Headline
Message text
My Dirty Secret Santa
Authors' Notes
This is our entry in the 2026 Winter Holidays Contest. This one is a gradual, slow-burn build with some anonymous erotic teasing developing along the way. All text messages in this story have been largely translated into actual prose, rather than just a string of letters.
To be clear, all characters involved in any type of sexual activity are at least 18 years old. To be even clearer, all characters in this story exist only in our imaginations and where our imaginations touch the page--but when we do imagine them, all such characters are 18 or older.
We hope you enjoy! -- C&S
Part 1 - The Thanksgiving Weekend Party
Chapter 1
"Never have I ever... given a guy a blowjob," Nicole announces, looking around the circle at the other gameplayers--me, my little sister, and seven more of my sister's friends.
I call Sabrina "my little sister," but I should clarify. She's in her first year of college. Eighteen years old. Everyone in the circle is eighteen or nineteen. Well, everyone but me.
Sabrina's mom and my dad got married fifteen years ago, when she was three and I was ten. Even though she's technically my stepsister, and even though she's now technically an adult, to me at least, she'll always be "my little sister."
Most of the circle blushes and there is nervous laughter at Nicole bringing up blowjobs on her turn. My sister Sabrina's face goes beet red.
"Damnit, Nicole!" Sabrina says, motioning in my direction. "My brother's right here and you have to bring up who's given a blowjob."
Sabrina puts on a good show, but her shock is mostly feigned. This type of potentially awkward escalation is par with my sister and her friends. Somehow, they always drag me into these little games of theirs, which always quickly devolve into whatever topic was most embarrassing at their age. It started with bathroom jokes and cooties. Now I guess we're up to blowjobs.
My sister has always been a social butterfly with a close group of friends. All nine girls in the circle have been friends since at least middle school. Some of them since early elementary. Being seven years their senior, I've watched them all grow up. I like to imagine that they think of me, Brad, as Sabrina's cool, cute older brother, but if I'm being honest, I probably top out at older and awkward but fun.
Nicole's fiery red hair, which matches her personality, bounces as she laughs at my sister's shock. Nicole has always been the group's resident troublemaker, especially when it came to embarrassing conversation topics. Pulling out the question that everyone wanted to answer and no one wanted to ask is her superpower.
About half the girls in the circle take a drink of their wine cooler.
I try not to notice that my sister is one of the girls who is drinking. Well, really, I try my best to not picture which of the string of my sister's loser boyfriends have had their dick in her mouth.
Rather than facing the existential dread of that image, I bring my beer up towards my lips, as if I'm about to drink.
"Wait a minute," Megan shrieks, her eyes going wide as she falls for my joke. "Brad, have you...?"
Mouths fall open and conversation stops around the circle as the girls wonder whether I am about to admit to giving a blowjob. I let the moment hang for just a beat.
"No, no," I say, laughing and shaking my head. "Just screwing with y'all to break the tension. I've never had a guy's dick in my mouth."
The near shock around the circle turns to cackles of laughter and comments of "Good one, Brad."
"You had me going for a second!" Megan says with a sly grin.
At nineteen, Ashley is the oldest of the girls. Even amongst a group whose aesthetic tends towards the preppy and polished, Ashley has always stood out as tailored and refined. She also carries a knack for making even the most normal of interactions feel close and flirty. I haven't seen her since this summer. A single semester into her sophomore year, she seems to carry herself with even more poise than I remember from her younger days.
"Never have I ever," Ashley begins, "had a one-night stand."
This time I have to drink for real, and it's little surprise that I'm the only one who does. Eyebrows rise around the circle as if an explanation is expected.
"What?" I say. "There was a girl in college. We always had a flirtatious energy between us that never had a chance to go anywhere. One night, we both had some drinks and found ourselves alone. But it was all very respectable. We were good friends before and after. Nothing scandalous."
"If you say so," Brittney says with a smirk, before whispering, "Man-whore," just loud enough for the whole circle to hear.
I smile and extend my middle finger towards Brittney, who smiles back and gives a mock bow from her seat.
These little parties have become a part of the unwritten culture of my sister's group of friends. No one has to announce it. The weekend after Thanksgiving they get together and celebrate. There will be another party the day after Christmas. Some time when they were in high school, they told me that I had a standing invitation to join them and that they would be more than a little hurt if I didn't.
Rachel sits beside Ashley, looking faintly embarrassed by how quickly the game is going off the rails. Rachel is the quiet one of the group. Smart with long, straight brown hair, soft brown eyes, and the sort of understated prettiness you might overlook if you were only interested in girls who demanded attention. She's also one of the few people I know who always gives out good book recommendations.
"Never have I ever," Rachel says, "had a crush on a fictional character."
Everyone nods as the suspicion that both Megan and Tiffany would have to drink on this one is confirmed.
Tiffany speaks first. "Make fun if you like, but I've never met a guy who could live up to Westley. He can be my farm boy any day."
Megan chuckles as eyes turn towards her. "Hey," she says, "Xaden can wrap me up in shadows and bring out my lightning anytime he wants."
The gaiety that erupts around the circle reminds me of why I'm glad that they pull me into these little gatherings, even if I would never admit it. Sure, these girls are my sister's besties, not mine, but I've known each of them for somewhere close to a decade. We've shared pool parties, gatherings for my sister's birthdays and holiday celebrations, and embarrassing conversations. Through their crushes, awkward dates, and heartbreaking moments, I have been an ear that would listen and a shoulder on which to cry. When my girlfriend dumped me right before junior prom, a gaggle of ten-year-old girls showed up with homemade cookies and a handwritten list of reasons that she was stupid and I deserved better. I still have that list somewhere. This really is a special group, and I love being a part of it, even if it's just at the edges.
Kelsey seems to be considering whether to follow Rachel's lead and cool things down or turn the heat back up. Athletic, honey-blonde, and almost always sporting a competitive grin, Kelsey had been trying to beat me at practically everything since middle school. The fact that I was seven years older had never discouraged her, even when she was a kid.
"Never have I ever," Kelsey says, "gone skinny-dipping."
Kelsey gives a smug smile as Brittney takes a drink.
Looking at Kelsey out of the side of her eye, Brittney cranks her wrist like a music box until her middle finger pops up, and says, "Mind the business that pays you, Kelsey!"
Kelsey gives Brittney a faux stern expression, saying, "We're not surprised, Brittney, just disappointed."
Brittney is the least inhibited girl in the group, maybe the least inhibited person I've ever met. She is short, blonde, and curvy with bright blue eyes and a winsome smile that gives her an appearance of innocence, at least until she opens her mouth. She always ends up drinking the most during games like this, as it doesn't seem that there's much that she hasn't done.
Up next is Megan. When it comes to personality, Megan is a perfect fit for the group. But, when it comes to fashion, her appearance is strikingly distinct. Most of the group's fashion sense leans toward the preppy side, but Megan's style is what my sister calls "Alt Girl." It reminds me of the mall goths from when I was in high school. She typically wears black baby tees, crop tops, low-rise jeans, or short plaid skirts with clunky shoes. Plus, I think she has every piece of silver jewelry that Hot Topic has to offer. She's one of the quietest members of my sister's group of friends, especially around new people, but when she warms up enough to talk, what she says is invariably clever.
"Never have I ever lied about liking something to impress somebody," Megan says.
No one drinks, so Megan has to. She doesn't seem to mind though.
My stepsister Sabrina is up next. She's the group's center and unofficial leader, the one who has been the glue holding the girls together since middle school. We're certainly close, but she has an annoying habit of finding joy in my embarrassment. She always knows just the right buttons to push, just the right prank to pull, and just the right direction to steer the conversation to keep me flustered and her entertained by it.
And the look on her face tells me that she has just thought of something that is sure to make me want to hide under a table.
"Never have I ever," Sabrina begins, giving me an impish grin, "had a crush on Brad."
I nearly drop my drink and now it's my turn to go beet red.
"Fuck, Sabrina," I blurt out. "You can't ask them tha..."
But then around the room, eyes connect, nods are given, and eight wine coolers rise to lips.
Every. Single. One.
"Are you kidding me?" I ask. "Is this one of you all's pranks at my expense?"
Ashley laughs. "Come on, Brad. I think at some point over the past ten years, every one of us has had at least a little baby crush on you."
"That's," I begin. "I don't know what that is... disturbing, maybe?"
"You're the cute older brother," Emily says. "What did you expect?"
"Not sure what I expected," I admit, "just not that."
"Don't let it go to your head, Brad," Megan says with a roguish grin. "Most of us had questionable taste in middle school."
"And," Tiffany adds, "there's a big difference between having a crush on your friend's cute older brother when you're thirteen and actually wanting to date him when you're eighteen."
"Speak for yourself," Brittney says with a giggle. "Brad can be my farm boy any day."
Brittney and Tiffany exchange smirks that thankfully take some of the focus off me.
"Okay, okay," Sabrina finally says. "Let's keep the game moving before Brad gets all hot and bothered. Your turn, big brother."
Still a little dazed, I try to think of the most boring question I can to spare any future mortification.
"Never have I ever," I say, "had a pet cat."
Boos ring out around the circle.
"Lame question, Brad," Ashley teases.
About half of the circle drinks.
"No pet cats, Brad?" Brittney says, looking like she's just holding back laughter that threatens to explode through.
"No pet cats, Brittney."
"That's too bad," Brittney says, "because Brad seems like the type of guy who could really own a pussy."
And with that the game is officially completely off the rails, but at least the room is full of laughter, even if most of it is at my expense.
Chapter 2
With the game having come to a crashing halt, conversations start up throughout the room. The girls are always good about including me, bringing me into the chitchat, and generally making me feel welcome and a part of the group.
Within a moment, Brittney practically bounces over to me, her shoulder-length golden-blonde hair swinging as she moves. She's wearing a fitted pink sweater, dark jeans, and a pair of fashionable little boots with heels that do their best to compensate for her five-foot-two height. The curviest of the girls in the group, she has the kind of figure that attracts attention, whether she is looking for it or not. Most of the time she is.
"Brad, can I ask you something?" she says, plopping down into the chair next to me.
"Sure. Ask away," I say.
"What the hell is wrong with guys?" she asks.
I chuckle. "I'm not sure I'm qualified to speak for my entire gender, Brittney."
"Well, you're a guy. Explain."
"That's a pretty tall order. Could you narrow it down a little?" I ask.
She sighs. "You know what my problem is?"
"How much time have you got?" I say with a chuckle.
"Asshole," she says, extending the middle finger of the hand holding her wine cooler.
"You asked," I say, taking a drink from my beer.
She laughs, then shakes her head. "Seriously, though. Every guy I meet seems to think I'm only interested in one thing."
"Well, Brittney," I begin with a gentle smile, "to be fair, you do spend a lot of time encouraging that impression."
"I know. But just because I like having fun doesn't mean I don't want somebody who actually likes me."
"That's fair."
"I mean, is it really too much to ask for a guy who's fun and doesn't treat me like an idiot?"
"No. It isn't."
She smiles. "See? That's why you're one of the good ones." Brittney gives me a quick surprise kiss on the cheek that makes my face go warm.
Before I can process it though, Megan is standing in front of us.
Today Megan is wearing low-rise, faded blue jeans that sit so low on her hips that I'm not entirely sure how they don't just fall off, a black baby tee with a tribal-style butterfly on the front that leaves her midriff bare, and chunky black platform Mary Janes. Her sleek, raven-colored hair reaches halfway down her back and perfectly frames her delicate pale face and dark, expressive eyes. She has gracefully proportioned curves that seem to defy her tiny waist and almost impossibly slender build. The whole look is unmistakably Megan, and I have to admit, she wears it well.
"You had me going on that blowjob thing," Megan says with a grin.
"Yeah, I'm not sure if I should be troubled at how ready you all were to believe it," I reply.
"What would be troubling is if, between the two of us, you were the first to give a guy a blowjob. Assuming you're not into that type of thing?" Megan says.
"No, definitely not my thing," I answer.
"Don't worry, Megan," Brittney says with a playfully wicked smile. "I'm sure one day soon, you'll not only see, but actually get to touch a real live penis."
Megan returns Brittney's smile. "I don't know, Brittney. With your hands all over every dick on the horizon, how do the rest of us have a chance?"
Holding her smile, Brittney flips Megan off. Megan responds by making a heart shape with her hands and blowing Brittney a kiss.
"So, Brad," Megan says, "I haven't seen you since this summer. What have you been up to?"
"Mainly just work," I say. "We're working on the integration and database components of a new inventory management system. It has to be finished by December 18, if anyone wants to celebrate Christmas."
"Brad!" Kelsey shouts from across the room. "Come play pool with me."
Our little party is in the finished basement of my parents' house, which contains a pool table that Kelsey loves.
"I'm not good at pool, Kelsey," I shout back.
Despite growing up in this house, I just never took the opportunity to develop my pool skills. Kelsey, however, has been playing on our table for years. Almost every game I've played has been against her and at her insistence. And in every game, she's wiped the table with me.
"Come on, Brad," Kelsey says in her best helpless girl voice. "I'll let you explain the rules to me. You can show me how to move the balls and handle the stick." She pushes out her lower lip, forming a pout.
"You're already amazing at pool, Kelsey. I'm not. You always kill me," I call back, ignoring her innuendo.
"That's why it's so much fun to play you," Kelsey says, leaning forward with a grin.
"I'll play you," Brittney shouts, hopping out of her chair. Then, turning to me, "Not that I'm not enjoying all this talk of integration and inventory, Brad, but someone has to go show Kelsey what's what." Brittney gives me a sultry smile and levels one finger against my chest. "But you owe me. I'll be back to collect." And with that, she bounces across the room to play pool with Kelsey.
"What do you think you owe her?" Megan asks, taking Brittney's recently vacated chair.
"I'm afraid to ask," I admit with a nervous laugh.
"So," Megan says, leaning a bit closer, "just busy with work?"
"Afraid so," I say. "What about you? What have you been up to?"
"I've been working on a new painting," Megan says with a smile.
Megan started painting in middle school and quickly developed a real talent for it. Her work is genuinely impressive.
"What are you working on?" I ask.
"It's a gothic forest scene with a ruined chapel overgrown by vines," she explains. "There's a partially shattered stained-glass window with sunlight shining through it. Sort of a contrast between ruin and beauty."
"Sounds cool," I say. "You'll have to show it to me."
"I will. I'm thinking of entering it in that art show I entered last year."
"Oh, yeah," I say. "The woman in the winter landscape?"
"Yes!" Megan says, her smile widening. For a moment, she looks genuinely surprised that I remembered her painting from the previous year. "I mostly entered last year so people could see my work and hopefully enjoy it. But they also have a contest where people can rate the paintings from one to five. It was exciting watching the votes come in, until they started disappearing."
"Disappearing?" I ask.
"Apparently, the judges periodically delete votes they consider suspicious. A few of my friends made accounts to vote for my painting, but their votes disappeared, along with some other good ratings."
"Why?"
"Nobody knows. The judges won't explain how they decide which votes count." She shakes her head. "Meanwhile, this girl who doesn't like me gave my painting one star just to be nasty. She even bragged about it. But somehow, her vote was perfectly legitimate."
"That's pretty screwed up."
"I know," she says, her eyebrows drawing together. "And I did okay for my first entry, so I shouldn't complain. But most of my friends say they're not going to bother voting again if their votes don't count. It kind of defeats the purpose of sharing my art."
"Did anyone ask the judges to explain?" I ask.
"They say revealing how they identify suspicious votes would just help people cheat."
"Well," I say, "sounds like the people cheating have already figured it out."
"Funny how that works," Megan says with a grin.
"Send me the link when you enter this year. I'll vote for you."
"They'll probably just delete your vote, too."
"Then I'll consider myself in good company."
"With all my suspicious friends?" Megan asks with a chuckle.
"Exactly," I confirm.
"Megan," my sister shouts from across the room. "Come settle an argument."
Sabrina is looking at something on her phone with Emily and Tiffany. Megan excuses herself and makes her way across the room.
In the interim, I take a moment to survey the party.
Brittney has just made a tough, game-changing shot and Kelsey throws up her hands, yelling, "Come on!" as Brittney paces around the table with a look of superiority on her face.
Emily, Tiffany, my sister, and now Megan seem to be arguing the virtues of emotional support guys versus dangerous bad boys in romance novels.
"I'm sorry," Tiffany says in an exasperated voice, "but I don't care how attractive he is. Half the men in these books would be exhausting to date in real life."
Rachel and Nicole are laughing hysterically about something over in the corner.
Then Ashley, who was standing near the pool table, notices me sitting by myself and makes her way over.
Ashley's face bears her usual easy smile as she approaches, her chocolate-brown hair bouncing with her steps. Her dark green, fitted jeans and cream-colored V-neck sweater show off her slender, toned figure that also has curves in all the right places. Ashley has always been equally comfortable complimenting and teasing me, and over the past couple of years a delightfully cozy, flirtatious energy has developed between us.
"Hey, stranger," she says, brushing a strand of chocolate-brown hair behind her ear. "Long time no see."
"Take a seat and join me," I offer, motioning to the empty chair next to me.
Ashley sits down gracefully, scooting the chair in my direction and giving me a warm smile.
"So, how's your second year of college treating you?" I ask, suddenly hyper-aware of how close she's sitting.
"Academically? Great," Ashley begins. "Socially? Entertaining. Romantically? A disaster."
"That bad?" I ask.
"College boys are idiots," she sighs, rolling her eyes with dramatic flair.
"I seem to remember being a college boy myself."
"Exactly. You should know."
"Thanks, Ashley," I say, feigning offense.
"I'm just saying, I'm beginning to appreciate the appeal of older men."
"Older men?" I echo, raising my eyebrows.
"Yeah," she says, "older. More mature. Maybe someone about halfway through their twenties. You know, an old man." Her eyes and her smile let me know she is toying with me.
"Ouch," I say, clutching my chest. "That's a shot right to my ancient, twenty-five-year-old heart."
"I could make it up to you," she says with a wink, her eyes dropping briefly to my lips.
"Always the flirt," I say, shaking my head.
"Hey," she says, leaning in even closer, "maybe one day I'll be serious."
As Ashley slaps me on the knee with a big grin, Nicole and Rachel wander over.
Nicole has wavy, copper-red hair that falls around her shoulders and frames her freckled face. She's wearing fitted black jeans that show off her slender but curvy figure, and a plum-colored blouse that contrasts with and accentuates her bright green eyes. I see the mischievous glint in her eyes that always lets me know she's about to stir up trouble.
Rachel, looking considerably more innocent, follows a step behind.
"So, Brad," Nicole says, taking position in front of me. "I've got a question for you."
"Of course you do," I say, before taking a sip from my beer and bracing myself for what comes next.
"Earlier," she says, her mischievous look not fading in the slightest, "all of us admitted to having a crush on you at some point."
"Unfortunately, that's not something I'm likely to forget anytime soon."
"Well, now I'm curious." Nicole pauses as her grin widens. "Have you ever had a crush on any of us?"
Ashley turns toward me, looking suddenly interested, while I suddenly choke on the pull I had just taken from my beer.
"Shit, Nicole," I say, once I've recovered from the brief coughing fit. "Do you ever stop?"
"Not when there's an important question that needs answering," Nicole says, pulling over a chair and taking a seat.
I glance from Nicole to Ashley, then to Rachel. I briefly consider an escape route, wondering, What would happen if I just made a run for it?
"Are you seriously asking me if I've ever had a crush on one of my little sister's friends?" I ask with an incredulous chuckle, trying to laugh it off.
"That's exactly what I'm asking," Nicole says, leaning forward to prop her chin on her hands.
"There's a seven-year age difference, Nicole." I set my beer down on the coffee table and gesture between us to emphasize my point. "When I was eighteen, you were eleven."
"Thank you for the math lesson," Nicole replies, rolling her eyes playfully and tossing her copper-red hair back. "Here's a current events lesson for you. None of us are eleven anymore."
She holds my gaze, giving me a knowing smile.
"Yes," I murmur, "I've noticed that."
As Ashley raises an eyebrow, widens her smile, and reaches over to nudge Nicole, I feel my cheeks flush and I quickly look away.
"Have you now?" Ashley says. "What exactly have you noticed?"
I could very well be imagining it, but Ashley seems to arch her back, pushing out her chest as she speaks.
"Look..." I stammer, not sure how I got myself stuck in this trap.
"Apparently you have been," Ashley says with a wicked glint.
Yeah, she's definitely thrusting her breasts in my direction. I make a point of maintaining eye contact so that it doesn't become obvious that I've noticed.
"I'm just trying to keep from saying something that gets me into trouble," I say, shaking my head. "And that's become increasingly difficult."
Nicole laughs, a look of triumph flashing in her eyes. "I'm just asking if you have ever had a crush on one of us, and your answer is sounding suspiciously like a yes."
Both Nicole and Ashley lean in closer to me, Ashley with a satisfied grin on her face.
I truly don't know what to say in this moment, but thankfully Rachel jumps in.
"You guys realize that he's never going to give us a name with all of us sitting here," Rachel says.
"I'm just asking for a yes or a no," Nicole says, rhythmically tapping her finger against the chair and refusing to let me off the hook. "No one said anything about a name."
"Look, girls," I say with a sigh, holding up both of my hands in a gesture of surrender. "I've known all of you since you were kids. Never spent time thinking about you in that way."
"Never?" Nicole asks.
Her tone drips with playful skepticism. I give her a look that begs for mercy.
"Nicole," I groan.
"What? I'm just clarifying," Nicole insists. She holds up her hands in feigned innocence.
I shake my head and laugh, hoping to ease the tension.
"I'll admit that you've all grown into beautiful young women," I confess. "But that doesn't mean I've fantasized about my sister's friends."
Ashley's smile widens. "Well, at least he thinks we're beautiful."
"That's what you got from that?" I ask, throwing my hands up in exasperation.
"Of course," Ashley shoots back instantly. She tosses her head with a giggle and then bats her eyes at me.
Nicole studies me for a moment, her green eyes searching my face. Then her expression settles into an amused smile.
"Okay, Brad," she says. "Fair answer."
"Thank goodness," I mutter, reaching for my beer on the coffee table.
"But now I'm wondering something else," Nicole adds, a new spark of mischief lighting up her eyes.
"Of course you are," I say.
I brace myself all over again.
"Would you ever date one of us?" Nicole asks.
I look at her in disbelief, my bottle frozen halfway to my mouth. But then I pause and consider the question for a moment.
"I don't know. Maybe."
"Maybe?" Ashley repeats, her eyebrows shooting up as she quickly leans forward.
"You're all adults now," I say, defensively but honestly. "I guess if something developed naturally with one of you, I wouldn't rule out anything just because you are Sabrina's friend."
Nicole's smile turns catlike. "Interesting."
"But," I add quickly, "there's still a difference between eighteen and twenty-five."
"Seven years," Rachel supplies, offering an innocent blink. "Really only six for Ashley."
I glance over at Rachel, deadpan.
"Thank you, Rachel," I say under my breath.
"Just doing my part," she replies with a cheerful salute.
"So, age is the issue?" Nicole asks.
"Not so much age," I try to explain. "I'm three years into a career. Most of you are in your first semester of college."
"Well," Ashley notes, "I'm a sophomore."
I shake my head and can't help but chuckle.
Ashley just grins.
"All I'm saying is that I'd have to think about it," I mutter, trying to cling to even a shred of dignity.
Ashley holds my gaze, her expression fading into a coquettish smile. "Good to know," she murmurs.
Chapter 3
"Okay," Sabrina calls out, and I don't think I've ever been so delighted to hear her voice fill a room. "I have an announcement. Everyone, listen up."
The conversations gradually die down as everyone turns toward my sister.
"So, I've been thinking about what we should do for our Christmas party this year, and I've decided that the ten of us are doing Secret Santa."
A chorus of enthusiastic responses comes from around the room.
"Wait," I say, looking at Sabrina. "The ten of us?"
"Yes, ten," she replies, giving me that all-too-familiar grin. "Including you, big brother."
"I'm beginning to think I should've stayed upstairs."
"Oh, quit complaining," Brittney says. "You love us."
"Against my better judgment."
"See?" she replies with a bright smile. "He admits it."
Sabrina waits for the laughter to subside before continuing.
"Anyway, I found this website that does the whole thing for us. I'm sending everybody a link. Just open it on your phone, join the group, and put in your info. Once everybody's signed up, I'll have it draw the names."
"And how do we know you won't rig it?" Kelsey asks.
"I don't pick the names, genius. The website does. I won't even know who gets assigned to who."
"That's exactly what somebody planning to rig it would say," I observe.
"Very funny, Brad," Sabrina says, glaring at me. "The whole point is that it's secret. Everybody finds out who they're buying for, but nobody knows who's buying for them."
"What's the spending limit?" Ashley asks.
"Thirty bucks," Sabrina answers. "That should be enough to get something decent without bankrupting anyone."
Sabrina sends out the link via text and phones start chiming around the room.
I pull out my phone, click the link for the invitation, and enter my information on the site.
One by one, voices from around the room announce that they are signed up.
"Okay," Sabrina finally says, studying her phone. "Is that everybody? Ready?"
Sabrina taps her screen and a moment later, my phone buzzes. I open the notification, and it informs me who I will be shopping for.
"Everybody got somebody?" Sabrina asks.
Nods and affirmative responses go around the room.
"Good. And remember," Sabrina instructs, "it's called Secret Santa. No telling who you got. We reveal everything at the Christmas party."
I slip my phone back into my pocket, my brain already spinning with gift ideas for my assigned girl.
Part 2 - The December Text Exchange
Chapter 4 (December 1)
I almost missed the first message entirely.
After work, I headed straight for the gym for a game of pickup basketball. There's a good group of us there that have been playing together for a while. I try to make it several times a week.
But I left my phone in my gym bag, so I didn't see the text during the game.
After the game, I headed straight home without looking at my phone, took a much-needed shower, and finally remembered to check my phone.
Now, I'm standing in my steamy bathroom, wearing only a towel wrapped around my waist, and staring at a picture of a naked woman that was sent to me hours ago.
Well, it's sort of a picture of a naked woman. Let me explain.
The image is black and white, tightly cropped so all I can see is the line of her neck, the ridge of her collarbone and one bare shoulder disappearing into the shadow. That's all it shows. She could be wearing clothing outside the frame, but there's none in the picture. The image itself isn't especially revealing, but there is something very sensual and intimate about its composition. The person who took this knew precisely how much to show and how much to leave to the imagination.
The text is from an unknown number. Below the picture is a message.
Unknown Number : Ho! Ho! Ho! This is your Secret Santa, and I've decided to give you the deluxe treatment. Here's a sneak peek at your present.
My immediate thought: This is someone fucking with me.
I send a text back.
Brad : Is this Sabrina messing with me?
Unknown Number : No, this is your Secret Santa.
Unknown Number : You took long enough to respond. I was starting to think you didn't like my picture.
Brad : Is this one of Sabrina's friends messing with me? Or all of you?
Unknown Number : Nope! Just me. Your Secret Santa.
Unknown Number : But I am one of Sabrina's friends. Obviously.
Brad : This seems like Sabrina messing with me.
Unknown Number : Does your sister send you a lot of racy photos? Because if so, I'm going to have to rethink this.
Brad : No, but you could have gotten that photo off of the internet.
Unknown Number : Possible, I suppose. But I didn't. It's me.
I scroll back up to look at the picture. Could this really be one of Sabrina's friends? If so, which one? No, this has got to be one or all of them fucking with me.
Unknown Number : You still there?
Brad : Yes. I just don't know what to say.
Unknown Number : Well... do you like my picture?
Brad : Tentatively, yes.
Unknown Number : Ok. In that case, I am tentatively not offended and tentatively not pissed off.
Brad : The picture is very nice. Beautiful. I'm just not sure it's real.
Unknown Number : Your choice whether to believe me. I can't exactly send you a picture of my driver's license, can I? That would kind of ruin the mystery.
Unknown Number : I've got to go though. We'll chat again in a few days. Goodnight, Brad. Don't stay up TOO late looking at my picture.
I pull the picture back up one more time. Could it be?
I list off the likely possibilities in my mind. One, Sabrina is fucking with me. Two, Sabrina and one or more of her friends are fucking with me. If so, they are probably cackling over this now. Three, some rando, probably a 50-year-old dude who lives in a basement, got my information and he's fucking with me. A very distant four, this is somehow real.
No, I think as I finally lie down to sleep. This has got to be someone fucking with me.
But what if it isn't?
Chapter 5 (December 2-4)
Three days pass without another message from my Secret Santa.
My team at work and I are still averaging fifty-five-hour work weeks with our looming project deadline, which keeps me distracted during the day. But in the evening after I received the first text, I sit down to give the matter some reasoned consideration.
My brain still tells me that it is almost certainly my sister and/or her friends just messing with me. But something inside me feels unsettled, unconvinced at the notion.
First, I check my phone's contacts to see if I have any of my sister's friends' phone numbers. I don't. Any time I had communicated with them, it had been through direct messages on their socials. So, next, I turn to their social media accounts looking through pictures hoping to find a familiar collarbone. I discover that my sister's friends don't post a lot of revealing photographs on their accounts. I also discover that the amount of time it takes me to feel like a creep looking through their social media accounts hoping to find pictures of them in bikinis is thirty-two minutes. I'm not proud of that number.
Then I look back at the picture in the text message.
The only one of the friends I can immediately rule out is Tiffany. At least I think I probably can. Even allowing for the black-and-white photography, the woman in the image appears to have a skin tone considerably lighter than Tiffany's rich brown complexion. Of course, I'm not exactly an expert in photographic lighting, so I can't be absolutely certain. But you have to start somewhere.
That leaves seven girls. Wait, I think. I hope it leaves seven girls! If my sister is a possible candidate for this photograph, I might need some therapy given the amount of time I've been staring at it.
No, I reassure myself, looking back at the image. That's not Sabrina. Seven girls.
Or all of this is completely fake.
I think back to the last time I saw the girls, the party.
Sending an anonymous, nearly naked photo to someone falls in the pretty wild category, which immediately leads me to think of Brittney first. Brittney is certainly the adventurous firecracker of the group. She also kissed me on the cheek at the party after complaining about guys who don't take her seriously. My first thought when looking at the image was slender. Brittney's curvy, but she's certainly not big. With the way the photo is cropped... maybe it could be her.
My next thought is Ashley. Ashley is definitely slim. Plus, she's a sophomore. Sending racy photos seems more likely for a girl in her second year of college than a freshman. At least it does to me, but I've apparently been dating the wrong type of girl to know for sure. At the party, Ashley was also pouring on the flirting pretty thick. But she's always flirted with me. Has she had a crush on me for a while? She did make that crack about interest in older men.
Then there's Megan. I've probably had more conversations with Megan than any of the other girls, but I'm not sure if that's a point for or against her being my Secret Santa. On the one hand, we're comfortable talking. But on the other, wouldn't it have come up at some point? The photo does have an artsy feel to it and Megan is definitely artsy. But, today, everyone is walking around with a photo studio in their pocket, and anyone can take a fancy picture.
Kelsey's an interesting possibility, but if it's her I'd be almost certain it was a prank. Would most girls send half-naked photos to a guy just so they could rub his face in the joke for the next decade? Probably not. Would Kelsey? Absolutely she would.
And that's only four of the seven possibilities. At the party Nicole explicitly asked whether I would consider dating one of them. Nicole's a redhead. Does she have freckles on her neck and shoulders? I briefly consider jumping back onto social media to check, but my don't be a creep alarm goes off first.
Rachel? She's too quiet and shy. But what's that they say about the shy, quiet ones.
Emily's definitely slender also. Hell, I think. I don't know at this point.
On the evening of December 3, I break down and send a text to the unknown number.
Brad : Hey Santa. How's it going?
Then later that night.
Brad : You there?
And then the next morning.
Brad : Oh Santa.
When I don't get a response to any of my three messages, I start feeling silly for even considering the possibility that any of this was real.
Way to fall into the obvious trap, Brad, I think, as I sense my sister must be somewhere laughing at this prank.
Then, on the evening of December 4, I get another text with another picture.
This image is also black and white and there is still no clothing in sight.
All that is in the frame is the gentle curve of her narrow waist as it sweeps down to her well-defined, unmistakably feminine hipbone. Just a bit more bare skin is shown above and below, but the image stops tantalizingly short of revealing any true nudity. There isn't enough in the frame to tell me much about the woman herself, but it is becoming obvious that these pictures aren't random snapshots. She is putting some thought into them.
Santa : Hey Brad. Sorry for the delay, but I told you it would be a few days. Looks like you need to learn to not get your panties in a knot.
Brad : Looks like you're not wearing any panties at all.
Santa : LOL. Yep, you got me there.
Brad : So, you are one of Sabrina's friends?
Santa : We've established that.
Brad : Are you going to tell me which one?
Santa : Are you unclear why they call it SECRET Santa?
Brad : Are you enjoying this?
Santa : Immensely.
Brad : Are you evil?
Santa : Maybe... would that be a turn-on for you?
Santa : My turn now. What's your idea of the perfect first date?
Brad : Are you asking for research purposes?
Santa : Of course! Santa's great at keeping lists.
Brad : Dinner somewhere quiet. Good food. Good conversation. Maybe a bookstore afterward.
Santa : A bookstore? Careful, Brad. You're going to make somebody fall in love with you.
Santa : Compatibility check: What's your idea of the perfect first date movie?
Brad : Easy. The Princess Bride.
Santa : That was probably too easy. (I would have also accepted Say Anything).
Brad : Are you going to boombox Peter Gabriel outside my window?
Santa : It's not the 1900s anymore, Brad. We have cellphones for a reason.
Brad : Was that an age joke? Because that felt like a joke about my age.
Santa : I don't mind about your age.
Santa : Got to go. We'll talk again in a few days. Sleep well. Enjoy the new picture.
The Princess Bride reference makes me briefly reconsider Tiffany, but looking at both photographs, it's not her. Brittney also made a Westley reference at the party, though. Overall, the messages are both flirty and conversational, which makes me think of Ashley and Megan.
Whoever she is, she seems funny, clever, and apparently doesn't mind that I'm six or seven years older. I'm still not convinced it isn't a prank. But part of me is starting to hope that it isn't.
Chapter 6 (December 8)
The next text and accompanying image arrive on the evening of December 8.
This picture is much bolder. Still in black and white, the frame starts just above her collarbone, cutting off near her hip. The photo reveals the line of her torso from the ridge of her shoulder to the outer edge of one full, heavy breast and then down to her ribs and side. There is still not the slightest bit of clothing in the frame, but the angle and the shadows keep her nipple completely hidden. Although still not explicit, she seems to be getting more daring in what she is allowing me to see.
The thing that draws my eye is the contrast in her proportions. She has a remarkably slender waist, but a considerably fuller bust.
Whoever she is, she clearly knows what she is doing with a camera.
And for the first time, I think I might actually be able to narrow down the possibilities.
Rachel is almost certainly out. So is Emily. Neither has the kind of figure suggested by the image. Tiffany was already unlikely, and this seems to settle it for her also.
That leaves five.
Brittney, Ashley, Nicole, Kelsey, and Megan.
Actually, I can probably eliminate Nicole, also. She has freckles scattered across her shoulders and upper chest, and the woman in the photograph does not.
How do I know about Nicole's freckles? Well, let's just say I'd conducted some additional research into the social media accounts of my sister's friends.
Entirely normal research, of course.
Remember how I said it took thirty-two minutes before I started feeling like a creep?
Apparently, that feeling was temporary.
Anyway, please don't judge me. Moving on.
That leaves four: Brittney, Ashley, Kelsey, and Megan.
Brittney, the group's short, curvy, blonde wild child. Certainly, the most likely to send provocative pictures to someone just for the fun of it. But, once again, when I think about Brittney, I think curves, not slender. Of course, the photographs don't exactly give me a full-body view, so I can't rule her out.
Ashley, the polished, flirtatious brunette who had made a point of telling me she was developing an appreciation for older men. She is slender, with curves in all the right places. Physically, she seems like a good match, and after the way she'd flirted with me at Thanksgiving, I certainly can't dismiss the possibility.
Kelsey, the athletic, competitive blonde who'd spent most of her life finding new ways to torment me. She is certainly thin, but I think of her as more toned and athletic than the woman suggested by the photographs. Still, if anyone would go to these lengths to pull an elaborate prank on me, Kelsey would be near the top of the list.
And finally, Megan. The quiet, bookish goth girl with long black hair and an impossibly slender figure. She is also a close physical match to what I am seeing. And the carefully composed photographs certainly seem consistent with her artistic interests. But Megan has never struck me as someone who would do anything quite this bold.
Then again, I wouldn't have expected any of them to do this.
I look back at the photograph.
Four possibilities. Between Ashley and Megan, two strong physical matches. But I can't quite eliminate the other two.
All of these girls admitted to having a crush on me at some point.
And one of them might be sending me these pictures.
Then suddenly, I feel like a kid who had snatched the cash out of a Christmas card he had just received without even pretending to read the card itself.
I've been staring at the picture for so long, I forgot to read the text that came with it.
Santa : Can I tell you something?
Brad : That depends. Is it your name?
Santa : No, smartass.
Brad : Had to try. What did you want to tell me?
Santa : Whenever someone compliments you, you turn it into a joke.
Brad : That's not true.
Santa : It's totally true. I've watched people compliment you for years. You always turn it into a joke instead of just accepting it.
Brad : Maybe I'm just super humble.
Santa : See? You're doing it again.
Brad : Maybe I just don't like talking about myself.
Santa : I noticed.
Brad : Nice picture, by the way.
Santa : Thanks! I'm glad you like it.
Chapter 7 (December 13)
The fourth photo arrives on the evening of December 13.
Still black and white, but this time, the camera angle is from behind.
The image shows the graceful contours of her bare back, narrowing toward her waist before reaching the gentle curve of her hips. At the very bottom of the frame, just the uppermost curves of her ass cheeks are visible, along with the faint line marking where they meet. Still no clothing. Lighting and cropping still keep the revelation just short of actual nudity.
I am starting to really appreciate her art in controlling what I can see and what she leaves me wanting to see.
This image punctuates her slenderness with an exclamation point. Brittney is probably out as a possibility. Is Kelsey? Maybe, but maybe not. Ashley and Megan are definitely the front-runners.
Santa : Serious question. What's the first thing you notice about a girl?
Brad : Depends on the girl.
Santa : That's a politician's answer. Try again.
Brad : Then probably her neck and collarbone first, then hipbone, then side boob, then just the upper edge of her ass.
Santa : Cute. Try again.
Brad : Usually her face. Especially her smile.
Santa : Not what I expected, considering our current arrangement.
Brad : Don't get me wrong. I've appreciated the previews.
Santa : Good. I'd hate to think my photography skills were wasted.
Brad : But a pretty face doesn't mean much if I don't enjoy talking to her.
Santa : And do you enjoy talking to me?
Brad : Yeah. I do.
And the funny thing is, I really do. Even without the pictures, I am starting to look forward to her messages.
After finishing the chat with my mystery Santa, I decide to text my sister.
Brad : Hey Sis! Can you send me Ashley and Megan's phone numbers?
Sure, there are several ways Santa could be using a number other than her regular phone number. But she might not be. It is worth checking.
Sabrina : Hey Bro! If you want to ask out one of my friends, you're going to have to narrow it down. I'm not sending you a list.
Brad : Not sure two numbers constitute a list.
Sabrina : Wait a minute!
Sabrina : Is this about Secret Santa? Are you trying to figure out who yours is?
Brad : Well... yeah, but it's more complicated than that.
Sabrina : NO CHEATING!!! Don't make me block your number.
Brad : Sorry. Shouldn't have asked. Goodnight Sis.
Sabrina : Goodnight Brad.
Chapter 8 (December 14-16)
The next day, everything comes apart at work.
The inventory management system our team was developing had been going smoothly and on schedule all month. We'd finished development and every preliminary test had gone off without a hitch. Still long hours, but the work was going well.
Then we run a full-system test that produces an inventory discrepancy. At first, it looks like a minor error that we can easily correct. But further testing reveals a much larger problem with no clear cause.
And here's the thing. The problem is in code that I had written.
So, rather than finishing touches with a chance of completing the project early, Monday through Wednesday turns into twelve-plus-hour days of brainstorming, diagnosing, and testing. Everything is working. Everything except for the issue with my code.
When I come home on Wednesday night, I am physically and mentally beat, but my brain is hyper-focused and unwilling to slow. What I need is sleep, but my body doesn't seem cooperative.
I don't even notice the text message waiting for me until I grab my phone as my head hits the pillow.
Santa : Hey Brad! How was your day?
No picture this time. That's different.
Brad : Not great.
Santa : Uh-oh. Rough day at work?
Brad : You could say that. Rough couple of days.
Santa : Want to talk about it?
Brad : Not really.
Santa : Want me to distract you?
Brad : You can give it a shot. Not sure you can though.
Santa : Okay. Important question. If you could have a grounded or mundane superpower, what would it be?
Brad : Define grounded or mundane.
Santa : Something that people would believe in real life or something that doesn't do anything impressive.
Brad : You know Mike Ross in that show Suits? Whatever he reads he understands and never forgets. That might be cool.
Remembering every line of code I had written. That would be useful at work right now.
Santa : Super eidetic recall. That is a good one. You distracted yet?
Brad : Nice try, but no. I think right now, that's too tall an order.
Brad : I think I might just lay here in the dark and try futilely to sleep.
Santa : Wait!
Santa : What if I send you my last ditch, break glass in case of emergency photo? I bet that will make you smile.
Brad : You have a last ditch, break in case of emergency photo?
Santa : Sure. Santa is like the Boy Scouts. Always prepared.
Brad : Okay. No offense if it doesn't work. But you can give it a try.
A moment later, an image in the usual black-and-white style pops up in my texts. While the composition is familiar, what it reveals makes me swallow hard.
The cropping is tighter than the other photos, the details closer. The left and right borders are framed with just the inner edges of her thighs. The bottom of the picture shows the very lower edge of her abdomen where it touches her waist. But center in the frame is the pronounced mound of her vulva presented from her perspective. With the lighting and the angle, there is just the slightest hint of the crease where the tops of her labia join. Everything is clearly shaved bare.
It's more revealing than anything she'd sent before. More revealing by a wide margin. For a moment, I forget about the mystery entirely. I think I even briefly forget about the troubles at work. And, as striking as the picture truly is, what truly gets me isn't the skin she is showing, but the trust that led her to share something so personal just to help me smile after a rough day. And I'm still not sure who she is.
Sure, I could absolutely be getting catfished, but I am starting to believe that making me happy actually matters to her.
Santa : Smiling yet?
Brad : Wow! Really wow! And yes. Definitely smiling.
Santa : Is that what it takes to really get your attention? Girl's gotta break out the pussy?
Brad : I'm just going to stick with wow.
Santa : Hope I've made your day better. Feel free to use my picture if it helps you get to sleep.
Brad : Did you just give me clearance to masturbate while thinking about your pussy?
Santa : Sure. It's only fair. Thinking about you has frequently done some really good things for her.
Santa : Goodnight Brad. I'm thinking about you right now.
Chapter 9 (December 17)
I sleep like a baby that night. And wake up with a smile the next morning.
At work, I feel like a new man.
I know my code is good. It did exactly what it was supposed to do in every preliminary test. That didn't mean there couldn't be a problem with it, but after three days of staring at the same code, I am beginning to think we are looking in the wrong place.
I talk my team leader, Priya, into taking another look at the entries in the old database that seem to be causing multiple instances of the same inventory items. By lunch, we start to notice a pattern. Under certain conditions, items in old, cancelled orders show up as both complete and outstanding at the same time. Priya realizes that these problem records were all modified after the date of their creation and this gives us a new thread to investigate.
Over lunch, we discover the commonality in these errors. The old system didn't always correctly categorize cancelled or modified orders. So, these records were not recorded as they should be.
The good news is that my code works just as I had designed it. The problem is that the data isn't following the rules we expect.
But this is a problem I can fix.
By four in the afternoon, I've revised the conversion logic so that these exceptions are corrected.
We take an actual break for dinner while the migration runs, and by eight that night, the full-system test comes back green twice.
Back on schedule.
Finishing touches tomorrow.
I arrive back home and receive a text from an unknown number as I'm settling in. Not from Santa. From another unknown number.
Unknown Number 2 : Hey Brad! This is Megan. Here's the link for the painting I told you about. Please check it out and vote if you like it. I appreciate it! See you around Christmas!
Megan and Ashley were the leading suspects. Does that solve the mystery? Megan's number is different than Santa's. Does that mean that Santa is Ashley?
Not necessarily. I'd already considered the possibility that Santa was using a second number to conceal her identity. If Megan is my Secret Santa, that's exactly what I'd expect her to do.
Still, it's one more piece of information, even if I'm not sure what to do with it.
I add Megan's number to my contacts and send her a text.
Brad : Hey Megan! I'll check out your painting now. I'm sure it's great. See you Christmas.
I click the link, which takes me straight to Megan's painting. The ruined chapel is exactly as she'd described it, but the sunlight coming through the stained-glass window is even better than I'd imagined. I give it five stars, although whether my vote will actually count is apparently up to the mysterious whims of the contest judges.
Brad : Your painting is amazing. The stained-glass window is incredible. I love the way you have the light coming through the ruins.
Megan : Thank you! I was hoping that part would work.
Brad : It definitely does. You should be proud of it.
Megan : Thank you, Brad! That means a lot.
A second number is certainly possible. I know that.
But somehow, talking to Megan feels different from talking to Santa. Like two separate conversations.
Which, of course, proves absolutely nothing.
I text my sister.
Brad : Hey Sis! Can you just send me Ashley's number? Pretty please?
Sabrina : Sure thing Bro! At the end of the party on the 26th, I'll give you anyone's number that you want.
Brad : Have you given my number to any of your friends since Thanksgiving?
Sabrina : No.
That raises another question. How did Megan get my number? I can't remember ever giving it to her.
Of course, we'd known each other for years. There were plenty of ways she could have gotten it.
Sabrina : No cheating! Don't make me block your number.
So, no luck matching Ashley's number with Santa's. I'm no closer to figuring out which of them, if either, is sending the pictures.
But could it be Ashley? I wonder as I scroll through the five images again. Slender. Full chest. Delicate features. That certainly matches Ashley.
Would I be happy if it turned out to be her?
Of course I would. Ashley is beautiful, smart, and fun to talk to. And she'd certainly made it clear at Thanksgiving that she wouldn't mind a little attention from me. I'd be a fool not to be flattered.
But Megan is beautiful, smart, and fun to talk to, also.
And the more I think about it, the more I realize I'm not sure which one I'd rather find out is my Secret Santa.
Do I actually have a preference?
Nine days.
I'll know in nine days.
Chapter 10 (December 18)
By the next evening, everything in the system has been checked again twice and all the finishing touches are in place. The project is on schedule and will be set to go live for the customer on January 4. It's 6:30pm when we have everything wrapped up, so Priya tells us to take the rest of the day off.
I grab pizza and a six-pack of beer on my way home to celebrate the project completion. I've had dinner and a chance to relax when the text from Santa comes in.
Santa : Are things better at work?
Brad : Much! We were able to solve the problem and get the project completed on schedule.
Santa : That's great! Congratulations! I'm so glad to hear it.
Santa : Can I confess something?
Brad : You're actually a fifty-year-old man named Steve?
Santa : Damn. You figured me out.
Brad : I knew it.
Santa : Seriously, though. It's not like me to be this daring.
Brad : Really?
Santa : Really. I've had a crush on you for a while, but I've never worked up the courage to tell you.
Brad : Well, the party is eight days away. I think we're heading towards a revelation.
Santa : What if you are disappointed when you find out who I am?
Brad : Why would I be disappointed?
Santa : What if I'm not the one you're hoping I am?
Brad : Well, whoever you are, I've enjoyed texting with you over the past couple of weeks.
Santa : Because I sent you a picture of my pussy?
Brad : Well... not just because you sent me a picture of your pussy.
Brad : I've enjoyed texting with you.
Santa : I've enjoyed texting with you too.
Brad : Good.
Santa : I'm going to be busy over the next week, so I might not be able to text often.
Brad : I'll miss the texts, but I'll be looking forward to seeing you at the Christmas party.
Santa : But you don't even know who I am.
Brad : I have some guesses.
Santa : Goodnight, Brad. See you on the 26th.
Brad : Goodnight. I can hardly wait to "meet" you.
Part 3 - Secret Santa Reveal (December 26)
Chapter 11
Finally, it's the evening of December 26, and my sister, her closest friends, and I are again gathered in the finished basement of my parents' house. Sabrina always insists that these events are more gatherings than parties. I'm not exactly sure where she sees the distinction lying, but I think I sort of know what she means.
Santa hadn't been kidding about not being able to text often. I didn't receive any messages from her for six days. Then, on Christmas Eve, she sent me another picture, but this one came without a text message.
Black and white, she's sitting on what appears to be a table, arms straight, hands pressed down, in near darkness. Her head is lowered such that the only detail I can discern is straight, dark hair. The limited light is strategically positioned to land on her arms and the sides of her back. The effect is a sensual image of her back, arms, and slender waist with just the suggestion of the outline of her ass.
Oh, also, on the top of her head, she wears a classic Santa hat.
Assuming it's really one of my sister's friends--and, at this point, I really hope that it is--it is either Ashley or Megan. No one else fits.
Then, on Christmas day, I received a single text message from her.
Santa : Merry Christmas, Brad. See you tomorrow!
Brad : Merry Christmas! I'm looking forward to it.
The party is decorated with holiday flair and is more festive than our Thanksgiving gathering. Two tables, covered with red and green tablecloths, hold all the finger foods you would expect. Pigs in a blanket, those ham and cheese pinwheels, bacon-wrapped dates, spinach and artichoke wonton cups, little sandwiches with the crust cut off, dips and chips galore. I brought my twice-baked potato skins, which are always a hit. There is also an assortment of cookies and sheet-pan, bar-shaped desserts.
"Have you tried the holiday punch?" Brittney asks as we are both at the table filling up our plates with food.
In addition to our normal assortment of beer and wine coolers, Sabrina also mixed up two very large pitchers of a cranberry-orange holiday punch, made with cranberry and orange juices, ginger ale, fresh cranberries, orange slices, and vodka.
"Sabrina let me taste it when she made it," I tell Brittney. "But I'm sticking to beer right now."
Looking around the party, everyone is here. Kelsey is playing pool again, this time with Emily. Much to Kelsey's delight, she seems to be dominating this game. My sister Sabrina is watching them play. Megan, Rachel, and Tiffany are standing across the room talking about the television version of some book-based romantic drama that started streaming earlier this year. Ashley, Brittney, and Nicole are on the couch talking about which of the appetizers are their favorites.
As Ashley stands to refill her punch, she spots me alone near the tables. She gives a warm smile when she sees me looking in her direction and makes her way over to me.
"Hey, stranger," Ashley says. "I get to see you two times in as many months. I'm going to be spoiled."
Ashley is wearing a fitted off-the-shoulder burgundy sweater, dark black skinny jeans, and black ankle boots. Her dark-brown hair frames her face in soft waves, and her overall look is polished and effortlessly attractive. Basically, Ashley's default setting.
"Always good to see you, Ashley," I say, returning her smile.
"How are things at work?" she asks, stepping to the table to pour herself another cup of punch.
"Good," I report. "We just finished a big project, and I've got some time off to relax. How are things at college? Any improvement on the romantic front?"
"Maybe," she says, drawing out the word. "There is someone I might be interested in."
"Really?" I say.
Ashley brushes back a loose strand of her hair, gives me a coy smile, and leans just a bit closer.
"We've been texting some," she explains. "He seems like a decent guy. I think I'm interested in seeing where it could go, and I hope that he is also."
"Well," I say, leaning my head closer to her, "if he's not interested in you, he's a complete moron."
Ashley glances away shyly for a moment, and bats her lashes as her gaze returns to mine. Her hand comes to rest on my shoulder.
"Look at you being so sweet," she says.
Just when I think something might come of this moment, Megan, Rachel, and Tiffany join us.
"Off Campus," Tiffany says, without any further explanation.
"At the bar," I respond.
"No," Tiffany says, shoving my shoulder lightly. "The television series. Have you seen it?"
"Yeah," I admit, before taking a drink from my beer. "I read The Deal a while back. I don't normally do romance, but Rachel suggested it," I say, nodding at Rachel, "so I figured it was worth checking out. Both book and show were good. Book's probably better. Really well written."
"So," Rachel says, joining the conversation, "you think they did a good job with the show? With the characters?"
"Sure," I say. "Overall, I liked everything. I mean Allie's hair is clearly blonde in the book and the actress who plays her is a brunette, but that's not a problem for me so far."
"What about Hannah?" Tiffany asks.
Megan is standing about a step farther away from us than I would expect, looking somewhat more shy than usual.
Tonight she's wearing a long-sleeve, fitted black top with a square neckline. A short, dark red-green-and-black plaid skirt, sheer black tights, and chunky platform Mary Janes complete the outfit. Her raven black hair hangs straight down her back, and she also wears a thin silver chain with a small star pendant and understated dark-red nail polish. It's her typical style, but with a touch of Christmas aesthetic.
"I think the actress did a really good job," I answer. "There were parts that didn't feel like Hannah, but I liked her in the role."
"Told you," Rachel says, shoving Tiffany. "What parts didn't feel like Hannah?"
I think for a moment before answering.
"Wardrobe, I guess. Seems like in the book the only place Hannah's breasts were on display was in the bedroom and in the show that was the only place they weren't."
A smile fills Rachel's face, and she leans in to give me a quick hug.
"See," Rachel says, beaming at Tiffany. "Here's a man who understands dramatic romance."
Rachel and Tiffany continue to argue the merits of the show versus the book as they excuse themselves and make their way back across the room, leaving Megan behind.
Ashley seems to give Megan an uncomfortable stare for a moment, before nodding her head towards her and excusing herself also.
"I'll talk with you later, Brad," Ashley says with a wink before returning to her place on the couch.
Megan steps closer to me once Ashley is gone.
"Thanks again for voting for my painting," Megan says, gently touching my arm. "It really means a lot that you took the time to do it."
"Absolutely," I say. "I really like the painting. I was impressed. I just hope my vote survives to be counted."
"I know," Megan says, brushing her black hair back behind her shoulder. "Some other artists have suggested ways to improve the voting, but no luck so far."
"Well," I say, "either way, it really was an excellent painting."
"Thank you, Brad," Megan says, her voice dropping into a softer register as she looks down momentarily. "I'm happy to hear you like it."
"Okay, everyone," Sabrina announces, standing as her voice fills the room. "It's that time. It's time for Secret Santa."
Cheers erupt around the room, but I feel a knot form in my throat.
After weeks of wondering, I'm about to find out who my Secret Santa is. Or maybe, I'm about to be the butt of a prank that I'll be hearing about for at least a decade.
I look over at Ashley, and the look she gives me tells me she doesn't mind me watching her. I look back to Megan, who gives me a small warm smile.
I decided a few days ago that I would be pleased with either Ashley or Megan expressing interest in me. Also, that it's okay for me not to have a preference. No one has made any commitments to anyone and it's okay for me to be potentially interested in two different beautiful, fascinating women.
"Everyone, grab the presents you bought," Sabrina tells the room, "and find a seat in the circle."
We all do so and the gift exchange begins. By fate, design, or happenstance, I go first and Ashley and then Megan will go last.
Standing from my seat, I walk across to Rachel and hand her a present wrapped in Christmas tree paper. She smiles as she tears into it. Rachel and I share a love of books, so I got her a hardcover of The Thursday Murder Club and a leather magnetic bookmark with her name engraved in a bar through the initial letter "R."
"Thanks, Brad," Rachel says beaming. "I've been wanting to read this one." She turns the book over in her hand. "Oh," she says, finding the bookmark. "I love this too. Great gifts, Brad. Thanks!"
Rachel stands and gives me a quick hug.
"I knew you liked mysteries," I tell her. "Plus, I figured it was safer than trying to buy you clothing."
"Definitely," she says. "This is perfect."
Megan and Ashley are next to me as far as the circle goes, but because I am on the couch and they are in chairs, they are both still a short distance across the room. I find myself exchanging quick glances and smiles with both of them.
The exchange of gifts continues as I retake my seat. The presents are a mixture of hardcover books, simple items of jewelry, clothing, and assorted drinkware. Brittney's gift to Sabrina, a hot-and-cold tumbler that reads, "I'm not bossy. I'm the event coordinator," is a big hit with everyone. With this group, all the gifts are thoughtful and there is no shortage of inside jokes amongst them.
Then finally, the two-part moment of truth. Ashley is up. Then Megan.
Ashley stands, and I hold my breath as she starts walking my direction towards the couch. What do I say if she reveals everything in front of everyone? I wonder. What if she just expresses her interest? I've spent so much time wondering who my Santa was that I hadn't given any thought to what I would say myself.
But Ashley walks past me, stopping in front of Tiffany who sits at the other end of the couch. When Tiffany opens her present, we all see that Ashley got her a mug with a scene from The Princess Bride on one side and the quote, "As You Wish," printed on the other.
"I'm going to use this every day!" Tiffany announces as she examines the mug with delight.
Ashley gives me a smile and a wink as she returns to her seat.
Finally, Megan is up. She is the last giver, and I am the last person without a gift. Megan is my Secret Santa. I am surprised both by how delighted I am that she is and how terrified I am of what is about to unfold.
Megan rises from her seat and crosses the short distance to stand before me with a smile. She hands me a rectangular package wrapped in dark green paper that is decorated with printed images of candies.
"Merry Christmas, Brad," she says.
Pulling off the paper, I discover a well-preserved, hardcover copy of an old book that I love. The green, black, and white cover depicts forests against a range of mountains with "The Hobbit" printed near the top in white lettering and "J. R. R. Tolkien" near the bottom in black. From the cover, I think that I immediately recognize this edition. Opening to the copyright page, I confirm it. It's the 1966 Revised Edition.
"Megan," I say, not believing what I am holding in my hands, "this must have been a lot more than $30. A lot more!"
Megan smiles even bigger and shakes her head.
"My uncle owns a used bookstore," she explains. "He got this as a surprise in a box of books he bought from an estate sale. I saw it, remembered you liked Tolkien, sweet-talked my uncle, and he gave it to me for twenty dollars. So, I guess I actually still owe you a bit."
"This is fantastic," I beam. "Really, Megan, I love it."
"I'm glad you like it," she says, still standing in front of me, shifting back and forth on her hips.
As she pauses in front of me, I examine the gift further. Might there be a note, another picture, some clue as to what is about to happen next?
But there's nothing. Just this perfect present.
"This is really special," I say, standing and giving Megan a big hug.
Megan melts into me for a moment, but then gives me a squeeze, another smile, and turns to head back to her seat.
And that is it. The Secret Santa exchange is over. Nothing more.
After that, the party goes on without even the faintest of references to the messages and pictures I've received over the past month.
I know that Megan got my name in the gift exchange, but is she the person who has been texting me? If so, she gave no indication during the gift exchange or the rest of the party.
Was it Ashley after all, even though she didn't draw my name?
Were my initial suspicions correct after all? Was this some strange, elaborate prank? But, if it were, I would have expected some group gloating by now.
I talk with Ashley and then Megan again as the party continues, but there is no reference to photographs. No telling, private smile. No revelatory wink. No teasing or suggestive comments. Nothing at all to give me any clue.
Is Santa being discreet? Did she chicken out? Is there something I'm missing?
Whatever the answer, as the party draws to a close, I begin to wonder if I will ever find out.
Chapter 12
My parents' house has plenty of space, so all of the girls are having a sleepover tonight. I've excused myself to my old bedroom upstairs and sit alone with my thoughts while I watch an episode of Gilmore Girls.
Don't laugh. It's a well-written show. Guys are allowed to watch it.
So, I'm watching some totally masculine television show when there is a knock at my door.
"Come in," I say, still sitting on my bed, my back against the headboard.
I'm not dressed, but probably everyone in the house has seen me in boxers and a T-shirt before.
The door opens and inside steps Megan, who immediately closes the door behind her. I start to stand, but she motions for me to keep my seat.
Megan wears a glossy black satin, long-sleeved sleepshirt that buttons down the front and is decorated with images of red, pink, and green wrapped candies. On her head is a classic Santa's cap that could very well be the one from the last picture.
"Ho, ho, ho," she says softly with a gentle smile. "It's your Secret Santa," she continues, holding her hands out at her sides as a sign of revelation.
"My Secret Santa from the gift exchange, or from the text messages?" I ask.
"Well," Megan says, stepping closer to my bed, "both, obviously."
"I was starting to wonder," I say, my words trailing off near the end.
"Well," Megan says, "I couldn't exactly just strip down and throw myself at you in front of everyone could I? People would talk."
I swallow hard, smile and nod, trying to keep my nerves from getting the best of me.
"I'm here. I'm real. And I'm here to give you the rest of your gift." She's right up against the side of the bed now.
"You knocked on my door in the middle of the night to bring me ten dollars?" I ask.
"Well," she says, placing her hands on the bed and leaning forward, "spoiler alert, this outfit doesn't have pockets for me to carry cash. It doesn't even have panties."
"You keep cash in your panties?" I ask, mainly because I'm apparently an idiot right now.
"No, but it's cute how you babble when you're flustered."
I open my mouth. Then close it. "I guess I do."
Even though it's my room and I'm seven years older, I feel absolutely certain that I am more nervous about what is about to happen next than she is. Whatever that might be.
Megan slips the Santa hat off her head and places it on one of my nightstands.
"I really don't want to embarrass either of us," I confess. "So long as this isn't some cruel, elaborate prank, I am super excited about what is going on here. But I'm also not entirely sure what that is."
"I already told you, this is real. Not a prank," she says.
Megan climbs up onto the bed.
My bed at my parents' house is an old bed with thick posts rising from each of its four corners. I sit on one side of the bed, my back against the headboard. Megan takes position in the opposite corner, her legs on the bed pointed towards me, her back against one of the bedposts.
Seated, her sleepshirt rides up to reveal essentially all of her legs but stops just short of revealing whether her statement about panties was talk or reality.
"I'm here to give you the rest of your present," she says. "I'm here to give you my virginity."
Virginity. The word hangs between us making the room feel heavy for a moment.
"Megan," I finally say, once I feel capable of speech, "that's too much. You can't make a gift of..."
But Megan stops me, holding up a finger, before I finish.
"This is a present for both of us," she explains. "This is something I've wanted... well, for quite some time. I want this. It's for both of us. If you want me too."
I can only nod my affirmation. My throat is still so tight that words won't come.
I've never had a moment where I felt an angel on one shoulder and a demon on the other. I'm having that moment now. But, in this moment, both the angel and demon are also too flustered to offer temptation one way or the other.
Megan just sits there smiling, seeming to enjoy my internal struggle.
"I don't have a problem with our ages," she finally says. "Is that your holdup?"
"Not exactly," I start. "But you are 18 and I am 25. You're one of my sister's best friends. I don't know all the implications of us dating."
Megan laughs.
"If you want to date me," she says, "you're going to have to ask me out. Don't get me wrong, I'll probably say yes, but I haven't said anything about dating."
"So..." I say.
"So," she echoes.
I want to grab her. I want to slide that shirt off of her and find out if there is really nothing underneath. A beautiful, fascinating woman who I love talking to is sitting feet from me offering herself. But the unknown still holds me in place.
"You know," she says with a wicked smile after a long moment, "I already know how to get your attention."
"Do you?" I ask, my voice gruff.
Megan nods.
Her hand travels up her shirt, to the top button of her shirt, which she unfastens.
Holding her shirt open to reveal her shoulder, she says, "It's not my collarbone."
Her hand slides back down her shirt unfastening a second button, then a third. She holds her shirt open just enough to reveal the inside edges of her bosom.
The satin material pulls taut across the center of her orbs revealing the soft slopes of her breasts and the deep valley between them. Even with this partial view, I can tell that they are high and firm, teardrop-shaped with a clear forward thrust. Her breasts rise and fall with every breath she takes.
"You haven't seen them from this angle," she says softly, "but it's not my breasts either. Though maybe they could do it also."
I swallow hard again. The soft light from my bedside lamp is the only light in the room, but it is enough for me to see her perfectly.
"It's my..." she starts, moving her hands lower on her shirt and pulling up slowly, stopping just before she reveals what is between her legs.
She holds the pose for a long moment before she speaks again.
"Do you want to hear about the first time I masturbated, Brad?"
You would think nothing would surprise me at this point, but the question just about knocks me flat.
"I remember it," she continues, "because it was one week after my 18th birthday. One week after my 18th birthday was your sister's 18th birthday. She had a pool party."
I nod, feeling my cheeks go warm and my heart rate quickening.
"We were doing chicken fights," she continues, shimmying her hands to continue to tease the lower edge of her shirt which just covers her core. "And I was on your shoulders."
I remember that party. I remember her being on my shoulders. But I feel what she is about to share is very new information entirely.
"When I was up on your shoulders," she says, "I suddenly realized that there was just a thin piece of fabric between my pussy and your neck. I was attracted to you before. Your kindness and thoughtfulness and clever humor. Plus, you're pretty easy on the eyes."
My smile broadens as she compliments me.
"But," she continues, "I don't think I had ever been as turned on as I was in that moment. I was glad we were in the pool, because otherwise you might have noticed my wetness against your neck."
Holy fucking shit! I think as I realize rational, reasoned thought is not going to be getting a vote in what's coming.
"When I got home that night, it felt like my clit was literally throbbing. I stripped off all of my clothes, crawled into my bed, and when I slid my fingers between my legs..."
She pulls her shirt higher, revealing her pussy. Her outer lips are large and plump, but neatly tucked together, with just a hint of her clitoral hood sticking out between them. She is still completely shaven. She is right in front of me. This isn't just a picture.
She slides one hand down between her legs, teasing around her lips with two fingers.
"... when I slid my fingers between my legs, I imagined that it was your fingers, then your mouth, then your tongue, and then your dick."
As she speaks her two fingers run first around her outer lips and then between them. They travel up to circle her clit before she sends them lower sliding them just inside her entrance.
"That night," she says, holding up her two fingers to show me her slickness coating them, "was my first orgasm."
Now she shifts, starting to crawl towards me.
"So, Brad," she says, reaching up to unfasten two more buttons from her shirt. "Do I have your attention?"
She does.
She's over me now, her mouth inches from mine. I feel the warmth of her body, the weight of her chest as it just skims mine, the silkiness of her shirt.
"Am I going to have to sit here and masturbate in front of you while I imagine you pressed against me... or are we both going to enjoy the real thing?"
My hand reaches up, lacing my fingers through her long hair, to pull her down to me, but her lips are already on mine. Our mouths come together in what begins in the hungry yet cautious manner of a first kiss and then deepens into something more. Our tongues dance together as she presses her hand into my chest. She tastes faintly of cherry lip gloss and her hair smells floral, perhaps like lilies.
We kiss until we are both breathless and then she pulls off, still straddling my waist, but rising up straight. As her fingers find the last button of her shirt, she shrugs it off and it glides down her arms and onto my legs.
As her soft sleepshirt pools across my lower thighs, she is suddenly completely naked. There is nothing left between us as her breasts come into full view. They are softly tapered, carrying just a bit more fullness in their lower half, with clear forward thrust and resilient firmness. Her light-tan areolas crown the tips, darkening to a rose color at her nipples, which already stand firm.
Fuck is she beautiful.
She just holds there for a moment, letting me take her in. Wanting me to take her in.
Megan moves first, her mouth returning to mine and my hands come up to feel the wonderfully dense cushion of her warm breasts, which compress and yet keep their shape as they overflow my hands. We both slide down, flattening out against the bed with her still on top of me, as our mouths continue to claim the other's. She has one hand on my face and mine travel around to feel the soft curve and gentle give of her small ass.
Our hands continue to explore the other, our mouths not parting, and I can feel our hearts pounding together.
Megan pulls back, leaning up just a bit and holding my gaze.
"If I give you a blowjob," she begins, somewhat skittishly, "will you... will you go down on me?"
"Of course," I tell her.
"And then we can..." she starts but stops.
"Yes," I confirm. "Then we can do whatever you want."
A smile comes to her lips before they crash back into mine for another long kiss.
Tugging at my T-shirt, she says, "One of us is overdressed," with sly amusement.
Without hesitation, I strip off my T-shirt, as she crawls down towards my waist and slides my boxers down and off. Scooping up her sleepshirt, which has already fallen to the bed, along with my boxers, she throws both to the floor, before looking back at me.
Looking at my cock, the corners of her mouth pull upward, her cheeks lifting, as her eyes go wide and her eyebrows rise. Her lips part and she takes a slow, soft breath.
"I didn't get any preview pictures," she says, her gaze still fixed between my legs, "but very nice."
Not waiting for a response, she lowers her head near my crotch, taking my already fully erect member in her grip.
One slow stroke from the base to the tip and then back down, turns into another, and another. My eyes close and my head drops back as the wet warmth of her mouth envelops the head of my shaft.
She explores me, taking just the first bit into her mouth at first. With each downward glide of her mouth to the upward stroke of her hand she takes me just a bit deeper.
Once she's worked down to taking most of me into her mouth, she pulls off, still holding me in her grip, and says, "Okay," seemingly to herself.
Her mouth immediately returns to my shaft, but she is no longer just exploring. She layers kisses along my cock, before taking it into her mouth again, and then switches to long slow licks. I'm in bliss as she repeats this pattern through several cycles, and then she takes me solidly into her mouth again, her tongue pressing firm against my underside with each bob and pull of her mouth. It's not long before I feel the tension build towards a breaking point in my balls.
"Megan," I murmur, "I'm close."
Megan softly hums an acknowledgement but continues to work against me with her tongue and lips.
Tilting my head up, I watch her mouth gliding along me as my orgasm approaches.
She jerks when the first ribbon erupts into her mouth, but after a beat, she resumes the same rhythm. My whole body shudders as I pump my release into her in pulses as she bobs and swallows around me.
She pulls off only when I have stilled, and asks, "Good?"
"That was perfect, Megan," I say with a pleased sigh. "That was your first time?" I ask in disbelief.
"It was," she says, settling her head against my chest. "But I asked some advice from some of the other girls."
"Well, thank them for me," I say, quietly hoping that "some of the other girls" did not include my sister. "That was amazing."
"I'm glad you liked it," Megan says with a contented breath. Then, after a moment, "Now can we do me?"
"Absolutely," I confirm, giving her a quick kiss on the mouth before sliding down lower as she lays herself back flat.
I work my way down slowly, layering kisses around her neck, then down to her collarbone, and finally along the edges of her breasts. I continue to tease with my mouth, hands, and tongue, stopping just short of her nipples until she is practically squirming. Only then do I pull each nipple into my mouth in turn, earning an ecstatic breath that escapes from her throat.
Continuing down her belly, I settle myself between her legs.
"Ready?" I ask, looking up at her.
She holds her breath and gives me a quick nod.
Starting playfully and light, I pepper kisses along the crease where her legs meet her abdomen, followed by the long, slow glide of my tongue. When I move inward to her plump outer lips, she purrs as my mouth works against her.
"That feels so good," she whispers.
I give a soft chuckle against her. "We're just warming up," I say. "We haven't gotten to so good yet."
Her hips rise toward my mouth as I run my tongue between her lips, tracing a path from her entrance to her clit. A sharp moan accompanies the rise of her hips as I repeat the trail twice more.
My finger moves to her clit, making small, slow circles, as my tongue darts around her entrance, tasting her delicate tangy musk. Her body responds to every touch, moving gently beneath me with gentle sighs and near breathless exclamations. As I sense the tension building within her core, I shift my mouth to her clit and slowly slide one finger into her.
And fuck is she tight.
Her hips continue to rock against my mouth and finger until her moans break into airy murmurs of, "Yes! Yes! Yes! Yes, Brad, yes!"
Her whole body tenses and then shudders as her tension tips over into release, and wave after wave pulses through her. I stay right with her, my mouth sucking against her clit, my finger maintaining its in and out rhythm, until she slows and stills beneath me.
"Good?" I ask, smiling up at her.
"Hell, yeah, it was," she says with a giggle. "That was so much better than anything I've done to myself."
"Well then," I say, crawling back up towards her face, "I'm glad I didn't let you just masturbate in front of me." Then I add, "Though, if you ever want to do that, it would be super-hot."
She smiles. "Play your cards right and we'll see what we can do."
My mouth is still wet with her when our lips meet again and we enjoy a slow, lingering kiss, as our hands begin to explore once again.
When our kiss breaks, Megan locks her eyes with mine.
"I want us to be intimate," she says. "I want to have sex with you."
"You sure?" I ask. "I don't want to rush into anything."
"I'm sure," she confirms with a nod. "You don't know how long I've wanted this." She kisses me again. "This is the least rushed thing I've ever done."
"Do we need a condom?" I ask.
She shakes her head. "I'm on the pill."
"I've been tested," I reassure her, "since my last relationship."
"And I've never been with anyone," she says with a smile.
"You're comfortable without a condom?" I confirm.
"Yes," she tells me with a soft nod.
I am almost fully hard already when I kiss her again and climb on top of her, positioning my shaft over her pussy. Maintaining our kiss, I rock my hips gently sliding myself along the slick heat of her lips and clit.
"That feels good," she whispers against my mouth.
Continuing the slow motion, I pull back from our kiss and my eyes meet hers.
"I've never been with someone for their first time," I tell her. "But my understanding is that it might hurt a bit."
Her eyes stay locked on mine, and she gives me a nod.
"Just go slow. I trust you. Whatever happens, I want it to happen with you."
Fully hard, I reposition myself at her entrance. Her eyes widen as I slide just my head inside of her. On the next stroke, she sighs hard and then tenses, her fingers digging into my shoulders, as I press just a bit forward, but then she relaxes and gives me a nod. Sliding back gently, I press a little deeper into the snugness of her warmth on the next thrust. Back and in deeper still, she gives me a more pleasant sigh, and I hold there for a moment.
"You doing okay?" I ask, looking into her eyes.
She nods. "Yes," she confirms. "Just one sharp pinch. Not nearly as bad as I expected."
Propping myself up on my hands, I begin to slowly rock my hips, pushing in and out of her. Her eyes close, her head tipping back as she enjoys the newness and wonder of the sensation. She is magnificently tight, her walls wrapping around me as I thrust in a measured rhythm.
After several moments, I adjust my angle and rhythm to find the spot that makes her whimper and the pace that will allow me to last. This is her first time. I don't want to finish before she does.
As we move, I just watch her, enjoying her enjoyment.
Megan brings her legs up, wrapping her heels around behind me, and lifts her hips to match my rhythm. Her eyes open, meeting mine as I feel her breathing become deeper and I feel her body tighten beneath me. Then they close again as she groans into her release, her core clenching around my cock, her body tensing and relaxing in rhythm as her orgasm courses through her.
Observing her crescendo, I am suddenly struck by all the things she is. The friend that I have known for a decade, now grown into a beautiful woman. The mystery in the text, now revealed and real. The astoundingly talented and clever person, who has set her affections on me.
I slow as she relaxes and her fingers lace through my hair, pulling my mouth down to hers. As we kiss, the pace of my thrusts quickens, as I feel the tension within me approaching its brink.
"I'm close," I tell her again, looking deep into her eyes.
"Yes, Brad," she says, her eyes on mine. "Come for me. Come inside me."
Another thrust and another and I bury myself deep, spilling my seed inside her as my body is racked with crests of pleasure. I hold myself there, my body pressing into hers, feeling the warmth and softness of her beneath me.
Rolling off of her, I pull her into me, our bodies locked together. A moment later, I pull away from the embrace to pull the covers up around us, and our bodies wrap together again.
Epilogue
We lie there, holding one another, enjoying the aftereffects of pleasure, and the proximity of each other's body. After a long moment, our eyes meet again and our hands begin gentle paths of exploration.
"Can I ask you some questions?" I ask.
Megan laughs. "I think it should be pretty obvious," she says, "but yes, I came."
I return her laugh. "I know that. Other questions?"
"Sure," she says.
"How did you get my number?"
"Sabrina gave it to me years ago. Told me to call you if I was ever in trouble and couldn't reach someone else."
"How did you hide your number?" I ask.
"Texting app," Megan answers.
"That's what I figured," I say.
I pull her in closer, kissing her again, before pulling back so that my fingers can trace along her arm and breast. I'm still a little amazed that she chose to share this special moment with me.
"So," I ask, "how long have you been interested in me as more than a friend?"
She thinks for a moment before responding.
"There wasn't a single moment," she says. "It's something that has developed slowly but steadily over a long time. One day I realized that I had been thinking about you as more than just my friend's older brother for quite some time."
"Did you somehow influence the results so you would be my Secret Santa?" I ask.
"No," she says with a chuckle. "That part was just luck. But I did take it as a bit of a sign. I figured I could reveal my crush as I revealed I was your Secret Santa."
"I'm glad you did," I say.
This time she pulls closer to me, her mouth pressing to mine in a slow lingering kiss.
"Megan," I ask, "do you want to hang out tomorrow? We could watch The Princess Bride or Say Anything."
"Maybe have some good food and good conversation?" she says.
"Definitely."
"Is this you asking me out on a real date?" Megan asks, batting her eyes.
"Yes, Megan," I tell her, "this is me asking you out on a real date."
"In that case," she says, her eyes meeting mine, "I accept." Then she asks, "Can we be intimate again first?"
I smile.
"We can be intimate whenever you want.
You need to log in so that our AI can start recommending suitable works that you will definitely like.
There are no comments yet - be the first to add one!
Add new comment