Headline
Message text
Authors note:
This one starts a little darker, there is some personal loss and physical recovery after a serious accident, which serve as a foundation for the story. Most of that happens in the first two chapters and I promise that things take a much more fun and enjoyable turn after.
If those themes are troublesome, please consider reading something else :)
I hope you enjoy 'Their Favourite Teacher'.
A. Strange
Their Favourite Teacher
--
I sat with my back against the headboard and looked down at the mess we made of the sheets. It had been a crazy Saturday night.
Abigail lay next to me sideways on the bed, limbs spread out, her cheek next to my leg, a bit of drool escaping from her mouth, her skin still glistening with sweat. We might have gone even harder than normal, knowing this could be one of our last nights together for the school year. She basically collapsed after her orgasm and hadn't moved since. She was good to stay over, having arranged an 'alibi' with a friend.
Once again I marvelled at her eighteen-year-old gymnast body. Tight, hardly any body fat, small boobs topped with dark nipples, her tightly trimmed pubic hair leading to a beautiful small pussy, currently leaking the remnants of our orgasms.
After the first time it happened, I thought 'this is it, no more', but then another eighteen-year-old senior girl approached me, ready and willing. Eager even. Just like Abi. She was one of my students, and one of three who had shared my bed over the last three years.
I didn't get into teaching to take senior girls to bed, though, given how the last few years had gone, it might be hard to believe. Even if I had, in fact, resisted.
It all started that one Friday morning in December...
----
Three years prior, Friday, December 8, Westview High School
Walking into the teachers' lounge I saw Stacy Bennett, our Vice Principle, holding Vicky Lim, who was sobbing. Vicky and I were close, I was the track coach while Vicky coached gymnastics, and I immediately worried, wondering what happened to her. Though once I looked at Stacy, she didn't look much better, clearly fighting back tears.
Wondering just what was going on I turned to Charles, the only other teacher in the room. Charles Davies had mentored me when I started here at Westview and we had stayed close. In fact, I often bounced ideas off him because he tended to have good suggestions--twenty years of experience will do that. Today he stood there and looked like he just ate a lemon, or maybe a raw onion. I shrugged to show that I had no clue what was going on.
He walked over to me, and leaning in, said, "I guess you haven't heard?" I shook my head. "You have Kelly and Dillon in some of your classes right?" I nodded. "They got into a car accident last night. I guess, really, he did. Sounds like it was after a party and he had a couple of drinks. Maybe a couple too many. Anyway," Charles wiped away a tear, "Dillon didn't make it, and Kelly is in intensive care."
It took me a second to process what he said.
Then my stomach turned and I immediately thought of Natalie, Kelly's best friend--they were pretty much inseparable--who had to be absolutely devastated. Nat and Kelly were two of my favourite seniors, friendly, eager to learn and always willing to help others, unlike so many of their classmates. They were also attractive, but that wasn't why I enjoyed having them in my class.
I snapped back to the present and noticed that I was staring at Charles, open mouthed, as I tried to process what he just told me.
Watching me, and seeing my face, he continued, "Yeah, it's such a shock. We're trying to figure out if we should cancel classes for the day, but Stacy is thinking of having a general assembly so she can talk to the students as a group. They're getting some grief counsellors to come in this afternoon, and more will be here next week and we want to have them there during assembly to immediately be able to talk to those that need it."
"And this morning? What are we supposed to tell our classes?" I didn't know how I supposed to handle the news. What would I tell Kelly and Dillon's friends and classmates? Really, what could I do? Reassure them somehow?
"The senior class mostly knows from what I've heard. We're supposed to try and run classes as usual, but if any students can't manage, send them to the office and they'll call the parents to come get them. We don't want anyone driving if they're not up for it." Charles patted my shoulder and I took a breath, letting it out slowly. "This isn't the first time a student of mine has passed away over the last twenty years, and well, it never gets any easier."
"God, I can't even imagine... Thanks Charles. I might want to stop by later to talk."
"Of course, you know my door's always open."
----
The day hadn't gotten any easier. Everywhere I looked between classes, I saw seniors huddled in small groups, many crying. Kelly and Dillon were popular, the classic good-girl / bad-boy couple. Kelly was smart, kind, active in a lot of school extracurricular activities--this year she was busy with the yearbook, taking many of the pictures that were going to be featured. She had a real eye for photography and shot most of the track meets and football games. The fact that she was fit and pretty hadn't hurt her popularity either.
I liked having her and Natalie in my classes over the last couple of years. Both were eager to learn and always willing to be paired with someone who could use some help, though they preferred to work together. This year I had them in my AP Calculus class, and both were doing well. Well, they had been until now.
Dillon had been decent academically--thinking about that in the past tense stung--but he hadn't really excelled. No advanced placement for him, though he maintained a solid 'B' average. He had a ready smile, and was pleasant enough in class, even if he skipped out now and then. From what I overheard, he liked to party and didn't shy away from the odd fight on the weekends, sometimes showing up on Mondays with a black eye or split lip, but always with a big grin. Despite that, I liked having him as a student, he made class lively. I just couldn't wrap my head around the fact that Kelly had gotten in a car with him if she knew he'd been drinking.
But there was no sense in trying to figure out the why right now. It was done.
Somehow we all got through the day, though most of Kelly's closest friends hadn't made it in. Natalie certainly hadn't.
----
That weekend was a tough one, but by Monday most of the students were back, including Natalie. While I had her in several classes over the years, I knew her best from the track, having worked with her closely since taking over coaching the girl's team last year. Nat and I immediately got along, she was our best sprinter and despite her success, listened to feedback and tried to follow my advice. Which had improved her results, shaving another two-tenths off her already impressive hundred-meter times.
She came into class looking like a zombie with dark circles under her eyes and no makeup, her hair back in a simple pony tail. When she saw me standing by the whiteboard her eyes welled up and she took two steps and leaned against me and started to cry. I hugged her and gave her a minute, while a few other students walked in averting their eyes--a couple of the girls wiping away some tears as they saw Natalie and me.
"Sorry, Coach," she said, sobbing slightly as she pulled back. "G... Got your shirt wet." She wiped at the wet spots as if it would make a difference.
"Don't worry about it. You sure you should be here today?"
She nodded. "They won't let me visit Kelly yet anyway. Only family's allowed in the ICU. They're saying she'll be in hospital for weeks. But now they think she'll make it at least. I talked to her mom last night, the swelling in her brain's gone down." There was a sad smile as Natalie wiped her eyes again, then turned and shuffled to her seat, shoulders slumped, displaying none of her usual pep.
I wasn't surprised at the length of the hospital stay. Over the weekend some pictures of the crash had been posted online, and there wasn't anything left of Dillon's car. The thing was unrecognizable, just a pile of twisted and ripped metal. The fact that Kelly came out of that mess alive was a miracle. It sounded like Dillon ran a red and got broadsided on the driver's side, before his car rolled, then hit a pole. He probably didn't feel anything and never knew what hit him.
We got through that class, though I ended up having to repeat myself a number of times. Both the students and I were distracted.
----
Over the next week, I slowly learned more about Kelly's condition as Natalie relayed updates. From the sounds of it, Kelly's left leg got seriously damaged in the crash, and she would need multiple surgeries over the next few months. If she was lucky, she would be able to walk normally. Eventually. Maybe.
She'd also broken two ribs, fractured her forearm, and had pretty severe whiplash. The most serious though was her concussion. There was some swelling of the brain at the start, and that had been what kept her in the ICU for the first few days after the accident. Though, by Tuesday she had improved enough that they transferred her to a regular room. Thank God for airbags.
Natalie and I fell into a pattern during that first week, she would stop off at lunch or after school and tell me how Kelly was doing, away from anyone else. I learned that while Kelly's body was slowly improving, except for the leg which was 'a real mess', her mental state was poor. I mean, how could it not be? Especially heading into Christmas.
I got to thinking of the banter we'd exchanged for for the last couple of years. Kelly had bugged me about wanting a ride on my motorbike. I took it to school most dry days, and every time she saw me she'd ask "When can I come for a ride Mr. A?" Then she would give me a big pouty lip when I once again told her, "Maybe when you're no longer one of my students." It had been an on-going thing that I'd enjoyed, and I was sad to realize that now she may never get the chance.
I was staring off into space after Natalie had delivered her latest update, when she interrupted my thoughts. "You know you're her favourite teacher, right, Coach?"
"Hmm, sorry?... I am?"
"Yeah, she always told me she was going to come back after grad, make you take her for that ride. And now... We were going to live together at Uni and everything." She stopped and wiped away a couple of tears and the look on Natalie's face broke my heart. I wanted to hug her to me and hold her while letting her cry all she wanted, but we were sitting in my classroom. And any kind of physical contact between teachers and students was problematic at best.
--
The holiday season wasn't exactly joyous, and by mid-January it was clear that Kelly would need at least two more surgeries on her leg, which meant extra time in hospital and even more time away from school. She wouldn't be able to graduate and would have to repeat senior year, given how much she had already missed.
"She's super bummed out about that," Natalie told me during practice. "I wish there was something we could do, but even if she takes summer school, she won't be able to make up all of the courses. They don't offer everything she needs in the summer."
It got me wondering what it would take to help Kelly graduate. The idea stuck with me during the rest of practice, and slowly a plan began to form. That night I sat at home, ignoring whatever show I'd put on TV while I doodled on a piece of scrap paper, and it turned into a compressed timeline of assignments and topics.
The next day I talked it over with Charles, who had Kelly in his Physics and Chemistry classes, and Vicky, who taught her English and History. After a bunch of back and forth, we agreed that it was feasible. If we worked together, we could get Kelly to graduate. But it would require some flexibility. We would have to adjust when she took exams and completed assignments, resulting in extra work for us.
That afternoon after classes had finished, we took our idea to Stacy, to see what she thought and whether she would sign off on changes to Kelly's exam schedule.
"This is a decent outline, but are you three sure you can spare that much time?" Stacy looked hard at Vicky and I. Coaching took a fair bit of extra time already, so the two of us had the most after-school commitments. Though to be fair, Charles was mentoring two new teachers this year and I knew from personal experience that he put a ton of effort into it.
"That's something we talked about," Vicky said. "Alone it won't be possible, but that's why we need to work together. Between the three of us, we think we can cover it."
Stacy didn't look convinced. "Kelly is already several weeks behind. You can't count on her being able to carry a full course load right away and you three have a lot of additional responsibilities." She looked back at the schedule. "This is tight..."
I jumped in. "I'm sure Natalie will help. She's been worried about Kelly not graduating and the two of them really want to go to Uni together. Given that she's an honours student and has aced most of her assignments, she can help Kelly study--after all they share most of their classes. And I'm okay stopping by Kelly's place one or two nights a week to work with her one-on-one. Think of it as 'office hours', with Vicky and Charles supporting me, and maybe even joining via video calls when needed."
After thinking for a second, Stacy smiled. "Oh hell, let's try! If we can get Kelly to graduate, that would be something positive for Grad at least."
----
The next day after I asked Natalie to stop by my room at lunch and sat her down to review the plan. "So, Ms. Lim, Mr. Davies and I, we talked it over and we think if we work together, we can still get Kelly to graduate, but we need your help."
There was a stunned moment of silence. "Seriously, Mr. Abrams, you would do that? Like, just tell me what I need to do, this is awesome!" She threw her arms around me and kissed me on the cheek in her exuberance. Seeing her face as she pulled back, mortified at what she'd done, was priceless.
"OhmygodI'msosorryMr. Abrams!"
I couldn't help but like Nat. "It's OK, we'll just forget about that."
"ThankyouThankyouThankyou!" She was blushing, but she was also bouncing with excitement, which was distracting. "What do we need to do? Like, when can I tell Kelly? Can I text her now? She's going to be so excited!"
"Ms. Bennett is going to call Kelly's parents today, to see if they're on board and I'm waiting to hear how that goes. I'm not going to sugar coat this Nat, it's going to be tough on Kelly, we don't know how much she can handle, especially at the start. And it's not going to be easy on you either. You've got practice, track-meets, then helping Kelly... So, weekends and evenings are going to be busy. You might not have much of a social life."
Natalie waved me off. "Doesn't matter. I'm not seeing anyone right now anyway." She frowned for just a second, then lit up again. "So, I have an idea. Like, to help motivate Kelly and stuff."
"Okay?"
"If she graduates, would you take her out on your bike? You know she's wanted to do that for, like, forever."
I hesitated. "Her parents might not like that. Plus, I'm not sure how far along she'll be in June--"
"Doesn't have to be right after school ends. Could be later in the summer? Please, Coach? She'd totally love it."
I thought about it, once she was no longer my student, it wouldn't be a big deal. "Sure. As long as it's after school is out, and her parents--"
"Forget her parents, Mr. A! We're both eighteen, she can make her own decisions. You think I'll let my parents tell me what I can and can't do once I get to Uni? Or even now. Hell, I'm an adult." The smirk on Natalie's face implied that there might be a number of things her parents weren't aware of. "Just tell her that if she works hard, she can graduate and then you'll take her on your bike when she's ready? Please?"
"First, let's wait to hear back from Kelly's parents. If they're on-board, then tomorrow I'll walk you through the lesson plan we put together, okay? Then, for the assignments you've completed already, it'd be great if you could take the lead on helping Kelly with those. We need to divide up the work as much as possible. The three of us will always be there to help you. You'd basically act like a teaching assistant. Then we can see about the bike thing once we see how she heals up."
"Totally! I'm so exited, I can't wait!" Natalie was bouncing again. It was cute, but given that she was wearing a tight v-neck t-shirt which really showed off her chest, I had to fight to keep my eyes on her face. Nat was super fit, with strong legs, an incredible bubble butt, and today was showing enough cleavage that I had a difficult time looking only at her eyes. As always, she seemed oblivious to the effect she was having.
----
The next day after getting the okay from Stacy, we went to work, identifying assignments that Kelly had already missed, finalizing the reading lists and setting some key milestones, so that she could be far enough along to take the final exams with her friends. It was going to be a difficult undertaking, but I was cautiously optimistic.
Natalie and I scheduled the visits to Kelly, so we could review assignments, and I would be there enough to answer questions of Kelly's that Natalie couldn't. She would spend as much time as she could with Kelly, while I started visiting two afternoons a week.
----
Seeing Kelly the first time was gut wrenching. She was propped up in bed and I didn't know how much weight she'd lost, but she looked like she was fading away. Around her leg she had some metal and wire contraption, I guess it held pieces of bone together while they healed, though it looked like some sort of torture device. I didn't want to think about how difficult basic things like going to the bathroom, were for her. Especially since her left forearm and wrist were also in a cast.
"Hey Kelly." I sat down next to her bed.
She held out her good hand and I took it and just held it for a while as she cried.
"It's going to take time," I said, gently squeezing her hand.
"So everyone says. Doesn't feel like anything's getting better. Dillon..." She stopped talking and cried quietly.
After what I thought was a reasonable amount of time, I tried to get us back on track. "So, your parents and Nat told you want we're trying to do?" She nodded. "OK, I've printed an outline for you to look at. We don't know how much you can do to start, so don't stress too much if our timing is off at the beginning. Just as long as you're making progress. Keep moving forward. Okay?"
"I'll try, Mr. A."
"Good. I have faith in you." I tried to give her a reassuring smile.
"Thanks. Glad someone does." She looked small and lost and I knew I had to do something more.
"And look, if you work hard, and you graduate..."
She looked at me a little confused. "Yeah?"
"I'll take you out on my bike once you're ready."
The waterworks started again, though she was trying to smile through her tears. "Thanks Mr. A. You're the best."
I sat with her for a while longer, but after a bit her hand went slack. She had fallen asleep, and I let go and quietly went out to find her parents
Kristy and Samuel stepped outside with me as I was leaving to thank me again for helping their daughter and to let me know how Kelly had perked up when she realized that there was a chance for her to graduate with her class. They looked as wrung out as Kelly had and I wondered when they last had a chance to relax.
--
The next few months were intense. Between coaching, track meets, and spending time with Kelly and Natalie, I had almost no free time. But it was worth it to see both the progress in Kelly's school work, and the improvement in her outlook. Once she saw some progress and started to believe graduating was possible, she worked tirelessly.
I'm not sure how much the promise to take her out on my bike helped, but she told me that she wanted to 'walk into prom even if it's on damn crutches', and between those two things it kept her motivated, both with her school work and with her physio.
In the meantime, I was spending a lot of time one-on-one with Natalie, more than I ever had with a student. It got to the point where she would stop by my place unannounced, often on the way back from Kelly's, to discuss a concept that she had a hard time explaining, or review a question from Kelly that had stumped her. We spent so much time together that I finally told her to call me Logan when we were alone, which had taken some effort on her part, but eventually she managed it most of the time.
I enjoyed spending time with her. She was young, sure, but quite mature for eighteen. And when we got back to school, she never let on how close we were getting, which I appreciated.
Eventually her frequent visits lead to us having dinner together several nights a week, while we worked and talked. We had already been close, but now our discussions started to go beyond school.
One Friday in late March after dinner, I caught Natalie staring at me. She blushed when she saw me look back at her, and quickly looked back at her plate.
"What?" I asked her after a second.
"Why don't you have a girlfriend, Logan?" She was still pretending to look at her food, but glancing up at me through her eyelashes.
"Well now, that's not the kind of thing I'd typically discuss with a student." I winked at her.
She shrugged. "OK, well, you asked, so..."
"Fair. Seriously, I was dating someone last fall, but it didn't work out. One of those things."
"She wouldn't do that thing you liked?" Natalie grinned at the look on my face.
"Natalie Bernard!" I tried to keep a straight face, but couldn't and laughed after a couple of seconds. Then I decided to tell her the truth. "She was looking for someone more 'upwardly mobile'. It became clear that a boyfriend on a teacher's salary would never be enough for her."
"Huh. Her loss. So now what, back to the dating apps?"
"What's with the fascination with my love-life?"
"Well, most of the senior girls on the team would totally... you know. You'd just have to say the word," she blushed. "They've been bugging me about how much time I get to spend with you, so that got me wondering why you weren't dating. You know, you're a good looking guy, got that motorcycle, which is hot, plus you're super nice. I mean just look at what you're doing for Kelly."
"Huh, thanks. Though I'm not sure how much we should be talking about this. If it got out--"
"I'd never say anything Mr. A. Honest!" Natalie was quick to jump in. After a second she added, "Except for Kelly, you know, she's my BFF. We tell each other everything."
"Okay. This is the kind of thing that can easily be misinterpreted. You know, single teacher has a student over on a Friday evening, they have dinner and talk about dating and stuff... Someone finds out and takes that even a little out of context, I would be in hot water."
Natalie's eyebrows were drawn. "Guess you need to think about that stuff all the time, huh?"
"Pretty much. Especially coaching you girls. I know some of the parents would prefer a female coach."
"That's stupid, you're a great coach. You've helped me so much! Anyway, I'll make sure to tell Kelly not to say anything. But also, we're only going to be students of yours for like a few months more. And I kinda would like hanging out now and then even after school's over." She was blushing.
Now we were on extremely thin ice and I hesitated. Not because I wanted Natalie to stay away necessarily, but the optics were an issue.
"Why don't we see about that after Grad, okay? Anyway, why aren't you dating anyone?" I had to stop myself from telling Nat that she was an extremely attractive young woman. "I've seen the way some of the guys in class look at you."
"Ugh, boys! I'm always busy with school and track, and that stuff comes first, and now with Kelly, I got no time. Plus, most guys want me to hang off their arm and look pretty and make googly eyes at them and can't handle it when I got my own stuff going on."
I steered the discussion back to schoolwork, and we talked a bit more about what was coming up, before Natalie had to go.
As she was leaving, she gave me a quick hug before rushing off. I watched her walk away, noticing the way her butt moved in her sweats. She had to be wearing a thong under there, if she was wearing anything at all.
I shook my head as I closed the door, I was playing with fire and hadn't quite realized it before tonight. I told myself I would need to be more careful, but that it would be fine.
It sounded good in my head, and I probably even believed it at that point.
----
It was another Friday a couple of weeks later, when I had an unexpected visit, though this time it was just after midnight when my doorbell rang.
On the intercom, I heard giggling, then "Mr. Aaa-aa, it's meeee-e," followed by more giggling. I buzzed Natalie up, and waited for her at the door, looking down my hallway to see if she would need help.
She came swaying down the corridor, one hand out, dragging her fingers along the wall to steady herself, still giggling, and hugged me at the door. "Oh god, your floor is so tilty! Did you know that? You shoulda warned me, Coach." She hiccuped, and I got a strong whiff of booze. Rum maybe.
"Christ Nat, how much have you had to drink?"
"Shhhhh, don't tell, K?" She hiccuped, shook her head, then frowned. "Ohhh, that was a mistake."
She was looking a bit green and I quickly got her inside and sat her on the couch, taking a large salad bowl out of the cupboard and placing it next to her on the floor. "Just in case you feel sick, try to remember the bowl is here."
"You're the best, Logan." Nat slid down a little, slumping and then tipping sideways on the couch. Based on her clothes--a short skirt paired with a low cut top visible under her light jacket--she had been out partying. Her clothing was in disarray, her jacket was twisted up behind her back, the skirt slid up, exposing some black boyshorts. At least it wasn't a thong. Her strong legs looked amazing as she lay there.
"Hey," I shook her shoulder lightly until she opened her eyes, "Why don't I get you something to change into?"
"Awwww, so sweet." Nat grinned and her eyes started closing.
I shook her shoulder again. "Nat, stay with me! Are your parents going to be worried?"
"Nope, planned ahead. Told 'em I was staying at Mi... Mira's." She closed her eyes and groaned. "Why's your couch so spinny?"
Shaking my head, I went and got a t-shirt and some boxer shorts. Taking off her heels, I pulled the shorts up her legs first, with Natalie giggling as I worked her skirt off after. She groaned again when I sat her up and leaned her into me so I could try to get the jacket off.
"Oh yeah! Soooo much better." Nat wrapped her arms around me. "You're the best." Then she kissed my cheek and I quickly pushed her back.
"None of that now."
"Awwww, big meany!"
"You want to put on a t-shirt?" I asked, looking at the tight sleeveless top she was wearing, which showed off some serious cleavage.
"Oh yeah! This's pretty tight..." And with that Nat crossed her arms in front of her, took the bottom of her shirt in her hands, and before I could stop her, pulled it up and over her head. It left her topless, apparently she hadn't worn a bra.
I was in trouble, because I wanted nothing more than to reach out and touch those breasts. They were damn near perfect, firm with small, hard nipples and absolutely no sag.
"Whoops," she said and giggled again. "You like 'em?" More giggles as Natalie reached up with both hands and squeezed her nipples. "Oh yeah. Wanna?"
Shaking my head--there was no way I was going to touch my drunk student, no matter how perfect her tits were--I held the t-shirt so she could slip her arms inside.
"C'mon Nat, put your arms in here. Let's get you covered up."
For a second she didn't move and I thought we were going to have a problem, but then she frowned and stuck her hands into the shirt, finding the armholes eventually and I pulled it over her head and down over her breasts.
Once I got it pulled down Natalie tipped sideways, giggled again, then groaned and raised both her hands to her face. "Oh God, I totally flashed you my tits."
I pulled her legs up on the couch, covered her with a blanket and got her tucked in. Something was missing, and I went back to my bedroom and got the spare pillow and gently worked it under her head. Nat was passed out.
Worried that she would wake up in the middle of the night and need to pee, I turned the light on in the bathroom so she could find it. Then I got a couple of Aspirin and a glass of water and left those on the coffee table for her. She was going to have a rough morning, maybe this would help.
I went to bed wondering if her visit was going to come back to haunt me.
Should I call Stacy in the morning to tell her a student had come by my apartment drunk and had flashed me? Or talk to Natalie first, see if she even remembered? Then again, how could she not, she would wake up in my shirt and boxers. The only bit of her own clothing she was wearing were those little boy-shorts.
It took me a while to fall asleep, I kept thinking about her, sitting there topless... Even jerking off didn't really help. I woke up numerous times throughout the night, listening to see if I could hear Natalie. At 8:24 a. m. the toilet flushing woke me and decided to get up and find out how she was doing.
Stepping out I saw her sitting on the couch, her head in her hands, groaning. But at least she'd had most of the water, and I saw she'd taken the painkillers.
"Rough morning?" I asked, keeping my voice low.
"Oh god. I'm so sorry." Natalie looked up and I saw tears in her eyes. "Do you hate me?"
I chuckled. "No. I don't hate you. I'm worried about a few things though."
She dropped her head back in her hands. "I totally flashed you, right?"
"You don't remember?" I sat down next to her on the couch.
"I mean, I kinda figured you wouldn't take my top off. But things are pretty fuzzy. Just sorta bits and pieces..."
"You were pretty sloshed, and yeah, you yanked your top off when I asked if you wanted to put on one of my t-shirts." She groaned again. "You need to call someone this morning? Anyone going to be worried where you are?"
She tried to shake her head, but stopped immediately and moaned in pain. "God, my head is pounding. I already messaged my mom to tell her I'd have breakfast with some friends and be home later. You want me out of here, I can get an Uber..."
"Why don't I make us some coffee, you look like you could use a cup." I took Natalie's groan as agreement, got up and went to the kitchen to put a pot on.
"Think you can handle a slice of toast? Might help settle your stomach," I asked, as I popped two slices into the toaster. If she didn't want some, I would.
"Um, I really want some eggs and bacon. Maybe we can go somewhere?"
"No problem, let me fry some up. I'm ready for some breakfast myself." I got a pan out and started heating it up.
Thirty minutes later we were on our second cup of coffee, the now empty plates in front of us, sitting at the kitchen table. Natalie still looked rough, but at least she didn't look like she'd throw up any second. Taking another sip of coffee, she was looking at me over the rim of her cup.
"So, just how bad was it?" she asked after a moment.
"You were pretty funny, actually. But yes, you flashed me when I came back with the t-shirt for you to sleep in, so that's a little problematic."
Natalie's eyes closed as I said it, and she lightly shook her head. "I'm so sorry Mr. A--"
"Logan. Please."
"Why are you always so nice, Logan?" Her eyes were on me again.
"Hmm, not sure how to answer that. Maybe because you're a good student? When you're sober anyway." I laughed at the pained expression on her face. "Look, we've all done stuff we regret. That just shows growth. At your ten year reunion, you'll laugh about it."
"That's an awful long time to be mortified though."
"No need. Believe it or not, that wasn't the first pair of breasts I'd seen."
There was a twinkle in her eye. "Yeah? How'd they compare?"
"Fucking spectacular." To this day I don't know what came over me.
Her whole face lit up. "Yeah? Cool!"
"Sorry, I shouldn't have said that--"
"No! I mean, as long as you meant it and weren't just..."
I took a deep breath. "I meant it, but I shouldn't have said it. I'm sorry--"
"Seriously, don't! You didn't do anything wrong, honest. I'm... I'm glad you liked 'em. You're always so careful, I see you with the girls on the team, you never stare at us like some of the other teachers. Even when we're wearing our skimpy workout stuff."
"Maybe we can keep what happened to ourselves? Now that we're on the topic?"
"Yeah, like I'm going to tell everyone that I got drunk and, naturally, I ended up at your place, and then made a total fool of myself, and flashed my favourite teacher." She picked up her phone and checked something. "Oh, shit. I texted Kelly..."
"Christ."
Nat was reading the messages. "She's jealous, she wants to flash you, too, now." She laughed for a minute before she put her cup of coffee down and held her head again. "You think I could get a couple of more Aspirin?"
"Sure. But, if Kelly knows, I'm wondering if I need to call Ms. Bennett to tell her--"
"Please don't. Neither of us will say anything. Nobody will ever know. Please, Logan?" Natalie dialed her phone and put it on speaker.
Kelly answered on the second ring. "Hey slut, how're you feeling?"
"Ugh, don't. You're on speaker with Logan."
"Hi Mr. A! Thanks for taking care of Nat when she was loaded," Kelly chuckled.
"No problem." I didn't say anything else, deciding to wait the girls out.
"Listen, you can't say anything about me coming over here. Promise!" Natalie sounded pretty desperate.
"This is why you're calling? As if. You know I... Never mind."
Natalie laughed. "I already told him you wanted to show off your tits, too. Slut."
"Damn you Nat! How could you!"
Now I was laughing. "OK, both of you. Nothing happened. Nat was drunk, and I'll pretend she never said anything about you. Okay, Kelly?"
"'Course," Kelly said. "Mine are better, though. Just sayin'"
"As if! I'm hanging up now!" Natalie said and punched End as Kelly was saying, "See you Tuesday Mr. A..."
I felt a bit better, it seemed that we had defused the situation, and I trusted Kelly to keep this to herself.
Natalie even made an attempt to help me clean up, but seeing how uncoordinated she was, I sent her back to the couch. I didn't have many dishes to spare, and was pretty sure she'd manage to break something.
Once cleaned up was done I joined her on the couch. Natalie leaned into me and I put my arm around her. We sat like that for a while and I was enjoying it, though I knew I shouldn't. But holding her like that felt good. I wasn't the only one who thought it was nice.
"Thanks, Logan. You're the best." She put her arm around my middle and hugged me, then stood up. "I should probably get dressed and start heading home.
Thankfully, this time she went to the washroom to change. Seeing her come out in her short skirt and skimpy top, with her hair a mess and looking properly hung over, she was the perfect model for 'walk of shame'. Except, of course, nothing happened.
"I used my finger and some of your toothpaste, 'cause yikes!" she said sheepishly.
"All good. You want me to drive you home?"
"Oh, hell no. If my parents saw, they'd know I wasn't out with friends. I'll just get an Uber. Thanks though."
"Okay. Probably for the best." I walked Nat to the door once she managed to get her heels back on.
She opened her arms and by this point I just let her hug me. Except, at the last moment she tipped her head up and kissed me on the lips.
"God, I'd wanted to do that for so long."
"Jesus, Nat!"
"Sorry, not sorry," she said, and at least she had the decency to blush. Then Natalie walked away, and I once again found myself looking at her ass, which looked delectable in that skirt. Just before she turned the corner she looked back, and smiled when she saw me watching her.
--
I was freaking out a little after she left. Why did I let her kiss me like that? I could have turned my head, or leaned back. But I didn't. I had never gotten this close to a student, and wasn't sure what to do.
By 2 p. m. I knew I had to talk to someone. My brain kept looping through what happened, from Nat flashing me, to us basically cuddling on the couch. And of course the kiss as she left. Part of me had wanted to pull her back into the apartment.
For a second I wondered if I should call Charles, but decided Vicky was a better option. We were much closer in age, and frankly, Charles was kind, but a nerd. Super nice, incredibly helpful, but I wasn't sure he could relate to my situation.
Vicky picked up on the third ring. I explained that Natalie had stopped by, drunk, and I had offered her the couch, struggling to tell her everything.
"Yeah? So she crashed. Not great, but not a crisis."
"Her outfit wasn't great for sleeping in, so I offered her a t-shirt of mine and--"
"Oh Logan! How bad?"
"She flashed me. And they're perfect and I can't stop thinking about 'em and I needed to tell someone. Kelly knows, but both the girls promised not to say anything. But I just keep thinking I should tell Stacy in case it comes out and... Christ."
Vicky hesitated a moment. "Don't call Stacy. You around tonight? Maybe this is a discussion we should have in person."
"You want to come by? I can cook or we can order something?" Now that I had told her, I felt a little better already. Of course, I still hadn't told her about the kiss.
"Done. If you order pizza, I'll bring the beer."
"Deal."
We agreed on 5:30 p. m. and Vicky hung up.
I did some laundry and cleaned my place to keep busy until she arrived.
----
Vicky was right on time and held up a bag as she walked in. "Got a couple of six-packs of Sierra Nevada."
"Nice, one of my favourites."
She hugged me once she'd put the beer in the fridge. "Still freaked out?"
"Not as much now that I've told to you."
"Why don't you order the pizza and then we'll sit and talk."
I made the call and we cracked open a couple of beer, sitting at the kitchen table. Then I spent five minutes walking her through the events, from the fact that Nat and I gotten closer as we helped Kelly--which Vicky already knew--to how casual things were becoming, finally telling her about the previous evening and this morning's kiss as she left.
"Christ, I can see why you're conflicted." Vicky had a grin that didn't match what she had just said. She must have seen by my reaction that something wasn't syncing for me. "You know, I've seen Natalie in the change room more than once."
"Yeah?"
"Hmhmm. Maybe I time it so I'm in there after you finish practice with the girls."
That took me a second to fully appreciate. "Wait. Are you saying..."
"Well, this is just between us, right?"
"Of course!"
"Then yeah. Fuck, she's got a smokin' bod. That ass! Those gravity defying titties. I'd love those thick legs wrapped around my head!"
"Holy shit Vicky! I didn't even know you were into girls."
"Well, I was a LUG." I guess my face showed that I didn't understand. "Lesbian Until Graduation. I dated a couple of girls during university. One was a gymnast like myself, the other I met in my Humanities class." She paused her face got serious. "You have to swear that this next part will never, ever, get out."
"What happened?" She didn't say anything, and I realized I didn't answer her. "I mean, yes. Of course. This entire discussion stays between us."
"A couple of years ago, two of the girls on my team gave me a special send off at the end of the year."
"You don't mean..."
"Oh, but I do!" She grinned, clearly there was no regret. "We fucked each other silly from Friday night to Sunday afternoon. I've never been so sore, or so satisfied."
I stared at her, my mouth open. This wasn't what I expected when she said she wanted to talk in person. I thought she would give me a bit of a hard time, remind me to be professional and not screw up any more.
Vicky gave me a minute before she went on. "I'm surprised you've not had any of the girls take a run at you. The way mine talk about you... Well, let's just say there is no lack of opportunity. If you wanted, I mean."
That took a moment to fully sink in. "You don't seem to have an issue any of with this. How come?"
She shrugged. "It's not like they're underage, obviously I'm only talking seniors here. And clearly you're not the one pursuing them. I mean, in a couple of months, Natalie won't be a student. If she'd come onto me like that, I'd have taken the little slut straight to bed. God, I'd eat that tasty looking snatch of hers in a heartbeat."
"Jesus Vicky! This is not how I expected this discussion to go."
"Well yeah, that's kinda why I wanted to talk in person. Hell, I'm getting hot just thinking about her." She was fanning herself with her hand for effect.
I was seeing Vicky in a whole new light. Maybe it was easier for a woman, especially a female coach, but the way she talked... "And nobody ever suspected?"
"Well, that time they gave me the send off, there were some rumours later that summer. Stacy called me and we talked, I didn't admit anything of course. And she let it go. But the girls and I are still friends, hell they visit now and then when they're back from school, to... you know. And again, if they're over eighteen and they initiate it," she shrugged, "where's the harm?"
"This isn't how I thought this would go."
"Yeah bud, you already said that." Vicky laughed at me. She was only a year older than me, but right now I sure felt like a babe in the woods.
I was saved by the doorbell; our pizza had arrived.
We ate in silence, sipping beer in between slices of cheesy goodness. I was digesting what Vicky had told me, while trying to adjust the way I thought of her. She'd shocked me, which didn't happen very often. I knew the girls she coached thought highly of her. So hearing about what she got up to with some of them... I had been busy beating myself up before she got here, wondering how I could screw up this badly, while trying to promise myself that I would do better. But now... God, I was seriously considering getting together with Natalie. We were ten years apart, but aside from that...
"So, you working through it?" Vicky asked eventually.
I realized I'd been sitting there, not saying anything for a while. "Yeah, sorry. It's a shock."
"I should mention that I have some rules."
"Like what?"
"Well, there's always a chance that things will go wrong. So here's what I do: First, no girls that are likely to get attached. You know, the needy ones, virgins, ones that haven't been with women before. Obviously, they have to be seniors, over eighteen and planning to go to University out of town, that way there's a natural break. And no one who's got a boyfriend or girlfriend, I don't need that kind of drama. Finally, they have to have the right attitude: Independent, self-assured enough that they're not going to get a huge schoolyard crush and get all clingy." She paused and looked at me.
"You've thought this through."
"Have to. It's risky, and I don't want to lose my job. But it's also super hot. Wait 'till the first time you take one into the equipment room for a frantic bang. You'll have a huge smile on your face the whole day after, while simultaneously being terrified that someone might find out. Lemme tell you, it's something else..." She had a big grin on her face.
I had no idea she was such a thrill seeker. One of the many things I hadn't known about Vicky.
We talked some more, and I wondered what to do next with Natalie. Should I wait for her? Let her know not to feel bad, that I didn't mind? It made our conversation choppy, but Vicky didn't seem bothered.
For the rest of the evening we mostly stuck to other topics, gossiped about teachers and students. It seemed the new drama teacher, Richard, was grossing out Vicky's girls with his comments and stares.
"You should hear them during practice, they hate him. When he's instructing them on stage, he likes to 'position' them, you know, touching them to move their limbs and stuff. Excusable, for a Drama teacher, but the way he does it, yuk. Some of the girls add an extra layer before going to his class, just to cover up everything. Which, just so you know, is pretty much the opposite of what they do with you. Ever notice that there seems to be a lot of skin visible in you class?"
I shrugged. "I try not to look."
"Exactly. Which makes you a challenge and they like that. I could give you a list you know." She smirked at me.
"Of... Oh, seriously?" I shook my head, struggling to believe what she was saying.
"Oh yeah, of all the seniors who would love to have you keep them behind for detention and 'atone for their sins'... and sin some more." Seeing the look on my face Vicky threw her head back, laughing loudly. "You look so stunned. It's cute."
"Ha. Ha. Very funny." I felt like the new guy again, something that hadn't happened the last couple of years. "What about the other teachers, does anyone... You know."
"Not sure. Not like we sit around the lounge when you're not there and talk about this stuff. I haven't heard any rumours, and just to be clear, you're the only person I've ever told about this. So mum's the word."
"Same, obviously."
I pictured Richard in my mind, since he was the drama teacher we didn't interact much. Artsy guy with a skinny goat-tee, seemed to be a touch too friendly with the students--the irony wasn't exactly lost on me. Now that I thought about it, I could see what Vicky meant. There was one time when I'd been talking with Kelly and Natalie in the hall at lunch, and he walked past and gave them this look. Sort of... hungry.
Vicky checked the time. "Look, this has been great, but I should get going. Keep me updated, and reach out if you need to talk. And don't stress about Natalie."
"That's easier said than done. I'm probably going to spend all day tomorrow thinking about how to handle things on Monday."
"My advice? Just do whatever you'd normally do. Don't act different. It'll be fine. Nat's smart, she won't do anything risky while at school." She had put her sneakers back on and we were standing by the door.
I was grateful for her advice and somehow as we stood by my door, that turned into a hug. Another woman I didn't think I'd be hugging regularly.
"Hmm, you're a good hugger, I can see why she likes it." Vicky laughed when she saw my face and was still laughing as she stepped out the door. "Too adorable. Have a great weekend."
"Thanks Vicky. You're not so bad yourself." I finally said to her back as she was walking away and she waved over her shoulder.
----
After Vicky left I felt better. While it was fresh in my mind, I took out a piece of paper to write out her rules. After a minute I shook my head, I couldn't believe I was seriously considering it--scratch that. The truth was, I was full on planning on taking things further with Nat if she came onto me again.
Christ.
That night I slept better than I thought I would. Sunday morning I had my coffee and a light breakfast, before going to the gym. It felt good, pushing the weight, tiring myself out. Getting out of the apartment helped clear my head.
It also gave me the opportunity to think while doing something physical. Mostly I thought of the taboo of a teacher having sex with a student. Hell, we let eighteen-year-olds vote, go to war, get killed for their county. Why can't they pick a teacher to sleep with?
Was I rationalizing? Maybe. No, definitely. Still, what if I met Natalie on a beach in August, and we got together?
As I was stretching after my workout, I felt calmer. The decision was made. I wouldn't pursue Natalie. But good lord, if she initiated, I wasn't going to hesitate. Obviously, she had to be sober.
On the drive home I thought back to Nancy, my last girlfriend. We started dating in June, and in October, a week after I stored my motorbike for the winter, it was over. Looking back, it's so clear that I was her 'summer boyfriend, with the bike'. She was pretty, but also quite self-absorbed. If I had to put money on it, even at twenty-two I'm not sure she was any more mature than Natalie.
----
Monday was the litmus test. Nat greeted me like she always did, maybe the smile was a little bigger, but not so anyone would notice. Class and practice went fine, she smiled, laughed, and behaved just like any other week.
I was feeling physically lighter as I headed home that night.
----
Tuesday after class I headed over to see Kelly as planned. Kristy opened the door and called out, "Mr. Abrams is here, Kelly!" before pointing in the direction of the dining room.
Kristy and Samuel were used to me visiting by now, and usually they just told me where their daughter was and left us alone. Now and then we sat together and I gave them a run down on the progress Kelly had been making, which had been slow at first--as expected--and then picked up as her overall condition improved, her attention span increased, and she started to believe she could do it. By now I was quite sure she would be able to graduate, as long as there wasn't a major set back.
Even better, Kelly was able to move around by herself, her final surgery had gone well--they had to do something finicky with the ligaments in her damaged knee--and now she was hobbling around on her own, with some crutches. The first time I saw her on them she grinned like a madwoman. Stairs were still an issue, but otherwise she was mobile enough to get a snack from the kitchen and visit the washroom by herself.
When I sat down with Kelly in the dining room, her books were spread out and taking up more than half of the table, it was clear something bothered her.
I took my seat next to her. "Hey sport, what's going on?"
"Nothing."
That was obviously not true and I waited her out. It only took a minute or so.
"Okay, so, it's my parents' anniversary this weekend, like their twenty-fifth, and now they aren't going on this trip they had planned, 'cause 'I'm not ready to be alone', or whatever. Which is bullshit. And, like, I overheard that they can't even get a refund. Anyway, it sucks and I feel totally guilty."
I nodded, but I wasn't sure what to tell her. If she were my responsibility I might not want her to spend three days alone, either.
Kelly was warming up to the subject now. "Thing is, Nat offered to stay here the whole time, but they're worried about me going upstairs or whatever. Like, we'll manage! Ugh. They've been looking forward to this for a long time, got tickets to some special show, and now none of that's gonna happen. I don't want them to miss out because of me, you know? I've caused 'em enough trouble already."
"I don't think that's how they're looking at it, Kel."
She leaned back and stared at me. "Well, would you want someone to miss out on a super fun trip because of something you did?"
"No, of course not."
Not knowing what to say next, I started pulling out my textbook and laptop. "Why don't we take a look at this week's assignment, and then I can walk you through what's coming up. K?"
"Ugh. Sure, why not." Kelly sat there frowning with her arms crossed, but once we got going she became more like her regular self.
When we were done with the schoolwork, Kelly slid back and looked at me. "So, you and Nat?"
"What about us?" I answered quietly, looking around to make sure Kristy or Samuel weren't around to hear.
"I mean, she doesn't just flash every cute teacher, you know?" Kelly looked at me like I was being dense.
"I would hope not. Also, this is all just between us, right?"
"Like, obviously. My lips are sealed." She made a zipper motion in in front of her lips. "But, she's my girl, you know. And, well. She likes you. Doesn't sound like you're getting any either. So..."
"Kelly Sullivan! Are you trying to get me to sleep with one of my students?" I hissed, trying for mock-outrage, but she wasn't biting.
"I'm telling you she won't say anything. Plus, she's hot. I mean, 'course I'm biased, but she is. Don't tell me you don't think so. She won't shut up about you, and she'd totally kill me if you told her what I said."
"Look, I appreciate it. But I think it would be better for all of us, if we let this go." Before I could stop myself, I added, "At least until after grad."
"Huh." Kelly looked pleased. "Sure. After grad, why not." She was grinning now.
"Now, any more questions before I go?" Seeing the look on her face, I quickly threw in, "About schoolwork, Kelly."
"Oh..." She smirked. "Nope, I'm good for a couple of days. Thanks." She carefully stood and held her arms open. "She gets hugs, so do I!"
"Fine." I wrapped her up in a gentle hug, making sure not to squeeze too hard.
"Thanks Mr. A." She smiled, something she was starting to do more of these days. It made all the effort worth it.
----
As I was getting ready to leave Kristy walked me out to check on the progress we were making.
After I gave her a quick update, I made a spur of the moment decision. "Kelly told me that you guys were cancelling a trip--"
"Oh, I'm sorry Logan, she shouldn't have bothered you with that."
"Well, thing is, I stop by here all the time anyway. I could check on the girls Friday evening, and pop in both Saturday and Sunday." She started to respond and I held up my hands. "Really, it's not a big deal. And then with Nat here the whole time, it wouldn't be an issue. If there's anything urgent, she can just call me. I'm like ten minutes away."
"We've imposed on you enough, really. But thanks."
"At least talk it over with Samuel. I haven't said anything to Kelly, but honestly, I don't mind. And she blames herself for you two missing out on your trip. Hell, maybe the girls and I can even watch a movie together or something. I'll even let you pay for takeout." I smiled at her, trying to make her feel better.
She hesitated. "Well... Let me talk to Sammy later. But honestly, you've done too much already." With that, Kristy quickly hugged me and went back inside.
On the ride home--I was taking my motorbike again whenever the weather was decent--I wondered if I was doing it just to help Kelly, or if part of it was that I wanted to spend more time with Natalie.
--
For the rest of the week Natalie seemed to wear the smallest and tightest clothes she owned, both to class and practice. Her skirts were tiny, shorts extra tight, tops either low cut or tight enough to show that her boobs stayed in place even without a bra, her hard nipples poking through the material.
The boys in class stared, while I tried to look at her only from the neck up. Not that any of this discouraged her, she always greeted me with a huge smile and had started to hug me after practice, sweaty or not. Some of the other girls started doing the same, and I was getting a touch concerned that some of the parents would find out and complain. Though, it was all rather innocent.
Vicky grinned at me when she saw me in the hallways, and more than once I heard a quiet, "Doooo eeeet!" as I passed her in the halls. It made me shake my head, but also laugh. We had our own private little thing, and it was kind of fun.
Thursday evening I got a call from Kristy, asking if I was really sure about checking in on the girls while she and Samuel were away on their anniversary weekend. I assured her, again, that it would be fine, and I'd be happy to do it. I could hear her smile as she thanked me and told me they were going to go.
Thirty minutes later I got a text from Kelly, 'Party at my house! Stop by anytime Mr. A! : D '
----
Friday, Natalie stopped by my classroom at the end of the day. "So, when you gonna come by? Should we order extra food for you?"
"Sure. But I don't want to get in the way of your fun either."
Nat looked behind her to make sure nobody was at the door. "Logan, come by as much as you want. Nobody else will be there, just Kelly and me. We're going to lay around, talk trash, maybe raid her dad's liquor cabinet. She said he bought some variety packs of beer, since he didn't know what you liked. They told Kelly to order in whatever we want, but we'll probably cook something tomorrow, just for fun. Kel can't do much, but still, she wants to feel more useful, and her mom isn't letting her do anything, afraid she'll trip and fall or something. Whattaya say?"
"Well, I don't drink and ride."
"Just stay as long as you need after. And if you drink too much, they have plenty of space."
It was time to pivot the discussion back to safer ground. "What's for dinner tonight?"
"We're ordering sushi. Wait, are you coming?" She was clapping her hands. "Awesome!"
I gave her an outline of what I liked, and she assured me they were into the same things.
At 5:30 p. m. I rolled up and by the time I parked the bike and took my helmet off, Nat already had the front door open and was waiting for me as I walked up. She was wearing a t-shirt that seemed a size too small, along with some cotton shorts that left very little to the imagination and seemed unable to contain her butt, leaving a quarter cheek exposed.
"Hi Logan!" She hugged me like we hadn't seen each other for months, even though it had only been a couple of hours.
"Nat, behave!" I said as I hugged her back.
Kelly wasn't far behind, she came hobbling over and hugged me awkwardly, trying to hold both crutches up with one hand while throwing her free arm around me.
"So, have you ordered yet?" I asked as we made our way to the living room, where Kelly was set up on the big couch so she could elevate her leg, putting Natalie and I together on the loveseat.
"Nope, just about to. Want to look over what we're thinking?" Nat brought up the app on the phone and walked me through what they planned to get. I thought of adding some more sashimi, but the girls had so many rolls and nigiri already, I decided to skip it, and she placed the order.
While we waited the girls went through a list of movies they were interested in watching. There were a bunch of rom-coms and I thought about leaving after dinner, but finally there were a couple of movies that I wouldn't mind watching, including a few Tarantino flicks that I had seen many times but was always up for seeing again. After some discussion, we picked Pulp Fiction.
Once the food was delivered, we set up on the coffee table and Kelly carefully positioned herself on the floor--leg somewhat awkwardly stretched out in front of her--so she could eat and see the TV at the same time, then we started the movie.
It turned out to be a ton of fun, the girls kept talking back and forth trying to figure out what was happening, until they realized that the action was 'out of order', then got even more into it. Since I'd seen it many times, I had to bite my tongue as they were guessing. They screamed when the gimp came out, their eyes wide and I laughed at them.
Somehow, the beer in front of me was never empty and by the time the movie had finished, I realized I had more than I wanted to. Natalie started cleaning up and I helped her carry the leftovers back to the kitchen, where four empty bottles were lined up by the sink.
"Shit, I didn't mean to drink that much. No way I can ride. Not for a while anyway," I said, more to myself than her.
"So, stay." Nat stepped in front of me, wrapping her arms around the back of my neck and rising up on her toes. I found myself leaning down and we kissed. I could blame the beer, but the truth was, I enjoyed hanging out and watching the movie with her next to me. Soon I had my hands on her ass, pulling her into me as our tongues explored.
"Now that's a kiss!" we heard from the living room, and when I turned Kelly was looking over the back of the couch, grinning at us. "Hell, don't stop 'cause of me. It's hot. I'll just watch."
"Shh, don't ruin it!" Nat said, before turning back to me and pulling me down for another kiss. I knew I should stop, but somehow that didn't happen. "Stay," she said again when we came up for air. "Have another beer, and crash here."
"Kelly's parents would just love that."
"They won't even know," Kelly called from the living room. "And I sure as shit ain't gonna to tell 'em. Also, I could just say you had a beer too many."
"Yeah. And this way you can make sure we're good girls and don't get into trouble." Natalie didn't even make an effort to try and sell that one.
"C'mon, have another beer, and I'll put on another movie. Something fun, like Shrek or one of the Despicable Me's," Kelly called, while Nat gave me her best puppy-dog eyes.
"Fine," I said and Natalie cheered and pulled me over to the fridge, where I got myself another beer.
We ended up watching Despicable Me 2, which was OK, but to be honest, I didn't see much of it, as Natalie and I were too busy making out, with Kelly providing the occasional commentary. Which was embarrassing at first, but after a while I didn't really care, because I had my hand up Nat's shirt and was having way too much fun.
"She's got great tits, no?" Kelly asked and as I looked over, she pulled up her own t-shirt to flash me. "But mine are a little bigger."
"Slut." Natalie laughed.
"Jealous?" Kelly fired back.
"His hands are on mine, so, no." She stuck her tongue out and Kelly laughed.
That little exchange gave me a chance to reassess, and I was seriously screwing up. "Maybe this has gone too far."
"Na-uh," Natalie said and slid onto my lap, sitting on my legs and facing me while pulling off her top and then kissing me again. "Not far enough."
"Bow chucka bow-oww. Am I gonna get a live show?" Kelly asked.
Nat looked over at her. "Want one?"
"Been going through a real dry spell here," Kelly said seriously. "But no. Your guys' first time together shouldn't be on the couch. Go use my parents' room." She glanced at me and grinned. "Nat already changed the sheets."
"What a bad girl!" I smacked her ass over her shorts and the way she smiled at me made me realize she liked it.
"Are you going to be okay to get ready for bed by yourself?" I asked Kelly, and when she smiled and nodded. I stood up, holding onto Natalie's butt. She squealed, but wrapped her legs around me.
"Don't drop me on the stairs!" she ordered as I walked over, then made my way up. She directed me to the bedroom, and I tossed her on the bed. She laughed as she bounced, looking up at me. "Do you want to peel these shorts off me? Or do you want a show?"
Instead of answering, I pulled off my shirt then joined her on the bed, kissing my way up her legs, taking my time and enjoying her soft thighs, slowly working my way up. Nat giggled and said it tickled, but kept spreading her legs to give me access.
When I got to her shorts, I looked up and she was biting her lip, watching me eagerly. "Please?"
I raised up on my knees and took hold of the waistband. "Last chance to stop."
"No stopping!" she said raising her butt
I slid the shorts off, then looked down at her perfect, pink little pussy, framed by just a touch of hair above it. It was glistening with moisture. "Damn."
"Gonna do more than just look at it?" She smirked.
Not answering, I lay back down, got my mouth as close as I could, and started blowing on her clit, which was poking out under it's hood.
"Oh, fuck." Nat's hands drifted to her nipples and she played with them as I alternately blew on her clit and kissed the little crease between her legs and her pussy. "Such a tease," she complained.
"What do you want me to do?"
Her head came up and she looked at me. "I mean... hell, what do you want?"
"Everything."
"Wow. Um, that's... I... I don't what that means." For the first time she looked flustered.
"For starters? It means your little pussy," I kissed it, "later your mouth," I kissed her wet lips again, "And then we'll see."
She moaned, then said, "Umm, that sounds good."
"We can go slow."
"Okay. Or, maybe don't?" she said quietly.
Have spent enough time teasing her, I finally kissed her wet pussy, starting lightly and not using any tongue. I avoided her slit and enjoyed the way she writhed around on the bed, trying to increase the contact. She moaned but didn't complain, and kept playing with her nipples. Once or twice she tried to sneak a hand down to her clit, but I pushed it away and told her to be a good girl for me. She told me she'd rather be bad, and I finally had enough and got naked.
"Protection?" I asked.
"Got the implant and haven't been with anyone for a while."
"Me neither. Condom?"
"I want to feel you, Logan."
That was enough for me, and I positioned myself between her legs. Nat hooked her heels behind my butt and pulled me into her.
She was soaked and I slid in to the hilt despite how tight she was.
"Do it hard. Just fuck me."
My plan had been to go slow, but that went out the window as soon as she spoke. Natalie fucked back at me, and no matter how hard I slammed into her, kept smiling and asking for more. She pulled my hands to her tits and told me to squeeze.
"Harder. No, fuck, harder!" she yelled, shocking me with just how much she could take.
After a little while, we switched positions. She got on her hands and knees and I started fucking her doggy style, using her hips to hold onto, my fingers turning the skin white where I squeezed. Looking down I could see her pussy lips try to hold onto my cock as I slid out.
I loved it, she was one of the most enthusiastic partners I'd ever had.
As she got close, Nat thrust a hand between her legs and flicked her clit, which finally pushed her over the top. She tightened as she came, but I wasn't quite there yet and kept going. She groaned after her orgasm passed, but never complained, and after a minute was fucking back at me again, screaming as she rushed towards a second climax. When I finally flooded her wet snatch, she came again.
"Fuck yesssss!" she yelled out, and we could hear some laughter from downstairs.
I let myself fall next to her, breathing hard and sweaty. "Guess Kelly heard."
"She'd have to be dead not to." Natalie grinned, then leaned over and kissed me. "So, eighteen year old pussy. Good?"
"No," I said. "But with time and practice, you can probably get to be half-decent."
"You fucking bastard!" Kelly laughed and smacked my arm. Then she rolled on top of me and kissed me again. "That was a seriously great fuck, Logan."
"Well, I'm not going to disagree with that. Hell of a workout, too." I was still breathing hard. "We going to be good on Monday?"
"Stop worrying. Let's just have fun this weekend. Monday is what it is. I promise I'm not going to let on. Really."
"Alright." I still worried a little, but was also looking forward to spending more time with Nat naked.
"I should go check on Kelly," Natalie said after a while.
"Want me to come along?"
"You really want to hear me telling her all about how well you just fucked me?"
"That'd be awkward."
"Ya think?" Natalie laughed, then kissed me again. "I tell her everything. Just so you know."
"So you said..." I pretended to be worried.
"All good! Really." She got up, looked at the clothes on the ground, and picked up my t-shirt, slipping it on. "Hmm, smells like you. I like it... You may not get this back." And with that she walked out, leaving me to think about what just happened.
After a minute I got up and dug my phone out of my pants pocket and texted Vicky. 'So tasty. And tight!'
She replied almost immediately. 'Holy shit, you did it! I'm jealous! Meet up tomorrow so you can tell me about it?'
'I might stay here all weekend.'
'Good for you! Feel free to shoot some video ;) '
I laughed, that's just what I needed, evidence of our... what, 'affair'? No, that didn't seem right. I wasn't sure what to call this. Partly I thought of it as a mistake, but really, I couldn't wait to fuck Natalie again. And I wouldn't mind having a vid of her and I going at it. My cock twitched, I wouldn't need much more recovery time. I heard the girls squeal and laugh downstairs, and decided that sitting up here alone was dumb. I pulled my pants back on, my spare shirt was by the couch in my backpack--I might have planned ahead and brought a change of clothes--and went downstairs to Kelly's temporary bedroom.
Kelly saw me first. "Nice job, Mr. A! You got high marks from my girl here."
Natalie giggled, blushed, then got up and skipped over to hug me. "Definitely. Top of the class. Best teacher I ever fucked."
"You got a lot of experience with teachers then?"
"Oh yeah, totally.' Natalie tried to look serious, but then laughed. "Or maybe you're the first. Well, first teacher."
We hung out on Kelly's bed and talked, with Kelly grinning at us. Nat kept leaning into me and I thought about Vicky's rules and wondered if we might have a problem. Maybe later in the weekend we could have a discussion about attachment.
"Just so you know, I texted my mom and told her you had a couple of beer and didn't want to ride your bike home. She's totally on-board with that, said she didn't want anyone riding or driving after too much, ever. You know, just in case any of the neighbours talk about seeing it parked here overnight while mom and dad are away."
"Hmm." I thought about it for a second. "That's a good idea. I'll clear out in the morning, give you two some time."
"But you're coming back?" Natalie face was tight.
"As long as I'm not going to overstay my welcome."
Kelly laughed. "As if. You better come back, Nat's not had a good fuck for a while."
"Well, not like you have!" Natalie shot back.
"Don't remind me. I'll be okay as long as you tell me all the dirty details."
"You know I will!" Natalie laughed at the face I made.
"Don't worry Mr. A, I'll totally get off thinking about it," Kelly said, shocking me. "What? You think just because I'm still hobbling around on crutches, I don't get horny?"
"I hadn't really thought about it. And now I'm trying not to."
She laughed. "I don't care if you think about me flicking my bean. Hell, you wanna watch?" Kelly started sliding her hand down the front of her t-shirt, towards her shorts.
"Hey!" Nat complained, "At least wait 'till tomorrow before you try 'n steal him!" But she was laughing.
I decided this had gone far enough and got up. "I'm going to go brush my teeth and get ready for bed."
"I'll be a few more minutes, then I'll come up to join you. Maybe, like, be naked?" Nat said and I shrugged.
"Ugh, I'm so jealous," I heard Kelly say as I was walking out.
----
I got into bed after visiting the washroom, dressed in a clean t-shirt and my boxer-briefs, having decided Nat could get me naked herself and have some fun in the process. Having a tight-bodied senior who wanted to fuck your brains out, and liked it a little rough... I wasn't sure things could get much better. I was thinking again about Vicky's request to shoot some video, and how nice it would be to have a visual reminder of what we'd done, when Nat came in.
She didn't hesitate, just pulled off the t-shirt she was wearing, and stood there naked. "You want me to go shower? Or, are you a kinky fucker and want me again even if I'm all dirty?"
"What would you like, Nat?" I asked, hedging my bets.
"Definitely dirty. Actually..." She crawled onto the bed, tugging down the sheets and then my shorts. "Let's hope you still taste like me..." She took my thickening cock into her mouth, moaned as she tasted herself, before licking the head all over.
It took no time at all to get me back to full stiffness and she never let up, sucking me carefully, licking all around the ridge below the head, before going to work on the shaft, occasionally drifting down to my balls to suck them.
I lay there and let her do what she wanted, happy to let her enjoy herself. Eventually she moved back to the head and I asked, "You think we should let Kelly watch sometime?"
She looked up at me, surprise evident on her face. "Would you? Like, seriously?"
"I didn't think you'd be up for it, but you didn't exactly object when Kelly suggested it earlier."
"That's 'cause it'd be super hot. Want me to get her?" She was downright eager and it made me chuckle.
I thought about it. "Not tonight. Plus, maybe it'd be better downstairs on the loveseat, so we don't have to carry her up here."
"Totally! Let's do it tomorrow." Nat was almost bouncing from excitement.
"And what if I wanted to shoot some video of us. You know, to remember this by?"
"Do I get a copy?" She was grinning, so apparently the idea didn't bother her.
"You want one?"
"Hell yes."
"And you'd not show anyone, ever?"
Natalie hesitated. "Wellllll.... I mean, I might want to watch it with Kelly. You know, later, like when we're in Uni and you're not around."
I gave her my best dirty-grin. "Just what would you be doing while watching it?"
A slow, filthy smile spread across Natalie's face. "Grab your phone and I'll show you."
I didn't hesitate, reaching over to the bedside table, and firing up the camera.
"Switch ends with me," she said, already moving. I went to the bottom of the bed, and Nat laid back on some pillows, spreading her legs, looking at me and raising an eyebrow. "Ready?"
I positioned myself so I was between her knees, focused on her pussy while keeping her torso and face in the background, as Natalie started playing with her pussy, narrating as she teased herself.
"You got me so wet, Logan. God, just look at this," she held her up her cream-covered fingers, then slowly brought them to her mouth to lick off her pussy juices and remnants of my cum, ensuring I got it all on video, before moving back between her legs to play with her clit, teasing it out from under its protective hood. Every now and then she dipped her fingers back inside, getting them wet, then spreading that wetness around her stiff nub.
"I can't believe I'm finally here and we're fucking. You can fuck me all summer. Anytime, just call, and I'll come over." Her breath hitched. "It's so damn hot knowing you're gonna watch me do this later. You enjoy watching me play with myself? Be a dirty whore with you? Your dripping little high-school slut. You like that? That I'm so much younger? And your student? Oh fuck." She shuddered and I made sure I got her face in the shot as she came. Not that it slowed her down, if anything she went even harder, stretching her orgasm.
"I'm starting to get a little sore, Logan. Wanna fuck me again? Or do you even care, are you going to fuck me no matter what, sore or not... Oh goddammit..." She stiffened, her legs straightening while her eyes closed and she came again.
At this point I had enough and I quickly stopped the video, throwing the phone to the side, before I slid up, my cock hard. I pierced her, driving into her and holding her down while I took what I wanted.
She cried out, then grinned at me. "That's it, use me. Your dirty student. Your little whore!"
I kissed her to shut her up. Not that I wasn't enjoying the dirty talk, but I didn't have it in me to respond right now, I was much too focused on getting to my second orgasm. Reaching down, I hooked my arms below her knees, bringing them up and forcing her legs back, opening her fully, while fucking her hard. That went on for some time, before I slowed until I was hardly moving, so I could catch my breath.
"I'd no idea you're such a dirty girl. Maybe if I'd known, we could have done this sooner." I kept moving in and out slowly, enjoying the feeling of her tightening up to try and keep me inside her.
"Hmm, I'll be even dirtier. Just tell me what you want." She kissed me again, our tongues wrestling, until I pulled back.
"One day I want you to meet me early, before class, and I'll fuck you. And then you'll walk around school all day, my cum dripping out of you. Sitting in it as classes go on, all day long."
"Oh, fuck!" Natalie tightened as she came again, this time it proved too much and it sent me over the edge as well, and I filled her, collapsing after.
"Holy fuck," I said, laughing as I lay on Natalie, "That was amazing." I kissed her. "You're amazing."
The grin on her face was huge. "Thanks. And you're not so bad yourself... Wow."
I rolled off and we lay there for a while.
"I'm too tired to get up, so I hope you don't mind me all cummy." She reached down and scooped some from her pussy, licking her fingers clean after. "Yum. Definitely need to give you a sneaky blowjob some day at school."
"Listen--"
"I know, Logan. We need to be careful, nobody can find out, you'll lose your job." She held up her hand, "And I won't let anyone find out what happened, honest. Kelly was talking about trying to go back for half-days, maybe she can be a lookout for us. I mean, she knows, so..."
It was too much for me to consider right then. "Can we talk about that tomorrow? You tired me out."
Nat laughed. "Good! Cause I'm going to be walking funny tomorrow. Hell, maybe Sunday too!" She reached over and turned off the light. "Night, Logan." Then she giggled. "I never thought I'd go to sleep in the same bed as you."
I put an arm around her and pulled her in, glad to have someone to cuddle, as she settled against me. That's how we fell asleep.
--
A loud crash jolted me from a deep sleep and sitting up I looked at Nat, who stared at me for a half-second. We both said, "Kelly!" at the same time. She bolted, sprinting for the stairs. I wasn't far behind, though I was nowhere near as quick, watching her naked back as she took the stairs two at a time.
"It's fine, I'm okay!" I heard Kelly yelling as I came around the corner to the kitchen. On the floor was a baking sheet, with some bacon still on it, but a lot of greasy streaks ending in slices on the floor.
Nat was standing nude in front of Kelly, holding onto her elbows as she looked her over. "You sure you didn't tweak your knee? Really?"
Kelly started to laugh as she looked over at me. "I see how you make Nat scream like you do."
I looked down at half-hard cock, my morning wood not quite gone. Neither Natalie or I had paused to pull on clothes. We'd gone to sleep nude after our second round of fucking.
"Wow, you smell," Kelly leaned forward and breathed in, "like a slut!"
She laughed again as Natalie hissed, "Oh fuck right off!" A few seconds later they were both laughing.
Nat and I quickly picked up the bacon, handing it to Kelly, who rinsed it, then we gave the floor a wipe. There was no way Kelly could get stuff off the floor with her knee bandaged and braced like it was. Afterwards we went back upstairs, though Natalie made Kelly promise multiple times to be careful, before she came along.
We showered together, taking our time, washing each other as I tried to find her ticklish spots. The bottoms of her feet, back of her knees, and her underarms were at the top of the list. She said she'd get me back, but in the end got distracted by my hard cock, and proceeded to soap it up at least five times, before I finally made her stop. I didn't want to cum in the shower.
The whole situation was way more comfortable than I had expected. We spent so much time together over the last few months, everything came easy.
Breakfast was tasty, and Kelly kept grinning at Natalie and me. She did have a moment after we cleaned up, started wiping her face and hobbled the couch where she cried for a little while, with Nat holding her. I stayed in the kitchen and busied myself washing pans and otherwise cleaning up, leaving the girls alone to sort through stuff.
Eventually Natalie helped Kelly to the bathroom before coming back. "She started thinking about never getting the chance to have breakfast with Dillon again, and... well fuck." Natalie had tears in her eyes, and I held my arms open, letting her settle into my chest and wrapping her up tight, until she took a deep breath and pushed back. "It's okay. She gets like this way less now, for a while there... God, I thought I'd never get her back.
When Kelly came back she tried to apologize, but neither Nat nor I would hear of it.
That episode showed me how fragile Kelly still was, and I decided to give the girls some time alone, telling them I wanted to go home, change, get some other clothes, maybe go for a ride, but promising I would be back in the afternoon, and stay for dinner.
"And the night!" Natalie said immediately. "No way are you going home, please? Logan, I'll do--"
"Stop. You don't need to promise me things to get me to come back. Just, take some time, do whatever stuff you two had planned, and I'll see you later. If you're real motivated, there are a few assignments coming due, maybe work on those?"
"Such a slave driver!" Kelly complained, but she looked grateful.
I packed my my dirty clothes, minus one t-shirt which apparently belonged to Natalie now, and rode home.
----
By the time I got back, it was clear that I wasn't in the right headspace to ride a motorbike. Twice I almost missed a turn and had to jump on the brakes hard at the last moment. When I checked my phone, which I had ignored most of the morning, there were several messages from Vicky asking how the 'morning after' was and whether things were still good.
Since I had time now that I wasn't going for a bike ride, I asked her if she wanted to meet up for a coffee.
An hour later we were sitting in 'Grind-a-Bean', a popular independent cafe about halfway between our places. Vicky tried to start quizzing me immediately, but I wasn't going to talk about anything until we could find a seat, hopefully not right next to people.
Seeing a table, I quickly went over to claim it as Vicky waited for our orders. As I sat, I looked through messages from Nat, and there were a couple of photos. Which, I realized after, I should have never opened in an public place. My only excuse is that I wasn't thinking straight. Because as soon as I clicked the attachment, it opened full screen on my phone, displaying a perfect teenage ass, shot from behind, her hands spreading her cheeks and showing off both her holes. Kelly must have taken it.
"Damn, nice!" Vicky had walked up behind me, and I almost dropped the phone.
"I... fuck."
"You did, didn't you. Looked a bit red to me, guess you didn't go all that easy on her." Vicky giggled as she sat, and I stared at her.
"Never checking messages around you again. You move like a cat!" I put my phone away.
"Yeah, or you're in a stupor from too much horny teen twat." She laughed at the face I made. I still wasn't used to this side of Vicky.
"I'm going to need to tell her." I said as I texted Natalie back to tell her that Ms. Lim had seen her photo.
'OMFG, NO :( ' was what I got back, before my phone rang.
She launched into a tense apology. I tried to stem the tide of words washing over me, and after a short while, Vicky reached out her hand, said, "Let me," and I handed over the phone.
"Natalie! Stop talking!" Vicky said in her best tough-teacher voice. The noise from the phone stopped and Vicky calmly explained that she and I had talked previously since I needed someone to bounce things off. They chatted a little, and at one point Vicky said, "There are rules, he can explain them to you," which made my stomach sink.
The idea of explaining to Natalie that Vicky and I both had clear rules on how to 'fraternize' with students made me feel like a pervert.
I was still thinking about that, when Vicky handed my phone back. "There, she sounds calmer. You might need to tell her a little about me. Not ideal, especially since her little sister, Isabella, is on the gymnastics team, but what can you do? Guess now we both need to trust Nat to keep her mouth shut."
"And Kelly, they tell each other everything."
"Right. Well, I'm less worried about her. She owes us." Vicky's smile was gentle, even if that sounded a touch harsh. "So, tell me how it went."
I gave her the outline, skipping the details, and she was happy for me. "Sounds like a good time. But, she definitely has a crush on you."
"Already breaking the rules then, aren't I?" I knew she wasn't wrong, Nat and I still needed to have a heart-to-heart about boundaries and what would happen when she and Kelly went off to University.
"Yeah, that one is tough. Truth is, I've had the odd crush on some of the girls. Sucks, makes everything harder, like them leaving, but..." She shrugged.
After a second, I grinned. "I did record a video to remember her by, but obviously I can't show you."
"Tease! I might have some of my own from the last few years, but yeah, same. I understand."
We chatted a while longer, and having someone who didn't seem to be judging me helped. Though I was still doing plenty of that all on my own. At the same time, I was already looking forward to seeing Nat again this afternoon. Well, and Kelly, too.
As we separated, Vicky offered to sit down with both girls if they needed someone to talk with, now that they were aware that Vicky knew. I promised to relay her offer.
----
Late that afternoon, I drove back to Kelly's place. No motorbike today, I didn't want Kelly to have to explain why I stayed over multiple nights. To make sure, I parked a couple of houses down, and it sure felt like I was about to do something wrong. 'Teacher sneaks back to student he's having an affair with'. Though, parts of me didn't care, my dick was at half-mast by the time I rang the doorbell.
Nat opened, with a finger to her lips. "Kel's talking to her mom," she said as she led me inside.
"Mom, it's fine. It was just a sheet with bacon... Like seriously, I have to start doing some stuff again... Mother! Nothing bad happened. Nat and Mr. Abrams came running to help and like five minutes later the bacon was washed and in the oven and they already cleaned the floor. Relax... Yes it was a good thing Mr. Abrams was here... Well, he just walked in because we're gonna make dinner for him... Yes, I'll ask him... Yes, I'll make sure he knows... Love you, too, mom. Relax and I'll see you tomorrow."
Kelly put her phone down, looked over at us and yelled, "Oh my fucking god!" Then she took a deep breath and started to laugh. "My mom wants me to thank you for staying over Mr. A. She also said that I should make sure that you know that they are grateful, and it's no problem at all if you want to stay here again, and they want to take you out for a nice dinner after Grad sometime, to thank you for everything you've done."
Nat cackled. "I'll be happy to how him just how thankful I am."
"Slut," Kelly laughed.
"Jealous much?"
"Well, duh!"
They laughed.
I held up my hands. "Just before you get too carried away, Ms. Lim wants you both to know that you can talk to her. She knows and is fine and figured you may need someone besides me, you know... Also, Kelly, you can call me Logan."
"Huh," Kelly looked at me sideways, "just why's she so cool, Logan?"
Natalie laughed. "Bella says some of the girls on the team have a huge crush on Ms. Lim and would... You know. If she let them." She shrugged.
"Your little-sis one of them?" Kelly asked.
"Naww, but she's gonna lose her shit if she ever finds out about us," Nat winked at me. "Isabella thinks you're dreamy, Logan."
"That so? Runs in the family?" I asked, shaking my head.
"Hmm, not sure. Want me to ask my mom tomorrow?" Natalie said with a smirk.
Knowing I wasn't going to win here, I let it go and asked the girls what they wanted to make for dinner. Kelly said they were planning to make beef stroganoff, which was fine by me. Checking the time, the girls decided they needed to start prepping. I joined them, sitting at the breakfast counter while they worked. Natalie got the ingredients, and Kelly helped with anything that didn't involved moving back and forth, or bending over. Which mostly meant chopping mushrooms and onions, and stirring once things were on the stove.
Dinner turned out well, even if the girls did add a ridiculous amount of sour cream. Mostly it was fun to see them work, and listen to their banter. I imagined it would be like this regularly once they lived together at Uni, the two of them working side-by-side, trash-talking and enjoying themselves.
After dinner, once we were settled on the couch, they wanted to hear about the rules Vicky had mentioned.
I explained that Vicky had 'rules of engagement for senior-students', and the girls eyes got big and they immediately wanted to see. So I pulled up the list on my phone and they read it, talking excitedly as they went.
"You know, this isn't half-bad," Kelly said, surprising me.
"It's unlikely I'll ever do something with another student," I said and Natalie's face fell. "No Nat, nothing against you. Just think about it, if Kelly hadn't gotten hurt, we never would have spent so much time together. I just don't see how we would ever get to this point without it. Sorry Kelly."
"All good. At least something positive came out of all this shit," she looked like she was going to cry for a second, then a forced smile appeared on her face. "I'm good."
"Well, we should add one more," Natalie said, and seeing my confusion, explained. "Whichever girl gets you, has to make sure she finds a replacement."
"Oh, like recruiting a successor, or whatever?" Kelly asked.
"Exactly!" Natalie looked pleased that Kelly got it.
"Do not try to recruit other girls into this..."
"Already done." Natalie said, and both Kelly and I stared at her. "I mean, obviously I still need to talk to her, but I already know who." She shrugged like it was no big deal.
"Natalie! You promised to keep this to yourself." The last thing I needed was for rumours to start because she tried to talk someone else into 'taking over'.
For a long moment Natalie sat there and just looked at me, her head tilted a little to the side, eyebrows drawn, before she finally asked, "Logan, do you trust me? Like, actually trust me. You know, to not act like a dumb little girl and fuck this up?"
What the hell was I supposed to that? If I said, 'no', then the night was going to go to shit. And, the truth was, I did trust her. Still, this was my life--and my livelihood--she could potentially mess up.
Kelly waved her over. "Tell me." When Natalie whispered a single word into her ear, Kelly's eyes went wide. Then her face tightened, before she relaxed, nodded and said, "Okay. Yup."
With both of them agreeing, I figured I need to cut my losses, and let it go for now. That, and Natalie had started undoing my jeans.
"Lemme make you feel better." She fished out my dick, mostly hard already, and started a slow blow job, right there on the loveseat with Kelly watching for a bit, before she worked one hand down her pyjama pants.
Taking a quick breather, Nat said, "You said she could watch, right?" before going right back to sucking the head. Kelly bit her lip as she waited for my answer, her hand moving steadily in her pants. Natalie didn't wait for an answer, she threw a leg over me.
And that's how I found myself in Kelly's living room, with Natalie riding me, while Kelly got off to the sex show we put on. Unlike the frantic, hard, fucking Nat and I did last night, this was much softer and gentler. She'd told me she was still a touch sore, and asked me to take it easy, so I let her set the pace and she rode me steadily, giving us lots of time to make out as we fucked, and eventually she had a orgasm.
Since I hadn't finished yet, she knelt in front of me on the floor, and gave me a sloppy blowjob, leaning back as I started to cum so I could cover her tits, and give Kelly a show.
I guess it worked, because Kelly looked sweaty and grinned at us. "That was... amazing. Thank you guys."
Nat spread my cum around on her chest, and told me to take picture. I still pull the shot up now and then, it's absolutely the filthiest photo I have of Nat.
For the rest of the night, we took it easy, watched another movie, before turning in, all of us tired from the day.
Tomorrow afternoon Kelly's parents would return, and I was planning to leave after breakfast. But laying in bed with Natalie in my arms, I tried hard not to think about leaving, or how the week would go.
----
Sunday morning, the first thing Natalie and I did was to change the sheets and get the dirty ones into the washer, before we had breakfast with Kelly. The mood was... not exactly tense, but there was some awkwardness. Things had changed, even if we didn't actually have a threesome, Kelly had watched us have sex while getting off herself. And maybe none of us were quite sure how things would work going forward.
I should have felt worse given what we'd gotten up to, but the girls were grateful for the weekend we had. Kelly especially seemed perked up, though I wasn't sure if it was due to what happened with Nat and I, or because she got a live show. Or even she was just looking forward to the week, because if her doctors appointment on Tuesday went well, she was going to start coming back to school half-days.
By 11 a. m. I was ready to head out the door, and I hugged Kelly while Nat stood at the door, waiting for me.
"Well, Logan, you're definitely still my favourite teacher." She grinned as she leaned in to kiss me.
"And you're still one of my favourite students," I said, and she slapped my shoulder, mock outrage on her face. "What? I still really like Kelly, you need to learn to share, young lady."
Kelly was laughing on the couch and Natalie shot her a dirty look. "Can't believe you're on his side in this."
"Oh, I'm totally on my own side," Kelly shot back, still laughing.
I kissed Nat one more time while she grabbed my ass and ground into me.
"Just so you don't forget," she said as we pulled back.
"Yeah. Forgetting isn't going to be a problem. You going to be good tomorrow?"
"Of course! Though, I might want to wait a day or two before you... you know, make me walk around after you have your way with me." She actually blushed.
I told her that was a good idea, then finally left. Surprisingly, I had a good afternoon, though I felt a touch guilty when Kristy called me to thank me again for stopping by to check on the girls. Apparently she was impressed that the house was no worse for wear and the girls were relaxed and happy. She wanted to have me over for dinner as a thank you for making them feel good about enjoying their weekend away to celebrate.
I tried to put on a good act and told her it was not an issue, that the girls were well-behaved and that I was looking forward to having dinner with them when they were ready.
--
Monday first thing, Vicky stopped by my classroom to remind me to 'be cool', but otherwise it turned out to be just a regular day. With the exception of the occasional glances I got from Nat, which reminded me that I had to be careful, because she looked at me like I imagine a hungry dog looks at a juicy steak. Pretty sure at one point she was literally about to start drooling, and the way she licked her lips had me quickly sitting down behind my desk so none of my students would see the bulge forming in my pants.
On Tuesday after work I got some great news, Kelly would be coming back for half-days. There would be some extra allowances for Natalie, so she could drive Kelly home at lunchtime, which meant that she would need to eat in class, which all her teachers signed off on.
But more importantly, Natalie stopped by my place after working with Kelly after school. When she came upstairs, I was a touch nervous, but she skipped into my place the way she so often did, though as soon as I closed the door she kissed me, pressing the entirety of her body against me, before saying, "Let's get the schoolwork out of the way, and then you can decide which you want to do first: feed me or fuck me."
I chose to feed her first, since I was hungry. After a decidedly quick dinner, we hurriedly cleaned up, and as I put the last dish in the drying rack, Natalie stripped and hopped up on the counter, her feet on the edge, legs spread, and her damp pussy on display.
"What d'ya think, Logan, perfect height?"
I didn't bother to answer, just dropped my pants and stepped between her legs. As I slid into her, Nat moaned and locked her heels behind my back, pulling me forward until I bottomed out.
"Fuck, so good. I was worried you wouldn't want me again," she said.
"Seriously?"
"Not sayin' it makes sense, just... dunno. Sometimes I feel like a dumb girl, sometimes like I could be your girlfriend. And I'm not saying that I want to be," she kissed me, "I remember the rules. Just, that's how I feel."
With her on the counter, we were pretty much eye level and I kept looking at her as we made love, I was taking my time, just enjoying being with her, seeing her reactions as I pushed into her, and again as I pulled out, establishing a slow, steady rhythm.
I'm not sure how long we spent like that, but it felt amazing. Unhurried, relaxed, just the two of us enjoying each other. Eventually I started to speed up, my orgasm got closer, and between that and her flicking her clit, it helped Natalie get over the top just as I did.
After we finished Nat quickly went to the bathroom to clean up, while I got my clothes back on.
She kissed me when she got back. "Hey, I have to run to pick up Bella from gymnastics practice, otherwise I'd stay longer."
"Maybe Friday morning you can stop by my classroom early?"
She gave me a little smile. "Yeah? Am I going to walking around dripping the rest of the day?"
"If you play your cards right."
"Oh fuck, I'm going to be so horny the next couple of days." She grinned at me, kissed me again, then ran out the door yelling, "Hate to fuck and run, but I'm gonna be late."
And just like that, she was gone.
----
I had expected the next couple of days to pass slowly, but Kelly decided not to waste any time and came back to school on Wednesday, which caused a bit of a scramble as we adjusted to having her back, getting her up to date on the current assignments while she was still playing a bit of catch-up on others, and as part of that, my classroom became Natalie and Kelly's go-to spot. Kelly would pop in after her parents dropped her off, and wait for Nat, or vice versa. Then they'd meet there again at lunch so that Nat could drive Kelly home.
Which is how I ended up with Natalie on my desk Friday morning at 7:45 a. m., frantically fucking her as Kelly guarded the door.
Well, she kept looking over and biting her lip, which I saw because I split my attention between Natalie--on her back, skirt pushed up, panties hanging off one ankle as her feet were next to my ears--and Kelly, who looked like she was about to jam a hand down her pants, or wet them. She kept doing that knee bend thing that girls do when they have to go to the washroom. With her good leg anyway.
When I came, Natalie quickly pulled her panties up, a blue thong that day, and wiggled as she stood. "Oh god, it's already running out. Fuck, Logan, I'm going to be so distracted today!" With that she gave me a quick kiss, then girls went out into the hall, giggling and whispering to each other, while I opened a couple of windows to air the room out.
During the day I got multiple messages from Nat and Kelly, Nat complaining about how wet and cold her crotch was, Kelly sending me updates of how dopey and distracted Natalie looked during class and lunch. It was distracting for me as well, but also a lot of fun.
----
Over the next few weeks that became our pattern, Natalie would stop by my place once or twice during the week--she said her parents pretty much stopped asking where she was going as long as she let them know if she'd be home for dinner or not--and one morning a week Nat and Kelly would stop by my room so that I could, in Kelly's words, 'Top Nat up'. She had way too much fun with the whole thing.
In the meantime, the girls had spoken to Vicky a few times, though Vicky wouldn't tell me what they talked about. However, she said the chats had gone well.
--
As April turned into May, Kelly kept improving, and by mid-May was off the crutches, using only a cane, though she still had her leg in one of those brace things, with the big pivots at the knee, which made her look a bit like a cyborg. But she could move around better and was attending full days again. She was also really looking forward to Grad.
Which suddenly was only a week away. With the girls having been so focused on getting Kelly back on track, neither had a date and they decided to go together. I had agreed some time ago to be one of the chaperones for the event--mostly to make sure nobody spiked the punch or got too out of line on the dance floor--so I knew I would see them there.
----
The ceremony was dull, as they typically are. We had a minute of silence for Dillon and there were tears, but in a way it was balanced out when Kelly got her degree, still using the cane, and got a standing ovation. She bowed, and cried, but it was a nice moment. Stacy had arranged for her to give a short speech, and Kelly thanked Charles, Vicky and I multiple times, and said that she'd be forever in our debt because now she could attend University with her best friend.
The party that night was held at a hotel downtown, and a number of seniors had gotten rooms. Which led to people going upstairs to drink. A few people got too drunk and we had to escort them out, but that was the worst of it. No fights or major issues, which was nice.
During one of the slow dances Natalie and Kelly dragged me out on the dance floor and away from my chaperone duties. Nat took Kelly's cane, and I held her close and we moved slowly. Otherwise we kept our distance until later that night.
The girls had gotten a room as well, and once things were winding down I snuck away and met them. Technically, they were no longer my students, but I still made sure nobody was around when I knocked on their door.
Inside they had a small bar setup with vodka, gin and rum, and were mixing drinks. I was surprised to see Vicky sitting on one of the beds, drink in hand, her shoes on the floor.
"Don't worry, I'm not going to stay and cramp your style. But these two," she swung her glass in the direction of Nat and Kelly on the other bed, "insisted that I stop and we all have a drink to celebrate."
"We'd have invited Mr. Davies, " Kelly said, "but he probably won't have come, even if he had been here."
"Not his scene," I said, winking at her.
"You gotta have a drink, Logan!" Nat jumped off the bed and came towards me. Instead of helping me mix, she kissed me and there were some cat-calls, but it didn't stop us.
"Maybe wait with that until I'm out of here?" Vicky asked after we took a breather.
"Why, you never been kissed?" Nat shot back.
"Listen here little girl--"
"Wow, wow. Let's not." I gave Nat a quick slap on the butt, and she wiggled it at me to get another. Which, I'm not proud to say, I delivered.
"Yup, it's time," Vicky said and slipped her shoes on. She got a hug from both girls, then gave me one and whispered, "You lucky fuck," before leaving.
I'd walked her to the door and stopped at the washroom quickly. When I came out, I was treated to the sight of both girls standing side-by-side in matching black lingerie. The lights were off, the only illumination provided by a few tealights they placed around the room.
"Wow, you two look stunning."
Kelly frowned, turning her leg to show her scars. "Nat does anyway."
I stepped over and gave her a hug. "You'll meet the right guy and he won't care one bit. I promise."
"Thanks, Logan." She gave me a kiss on the cheek, then pushed back and moved over to one of the beds.
Nat led me to the other one. "Kel's gonna watch again, yeah?"
"Sure, if you don't mind."
"Nope," she said and kissed me. It turned into a long, drawn out kiss, and by the end I forgot that we had Kelly with us.
We took our time, Nat slowly stripping off my shirt while we moved around, neither of us in a hurry. I let my hands roam, eventually pulling off her bra, freeing her perky tits, enjoying them, first with my hands, then with my mouth.
By the time I went to move lower, Nat said, "You get me so damn riled up when you do that."
Kelly piped up. "Everything he does gets you riled up!"
Natalie threw a pillow at Kelly, who easily blocked it with her arm and cackled.
"She's not wrong," Nat admitted, and focused on me again.
Nudging my shoulder, she got me onto my back and slid down my body, until she was level with my belt. She slowly opened it, unbuckled my pants, then sat up and let me watch as she played with her nipples, tweaking them, licking her fingers and rubbing them to get them hard. The whole time she was casually grinding her pussy on my leg, ignoring me otherwise. Finally she grinned at me, and started working my pants off. In a hurry now, she tugged them hard when I wasn't lifting my hips and legs quick enough, then tossed them over her shoulder.
Standing on the bed, she slowly slid her panties down, revealing a completely shaved pussy glistening with her juices.
"I thought I'd try fully bare."
"Looks amazing. But you look amazing no matter what."
She grinned and bit her lip. Then she lowered herself and took my dick, sliding it through wet folds a few times.
"Mind if I'm on top?"
"Nope. You can do all the work. I'll just lay here and enjoy looking at you."
"Lazy." She slid down on my hard cock and started rocking forward, grinding her clit against me.
Seeing her like that I couldn't just lay there after all and I held her tits, lightly running my thumbs over her nipples now and then.
"Fuck." I heard from the other bed, and looking over saw Kelly, head back, legs straight, strumming her clit. She let out a quiet moan and went slack.
Nat giggled. "Good one?"
"So was."
"Nice."
She turned back to me and sped up, one hand dropping between her legs and flicking her clit hard. I let my hands settle on her hips and started thrusting up into her, matching her strokes. A couple of minutes later Nat had her first orgasm.
I spun us around, putting her on her back, and took charge, setting my own speed and kissing her hard while driving into her. When Nat tightened again and groaned into my mouth I came, at least five or six shots, filling her, before flopping on my back next to her, breathing hard.
"I think I'm ready for that drink now."
Nat chuckled. "You can go make it. I'm just gonna lay here for a minute."
When I had made my Sapphire and Seven, I sat back on the bed and Nat slid close to me and pulled up a sheet to stay warm. We stayed like that for a while, me sipping my drink, the girls chatting about the dance, who had a horrible dress, which guys couldn't dance. I mostly tuned out, periodically tracing little patterns on Nat's skin, making her shiver.
Eventually it was time for me to get dressed, to give the girls a chance to check out some of the party rooms and enjoy their Grad. Natalie sent me a few texts throughout the night, though they got pretty garbled as things got late. The gist was that she was leaking my cum and loved it.
--
By the end of July, Kelly's leg had healed enough that I could take her out for a ride, and she beamed when the helmet came off and told me that she definitely needed to find a guy at Uni who had a motorcycle. I figured her parents would be thrilled.
Natalie and I spent time together when we could, she liked coming on rides as well. I was curious about who she'd recruited, but she flat out refused to talk about who she'd picked as her 'replacement'. Whenever I asked, she would just say, 'You have to wait, Logan. Patience.'
We saw each other regularly, until we spent one last memorable Saturday night in late August together. She'd told her parents she was staying with friends, and while it was fun, we were both aware that this was the end.
Monday she would be flying out, and I would be heading back to teaching Tuesday.
I knew I would never forget her, even if the memory would always be bittersweet. I broke the most important rule, I'd gotten attached.
----
Life went on, and by early October, I had forgotten about Natalie's promise to find someone to take her place. That was, until Isabella stayed behind after my last class on Friday afternoon, taking her time packing up and letting her classmates rush out to start their weekend.
When the classroom had emptied, she came up and stood right in front of my desk. "So, did you know I had my birthday yesterday?"
"Is that so?" I stared at her, thinking maybe she'd talked to her sister, and Nat had asked her to relay a message.
"Yup, all legal now," she blushed. "Nat said you're the best she ever had, Mr. A. And that I should take real good care of you, since she can't. And, if you're interested, I'd really like to. And, I'm like, way more flexible." At that she put one finger on the edge of my desk, and did a standing split right there in my classroom.
I was speechless. She grinned, and put a piece of paper on my desk. Unfolding it, I saw, 'For the best time, call Bella' and her phone number.
"Nat says 'Hi' by the way. And, she said to tell you, 'Don't overthink it, Logan.'"
With that she walked out, a smirk on her face, leaving me sitting there, shocked.
I shook my head, Nat's sister...
----
I did get together with Bella that year, and while it was fun, a small part of me kept thinking about Natalie. Not because the girls were alike sexually, Bella was more of a risk taker, we christened the equipment room, a quiet corner of the library, and we even met up at the mall and had an intense ten minutes in a change room. But the truth was, I kept comparing her attitude and behaviour to Natalie, which lead to me wondering what she was up to at school. If she met that special guy yet, or was just having fun and playing the field.
Things felt strained when Kelly and Natalie were back from school the next summer. I saw them, we got together to catch up, but there was something different between Natalie and me. Which, given that she had set me up with her little sister, was understandable. But still, I didn't like it. It felt like we lost something important, and special, in the process.
Isabella connected me with Abigail, who she was on the gymnastics squad with, but by the end of that year the pattern became clear to me. Even though I always planned to keep my distance, each time one of the girls left, it felt like a breakup. And frankly, I wanted more than flings I had to hide.
Over the years Vicky and I had become even closer friends, and while she didn't share my outlook, she said she understood when after Abi, I called the whole thing off.
----
I still got updates from Kelly--she met a guy in her second year at school, George, and they got serious enough that he came and spent time with her during the summer and the three of us even went out for dinner--but I lost touch with Natalie. Maybe things had gotten too difficult, but she didn't come home the summer Kelly brought George. I found out from Kelly that Natalie had accepted an internship on the East coast before her final year and was hoping to make some connections that might lead to a job for her after she got her degree in communications. It sounded like she was doing well, and I was happy for her, but there was also a fair bit of regret. I wished we could have at least stayed friends.
The next year the girls got their degrees, and along with the photos I got from Kelly of them in their gowns, I got a picture of Kelly's engagement ring. She said George proposed right there at the convocation ceremony--he did the whole 'get down on one knee' thing to huge applause from the people around--and Kelly said yes immediately. I could see the tears in her eyes in the photo of the two of them where she held up her ring.
She told me that she and George would be back in town and wanted to meet up for coffee, since without me she wouldn't have been able to get to school the year she planned, and probably wouldn't have met her future husband. I figure if it was meant to be, they would have found each other anyway, but happily agreed to meet up. Even knowing that it would bring back that subtle underlying feeling of loss since Natalie wouldn't be there with them.
When the day came I arrived a little early at the coffee shop, and having gotten my order, found a table for us.
As I sat and watched the door, a young woman came in, dressed in stylish heels, tight grey slacks, a form fitting white blouse showing off some cleavage, and wearing those huge designer sunglasses with the gold logo on the arms. When she pushed the glasses up to the top of her heard, I gawked and my heart skipped a beat.
It was Natalie.
Older, more mature, her hair a little shorter with highlights, face more angular, like she lost a bit of weight. She looked right at me and a small smile appeared on her face as she walked over.
Standing in front of my table, looking just a touch uncertain, she said, "Hi Logan."
I got up and walked around, stopping a foot in front of her, my arms slightly out. "Is it okay if I give you a hug?"
"Definitely," she said and moved forward, wrapping her arms around me. We stood like that for a minute, just holding each other.
"Are Kelly and George coming soon?" I asked when she stepped back.
"Oh... No. Sorry, I wasn't sure where we... I mean, I didn't know if you'd come if I asked. So Kelly set this up for me."
"You actually thought I wouldn't want to see you?"
"I wasn't sure. I felt bad for avoiding you, but seeing you was too hard." She looked away for a second, before her gaze returned. "Things got complicated. You mind if I get a coffee, and we can talk?"
"Of course." I watched her get in line. Every now and then Natalie would glance over and I'd smile. Whenever she caught my glance, she looked happy that I was watching her
When she finally got her mocha she sat across from me and after taking a sip, said, "You look like you have questions."
"I guess the first is, how long are you in town for?" There were other things I wanted to ask, but felt like I should start with something 'safe'.
"That depends," she saw my reaction and added, "at least for a few weeks. But maybe longer."
"What's it depend on?" My stomach was tight and my palms were damp as I waited for her answer.
Natalie took another sip. "On whether you want to take me out to a real date."
"And if I do?"
"Then, maybe I'll accept the offer that I got from a firm headquartered here, instead of the one in the East." Natalie smiled.
I leaned back, taking a drink myself, just looking at her. While she was still the girl I'd known, and had fallen for four years ago, there was something else. This was a different version, a woman. More mature and experienced. This Natalie seemed sure of what she wanted.
"I would love to take you on a real date, Natalie."
"You're not seeing anyone, dating or... you know?"
"Neither," I said, and there was that smile again. It made my stomach do flip flops.
"Well, I might just be around for a long time then," she said and getting up, slid her chair next to mine and leaned her head on my shoulder. I put my arm around her.
Settling into me, Natalie let out a breath. "God, I missed you, Logan."
--
Thanks for reading the story! If you enjoyed it, please consider leaving a rating or a comment.
You need to log in so that our AI can start recommending suitable works that you will definitely like.
Love Times 2
Part 8 of 15
-----------------------------------------
Kurt feared that he wouldn't be able to survive without daily sex from Yvonne. How does he cope? Find out in Chapter 8 of the 15-part series "Love Times 2."
-----------------------------------------
The rest of th...
Oliver did reveal to his four guests - there on the beach, his four delightfully naked guests, that he had, indeed, thought of bringing a girl or two to that very beach and swimming ashore and...
"And?" interrupted Phoebe, "would that be to fuck them, Oliver? Did you conceive of having four?"
"No!...
I am 31 years old, and I have always struggled with intimacy. It all stems from an event when I was 19, where I was sexually assaulted by a classmate during my first year of college. Ever since then, I had associated sex with pain, something that I, as a woman, must do for my male partners but never...
read in full"Time to go," Crispin said to Lexi as he put a holdall on the bed. "Your clothes are in there."
"Oh, right," she replied.
Crispin had climbed out of bed after he had put his seed in her and gone to the bathroom, leaving her to doze. She had lain in the big soft bed fantasising about being in the r...
I took in the female students in front of me. I love teaching but I love watching a woman's panties flash from under the desk more.
"That's all for today." I said in conclusion.
Laura smiled as she patted her legs for the umpteenth time.
I cleared my throat as I walked out from the class hurriedl...
There are no comments yet - be the first to add one!
Add new comment