An Unconventional Family Affair

Author's Note: 'An Unconventional Family Affair' is my entry for this year's 'Tis the Season... for Conception' challenge. It's an 'Erotic Coupling/Breeding', 'Taboo', 'Fetish', 'Cuckold/Hotwife', 'Age-Play', 'ménage à trois' crossover story in which I confront two rarely discussed aspects of human sexuality, namely failure to conceive and sexual incompatibility in a marriage. If one's negative emotions fester from either of these uncomfortable topics, they can lead to grief, sadness, anger, resentment, guilt, shame, anxiety, depression, isolation, loneliness, loss of control, and even decreased self-esteem. This upbeat fictional story aims to illustrate that such problems in a marriage are not insurmountable if one is imaginative and unconventional, as the characters in this story are in their pentad family. Finally, I thank Literotica member 'NaughteeDragon' for organizing this Literotica competition.

If you like this story, please vote favorably.

****

Background

Professor David Shelby and his friend and colleague, Professor Victoria Bruno, are faculty members of a prestigious medical school. Dave's a handsome, red-headed, 45-year-old infectious disease expert. Dave's wife, Joan, passed three years ago. Since then, he hasn't been romantically involved with another woman. That's a three-year dry spell.

Vicki's a stunning 43-year-old molecular biologist of Italian descent. Her long black hair accentuates her curvy body and bronze Mediterranean complexion. Vicki's husband, Harold, is the CEO of a small biotech company. They're happily married and have a twenty-one-year-old daughter, Alice, who resides in Manhattan.

Dave and Vicki have known each other for more than a decade. Once a month, they usually have lunch together to discuss an aspect of their biomedical research. While their friendship has always been professional, that was about to change.

****

The Proposition

Dave picked up his ringing cellphone and uttered his standard greeting, "Professor Shelby speaking. How can I help you?"

"Hi Dave. It's Vicki. Are you available for lunch? It's on me," Vicki began their conversation.

"Sure. I never turn down a free meal. Is there a particular topic you would like to discuss? Is our Department Chairman still trying to get you to teach a graduate-level molecular biology course to disinterested medical students?" Dave guessed.

Vicki laughed. "No, that's not it. I wish it were that simple. Nevertheless, you guessed it. I need valuable advice from one I can trust. Can we have lunch at a nearby location that's private and quiet? I don't want others to hear what I have to say," Vicki tested the waters.

"A secret always gets my attention. I can be discreet. I'll meet you in the school cafeteria. It's a sunny day. Why don't we take our lunches outside and sit on the Dean's manicured lawn where we can talk in private?" he suggested.

Thirty minutes later, Vicki and Dave met in the designated cafeteria. After Vicki paid for their meals, the two headed outside. After both were comfortable, Dave started their conversation. "What's this about? I'm intrigued."

"Thanks for agreeing to meet me today on such short notice. Do you mind if I ask you a few personal, non-academic questions? I'm nervous, but what I have to say today is my daughter's idea and for her benefit," Vicki began.

"Okay, shoot," Dave responded.

"Here goes. Are you aware that Alice is a lesbian who's living with her partner in New York City? Alice and Rachel have been together for three years, ever since they were college roommates. Once she obtained her business degree and Rachel her architecture degree, they moved to the Big Apple for their jobs and more acceptance of their sexuality. Alice and Rachel recently married," Vicki offered.

"I didn't know that. You rarely discuss your daughter. I don't think we've met. The world's changed since we were teenagers. Homosexuality is tolerated nearly everywhere these days, at least in America's Blue States. I hope she and her partner are happy, but what does this have to do with me?" Dave questioned.

"I'm getting to that. Now that they're married and their professional careers have progressed, Alice wants to give birth to a child. Rachel supports that decision. To do that, Alice can go to a fertility clinic in New York City to obtain an anonymous donor's sperm. The problem with that crapshoot approach is that she will have no idea about the genetics of the donor. She, therefore, decided she wants to get pregnant by a mature man, whom I select, who is healthy, tall, in shape, highly intelligent, fertile, professionally successful, and White. To her, you're known as 'Mr. X'. To get bred, Alice proposes to have vaginal sex with you every month at the height of her fertility cycle until the deed is done.

"Assuming she eventually gets pregnant and delivers a healthy baby, Alice and Rachel are hoping you'll walk away. Because they're financially well off, Alice and Rachel wish to raise the conceived baby primarily by themselves. There would be no long-term commitment on your part unless you desire it. If you agree, the resulting child will never know who impregnated his/her mother. Even Alice would not know for sure who you are, although she probably can guess.

"I know it's a lot to ask, but Alice and Rachel are desperate. Harold and I love them so much that we both agreed I should talk to you about this delicate matter," Vicki propositioned her colleague.

"Vicki, I'm honored, but I don't think I can have sex with a lesbian who isn't into me. I haven't had intercourse with a woman in three years. Because I also don't have a 'Daddy-Little Girl' fetish, I might not even be able to get it up when it's time for the sex act. The pressure for me to deliver might be too difficult. Don't you have another candidate in mind who's more age-appropriate and sexually active than me?" Dave asked.

"I don't. I've known you for more than a decade. You're a decent man. You're highly intelligent and look younger than your age. The fact that you already have two beautiful children documents the quality of your sperm. Believe me, we've done our homework. After numerous discussions, we unanimously concluded you're our preferred candidate.

"I anticipated your reluctance to breed my daughter, who I admit is more than twenty years younger than you. Would you change your mind if I agreed to have sex with you whenever and wherever you want for an entire year? That's how much I want to help Alice and Rachel out.

"I know you're attracted to me. Many times, you've checked me out in a lustful manner, even though you try to be coy. For what it's worth, I've fantasized about us having an illicit affair ever since I first laid eyes on you and became aware of your intelligence. Your wife was the only reason why I didn't act on my desires in those days," Vicki revealed.

Dave expressed his concern. "Wow, I can't tell you how many times I've imagined having sex with you after my wife passed. What about Harold? I'm not going to upset your marriage."

"Don't worry about him. Harold supports Alice and me. At his biotech company, Harold portrays a dominant persona with his employees. That's just an act. In the bedroom, he's a submissive voyeur who enjoys seeing his hotwife get fucked by my bulls. If he pisses me off at any time, his junk gets caged to remind him who's in charge in our marriage. He'll do whatever I say because his primary 'love language' is 'acts-of-service'.

"He's discreet, but Harold is also bisexual. These days, he's probably more homosexual than heterosexual. He enjoys watching my sex acts and then cleaning me up. In fact, I think he's become addicted to my creampies. He's also a talented cocksucker of alpha men. Do you want to talk to Harold directly to get confirmation of my claims?

"Just so you know, Harold and I have a complicated open, but successful, marriage. Despite our sexual incompatibility, I love Harold and appreciate what he's able to bring to the table in our marriage. For example, he's a great father and has always supported Alice financially and mentally," Vicki revealed.

"I admit I'm fascinated by your family's story. You got my attention. Let me get this straight, though - we're now going to be intimate, as well as remaining colleagues and friends?

"I hate condoms. What happens if you get pregnant after one of our sexcapades? Our contemplated affair can't adversely affect our professional careers, our academic standings, and even your husband's leadership role at his company," Dave decided. He considered the long-term ramifications of the proposed 'ménage à trois' if it was ever discovered by one of their foes.

"It will be our four-way secret, namely between my daughter, you, Harold, and me. Even Alice's wife is unaware of the plan. To her, you're simply an unknown sperm-bank donor. Regarding my pregnancy risk, I doubt that can happen, considering my age. Anyway, we'll cross that bridge in the future if it occurs. I'm not worried. At worst, Harold and I will raise the child on our own if we keep it. You don't have to be involved if that's your decision," Vicki tried to alleviate his concerns.

"Okay, why don't you and Harold come to my place this evening so we can discuss your proposal in more depth. Specifically, I've got to be sure he's comfortable with it," Dave suggested.

"He's already on board, but we'll be there at 8:00 pm once you text me your home address. To seduce you, I'll wear something sexy. We can start our affair tonight," Vicki proposed. "Instead of a handshake, our first sex act (in Harold's presence) will be to cement your participation in our scheme to get Alice pregnant."

At the designated time, the couple rang the doorbell at the front door of Dave's home. Vicki was wearing a Flamingo-colored Monique Lhuillier designer gown draped over her naked body. The stunning evening dress left little to the imagination. Vicki's DDD breasts were falling out of the tight-fitting gown. Due to the large slit up the dress's front, her hairless vagina was visible when she walked or sat down in a chair. Just above her clit, a diamond-encrusted piercing sparkled in the light.

When Dave opened the door, Vicki jumped into Dave's arms and gave him a huge kiss. Harold shook his hand in a more reserved manner. The three entered the house's living room, and Dave rested in his favorite chair. Vicki and Harold sat on the room's couch.

Vicki began the conversation. "Dave, do you remember my husband, Harold? You briefly met him at a couple of academic gatherings. I brought him along, as you requested, to confirm our lunchtime conversation. Please feel free to ask him any questions you want.

"It's nice to meet you again, Harold. I sought your presence tonight to confirm the over-the-top proposition your wife offered me. Specifically, Vicki requests that I impregnate your lesbian daughter so that she and her wife can have a child. As an incentive, Vicki's agreed to have sex with me anytime and anywhere this year. She told me that you enjoy seeing your wife get fucked by virile men. Apparently, you're also willing to prep and clean up. For this scenario to occur, I need to hear you say, for the record, that you agree and support Vicki's and Alice's outlandish scheme," Dave stated.

"She's right," Harold confessed. "I like to see her get taken by those dominant men I admire. Although she's still my wife, Vicki requires the physical and mental attention in our bedroom that I'm not always able to give her. I'm here for Vicki's and your enjoyment."

"That's all I needed to hear, Harold. For us to move forward, my only request now is that we keep this agreement secret. Okay, let's move to the bedroom so that I can enjoy Vicki's body for the first time. I've wanted to screw her for years. It's now going to happen," Dave announced.

The three headed toward the master bedroom. Dave and Vicki held hands as they proceeded down the hallway. When Dave unzipped Vicki's gown, the released dress fell to the floor. Harold picked it up and quietly sat in a nearby chair, holding the folded item. Dave and Vicki French-kissed. After fondling and sucking her voluptuous breasts, caressing her butt, and nibbling her sensitive neck like a vampire, Dave forced his infatuation onto his bed. Lying face up, Dave spread Vicki's pussy with his hands and then proceeded to go down on this incredible MILF in front of her husband.

"Oh my, you've had considerable practice giving oral to a woman. You know what you're doing. Get me off, Dave. It won't take long. I'm incredibly wet. Can't you tell? Fuck yeah. HERE I GO. THAT'S YOUR SLUT'S FIRST ONE," Vicki screamed.

After Vicki's orgasm, Dave bent her legs backward toward the bed's headboard. He rubbed her protruding clit with the mushroom head of his seven-inch circumcised cock until she started to squirm once again.

Vicki encouraged her lover to proceed with haste. "Don't be a tease. Fuck me hard and deep. Wack my breasts and bubble-butt while you're screwing me. Let Harold see how a real man takes charge and passionately fucks his hotwife."

Dave increased the pace of his cock's in-and-out penetration of her womb. Just minutes later, he screamed, "Take my cum. Drain my balls. I've got three years of spunk for your pussy. I'm going to fill it to the brim. HERE COMES MY LOAD, YOU SEXY WOMAN," Dave voiced when he climaxed.

Although their sex act was completed faster than intended, Dave rolled off Vicki's sweat-soaked body when he finished. Vicki pointed to her husband and then to the leaking mess. Harold knew what that meant. He dropped his wife's dress on the chair, climbed onto the bed, and placed his mouth on his target. He then enthusiastically licked her sex, ingesting her vagina's nectar and Dave's gift.

"Don't be shy. I know how much you enjoy my creampies. Get all of my lover's cum, honey," Vicki instructed her husband. "I'm not going home with a leaking creampie that could ruin my designer gown. How does it smell and taste? You'd better get used to it. You'll be eating our creampies numerous times this year."

Dave laughed and got dressed. When Harold was done feasting, he handed his naked wife her evening gown. While she pulled up its zipper, Harold used one of the towels in Dave's bathroom to wipe his face.

"Harold, did you forget something? Fuck'n hell. Do I have to tell you everything? Polish Dave's cock and give it a proper kiss before we leave to acknowledge his ability to make me happy," Vicki ordered her husband.

Harold got on his knees and began to suck Dave's deflated penis.

"As soon as Alice is at the height of her fertility cycle, she'll come home," Vicki began to detail her scheme. "Once here, I'll get a hotel room for three days and nights. You can fuck her as many times as you desire during that time. Once you're done with her, I'll satisfy your sexual needs in any way you desire. I'll become your three-hole fuckbuddy this year if that's your preference. I'm available whenever you're horny and need relief. So that you know, I'm looking forward to a wonderful year of pleasure."

Vicki kissed Dave one more time at the front door and then waved goodbye to him as she and her trailing husband stepped onto the sidewalk and headed to their car.

****

Dave Impregnates Alice on His First Attempt

Two weeks after Vicki and Harold met Dave at his home, his cellphone rang. Dave picked up the device and once again uttered his standard greeting, "Professor Shelby speaking. How can I help you?"

"Hi Dave, it's Vicki. It's that time of the month. I just got off the telephone with Alice. She's at the peak of her fertility, as assessed by an 'ovulation predictor kit'. She's on her way. Her airplane will arrive in an hour. I reserved a suite at an upscale hotel for you and her.

"Are you available tonight? If you are, I can collect you at your home when you're ready. In that way, you don't have to worry about finding the hotel and navigating the downtown traffic," she offered.

"I'll finish up here shortly. I'll then go home and get cleaned up. I'll be ready at 9. See you then. Will you be present during the sex act?" Dave questioned Vicki to get mentally prepared for what was to happen.

"Unless you don't want me to, I thought I would be there the first time to introduce Alice to you and to ensure that everything goes smoothly. I'm also willing to help in any way I can to get you aroused so that you can nut inside her. Just so you're aware, she's never been with a man. While Alice is nervous, I'm confident she won't chicken out because she's desperate to get pregnant," Vicki brought Dave up to speed.

At 9:30 pm, Dave and Vicki entered Alice's hotel room. The young woman was lying on the hotel's queen-sized bed in her underwear.

Vicki introduced the couple. "Alice, this is 'Mr. X'. He's the anonymous man I selected who's going to try to impregnate you tonight. Mr. X, this is my daughter, Alice. She's looking forward to your attempt to help her."

After some small talk, the three unanimously concluded it was time to begin.

"Alice, your mother informed me that you've never been with a man. Are you a virgin? Have you been penetrated?" Dave inquired.

"While I haven't had a man's penis inside me, my partner, Rachel, regularly fucks me with a strap-on. Taking your cock, therefore, shouldn't be a problem," Alice informed Mr. X.

"That's good news. Nevertheless, I promise to be gentle. Your mother will be present to comfort you. If you want me to stop or pause at any time, just give us a verbal signal. Let's begin. Place a pillow under your butt so that my sperm doesn't rapidly leak out of you. That will give the little guys a decent chance of fertilizing your egg. To warm you up, do you want me to go down on you? Alternately, if you brought your favorite dildo with you, should I use that toy before we begin?" Dave inquired.

"Thanks, but I'm ready. I've been thinking about getting knocked up ever since Mom brought you to my attention. I've also had a couple of drinks to take the edge off and loosen up. Even though I'm a lesbian, I'm confident you'll be able to give me an orgasm," Alice guessed.

While lying on the hotel bed in the missionary position. Dave parted Alice's legs and slowly inserted his cock into her. She let out a gasp when he was halfway in. When that occurred, Vicki kissed the forehead of her daughter, and the eyes of the two women met. Vicki held one of Alice's hands while Dave bottomed out and then slowly fucked the girl's tight pussy. Alice closed her eyes and tried to imagine her wife.

Alice's free hand grabbed the surrounding sheet. Her body tensed, and she experienced an orgasm. It was a solid 8 on her 1-10 orgasm scale. Seconds after that occurred, Dave shot his wad inside her.

When the deed was done. Vicki once again kissed her daughter's forehead. She then kissed Dave's mouth and expressed her appreciation. "You're tremendous. What a devoted friend! My daughter, her wife, my husband, and I are indebted to you. I look forward to our intimate time together whenever you're ready to begin in earnest."

Vicki then informed her daughter, "Honey, keep your hips raised for the next thirty minutes to increase the chances of getting pregnant. Once I say goodnight to Mr. X, I'll spend the entire night with you to ensure that you don't have any regrets."

"It was great meeting you, Mr. X. Thanks for your help. Rachel and I mean it," Alice uttered as the stranger headed to the hotel room's front door.

Vicki held Dave in her arms and kissed him passionately.

"Good night, Lover," Vicki said, expressing her true feelings for the man she'd known and admired for years.

"Same to you, Baby. I'll call you tomorrow to make sure everything went well," Dave said his farewell.

"Good luck, Alice. I hope you get your wish," Dave bellowed over his shoulder.

****

Good News

Thirty days later, Dave's cellphone rang again. It was Vicki. She was calling to inform him that Alice's pregnancy test was positive today.

"Dave, for a 45-year-old man, you have primo sperm. It took you just one attempt to get Alice pregnant. It's time for you to get paid. When and where do you want me? I'm ready to receive your 'USDA Prime' sperm," Vicki offered.

"Let's do it tonight," Dave decided.

"Do you mind if Harold accompanies me? You know how much he enjoys seeing you fuck me. He's also been begging for a fresh creampie all week," Vicki let it be known.

Dave laughed. "Sure, he can tag along. He should be able to get a decent meal tonight."

****

Epilogue

Dave and Vicki had been having sex regularly for the last three months. They had become inseparable. Today, Dave's cellphone rang as it did most days. The picture and telephone number that appeared on his device's screen indicated that Vicki was calling.

"Hi Vicki. What can I do for you? I thought we're having dinner tomorrow. Did I mess up my calendar?" Dave started the conversation.

"Um, Dave, are you sitting down? I've got something unexpected to tell you. I hope you don't get mad, but you knocked me up. I started throwing up a couple of days ago. I initially thought I got infected by an intestinal bug. However, because it felt more like morning sickness this morning, I went to the drug store to obtain a fertility test kit. The results came back positive.

"Considering my age, I assumed I couldn't get pregnant. There's no doubt about the quality and power of your sperm. After thinking about our situation, I decided to keep the baby, even though I can only imagine the gossip that will most likely occur at our Institution. For years, many of its faculty have seen us having lunch together.

"Of concern, what if our baby has your red hair? How am I going to explain that to my Italian mother and father, and my friends and colleagues? My Catholic parents will probably want me to go to confession to get absolved of my sins by their priest.

"Can you believe that Alice, you, and I created a bizarre overlapping genealogy and genetics loop where the two children fathered by you will be both half-siblings and a niece/nephew to one another?" Vicki tried to figure out the complex relationship of the two children once they're born.

"Relax. There's nothing that can be done right now. Harold, Alice, Rachel, you, and I will deal with whatever issues surface down the road. The logistics of how the two babies will be raised must be worked out, but, overall, I'm pleased. How are Alice and Harold taking it?" Dave asked.

"Alice is consumed with her own pregnancy. She doesn't want to think about my situation. Harold, on the other hand, is confident the child will be a boy. He always wanted a son. He's, therefore, excited and is looking forward to helping raise the child. He wants the child to have two fathers," Vicki replied.

"I'm pleased you decided to keep the baby. At my age, I thought I wouldn't have another child. Having said that, I'm going to enjoy seeing him develop. I'm also looking forward to our adult play tonight. I can't wait to see your breasts blow up in the next couple of months when they become filled with the tasty, sweet milk that I plan on sharing with our baby," Dave staked his claim on a significant percentage of Vicki's future breast milk.

"My breast milk? Really? That's what you are looking forward to? I didn't realize what a freak you are when it comes to a misshapen, lactating, mature woman like me. Do you know what this pregnancy is going to do to my luscious body? The size of my breasts will probably balloon to a 'J' or 'G' cup. Due to their immense size and weight, they'll probably sag to my knees. I'll have to spend months in the gym to regain my shape after our baby's delivered. You and Harold can pay for my expensive physical trainer.

"I got a feeling you're going to get lucky tonight. I'm incredibly horny and ready to get it on. That's what the early stages of a pregnancy can do for a woman when her hormonal imbalance is out of control. See you tonight, Lover. I'm going to take a shower to prepare for you. Let yourself in the front door. I'll be nude, lying on our bed waiting for you. I plan on having multiple orgasms tonight. You, therefore, better be on your 'A' game," Vicki threatened.

The End