Beth 02: Threesome in a Closet

There always seems to be that one girl in the crowd. She's the one who thinks it's her job to preserve the virginity of all the other girls. She's prudish, judgmental, and messes in everyone's business. Honestly, she's often not very attractive either.

Beth and I had gone out several times over the past few month. We've enjoyed dinner at McDonalds (give me a break, we're college students), movies, nature walks. Just a variety of dates.

We've also enjoyed our time in. When we would lie in bed and I would have her healthy BBW body on top of me, grinding into me and making my cock explode into her.

Beth and I were also quite loud in bed. The dorm Resident Assistant was constantly pissed at us for having a boy on the girls floor, which was against the rules. However, she came to realize that I was harmless to everyone else, so she left us alone.

Beth's roommate was often pissed too. She had to sit out in the common room while we fucked like bunnies. Beth invited to come in and watch if she wanted. I think Beth really wanted that to happen. She'd hinted often of a desire to include another girl in our playtime. Dawn, her roommate, never took us up on it.

One night, Beth and I went to a party at the house where we first got together. One of the guys that lived in the house apparently snored real loud so the others cleaned out a huge closet and made him sleep in there. It basically had an overhead light and a mattress on the floor and nothing else. It ended up being the room where people would go to fuck. The guy had a sleeping bag he kept rolled up so no one would soil that. Otherwise, it was just a mattress, with plenty of stains. Gross I know. But we were in college and horny all the time.

That night, Beth and I were getting quite handsy on the dance floor. Prude Penny was working the crowd, pulling drunk girls away from guys who were looking to score. I guess she served a good purpose, but not when they were people who had been dating a while.

Penny decided she needed to get between me a Beth. It was a slow dance and I had a hand on Beth's tit and she was groping my crotch. I was good and hard when Penny stepped in between us. Seriously, she pried us apart and stood between us, facing Beth. "Beth, I think you've had too much to drink and are unaware of what you're doing," Penny said in her pretentious concerned voice.

The closet was only about 5 feet away. Beth grabbed Penny's hand and dragged her to it. I followed. Penny nearly tripped on the mattress as the space beside it was very narrow. I closed the door behind me and Beth laid into Penny, "I don't know what you think you're doing. Evan and I have been together for 67 days," I was surprised to learn she knew the actual number of days. "Yes, we fuck, often. I like him and I love his cock. He likes me and compliments my shape all the time. I'm sorry you haven't found a guy who loves you for you, but you gotta quit being a cock-block for the rest of us."

Penny was standing there shaking. She was about an inch taller than Beth. She was thin with what appeared to be very nice tits. She liked to keep them covered in loose fitting clothes. She wasn't ugly, she was just kinda homely. I'm sure there would be some guy who would love to be with her. I'm not one to judge that. I enjoy Beth's body because she's chubby. Some other guys won't be into that. Not the point. I'm just saying, Penny isn't my type but I could see how she might be someone else's type.

At this point, Beth was in her face and I thought I might have to break up a cat fight. Beth raised her voice and spoke through gritted teeth, "I don't know what it is about you always wanting to be in our business. Is it that you want my boyfriend's cock? Or is it that you want my pussy? Which is it? I'm getting real pissed at trying to figure you out."

Penny cowered at this verbal attack. She began to cry. I thought it was just a defense mechanism but then she whispered very quietly, "Can it be both?"

Fuuuuck I didn't see that coming. Penny wanted us both. She was bisexual and apparently was jealous that she couldn't have either one of us.

What happened next surprised both Penny and me. Beth closed the distance between them, grabbed the back of Penny's neck and pulled her in for a kiss. I was familiar with Beth's kisses and I knew that Beth had her tongue halfway down Penny's throat in mere moments. Penny seemed to melt into her. She didn't resist at all.

After a few moments, Penny wrapped her arms around Beth as if to surrender to her assault. Beth turned to me for a moment, "Evan, I need you to turn off the lights, lock the door, and step closer to us."

I did as she requested and Beth took full charge of the situation. "Penny, would you like to explore us both?"

Penny moaned a soft, "yes."

"OK, I'm going to guide you but if at any moment you want it to end, just say stop and we will, OK?" Beth instructed more than asked.

"OK" was the whispered reply. I could hear the shaking in her voice. Penny had not come to the party expecting this. She was the cock-block but now she was in a position to experience cock, pussy, whatever part of our bodies she wanted. I think that scared her half to death. Her identity as the prudish one was going to die tonight. Then who would she be?

Beth instructed, "Penny, have you ever felt someone's breast?"

"No" came the whisper.

"I need you to take my shirt off me," Beth instructed. By the rustling noise, I knew it happened. "Now, reach behind me and undo my bra." Again, I could hear it happening. I was getting hard and rubbing my crotch.

"Now place your hands on my breasts... Feel them, weigh them in your palm... Feel how hard you're making my nipples... Now I need you to put a nipple between your lips and suck on it... Yes, like that... Lick my nipples and bite them softly... That's so nice... You make me feel so good." This took several minutes. It was very dark in the room and I couldn't see what was happening but I assumed Penny was following the instructions and I could see in my mind's eye what it looked like.

"Now Penny, have you ever felt a cock before?" Beth asked.

"No" came the whisper.

"I bet you'd like to. Evan, I need you to step closer." I closed the distance and could feel the heat from both bodies. Beth on my right and Penny on my left.

"Penny, give me your hand... I'm going to guide you to Evan's cock... do you feel how hard it is... he's hard for you... he wants you to do more with it... would you like to feel it without his jeans on?"

"Yes," Penny whispered. It was like she was in a lust filled trance. Then she followed up with "please."

"Take down his pants," Beth continued. I felt Penny undo my button and then pull down my zipper. "Wrap your hands around his cock... feel its size... feel its warmth... he's getting harder as you rub him... take one hand and place it on his balls... they are large when he's soft... but they shrivel up some when he gets hard... they are preparing to shoot cum when he's ready... carefully play with his balls... he likes that but they are very tender so you can't be rough... unless he asks for it... put your fingers on the tip of his cock... do you feel moisture there?"

"Yes," came the whisper.

"His cock is leaking for you. That's so he can lube you as he fucks you... but that's a conversation for later. I think you'd really like the taste. Put your lips against his cock head and taste him... lick him with your tongue... he tastes good, doesn't he?" Beth asked and I could feel the nod of Penny's head.

"Now Penny, it's time to put him in your mouth. Before you do, lick up and down the shaft. Get it nice and slick. That way it slides into your mouth easier." I could feel myself getting hypnotized into Beth's trance as she guided Penny.

"Now take him in your mouth, Penny. This is what you've longed for and now you can make it happen. Suck his cock. Lick it... make love to it with your lips and tongue. You'll find that he leaks a lot more and I know you'll enjoy the taste."

This continued for several more minutes until I felt that I would explode. I knew that wasn't the goal so I grabbed hold of Beth's arm and squeezed it. She got the message.

"Penny, I find you quite attractive," Beth poured it on strong, "I'd really like to enjoy your body. Can I do that?"

A mumbled whisper came from Penny's full mouth. We both took it as a yes. I took hold of Penny under her arms and pulled her to her feet. I went in for a kiss and found that I was competing with Beth. We had a threeway tongue engagement and I could feel Penny shaking nervously.

Beth moved behind her and pulled her shirt over her head, interrupting our kiss momentarily. Then Beth undid Penny's bra. Penny naturally reached to cover herself and Beth said, "It's OK, we can't see anyway. Though I can tell you we both would love to look at your naked body someday."

Beth took another bold step by reaching around and undoing Penny's pants. Penny dropped her hands to prevent it. I moved in and kissed her deeply and grabbed a handful of her youthfully firm tits. They stuck out quite nicely from her body and I could feel that her nipples were puffy. I've always liked seeing those in porn and would have really liked to be seeing them now.

I broke our kiss and dropped my head to suck on her puffies. Penny reached for my head with both hands, freeing up Beth's hands to continue with Penny's jeans. Penny was naked and moaning at me sucking her nipples.

Beth came back to our ears and said, "I'd like us to lay down on the mattress. Is that ok with you, Penny?" She didn't reply but just moved to do it. I took that moment to get completely naked and I could tell that Beth was doing the same. Oh, how I wanted to turn the lights back on and see these two naked women but I knew that was part of the mystique of the moment.

We lay down on either side of Penny and each of us took a nipple in our mouths. Penny moaned her approval. Suddenly Penny drew in a quick breath and I knew Beth's hand had reached her pussy.

"Penny, I love that you've shaved for us. I am surprised that you do shave. You were hoping someone would touch you tonight weren't you?" Beth asked.

"I was hoping it would by you," Penny moaned.

"Penny, would you like me to kiss you down there too?" Beth asked, pressing the situation.

"Please," was all we heard.

"I'm going to go down on you. While I do, please enjoy kissing and petting Evan. We don't want him to go soft, do we?" Beth asked.

"No," came the reply. Her hand moved to my waist and took hold of my cock. She wasn't experienced at giving a hand job so it was a bit jerky and awkward. But it was enough to keep me hard.

After a moment, Penny drew in another deep breath and I suspected Beth's tongue had found the target. Penny moved from moaning to hard breathing very quickly. Beth's hands came up to play with Penny's tit and Penny responded with a small orgasm. When it subsided some she said, "Oh my god, what was that. I've never felt like that before."

"Penny, that was a small orgasm. Believe me, there is more to come. If you want me to continue." Beth instructed.

"Please keep going," was her reply, making sure to use the opposite of the safe word she was given.

After several minutes of caressing, sucking, kissing and so forth, Penny began to shake. She was having an orgasm that was rocking her world. She jerked and spasmed. I couldn't really keep her tit in my mouth and I didn't want to get head banged by kissing her. So I put an arm around her shoulders and held her as she writhed uncontrollably.

When she settled down, Beth moved back up to be with us. Penny asked, "Is it always like that? Does it always feel that good?"

Beth responded, "Sometimes it's much better, stronger. Sometimes it doesn't happen at all but you're left feeling fulfilled. Sometimes it feels the same as the last time. Other times it feels way different. When I orgasm from my vibrator, it get the release I need. When I cum from making love with Evan, it feels way better and very different. I think it has everything to do with who you're with."

Penny nodded her understanding. Beth then said, "Now you have one hand on Evan's cock and your other has found my pussy. Do you want to continue this?"

"Can I go down on you, Beth?" Penny asked.

"Of course, have you ever eaten a girl before?" Beth asked.

"No," Penny answered.

"Well just do to me what you felt me do to you. If I missed anything you like, go ahed and try it on me. I'd love for you to make me cum," Beth invited.

There was shuffling on the mattress as Penny awkwardly moved down Beth's body. There was no intimacy like "kissing her way down," she was inexperienced and nervous. So things seemed a bit awkward.

Beth moaned her pleasure as Penny went between her thick thighs. I've been there often and have always enjoyed her aroma and taste. I hoped Penny was taking that all in. Beth was sure enjoying it. I wasn't sure how much experience Beth had with women and it was only later that I learned that this was only her second time.

As the minutes passed, Beth began to moan. I was busy sucking on her nipple when she raised her hips up and began to buck in pleasure. Out of the blue she shouted, "Wait, stop, fuck, shit, ow, stop it."

Penny stopped said in a horrified voice, "I'm so sorry. You said to do to you what I would like. So I did. Was that bad. I didn't mean to hurt you."

Beth's voice turned to something like a teacher's voice, firm and caring. "Nibbling is nice. I like it. Biting my pussy lips when I'm orgasming... well let's not ever do that again."

I think Penny was probably bright red with embarrassment. She begged, "Please, don't tell anyone. I'm so sorry. I just thought we might both like it."

"Penny if you want, I can try it out on you another time. But for now, I'd like you to gently use your tongue on my clit to bring my to an orgasm. I really need you to finish me now." Beth told her.

Beth laid her head back and I kissed her softly. I could tell by her light moans that Penny was back on track. We also had a moment of knowing laughter between us.

Beth came again and it was kinda loud. The music outside on the dance floor was between songs and I'm pretty sure everyone heard her. When she was done she pulled Penny back up. Then she asked, "Penny, are you a virgin?"

Penny whispered her "yes" again.

"Would you like that to end tonight? Would you like Evan to be your first?

"Yes, please Evan. Yes," she panted.

"Do you understand that this is just sex. We might do it more together. We might decide never to do it again. But we aren't making a commitment. If we hook up, great. I've enjoyed you so far. But if not, no more stalking. I'd like to see his big cock in you, but you have to agree to my terms." Beth said, as though I had no say in this at all. It didn't matter. I'd be their boy toy for now.

"I understand. I just need this now. Tonight. With you two." Penny whispered with some urgency in her voice.

I positioned myself between her legs and began to massage her clit. She was already soaking wet so I didn't feel the need to go down on her first. Beth was in her ear and whispering to her, "It may hurt a little at first. Evan is bigger than most guys I've dated. But he will take it nice and slow and you can say stop if you want it to end."

I felt movement and I assumed that was a nod of Penny's head. I was about to spit on my hand when Beth said, "Let me make sure he's good and hard. You definitely don't want a limp dick your first time." I felt more movement and then Beth's amazing lips on my cock.

I would have been just fine to finish in her mouth, but I knew the assignment. When I was plenty hard, Beth aimed me at Penny's opening.

Penny was already moaning from my fingers and she gasped when my cock head touched her. I slowly pushed in and met quite a bit of resistance. I guess I've never fucked a virgin and didn't know anything about it. But it could also have been her nervousness.

Beth sensed this and went back to Penny's head. She whispered, "Penny, I need you to relax. Remember how much you want this. Give yourself over to it. Let Evan in. He's tender and will bring you to another amazing orgasm if you let him." Then she kissed Penny, surely with a lot of tongue.

That was all it took. Penny relaxed and suddenly I was halfway in. Penny groaned in a way that it was hard to tell if it was pleasure or pain. I waited a few heartbeats and pulled back out, to the head at least. Then I pushed back in, about three quarters of the way. Again there was the groan. This time Penny's hand also came down to my waist and held me from going deeper.

I pulled back and then went in again. I repeated the motion, each time halting at Penny's hand. Then, her hand moved away. I pulled out and then pushed in. Not all the way yet, but nearly so. With the next push I felt my balls nudge her ass. I was in.

I picked up a pace that was gentle but constant and Penny moaned the whole time. My hands were on her tits, which were so amazing to the touch. Beth's tits settled into her chest and a little to her side when she was on her back. Penny's stood just as upright laying down as when she was standing. I liked these tits to play with.

Penny was beginning to get close to an orgasm when I felt movement on the mattress. I realized that Beth was standing. I didn't know where she was going. Without warning Beth switched on the lights and we all blinked. When my eyes adjusted I looked down at Penny to find a lovely orgasmic face.

Beth came back to us and said, "I told you I wanted to see my boyfriend's cock in you. I also want to watch your face as you cum. Then I want you to watch his so you can see the potential you have to give pleasure if you use your body right."

Beth watched me fucking Penny with rapt attention. She had her hand between her on legs and was getting herself off as she did. I was close and I could tell Penny was closer.

Penny growled deeply as her hands pressed down hard on the mattress. Her hips raised up and pushed against me at the same time. Her head rocked side to side as her climax gripped her and it seemed her eyes rolled back in her head. It was like she was possessed.

Penny's pussy tightened so much that I couldn't postpone it any longer. I came in her hard and as I leaned into her and kissed her as we reached the height of bliss together.

I collapsed on her and saw Beth with a huge smile as she came on her own hand. She lay down next to us and we enjoyed another three way kiss.

Then we all got up to dress. Penny said, "Thank you so much. It was everything I wanted. I want to do it again with you guys soon."

Beth replied with a stern voice, "I think we'd like that too. But you made a promise. Respect our boundaries and we will let you in. Disrespect us and we will shut you out.

Penny smiled. Kissed Beth. And said, "Agreed."

I opened the door and we walked out. It's not like the crowd was waiting and watching for the door to open, but many people saw us leave the room. A couple of the goofier guys came over to high five me, but I offered a menacing look and put an arm around each girl as I walked them to the bar for a beer.

When it was getting late, Beth and I noticed Penny on the dance floor with a guy I vaguely knew from class. Nice guy, Paul I think was his name. Really tall. Probably 6'4" so he was easily a foot taller than Penny.

They were slow dancing and Penny was grinding in his waist. I knew there was a hard on between them. Penny looked up and made a "come here" motion with her finger. Paul bent down and she whispered in his ear. Paul's eyes went wide. Then he grinned and nodded. Penny took his hand and headed for the closet.

Beth turned to me, "I think we've created a monster. A slutty monster." Then she ran to catch up to them. Beth pulled Paul down and whispered in his ear. He looked at Penny with shock in his eyes. Then he pulled her into the closet.

When Beth got back to me I asked her what she said. "Oh," she replied, "I just told him where and when to bite her."

"I think we should leave before that monster howls," I said with a laugh. We headed back to the dorm for another nice fucking.

Beth's roommate Dawn had already gone to sleep so we made love very quietly. When we both came, I told Beth to look over at the other bed. Dawn was staring at us with a smile on her face. I knew Beth was thrilled. She really wanted to be watched.

We both winked at Dawn. She smiled and turned over. We fell asleep in one another's arms.