SexyText - porn stories and erotic novellas

The Real Villain

This essay was originally published for the Winter Holiday 2026 Story Contest.

'It's a Wonderful Life' is a 1946 American Christmas fantasy drama film directed and produced by Frank Capra. It is based on the short story and booklet "The Greatest Gift", self-published by Philip Van Doren Stern in 1943, which itself is loosely based on the 1843 Charles Dickens novella A Christmas Carol.

Although the film was well received, it did not recoup its production costs, and its copyright in the U. S. expired in 1974, and it entered the public domain, allowing it to be broadcast without licensing or royalty fees, at which point it became a Christmas classic.

'It's a Wonderful Life' is now considered to be one of the greatest films of all time and among the best Christmas films. I try to watch it each year, if I am able, and I have thought about it more than is probably reasonable.

I have a theory about the real villain in the movie...

 

**********

 

 

The Real Villain

 

 

In 'It's A Wonderful Life'

 

 

**********

 

If you have watched 'It's A Wonderful Life', it is obvious who the Villain is supposed to be. That would be 'Henry F. Potter, the richest and meanest man in the county'. His greed and corruption (for example, having a Congressman at his beck and call) are obvious. In the alternate timeline where George Bailey is never born, Bedford Falls is even renamed to Pottersville in his honor. Everything changes from the wholesomeness of Bedford Falls to the big city trashiness of Pottersville. The bars serve hard liquor to men who want to get drunk quick, the dance hall has turned into a strip joint, and Violet Bickes is a lady of the evening.The Real Villain фото

But Mr Potter isn't the villain of the story. Sure, he is evil and self-serving, but he isn't the villain. He doesnt ruin George Bailey's plans for his life.

Neither is Uncle Billy, the doddering old fool who precipitated the events of the movie by accidentally giving Mr Potter money meant to be deposited. The forgetful old fool is too stupid to be a villain.

Who else could it be, then? It isn't George's brother, Harry. Harry would have worked at the Building and Loan while George went off to school, except that the board appointed George to stave off Mr Potter. He also intended to return from college to replace his older brother, except that George released him from that promise so that he could follow his wife Ruth's plan to get into 'research'.

So, who else could it be?

Who else, indeed.

Who is the real villain of 'It's A Wonderful Life?'

Mary Bailey, born Mary Hatch.

You don't believe me, do you? Fair enough. Let me tell you what my repeated viewings of the movie have revealed. The first scene where we meet George and Mary sets the tone for the whole sordid affair.

Picture this: George is telling Mary of his plans to travel the world when he gets older and shows her the new magazine he just received from 'The National Geographic Society'. Mary is unimpressed by his plans, and when he is distracted making her ice cream sundae, she leans over and starts casting her first spell on him, "I'll love you until the day I die."

Sure, that isn't villain behavior, by itself. But not caring what your partner wants from their life? That sounds like villainy to me.

But the real villainy? That takes place after Harry's graduation party dance, where George and Mary, and lots of others, end up in the pool. While walking Mary home, they stopped at the old Granville Place and broke some glass so they could each get a wish.

That is sweet, right? Just a fun bit of petty vandalism between friends.

Except what happened immediately afterwards? George's father, Peter Bailey, dies of a stroke which traps George as Executive Director of the Building and Loan.

What does that have to do with Mary's Villainy? Well, we find out the day of George and Mary's wedding. After the run on the bank (and the Building and Loan), George finds Mary in the rundown, leaking money pit of a house. When they come together, she confesses that this is what she wished for: to be married to George and living in that old run-down drafty barn of a house.

She wished for what she wanted, killing George's father and trapping George in Bedford Falls in the process. Forever.

Forever? Isn't that a bit much?

No. No, it isn't.

George had saved two thousand dollars cash for his honeymoon so that he and Mary could travel the world, and what did Mary do with that money? She waved it in front of a crowd of desperate people during the run on the banks and George had to use it to save the Building and Loan. That was the last time the couple had any spare money until the end of the movie.

They didn't even have money available to travel with Sam Wainwright and his wife when they offered to have the young couple join their trip to Florida. George just couldn't get away.

When the Angel Joseph is explaining Clarance's mission, he even says that George never leaves Bedford Falls. He is trapped there forever by Mary's unthinking wish.

Georges' financial chains are finally broken at the end of the film when his friends, family, and even the police who had come to arrest him, donate funds to help him. Yes, that outpouring of support is because Mary organized it, but only after the Divine Intervention of at least three angels.

Make no mistake about it, Mary Bailey is the real villain of 'It's A Wonderful Life'. She got what she wanted, and George never left Bedford Falls.

 

**********

 

Thank you for reading!

Rate the story «The Real Villain»

📥 download as: txt  fb2  epub    or    print
Leave comments - we pay for them!

There are no comments yet - be the first to add one!

Add new comment


Our AI advises

You need to log in so that our AI can start recommending suitable works that you will definitely like.