Pot has to offer before the end of the week."

He aligned his dick with her tight ass and thrust in, belying her fear. "So, are you saying you don't want to have sex with us as much as possible?"

She arched. "I'm saying... I don't want it to be a competition."

"I am saying that for what you want, you have to compromise. We are.

"And I'm saying I've spent five hundred years as an object. I don't want to stop being an idol to become a trophy."

He took her hands and placed them over her head so he could hold them down with one hand and he used the other to cover her mouth as he fucked her tight ass. Simply taking her and silencing her.

She accepted this, closing her eyes with a quiet moan as he began to move within her body.

He kept it steady, not pushing her to rapid climaxes this time. When it was clear she was done complaining, he released her hands and said, "Touch yourself. But don't cum until I do."

She shivered and her hand slid between her legs, two fingers pulling her lips open while her middle finger started to move in small circles on the sensitive nub of her clit, making her ass tighten on him.

"That's it..." He thrust nice and deep. "Listen. Don't talk. I know what you want. I am sure your hellspawn does too." He used his hand to massage her breast. "If either of us couldn't handle it, we'd leave. But both of us think you are worth it. Don't expect us to be friends. But I think you can count on us to want you to be happy. Let us compete and try and one up each other. It's healthy. Just accept that we love you. Can you do that, luv?"

She shivered slightly, and it took a moment, but she finally nodded, quietly moaning as she continued to slowly circle her clit with her finger.

"As for today, yes, I am going to stick it to him, by sticking it to you. I am going to start reaming your ass now. I want you to keep rubbing. And I want you to not cum." She was loud enough that he covered her mouth before he started ramming his cock in and out of her bowels hard and fast.

A good precaution, as she arched beneath him with a scream of pleasure as he began, tightening on him more and her finger froze in place before she sent herself over only a few seconds in.

He tsked. "You came already. Can I punish you?" He had never asked this before. So, he clearly intended something they had not done.

With the only frame of reference she had for punishment being Eris, she wanted to know what James would do, how far he'd push her... and she nodded.

His massaging hand grabbed her nipple between thumb and finger. "Maybe this will help control your urges." James pinched and twisted as he fucked her hard and she rubbed herself. He rested on his elbow so he could cover her mouth.

Unfortunately, his attempt failed utterly as Eris had already made a mild masochist of her through the abuse of her nipples, and she tightened further on him while whimpering hard.

James smirked. "So corrupted." He teased her. As she got close he suddenly spanked her across the face, without warning.

This time, the distraction succeeded, and James nodded to himself and began assisting with her self-restraint as necessary.

Filli jumped with each strike as though caught entirely off guard, not expecting them, but never telling him to stop or making any indication that it was too much for her, although she did start to growl after the second time he halted her orgasm as her need increased.

"Rub fast, unless you want to quit," he challenged her, thrusting harder, deeper, filling her completely. And slapping the climax out of her from the other direction when she tensed and squinted the wrong cheek.

She was starting to shiver now as her body became overwhelmed, forcing tears to fill her eyes and start to trickle into her hair. But her finger moved faster, making her tighten further on him.

"Do you want me to cum?" He demanded as he swelled in her. He slapped her again as she grew close.

"Yes!" She sobs.

He continued for a minute then said, breathless. "Stop rubbing..." A slap, but he must have been close.

Her hand slid from her mound, and her teeth chattered as she waited. Please, please....

Then he pulled out, and she felt him leaking out of her. He came, the fucker came! "You already came." He said with a wicked grin as he rose to dress, having left her ass nice and sore. And leaking.

All she could do was stare at him in abject disbelief from her position on the floor as her body screamed.

She had a bad ten minutes before Eris returned while James sorted through the loot.

Filli collected herself after five, swiftly dismissing the thought of getting herself off as her body continued to ache. So, she healed the light redness in her cheeks from the slapping and began to dress, mostly done by the time Eris returned.

"Okay, I found the Labyrinth. Let's go," Eris announced his return. He sounded casual, but the way he looked at Filli told her it was a good plan to heal herself as he examined her closely after finding them dressed.

She stepped up to kiss him, asking James, "You got everything sorted?"

"Yep. That wasn't too torturous, ya?"

She smirked. "We'll have to agree to disagree." and she stuck her tongue out at the human, clearly holding no grudge, even if her body was still aching with needy hunger.